Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Angry at being told I'm not really part of the family

212 replies

MakingUpTheNumbers · 07/01/2024 08:18

DP and I have been together since uni. 23 years this year. We've got 3 DC, 2 dogs, own our house together etc, etc but we're not married. Not for any particular reason but for both of us it wasn't ever a priority and other parts of our developing lives always seemed more important. We're happy with our lives and we've never had cause to question our arrangement.

Last weekend on NYE we were round at DP"s brothers house, his other siblings were there with their DW and DHs (they're all married) and all the kids. DP was making arrangements with his DSis for us to take their kids for a weekend at the end of Jan and when organised and said to the kids, that they were coming to stay and Uncle Paul and Auntie Numbers and we'd need to plan to do something cool.

In front of everyone including all the kids DP's father who was a bit drunk bellowed and has form for being argumentative. ”Don't call her Auntie, she's not their Auntie, she's of no relation to them, she's actually no relation to any of us"

DP and his siblings called their father out on it and DP's mother pulled me aside to make excuses for it all and apologise but a week on and it's still really bothering me.

I know he's technically right, we're not married, I'm not their Auntie but WIBU to talk to DP's father and ask WTAF?

OP posts:
martinisforeveryone · 07/01/2024 16:11

Congrats @MakingUpTheNumbers on your impending marriage and the fact you do have some good people around you. Unfortunately I had experience of a toxic in law like your future FIL. Whoever said it, nailed it, you can choose your friends but not your 'family'

While I'm here it seems a good place to ask if anyone's tried the Festive Bake at Greggs? That would've been very celebratory if it's still on offer, if it's nice.
Otherwise, I'd go for the cheese and onion one, the pattern on top's very elegant as well as the filling.

wronginalltherightways · 07/01/2024 15:41

Gymnopedie · 07/01/2024 13:53

Have you not heard of wills?

DP and I were together for nearly 44 years when he died suddenly. I was aunty to his sister's DCs from the day they were born, ditto him being uncle to my sister's kids. To the hospital I was NOK. Joint tenants on the house.

We'd been together since uni and felt if it ain't broke don't fix it.

Inheritance tax rules. Government spousal payments due to a spouses untimely death when you still have minor children at home.

Nonamesleft1 · 07/01/2024 14:49

caringcarer · 07/01/2024 14:34

But the amount you can leave a spouse is different for IT purposes.

if you and your partner have everything in joint names none of that comes under IHT.

if you have over £325k/500k including property in your sole name then anything over that is taxed, if you are not married.

so you can put your house and savings in joint names, or get married. Same difference.

i am married but am not leaving my house, in my sole name, to dh. So even though I’m married I will still need to make sure that if my house value exceeds £500k I take steps to safeguard that. Being married has actually made my circumstances more difficult as I need to keep my will up to date and relevant parties informed, as I do not want the default, which is for dh to inherit everything.

so depending on your circumstances marriage may affect IHT, but there are many simple remedies other than marriage.

caringcarer · 07/01/2024 14:34

MakingUpTheNumbers · 07/01/2024 08:38

Yes, wills, pensions, life insurance all reflect our non married relationship and ensures were both taken care of

He wasn't that drunk. He knew exactly what he was saying.

Funnily enough, because of his life long piss poor behaviour re being overbearing with his children, being argumentative, grouchy with the kids etc he's actually the one amongst us all who's kept at arms length by DP and his siblings etc. Mostly because he's such a prick to have around.

I'd just like to have the satisfaction of challenging him on it and pointing out that while I might not be family, I'm more often than not more welcome in all their lives than he is.

Obviously I won't, it would create havoc and put everyone in a difficult position, especially DP.

But the amount you can leave a spouse is different for IT purposes.

caringcarer · 07/01/2024 14:33

ACynicalDad · 07/01/2024 08:22

Our kids call all sorts Auntie, he’s a knob. But if anything ever happens you’d be much better protected married or civil partnered.

This.

FreshWinterMorning · 07/01/2024 14:20

Gosh he is a bit rude isn't he @MakingUpTheNumbers ??? After a quarter century you are not classed as being part of the family? Sad My son-in-law who married my DD recently, AND my other DD's fiancé have been 'family' to me for some years now. I'd say since they moved in together (both 2 and 3 years after meeting.)

I would say get married though, for all the reasons cited on here from many posters. Because your relationship will not be taken really seriously by some.

I have known one couple who were together for 20 years and not married, and another couple together 7 years and married. (I worked with both of the women.) In both couples, the man died 2-3 years ago.

The second couple were taken far more seriously by their families, and friends, and the law.

When their husbands died, widow 2 who had been married 5 years and with him for 7, got much more sympathy from everyone - colleagues, friends, neighbours, and family, and more time off work etc, as well as financial benefits.

Widow 1 (together 20 years with her man, never married,) got naff-all. Not even any rights to his possessions or property or money or pension. And the employer didn't allow her a single second off work. She got no sympathy from ANYone, as people said 'well, it's not like you were married is it?' She was not even allowed to decide how or where he was buried... Or if he was to be buried or cremated.

She really had no more rights than a flatmate at the end of the day.

As has been said, although it sounds like it's from 'the 50s' (it's always the 50s LOL!) if you don't live within the law, you can't expect the law to protect you. And as a poster said further back - you can't have your cake and eat it. If you don't want to be married, some family members in your 'boyfriend's' family will not class you as family. They are entitled to that view. (I don't agree FWIW.)

Gymnopedie · 07/01/2024 13:53

wronginalltherightways · 07/01/2024 13:02

Not being married is going to cost you when one of you dies because that is how UK law is set up re inheritances.

I'd quietly get married, tbh.

Have you not heard of wills?

DP and I were together for nearly 44 years when he died suddenly. I was aunty to his sister's DCs from the day they were born, ditto him being uncle to my sister's kids. To the hospital I was NOK. Joint tenants on the house.

We'd been together since uni and felt if it ain't broke don't fix it.

PinkArt · 07/01/2024 13:50

JG4 · 07/01/2024 12:47

Not related to your question , but I just had a thought : do you know that in the event of his death you would not inherit anything or be protected in any way ? Lots of people in this country believe that after a certain number of years there is a thing called a ‘common law marriage ‘ , no such thing exists . Same applies in the event of separation. I just thought I would let you know , just in case xx

OPs posts show she's very aware of this and that they have put all relevant paperwork in place re wills etc. Yes being married makes some things like that more straightforward and comes with some financial benefits, but this is clearly not a couple with their heads in the sand.

GreggsWedding · 07/01/2024 13:27

I wonder if this thread has spawned a new bit of MN slang?

I wish you every happiness with your Greggs Wedding

WombatBombat · 07/01/2024 13:18

Get married on 29th Feb this year, means you don’t then have to celebrate every year if you don’t want to!

Nonamesleft1 · 07/01/2024 13:17

wronginalltherightways · 07/01/2024 13:02

Not being married is going to cost you when one of you dies because that is how UK law is set up re inheritances.

I'd quietly get married, tbh.

Is it?

firstly it only really matters if you have sole assets- if everything is joint it automatically passes to the survivor, there is no will (everything in sole name will pass to kids), and sole assets are above £325k/£500k including property.

a will can sort that issue out.

I am leaving everything to my dc. Being married will only matter if I die before dh, and my assets are over £500k, including property.

if I ever do get to that point, I’ll make arrangements to reduce my assets or put them in trust for the children so IHT limits are not exceeded.

inheritances are easily solved by writing a will and sorting in advance.

Fifteenth · 07/01/2024 13:06

MakingUpTheNumbers · 07/01/2024 09:57

I agree r.e. marriage/civil partnership and how it makes sense for most couples and provides security and benefits for both halves.

For us, for a variety of reasons it doesn't bring the same level of advantages.

That said, we've just read this post together and have decided that we're going to get married. Definitely not because of the NYE comments but because we've talked about it on and off for the last year or so .......kinda in the same vein as we talked about decorating the living room. DP is currently painting the ceiling in there so while we're on a roll of making 2023 plans happen we might as well make it 2 for 2! 😂

Now for the most important part of the day's decisions......will it be a celebratory sausage roll or steak bake?

Congratulations

great news!

Fifteenth · 07/01/2024 13:05

You are not being unreasonable.

But your DP is being unreasonable in not marrying you.

wronginalltherightways · 07/01/2024 13:02

Not being married is going to cost you when one of you dies because that is how UK law is set up re inheritances.

I'd quietly get married, tbh.

RB68 · 07/01/2024 12:59

well you are not a member of the family so you can call him out and tell him you are glad not to be related to suck a knobhead. Shame that it means the rest of them are not related - all for the sake of a bit of paper. Married doesn't make you part of the family - but it sounds like the rest of them think the exact opposite. I would just utterly ignore him and speak to everyone else and get on with life. Revenge is a life best lived despite his arsiness

JG4 · 07/01/2024 12:47

Not related to your question , but I just had a thought : do you know that in the event of his death you would not inherit anything or be protected in any way ? Lots of people in this country believe that after a certain number of years there is a thing called a ‘common law marriage ‘ , no such thing exists . Same applies in the event of separation. I just thought I would let you know , just in case xx

betterangels · 07/01/2024 12:45

TheOriginalFrench · 07/01/2024 08:28

Presumably your wills, pensions, life insurance, etc, all take account of the fact you’re not married and need to make specific instructions about what must follow if ‘anything happens’ to either of you?

Because as you’ve seen, at times of heightened emotion, or at legal checkpoints, you may find yourselves in difficulty.

Do you know, here and now, whether you’d be the person who gets to decide what happens to your partner in a medical crisis?

These are very good points.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 07/01/2024 12:44

Normally I would say rise above it too.. but I think he mistakenly hoped that everyone would join in. I think the fact that the kids all liked you made him really jealous. They were being more affectionate towards him than you. Drunk or not - he knew what he was saying and that it would hurt. He's signalled that he thinks you have lower status and are fair game for picking on.

So I don't understand why he should be allowed to get away with it...If there is any awkwardness arising, it is caused by him. If he's allowed to say things like that to you in front of the whole family, he will feel safe continue until you feel forced to stop going to family gatherings. It's unjust. Your children shouldn't have to hear him saying things like that.
Also usually I'd say speak to him yourself.. but in this case I think you DH needs to take him to one side first before you do, if you still feel you need to after that. It's not arguing. It's saying his behavior was insulting and unacceptable and will not be tolerated, no debate. I feel sorry for the MIL who did apologise to you and could see it was unacceptable. It's good that the rest of the family doesn't share his horrible views. Sorry you had to go through that but its great that you have support from your DH and others who recognise this nonsense for what it is.

CleansUpButWouldPreferNotTo · 07/01/2024 12:40

Pencilltime · 07/01/2024 11:02

You cannot have your cake and eat it. You are not married so you are not part of the family. If you don’t like it, change it.

^ this is nonsense!

Steak bake, apple turnover, and champagne for @MakingUpTheNumbers

jiggyjiggyjig · 07/01/2024 12:33

The biggest reason I got married was in case something happened to them DP now DH. His assets would have been subject to IT were we not married.

madeinmanc · 07/01/2024 12:30

23 years and he comes out with that! What an absolute arse 😒

As someone else said, he's probably the type that would never see you as belonging even if married.

Don't do anything more for him, ever, and if he questions it, remind him of his words.

wellhello24 · 07/01/2024 12:28

Pencilltime · 07/01/2024 11:02

You cannot have your cake and eat it. You are not married so you are not part of the family. If you don’t like it, change it.

Bullshit. Marriage is not the only thing that makes you family. Being with someone 23 years and having children with them definitely counts. Get back to the 1950s with your silly comment

Anniegetyourgun · 07/01/2024 12:25

TempleOfBloom · 07/01/2024 10:14

Just to counter the ‘get marriage for the protection’ parrots on MN:

Marriage isn’t always a protection for a woman. If she earns far more. If she has saved a much bigger pension. If she saved and bought property and built up equity in a house and he didn’t. If she works, kept up her earning power, and the kids no longer need expensive childcare costs.

What does marriage offer such a woman that cannot be covered by a separate arrangement? And to address which risk that is more likely to happen than divorce which affects a far greater % of couples?

No one can say it’s better to get married unless they know the circumstances.

You're right about circumstances making a difference. For example I'd have been much better off if I hadn't married. But that's hindsight. At the time it made sense to protect then-H and any children that came along (plus I had an old-fashioned upbringing). I guess though after 23 years OP will be in a better position to know what the risks are as well as the advantages in their own situation. She's going for it, but there isn't the huge advantage or disadvantage that may affect other couples.

Daffodilsandtuplips · 07/01/2024 12:18

You could be pedantic and point out to him that he’s correct, you aren’t biologically a member of his family and by the same token neither are his sons/daughters in law. A piece of paper doesn’t make them any more related to him than you are.
However your children share both yours and DH’s DNA, just like his other grandchildren do from their parents. So by that token you actually are entitled to be treated with as much respect as the married ones are.

Rude people use the excuse of being a drunken arsehole to lob verbal grenades in and stand well back to enjoy the fallout. They then claim not to remember “I didn’t mean it, I was pissed”
Well, if it’s affecting their memory they need to stop getting so pissed then

Anniegetyourgun · 07/01/2024 12:18

Nonomono · 07/01/2024 10:35

That said, we've just read this post together and have decided that we're going to get married.

So you’ve been together for 23 years and all of those 23 years you’ve both been adamant that you don’t want to get married.

Then in under 2 hours you’ve decided that you definitely are getting married (not even going to discuss it for a few days) and want to light heartedly talk about wedding plans.

There is obviously a backstory here (perhaps you wanted to get married but DP refused) and it sounds like FIL’s comments were very valid.

OP never said they were "adamant" they didn't want to get married. Read her very first paragraph in which she says something quite different. Later in the thread she says they had in fact been talking about it as a maybe to-do during last year. So no, not suddenly deciding against what they'd always believed, but just having a nudge to get round to it at last. No backstory, just a front story open to all to read.

Swipe left for the next trending thread