Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

unruly kids

110 replies

xxxJess123xxx · 06/01/2024 21:05

hi all my kids are just turned 8 and just turned 5, oldest girl and youngest boy.

their behaviour is actually driving me to depression and I genuinely cannot cope.
it starts from the moment they wake. DD won't get out of bed, dressed, teeth you name it, so won't do it. iv tried numerous punishments and it works for an hour then back to square one. She can be rude, defiant and answers back. Pushes the boundaries constantly. Talks in an annoying deep loud voice (purposely) when over excited, which is constantly.
Is apparently an angel at school and doing well in all areas, excelling actually so its obviously just me.

DS is an absolute nightmare. Taking him to the shops sees him run off, pick things up from the shelves, not listen, I tell him off or hold him hand so you throws himself around/on the floor and screams blue murder. I have had people tut and huff and stare at me which is actually soul destroying.
Indoors he runs full pelt everywhere, does front flips on the sofa, is so loud and doesn't listen to a word I say. Again I have tried all sorts of punishments, time out in room, taking toys away, taking weekend screen time away (not allowed any Monday to Friday as makes behaviour 10x worse) but again nothing works.
I have even tried the over the top love bombing parenting but it only works for a short time and it just back fires in my face.

Together, they fight constantly, with hitting, kicking, shoving and slamming doors in faces. Just before bed is the worse, with them genuinely acting possessed running and fighting.

No one wants to come round and see me.
I hate taking them anywhere
I hate being at home.
im so embarrassed by how much I have failed as a parent.
I just feel like I am slowly loosing my mind.
I have a husband, he works long hours. I work school hours. They behave the exact same for him.

Im so sorry for the essay and writing it all on here but I don't know how to carry on xx

OP posts:
Spomsored · 07/01/2024 05:56

xxxJess123xxx · 07/01/2024 00:23

I do give clear explanations before heading into the shops. I say, I would like you to be a good boy and hold mummy’s hand please when we are in the shop it just doesn’t go in.
I understand completely the mentality of positive parenting, but when your children are unruly nearly all the time, what is there to praise

The problem is "being a good boy" is a bit vague. "You will hold my hand" or "Hold onto the trolley" is clear and specific and you can concentrate on that particular action. If he manages that you have something to praise (you may have to ignore something else, like being loud, but focus on anything he has done well).

Similarly with your daughter in the morning - break the process into steps then you can work on one thing at a time. Perhaps you can make a chart together (get up when told, eat breakfast, get dressed, brush teeth, put on shoes and coat etc) so she has input into what needs to be done. You may decide to focus on one or two actions each week, reward with praise and stickers and ignore any 'bad' behaviours. Rewards need to be small at first but with the possibility of a bigger treat that can be earned.

You're obviously trying hard but it isn't really working so you need to try another approach

mathanxiety · 07/01/2024 04:51

xxxJess123xxx · 07/01/2024 00:23

I do give clear explanations before heading into the shops. I say, I would like you to be a good boy and hold mummy’s hand please when we are in the shop it just doesn’t go in.
I understand completely the mentality of positive parenting, but when your children are unruly nearly all the time, what is there to praise

The language here is insufficient.

You're asking "please".
You're saying "I would like you to..."

You need to get down to his level, look him straight in the eye and tell him that you "expect" him to hold your hand at all times in the supermarket and that you and he will both go straight home if this doesn't happen. Then you require verbal acknowledgement of what you said - he needs to repeat your words.

Do not use the word please. Issue direct instructions and sound like a woman who takes herself seriously.

Leave the supermarket immediately if he breaks the deal. Abandon your trolley. Go home. Tell him why.

LivingFire · 07/01/2024 03:54

I so relate to you OP. It’s so debilitating and I can barely go anywhere for fear of what they’ll do. Just last week DD threw her favourite weasel puppet down a well at a family wedding. Ruined the whole weekend and we had to go home immediately

User373533 · 07/01/2024 01:26

No advice but just wanted to say I relate 100%, and it is reassuring to read tbh, as all I seem to see in public is calm and patient parents with children who aren't draining the life out of them. Myself and DH are starting to feel depressed with the stress of the constant fighting between them and their constant loud voices, defiance etc. One does have diagnosed ADHD, but a diagnosis hasn't fixed anything at home. Both behave very well in school too (the one with the diagnosis did display obvious ADHD in school when younger but has matured enough to hold it together at school now, but not anywhere else).

Dragonflyhelper · 07/01/2024 01:12

I did go to a parenting class when my first was about 2 just so I would have a few strings in my bow ahead of time. We can always learn more and we all have unexpected things happen.

One piece of advice I liked is you don't have to give immediate consequences when something happens and you're not sure what your discipline response should be. You can always say "I am going to have to think about what the consequences of this are going to be" or "Dad and I need to talk about what your consequences should be".

It gives you time to calm down and think things over and maybe get imput from others, because sometimes in the moment we do draw a blank.
For some kids just saying that will get them worried and it's good to let them sweat for a while! You just need to make sure you DO follow up with a consequence, otherwise your kids will learn you are full of sh**.

This article explains about how all behavior had a consequence, natural or otherwise.

A natural consequence is your kid forgets their football kit and you don't take it to practice for them (some parents would never do this anyway, but if your kid is lazy, they are less likely to forget their kit again if they have to run around in their clothes or are benched for the session).

centerforparentingeducation.org/library-of-articles/discipline-topics/consequences-made-easy/

xxxJess123xxx · 07/01/2024 01:07

Baking ok I will ask the school. I’m so done

OP posts:
Bakingwithmyboys · 07/01/2024 00:51

Yes they absolutely can be angels at school and nightmares at home. It may not be ADHD but do talk to the school about it. A good teacher/SENCo may be able to pick up on other little bits in the classroom that are parts of the puzzle.

As a teacher I hear about it a lot. Sometimes it's down to the relationships in the family (yours sounds strained as you are drained from their behaviour - which is understandable) sometimes there is an additional need.

School can also get you signed up to early access.

SequoiaTree · 07/01/2024 00:50

Useruser1212 · 06/01/2024 23:53

Instead of trying 'various punishments' why not try positive reinforcement? So when they do behave well (without being asked), really affirm it with them and let them know that you're proud of them (without being too obvious or over the top). Psychologists will tell you that research shows you get the desired behaviour faster with rewards than you do punishment. It's just trial and error figuring out what rewards they respond best to.

Agree with this. It really works.
Two books I found useful are Little Angels by Dr Tanya Byron and Divas and Dictators by Charlie Taylor.

xxxJess123xxx · 07/01/2024 00:46

Deep, I have read bits on ADHD which describe him to a t at home but he is perfect at school, is that the case that they can be fine at school and crazy at home x

OP posts:
Dragonflyhelper · 07/01/2024 00:41

@xxxJess123xxx I would read stuff about ADHD but my 20 yr old dd was recently diagnosed as an adult and she was never out of control, abusive or disrespectful in any meaningful way (every kid has their moments), however she was the 5 yr that couldn't get up! 😂😂 and was always my most unusual one, as if she was dancing to a different tune.

I have a lot of empathy for you, you have a lot on your plate and it must be so stressful.
I would just start with ONE thing that is a priority for you that you want to see change in your kid(s). It takes a least 3 weeks to develop a new habit, get that ingrained before you move on. It will take some time and dedication to turn this ship around.

What is your NUMBER ONE priority for your peace of mind right now so we can troubleshoot with you?

coxesorangepippin · 07/01/2024 00:33

Can you avoid taking them to the shops? Go alone? If you can't change the behaviour, change the situation

They need more outdoor exercise, rain or shine

whiteboardking · 07/01/2024 00:31

ADHD. Buy the book 'how not to murder your ADHD child'
Great for ideas to change this

xxxJess123xxx · 07/01/2024 00:23

I do give clear explanations before heading into the shops. I say, I would like you to be a good boy and hold mummy’s hand please when we are in the shop it just doesn’t go in.
I understand completely the mentality of positive parenting, but when your children are unruly nearly all the time, what is there to praise

OP posts:
Moier · 07/01/2024 00:12

ADHD. My daughter was the same.. never realised until she's now nearly 40 and just got diagnosed herself.. but her consultant contacted me and asked me questions about her childhood.. this took two hours.. looking back now and with more knowledge about ADHD..I can now see she had it from being a child.

Dragonflyhelper · 07/01/2024 00:09

Every parent has hellian days when all you can say as your head hits the pillow (or you hit the whisky) is "everyone fed, nobody dead".

N4ish · 07/01/2024 00:05

Well, your punishment approach isn’t working so maybe you need to try something different. Your children sound very disconnected from you and acting out in an attempt to get some kind of reaction so I think that’s what you need to work on.

I agree with previous posters suggesting a parenting course and also recommend Janet Lansbury and Dr Laura Markham. Found both very useful when I was going through challenging times with my kids.

Bladwdoda · 07/01/2024 00:04

op you have my sympathies. I struggle with my kids at times. They are either getting on amazingly well or awfully. I used to run a parenting course, but that hasn’t made me immune from struggling…though it has helped me with different ideas to try out etc.

I think you need to shift your mindset from “I have failed” to “what can I (and my husband) do to make life easier and nicer for our children and family”.

Are there any practical things you can do to make life easier?
Things I have found have worked for us are…
*DH and I splitting up kids at the weekend and each taking one with us for half the day so they get a break from each other.
*Using to do lists boards for each child that they can tick of things as they do them in the morning.
*Reducing/managing screen time, particularly for youngest who seems to go wild if she has too much (we’ve not been as successful as we need to be at this).
*Making extra massive effort to model what behaviour I want to see from them, and pointing out when they do nice things for each other.
*working to keep myself calm and focused on getting the best outcome with the kids rather than just punishing for the sake of punishment.

A parenting course is a great idea, even if only to pick up a few extra ideas. the weirdest one I picked up from leading the course was from a mum of a teenager who used a gong to call her kids down for food. She hated shouting up to them and being ignored, the kids hated her shouting at them so she now used a gong. Bit of fun for them all and avoids shouting.

Also though op try to find time for yourself, keep yourself as well and recharged as you can. Things are always easier if your own tank is as full as possible.

JMSA · 06/01/2024 23:55

That sounds so hard Flowers
I'd never stare at you or tut.

Dragonflyhelper · 06/01/2024 23:55

Also be very clear about what expectations are and explain/model it before it happens.

For example when we were going to visit somewhere before we arrived or went in I would sit in the car and ask them how a good guest behaves.

If they were baffled I would say: "saying please and thank you", "picking up after yourself" "sharing" "being friendly" etc etc. If they all behaved well I.would tell them afterwards how proud I was of them give them big hugs and point out certain things they did that were great "I saw you took your dirty dish into the kitchen" "I saw you being so kind to the little brother" etc. etc.

Kids are often a lot more clueless than we realize and need very clear expectations. It's also much easier to discipline if the boundaries and expectations were clearly explained beforehand and they asked questions and agreed they understood what to do and how to behave before you start.

Also the natural consequences of bad behavior somewhere fun are the child leaves immediately. Sometimes this is harder on you than them but it's the only way they learn that you mean it.

Useruser1212 · 06/01/2024 23:53

Instead of trying 'various punishments' why not try positive reinforcement? So when they do behave well (without being asked), really affirm it with them and let them know that you're proud of them (without being too obvious or over the top). Psychologists will tell you that research shows you get the desired behaviour faster with rewards than you do punishment. It's just trial and error figuring out what rewards they respond best to.

notvirginiawoolf · 06/01/2024 23:52

123 magic great book which gives lots of practical suggestions. It's easy to implement and gives you strategies and phrases to use at the most difficult times. It also helps you understand why your children might be behaving how they are and most importantly your role in their behaviour. Good luck.

eatpiedrinktea · 06/01/2024 23:45

I have no words of wisdom but i hope it gets better.
Your not the only one going through this there are plenty of mums and dads going through it.
Do see a GP for yourself.
My son is an adult now but i know how hard them days were.
Your doing your best but think you fail your doing a grate job.
People staring huffing and tutting look at them and say you never kids then or want a pitcher!!!

Dragonflyhelper · 06/01/2024 23:40

Yes I started something called the "Heart Chart" when my middle dd was 5 as she was hell on earth getting out of bed in the morning and I had an 8 yr old to get to school too and a toddler.

I explained to all the kids that if they did certain behaviors (I started with getting up and ready for school on time as that was the major issue) they could put a sticky heart for that day on the weekly chart I made. If they made it to 3 or 5 days they got a reward (I started with very small achievable goals and small rewards such as sweets). I then had stages of achievement up to if they changed that behavior it for a month or more they got to go out with mummy or daddy ALONE and have ice cream.

TBH I had very little faith it would work but it had a magical affect on my 5 yr old and she absolutely LOVED it. Years later she was still asking if we could do the Heart Chart again.

It's very important to understand that behavior you give attention to (even negative attention) you will see more of.
So you need to "catch them being good" and shower them with attention while ignoring bad behavior or if you can't ignore it (bad behavior in a shop) you don't start screaming, freaking out etc etc but stay incredibly boring and inexpressive but remove the child from the situation.
Bad behavior should get natural consequences as much as possible.

Be very honest with yourself and think about if you are showing the most attention to your kids when they are badly behaved and ignoring their good and peaceful/cooperative behavior by not rewarding it with smiles, hugs "thank yous" etc.

Whenever one of my kids would act up I would think about what we were doing as parents. Sure enough most at the time we unwittingly were only giving this kid our full attention when they were behaving badly. So our own change of behavior was essential.

Strictly1 · 06/01/2024 23:25

School can get you signed up for a parenting course - we have TACs (team around the child). Parenting is hard. Taking action now, which will be hard, will be well worth it. You don’t want a 15 year old, possibly bigger than you, hitting you if they don’t get their own way. Good luck

sonicmum2002 · 06/01/2024 23:19

Have you tried star charts and rewards for good behaviour, eg no hitting?