Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what has happened to my Son's school

989 replies

k2493 · 07/01/2024 11:09

Just posting for thoughts

Both my kids have gone through the same secondary school. When my daughter started, the school was lovely and new with around 750 kids.

Fast forward to 2024 and there is now 1500 kids and it's become like a dictatorship.

Due to the number of kids, the school has put lines either side of the hallway that they have to walk within otherwise they get detention.

Every hallway is a one way system.

The minute they arrive in school, they have to remove their coats or it's detention even with no heating in the middle of winter. The other day my son arrived back to school to find that there were long queues outside while they did two uniform checks at the door. By the time he got in, he was frozen. Immediately he got shouted at for still having his coat on even though he had just stepped in from the cold.

He then went around the corner and got shouted at again even though he tried to explain it's really difficult to be expected to stay warm, keep moving and remove your coat all at the same time. Nope. Threaten with detention again.

AIBU to wonder what has happened to our education system? I'm lucky in that my son is quite strong minded and just brushes it off but what about the kids who's mental health this is impacting? Surely we want our kids to remember school as being enjoyable for their education and friendships rather than for being shouted at every two minutes for not walking between lines or not taking their coats off the minute they arrive in school?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Verbena17 · 10/01/2024 09:06

*instead of having deteriorating behaviour …

twistyizzy · 10/01/2024 09:06

Verbena17 · 10/01/2024 08:57

@twistyizzy but those are normal changes for that age group. If secondary continued to normalise the eating together, staff chatting to parents, time for arts & creativity type ethos, perhaps the majority of children would continue to progress into of having deteriorating behaviour once shocked into it by the academy regime!

Teachers don't have time though. They don't have 1 x class of 30 kids like in primary, they have lots of classes of 30 so that's impossible.
The National Curriculum doesn't allow for arts and creativity and Ofsted doesn't judge on this.
How can 1500 kids eat together in a canteen built for 500 kids?
You have completely unrealistic expectations of what a school can reasonably do.
Add to that 3 x secondary schools in the near area are closed to RAAC and kids are being taught across different random portakabins across other different schools in the county so there isn't even a physical school 🙄.

Verbena17 · 10/01/2024 08:57

@twistyizzy but those are normal changes for that age group. If secondary continued to normalise the eating together, staff chatting to parents, time for arts & creativity type ethos, perhaps the majority of children would continue to progress into of having deteriorating behaviour once shocked into it by the academy regime!

twistyizzy · 10/01/2024 08:53

dontbenastyhaveapasty · 10/01/2024 08:46

@twistyizzy i might agree with you if primary schools in an area were having the same problems. But they aren’t.

Parents engage just fine with primary schools, and children love going to school. Behaviour is good. The approach is child-centred, there is space and time in the school day for play. Lunches are eaten at a table, in a normal civilised environment. Children are listened to and feel valued as individuals.

The same children then start secondary school. From day 1 they are subjected to a punitive, cold, authoritarian environment. They are not listened to - in fact, they are punished if they speak. They are punished if they do not sit up straight enough at their desks. They do not have space, time in the school day, or any equipment for play. There is minimal art or creativity of any kind in the curriculum. There is nowhere to sit and eat lunch. Not only that, they are made to chant slogans at the start of every school day about the school’s rules and regulations. It is dehumanising to an extreme extent.

Is this really a proportionate or rational response to behaviour in some (other) schools being bad? Or would it be more sensible to deal with the problem of knife crime as a problem in society rather than brutalise every child in the country?

Of course we should deal with knife crime but that isn't up to the school to do, all they can do is mitigate it and the safety of the other kids and staff.
There are issues at primary but generally schools are smaller, teachers and parents have face to face relationship and there is less issues with mobile phones etc.
There was a massive change in personality in some of the kids DD went to primary with once they started secondary school ie the change in language and attitude was almost immediate. She doesnt go to school with the but sews them at the bus stop every morning and was on the Yr 6 Leavers group chat. She left the group after 4 weeks of Yr 7 because the language and bullying was horrendous. These kids 2 months earlier had been friends at primary. So there CAN be a change from primary to secondary.

dontbenastyhaveapasty · 10/01/2024 08:46

@twistyizzy i might agree with you if primary schools in an area were having the same problems. But they aren’t.

Parents engage just fine with primary schools, and children love going to school. Behaviour is good. The approach is child-centred, there is space and time in the school day for play. Lunches are eaten at a table, in a normal civilised environment. Children are listened to and feel valued as individuals.

The same children then start secondary school. From day 1 they are subjected to a punitive, cold, authoritarian environment. They are not listened to - in fact, they are punished if they speak. They are punished if they do not sit up straight enough at their desks. They do not have space, time in the school day, or any equipment for play. There is minimal art or creativity of any kind in the curriculum. There is nowhere to sit and eat lunch. Not only that, they are made to chant slogans at the start of every school day about the school’s rules and regulations. It is dehumanising to an extreme extent.

Is this really a proportionate or rational response to behaviour in some (other) schools being bad? Or would it be more sensible to deal with the problem of knife crime as a problem in society rather than brutalise every child in the country?

Verbena17 · 10/01/2024 08:45

whotospeakto · 10/01/2024 06:09

I see some of the points raised but as a teacher in a pretty rough school where there is no discipline from senior management, we need a bit of this.

If this is the same building where the numbers have doubled then the school probably isn't designed to show that many pupils. One way systems are a pain but not something to get worked up over if it's for safety reasons. The lines in the corridor were put into my school in return from Covid and maybe in some schools it's been beneficial.

As for the uniform, I am 100% for this. Some of our pupils don't comply with this and nothing is done. Last year we had very serious problems with intruders coming into school and they were not easily identified due to the number of out pupils in hoodies and joggers. Some of these kids came in for a laugh and wandered around, some came in to attack some of our pupils for outside issues - gang mentality. Again, uniforms aren't the best, but if it keeps your child safe then there's a bigger picture. If they are doing uniform checks at the door, it could actually be something like this but they don't want come out and say it. There are a number of staff in my school who are concerned that someone will get stabbed in our school before things change and that's terrifying. I've had kids in my class who have obviously taken something during their break and you're concerned over what their behaviour is going to be like.

The jacket thing is annoying and common sense should be used. My classroom is terribly cold, I let my kids keep them on if it's too cold, and when smt come in and moan at them I tell them it was me who let them keep it on due to how cold it is. I've been in the same school for over 15 years and I used to think they were ott with jackets off as soon as you came in the door but that standard was let slip and that was the start.

Yes, I work in a god awful school, why do I not leave? We have some amazing kids who need teachers who are on their side and will do what they can for them despite the fact they're in a terrible school.

As a pupil I'd be fed up and would be rolling my eyes at the rules, as a parent I'd maybe still feel a little like that but would tell my son he just needs to get on with it.

I think it’s sad that you only call some of the kids at your school ‘amazing’ and they seem to be the ones who are potentially going places 🤔.

All kids are amazing - teachers and schools need to treat them all as if they are amazing and perhaps then, the school dynamic will change.

Verbena17 · 10/01/2024 08:37

Pollythenurse · 10/01/2024 02:26

.....and your tone smacks of entitlement.

Was this a reply to my post?

twistyizzy · 10/01/2024 08:27

@dontbenastyhaveapasty I get your point but you aren't acknowledging that pupil behaviour in SOME schools has declined significantly and this is irrespective of race etc. NDN is HoY and has been threatened with a knife twice this term in a "MC" rural area. There is generally a larger % of pupils who have zero respect for teachers or theIr own learning that isn't down to SEN.
Add to that a significant minority of parents for whom education didn't work so therefore they don't engage with their children's education.
Then combine with schools that have a much larger cohort than they were built for so everyone is cramped in together, lack of staff and resources etc and you have a perfect storm.

dontbenastyhaveapasty · 10/01/2024 08:17

What's being described here isn't about supporting education, it's about crowd control and uncivilised cohorts who from cradle to grave have lost contact with societal norms. This has resulted in an unkind and punitive environment for all which cannot possibly support learning.

This bit about “uncivilised cohorts”: it’s the same mindset that brought you “migrants are all bad”, “this country is going to the dogs” etc. It is bedded in unspoken very right-wing assumptions about people and society as a whole - particularly people who are working class or black, and it it TOTALLY UNTRUE!

Children today are NOT less civilised than in the 1970s or even the 1870s. Overall, we live in a safer and less violent society now than in the past. Over the years it had been demonstrated that treating children with civility, compassion and love results in better behaved, happier children who are more able to learn effectively.

The “unkind and punitive environment” you so rightly identify has been created by the academy leaders who spout this mad right-wing ideology - Kathryn Birbalsingh et al. It is the schools who have created this culture, it wasn’t there in society first - certainly not in most parts of the country.

The head of “school improvement” at my son’s school was formerly a senior member of staff at the Michaela school. Maybe the Michaela approach can work in a (very)small London school where there is huge choice in which school children can attend, and where maybe there are problems with gangs and knives. Maybe.

All I can say is that it is a total disaster when applied to schools in the rural westcountry, where a single school serves the entire population including all the kids with additional needs. And where society as a whole is broadly friendly, pleasant and kind. It’s like some bizarre Nazi experiment has taken over our schools in order to brutalise an entire generation and destroy our (currently kind and friendly) local culture.

Hollybobs1 · 10/01/2024 08:13

Personally, I'd make a serious complaint. How can they learn when they're freezing?

twistyizzy · 10/01/2024 08:13

RosesAndHellebores · 10/01/2024 07:10

When I were a lass I got into the grammar school. Three form entry, 90 girls a year. Other local schools were 4 form entry. A couple of schools were rougher than others with poorer results, offering only cses. Compared to posts on here they were probably akin to finishing school. The rot set in, in about 1970, and it was the one size fits all comprehensive system that started it together with the Liberal left "anything goes" mentality.

What's being described here isn't about supporting education, it's about crowd control and uncivilised cohorts who from cradle to grave have lost contact with societal norms. This has resulted in an unkind and punitive environment for all which cannot possibly support learning.

It is not helped by the focus shifting from education to qualifications. An education should always be about more than paper quals, the value of which is becoming increasingly diluted.

That is the most rational post of the thread!
It isn't just 1 thing, it is a combination of many things.
You are right in saying the focus has moved away from education. Education shoukd be about broadening the mind, being inquisitive and learning for the sake of learning. What we currently have in state education are exam factories. Parents buy into this though ie looking for the school that has the highest 7-9% rather than the school that offers the broadest curriculum and a supportive learning environment.

Dasy2k1 · 10/01/2024 08:12

The current ethos which comes directly from the DoE via ofsted is comply at all costs.
The pettier the rule the better the only purpose is to install unthinking unquestioning compliance
Petty uniform rules such as this are generally the easiest to implement and so that's what the schools focus on which is frankly ridiculous.

Especially as a sensible rule for coats would require them to be taken of at the Classroom door rather than before you even get to the halls.

And it's the same in hot weather these days. Even if multiple pupils pass out from heat stroke you are not permitted to remove blazers or ties as that would set a dangerous precedent that would make mass insubordination and mutiny inevitable

RosesAndHellebores · 10/01/2024 07:10

When I were a lass I got into the grammar school. Three form entry, 90 girls a year. Other local schools were 4 form entry. A couple of schools were rougher than others with poorer results, offering only cses. Compared to posts on here they were probably akin to finishing school. The rot set in, in about 1970, and it was the one size fits all comprehensive system that started it together with the Liberal left "anything goes" mentality.

What's being described here isn't about supporting education, it's about crowd control and uncivilised cohorts who from cradle to grave have lost contact with societal norms. This has resulted in an unkind and punitive environment for all which cannot possibly support learning.

It is not helped by the focus shifting from education to qualifications. An education should always be about more than paper quals, the value of which is becoming increasingly diluted.

Kikisweb · 10/01/2024 06:56

My DS starts in September. He has high anxiety levels which are going to be made so much worse by modern secondary schools. He has a lot of problems with executive dysfunction so homework and having equipment is going to be a nightmare for him, and the punishments are going to trigger school refusal. I think most secondary schools take petty things to extremes and are creating the current extremely high rates of teen anxiety, self harm and suicide. The current system fails more children than it helps.

Stressedmumoftwoteens · 10/01/2024 06:46

Try sending your child to a school where there is no uniform code, no rules and no discipline because that is what my child's school has become! Regularly my child has come home from school with ripped uniform or bruises where from where they have been pushed down the stairs because there is a mass bundle of kids rushing down the corridors. No one cares what time you turn up as long as it is vaguely right. Thank goodness my child is in year 11 and leaves soon.

Poppytops88 · 10/01/2024 06:44

I watched 'The UKs Strictest School' on ITV yesterday. Its called Michaela Community School' in West London. Its a very deprived area and they get amazing results.
They think if you're really strict with the tiny things and zero tolerant then the big things won't happen. Some of it all very strange though and I can't see how the school could work for SEN children, I don't think they'd be accepting, I assume the parents of SEN children wouldn't consider the school.
Has anyone watched it or have any experiences of the school?

whotospeakto · 10/01/2024 06:09

I see some of the points raised but as a teacher in a pretty rough school where there is no discipline from senior management, we need a bit of this.

If this is the same building where the numbers have doubled then the school probably isn't designed to show that many pupils. One way systems are a pain but not something to get worked up over if it's for safety reasons. The lines in the corridor were put into my school in return from Covid and maybe in some schools it's been beneficial.

As for the uniform, I am 100% for this. Some of our pupils don't comply with this and nothing is done. Last year we had very serious problems with intruders coming into school and they were not easily identified due to the number of out pupils in hoodies and joggers. Some of these kids came in for a laugh and wandered around, some came in to attack some of our pupils for outside issues - gang mentality. Again, uniforms aren't the best, but if it keeps your child safe then there's a bigger picture. If they are doing uniform checks at the door, it could actually be something like this but they don't want come out and say it. There are a number of staff in my school who are concerned that someone will get stabbed in our school before things change and that's terrifying. I've had kids in my class who have obviously taken something during their break and you're concerned over what their behaviour is going to be like.

The jacket thing is annoying and common sense should be used. My classroom is terribly cold, I let my kids keep them on if it's too cold, and when smt come in and moan at them I tell them it was me who let them keep it on due to how cold it is. I've been in the same school for over 15 years and I used to think they were ott with jackets off as soon as you came in the door but that standard was let slip and that was the start.

Yes, I work in a god awful school, why do I not leave? We have some amazing kids who need teachers who are on their side and will do what they can for them despite the fact they're in a terrible school.

As a pupil I'd be fed up and would be rolling my eyes at the rules, as a parent I'd maybe still feel a little like that but would tell my son he just needs to get on with it.

Gillypie23 · 10/01/2024 05:46

Has it turned into an a academy. They bring in stupid rules.

Natsku · 10/01/2024 05:24

UndertheCedartree · 09/01/2024 22:53

It must be something like that but it doesn't seem to be a common rule as most schools I've heard of put them on the back of their chairs. I think DD would have to have an extra tote bag or something with her as her coat wouldn't fit in her rucksack. But by the time you've got a rucksack, tote bag and lunch bag it would seem to be making more of a trip/fire hazard.

Wasn't against fire regulations when I was in school. Are classes just more crowded now perhaps?

Natsku · 10/01/2024 05:22

@mathanxiety Minor infractions of rules did not result in detentions or exclusions. A buildup of minor infractions resulted in a referral to a dean of discipline and a discussion of issues behind the behaviour, and problem solving. The school did not expel students and did not use detention as a constant response to chronic problems.

Sounds similar to how they handle discipline in Finland, discussing the behaviour and trying to get to the root of it.
No automatic going up to the next school year either, if they fail they can do summer school and resit exams to see if they pass and get into the next grade, but they can be made to repeat the year. I think its pretty rare for that to happen though I know of at least two children in my DD's primary school that have repeated a grade (though one was because he had cancer and missed too much 1st grade). Lots of SEN support and seems relatively easy compared to the UK to get the support - I bet a lot of poor behaviour (not all of course) is due to struggling too much in a school that they can't cope with where their needs aren't met.

No rules about moving around between lessons beyond the usual no bullying rules. Sometimes they have to travel across town to another school for lessons and the teenagers are trusted and expected to do this within the time given, by themselves. This is a factory town, the vast majority are working class kids (though class differences are different here compared to the UK, or the US I expect) not naice middle class suburbs.

mathanxiety · 10/01/2024 03:38

dontbenastyhaveapasty · 09/01/2024 21:35

This is the ludicrous fallacy behind the whole ideology: that children (particularly if they’re working class) are feral and wicked, and without punitive discipline they will be dangerous and uncontrollable. And everyone who complains is labelled as a bad parent who doesn’t value education and has no boundaries.

It is utter nonsense.

Also, the idea that the “disruptive element are removed”: removed from where and to where exactly? They still exist. They are not being eliminated from society, just off-rolled to make the academy’s results figures look better - at considerable long-term cost to society as a whole.

I agree with all of that, @dontbenastyhaveapasty

The classist assumptions are gobsmacking.

mathanxiety · 10/01/2024 03:30

Grammarnut · 09/01/2024 16:11

The environment you both describe works fine for nice middle class children from supportive homes who have access to lots of opportunities. It is useless in a school where many children live in unsupportive homes, are not fed breakfast, have families with no interest in education or reading etc. and set no boundaries on their children. In that situation, uniform, rules, detentions etc are the bulwark against chaos, as are exclusions, and these things allow the children who do want to work and progress, because the disruptive elements are removed.

That's nonsense.

I'm speaking from the perspective of a parent whose DCs went to a public high school in the US, a school with a very mixed student intake - a student body of 3,500+ from all sorts of ethnic backgrounds, income levels, cultural backgrounds, parents with wildly varying levels of aspiration and ambition and different experiences of school and school systems.

There were kids heading for Harvard and kids who wanted to be mechanics or hairdressers and all points in between. Many of the students were TESL students, from homes where Spanish or Polish or (lately) Ukrainian were the first languages. There were students whose ancestors came from the rural South whose experiences of segregation had an effect on how they viewed schools.

There were no uniforms, just a dress code.

There were lockers for every student, assigned on the first day of freshman year and kept for all four years, and PE lockers where students could keep their school issued PE shorts and Tshirts and leave their day clothes and bags while doing PE.

There was a five minute passing period between classes. Students could talk and use whatever side of the hallways they wished to use, getting around a building that is a city block long (1/8 of a mile) and four floors high.

Students could get a hall pass to use the bathroom during class. Hall passes were tracked.

Students were placed in academic tracks based on placement exams and performance in classes. They did not advance year by year with kids their age.

The library was specifically remodeled as a place where students could hang out, supervised.

Minor infractions of rules did not result in detentions or exclusions. A buildup of minor infractions resulted in a referral to a dean of discipline and a discussion of issues behind the behaviour, and problem solving. The school did not expel students and did not use detention as a constant response to chronic problems.

The school employed security guards to keep order in the hallways, cafeterias, and surrounds and to double as crossing guards/ direct traffic.

SEN were diagnosed and IEPs developed by SEN staff employed by the school. The school had a Special Ed section, plus a nursery for the babies and small children of staff and students, and farmed out kids who couldn't function in the mainstream school environment because of emotional or MH needs to specific alternative educational providers, with each student fully funded by the school, including school bus transport.

The school served breakfast and lunch in the cafeterias, with FSM students able to get a hearty meal at no cost twice a day, and reduced cost food available to hundreds more. During the covid shutdown the school distributed iPads and chrome books to all students and had free meals available for pickup to all registered for free school meals plus any other students whose families needed a weekly package of dry/ tinned pantry items - noodles, pasta, jars of sauce, dried fruit, instant porridge, etc.

Yes, all of that (and there was much, much more) costs money. If you think operating what amounts to a stressful boot camp masquerading as a school will accomplish what money and evidence-based approaches to discipline do, you need to examine what it is in your assumptions about your fellow Britons that makes you think that way.

Pollythenurse · 10/01/2024 02:26

.....and your tone smacks of entitlement.

Verbena17 · 10/01/2024 00:30

greengreengrass25 · 09/01/2024 20:38

@Verbena17

Yes I see

Shouldn't he have been getting differentiated work or does this no longer exist

It’s supposed to be differentiated but in reality….to have the work differentiated per pupil was seemingly too much of a stretch. I’ve spent the evening reading through all the old emails between me and DS’ year 7 tutors and for every single subject, there are back and fro emails that left me (once again) crying. I’ve not read them for a few years (he’s almost 19 now) and I just felt like I’d been hit in the stomach.

In their response emails - they were explaining why they were sticking with their C3 or C2 break detentions….when in fact he had only been hyper focussed on retrieving his things or was late for a lesson because they wouldn’t let him go to the loo just before his lesson began, as he couldn’t process how much time there was left before the end of break bell rang.

The ‘reasonable adjustments’ they stated were in their mind reasonable but upon reading them, weren’t adjusted for my child’s needs at all. The emails are mostly me requesting (and at times almost begging albeit very humbly) for help with planning homework, asking for text books to be sent home to help him or just asking that tasks are broken down more etc.

Anyway - just trying to illustrate how inflexible mainstream schools are and I’m pretty sure the staff are all sat in staff rooms (if they have them) saying ‘let’s go back to the old days instead of all this crap’.
Surely happy, well rounded children who can function as adults should be the outcome and as a mum, I’m pretty sure a dictatorship style discipline regime is not the way to go about it.

Phoenixfire1988 · 10/01/2024 00:03

Is this an outwood academy by any chance ? There's been a big hoohaa in my area about children being suspended for refusing to remove coats because it was freezing and in 1 video the staff shouting at children to take coats off are wearing .... you guessed it big thick winter coats !!!