Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

unruly kids

110 replies

xxxJess123xxx · 06/01/2024 21:05

hi all my kids are just turned 8 and just turned 5, oldest girl and youngest boy.

their behaviour is actually driving me to depression and I genuinely cannot cope.
it starts from the moment they wake. DD won't get out of bed, dressed, teeth you name it, so won't do it. iv tried numerous punishments and it works for an hour then back to square one. She can be rude, defiant and answers back. Pushes the boundaries constantly. Talks in an annoying deep loud voice (purposely) when over excited, which is constantly.
Is apparently an angel at school and doing well in all areas, excelling actually so its obviously just me.

DS is an absolute nightmare. Taking him to the shops sees him run off, pick things up from the shelves, not listen, I tell him off or hold him hand so you throws himself around/on the floor and screams blue murder. I have had people tut and huff and stare at me which is actually soul destroying.
Indoors he runs full pelt everywhere, does front flips on the sofa, is so loud and doesn't listen to a word I say. Again I have tried all sorts of punishments, time out in room, taking toys away, taking weekend screen time away (not allowed any Monday to Friday as makes behaviour 10x worse) but again nothing works.
I have even tried the over the top love bombing parenting but it only works for a short time and it just back fires in my face.

Together, they fight constantly, with hitting, kicking, shoving and slamming doors in faces. Just before bed is the worse, with them genuinely acting possessed running and fighting.

No one wants to come round and see me.
I hate taking them anywhere
I hate being at home.
im so embarrassed by how much I have failed as a parent.
I just feel like I am slowly loosing my mind.
I have a husband, he works long hours. I work school hours. They behave the exact same for him.

Im so sorry for the essay and writing it all on here but I don't know how to carry on xx

OP posts:
xxxJess123xxx · 07/01/2024 22:59

Their reaction to the praise tbh was really good. They had huge smiles. I think it’s going to take a lot of getting used to as default I just have to correct bad behaviour all day long and miss any tiny bits of good which I should be praising

my own childhood was shouting and being hit unfortunately. I shout but have never hit my kids

OP posts:
Dragonflyhelper · 07/01/2024 22:33

@xxxJess123xxx if you have struggled to praise them and you start doing it more (while being firm when you need to) I wouldn't be surprised if you get a very positive reaction, everyone loves to be appreciated. It may seem so obvious how to behave to us but children need to be shown and told over and over.

Also if screaming and fighting gets your attention but calmly playing you ignore, you will get more of the stuff you give your energy and attention to.

It may have been only 5 minutes of sitting nicely but that is where you start: small. Give him a big hug when he does it and tell him how much you enjoy being around him when he is calm so he understands what he doing right.

Just aim for small increases, 5 minutes to 7 minutes etc. Gradually that will lengthen as he is positively reinforced.

Don't let yourself get sucked into negative drama with them, separate them and tell them when they can calm down you will all do something they enjoy together and you will wait until then.

The teachers they love may be able to give you some useful pointers too as they obviously constantly deal with challenging behavior.

What was your own parenting like @xxxJess123xxx ?

00100001 · 07/01/2024 22:01

xxxJess123xxx · 07/01/2024 20:34

Math, thank you for your reply. That really is helpful with some practical advice in how to put things into practice

i tried this evening with more praising. Well done for sitting nicely (5 mins but still lol) and he combed his sisters hair which I said well done that was very nice.

vitrio, yes my daughter is a big fan of the teacher. She looks up to her and teachers says she wishes all her kiddos were as lovely and well behaved as her which is ironic as she can be so awful at home. so yes, speaking to the teacher could work

i like the idea of a marble into a jar, i bet they would love that.

That's great you found some good stuff to praise.

What was their immediate response to the praise?

00100001 · 07/01/2024 21:59

Gentle parenting is not permissive parenting. You can be the "ultimate authority" in your child's life... without using food as bribery or using threats to make them comply. You can be the authority whilst also understanding that children are living thinking feeling people that can't always emotionally regulate nor can they always express themselves properly and giving them the tools and opportunities to do the right thing etc.

It's not "ohhhhhhh noooowww Johnny kiiiiiiiiind hands baby. Don't hit baby sister in the face.boo hooo it hurts".

It's "no. We don't hit." and remove the child or baby from the violence. But ideally the parent will be able to prevent the child reaching breaking point in the first place. The child who hits is doing this for attention. The child who lashes out in anger or frustration is a child not having their needs met on some level. So to actually punish a small child for having a lack of control of emotions isn't ideal.
All a fear based/authoritarian relationship leads to is a failure to express your negative emotions in front of that figure of fear. They will hide things that they accidentally broke. They will hit people when the person can't see. They will lie to get out of trouble etc. and I can guarantee there's someone reading this going "huh.. whatever. My parents did this to me and I'm just fine" meanwhile they are doing thing alike dropping a glass and going "oh shit shit shit ..and trying to clear it up before anyone notices" or sitting there in seething silence whilst some upsets or angers then or finds it really hard to admit to people they're sad/feeling low. You don't feel like you can tell anyone you're being abused by your DH... you etc. this is because they learned from very young age that one people don't care to notice you're struggling and two when you do express a negative feeling/emotion you will be punished for it. So you learn to keep quiet, you learn to lie, you learn to keep the peace for fear of recrimination.

xxxJess123xxx · 07/01/2024 20:34

Math, thank you for your reply. That really is helpful with some practical advice in how to put things into practice

i tried this evening with more praising. Well done for sitting nicely (5 mins but still lol) and he combed his sisters hair which I said well done that was very nice.

vitrio, yes my daughter is a big fan of the teacher. She looks up to her and teachers says she wishes all her kiddos were as lovely and well behaved as her which is ironic as she can be so awful at home. so yes, speaking to the teacher could work

i like the idea of a marble into a jar, i bet they would love that.

OP posts:
mathanxiety · 07/01/2024 19:57

xxxJess123xxx · 07/01/2024 10:32

Math, he would love to not go to the supermarket so I’m sure, if I tell him that we will leave straight away if he does xyz, I guarantee he will do xyz.
I never do a full shop, I popped into the shop yesterday to get a kettle as mine had broken that day.

the reward for listening is not getting bloody told off. He’s already been in his room this morning but smacking his sister in the face. Tell me how you gentle parent that

I'm not a fan of gentle parenting. I'm a fan of laying down the law and having the last word.

I do not advocate using the word Please to children who are headstrong or inclined to think they are in charge and what you say doesn't count. It gives them the wrong idea.

Another consequence for misbehaviour in the supermarket is the complete lack of any snacks or favourite breakfast cereals for the child who misbehaves, if leaving without the groceries is a victory for him. A reminder of the reason why there are no Rice Krispies or whatever every time he asks for them might be salutary. Order what you need for yourself and the rest of the family.

I do urge you to make them do chores. Children who spend their time fighting and bouncing around on the furniture and misbehaving when out are very possibly bored and lacking in self esteem. Doing chores together with you teaching them how is also a way to bond. Stickers or marbles in a reward jar for chores can be motivators. You can introduce the concept of the family working together as a team too, with a bonus reward of some nice family activity as a reward.

Part of the chore regime could be DS helping you find certain grocery items or doing a grocery bingo card in the supermarket - checking off your list as you go round. Is he too big to sit in the trolley?

For the constant fighting, it's important to have a zero tolerance policy.
Pull over and stop driving if they fight in the car. Tell them you'll get going again when there is perfect silence. Let them rip. Do not try to intervene except to tell them it's their choice whether you get home or not.
At home, step in and stop fights immediately. Pull them apart and restrain them if necessary. You need to demonstrate physical strength.
When there is a quiet time, insist they come up with better ideas for dispute resolution. Wait for them to verbalise their ideas. Write these down. Put their list of ways to resolve disputes on a wall.

You might find that holding family meetings weekly to review behaviour in the last week and set expectations for the coming week would help. The kids would have their chance to speak too, assessing their own performance.

Vitriolinsanity · 07/01/2024 17:38

I don't have many pearls, but I sympathise enormously and certainly wouldn't tut at you.

Would a little reverse psychology work? Your DD loves school, could you get the teacher onside to get the whole class talking about their "get up and out" routine. Dangle the notion that children who do, have a much better day etc. As I child I did EVERYTHING a teacher said, might that work? At the door the teacher asks if she got up and did? Massive praise if so, sad face and better luck tomorrow if not.

Examine the pinch points. Knock shopping on the head, as it's clearly a source of friction. Then talk long and loudly about what a shame it is you can't go together anymore as it would've been nice to go to feed the ducks afterwards. Shame that couldn't happen etc...

Also, sign them up for AS clubs. Gym, ju-jitsu etc wear them out totally. Then tag team for when you get home. Pity you couldn't have had ice cream, but you know, you blew it by bickering in the car. Sad face, bet we can do it better next time etc

00100001 · 07/01/2024 14:52

xxxJess123xxx · 07/01/2024 14:46

Iv brought them to the park this morning after the smacking incident

a good run around while I was freezing cold but I’m trying
as soon as we are back in the car they are fighting and screaming
it’s very hard
I’ll try more praising but it doesn’t come naturally

Well, they're not going to magically change their learned behaviour in a short few hours.

Well done for getting them out.

There were probably a few opportunities to praise them going to the park, for example;

  • getting ready to go out e.g. putting on shoes quickly etc
  • waiting for you to do something like.. get the parking ticket.
  • getting in/out of the car nicely
  • playing with each other nicely at some point
  • leaving the park without complaints

You have to REALLY look hard. But they will have done some good stuff.

As for the fighting in the car, hmm I'd try and keep them out there longer! They obviously weren't worn out enough!

Next time, perhaps try to go for a walk/run/scoot/explore together so you're moving as well, so you don't get so cold. Can you walk to the park?

xxxJess123xxx · 07/01/2024 14:46

Iv brought them to the park this morning after the smacking incident

a good run around while I was freezing cold but I’m trying
as soon as we are back in the car they are fighting and screaming
it’s very hard
I’ll try more praising but it doesn’t come naturally

OP posts:
FannyFarts · 07/01/2024 14:21

It sounds like you’ve all got into a negative cycle. Do you reward and praise them when they are good? Give lots of attention when they are good?

00100001 · 07/01/2024 12:25

xxxJess123xxx · 07/01/2024 10:32

Math, he would love to not go to the supermarket so I’m sure, if I tell him that we will leave straight away if he does xyz, I guarantee he will do xyz.
I never do a full shop, I popped into the shop yesterday to get a kettle as mine had broken that day.

the reward for listening is not getting bloody told off. He’s already been in his room this morning but smacking his sister in the face. Tell me how you gentle parent that

Well, clearly the way you're going about focusing on punishment isn't working.

It depends on why he smacked her. What led up to that event? Did smacking her result in your undivided attention? Were you drawn from something else?

How much positive 1 to 1 time do your kids get with you? Because kids will seek attention, negative if needed, if they aren't getting enough.

00100001 · 07/01/2024 12:23

xxxJess123xxx · 07/01/2024 10:32

Math, he would love to not go to the supermarket so I’m sure, if I tell him that we will leave straight away if he does xyz, I guarantee he will do xyz.
I never do a full shop, I popped into the shop yesterday to get a kettle as mine had broken that day.

the reward for listening is not getting bloody told off. He’s already been in his room this morning but smacking his sister in the face. Tell me how you gentle parent that

That's crazy... Your reward is not getting punished???

Imagine your life right now. Every tiny thing that was wrong got punished and you had zero reassurance you were doing the right thing...and you're a child and need your mum to help you learn.

And all she does is punish you for things you do wrong with no recognition of the things you're doing right.

xxxJess123xxx · 07/01/2024 10:32

Math, he would love to not go to the supermarket so I’m sure, if I tell him that we will leave straight away if he does xyz, I guarantee he will do xyz.
I never do a full shop, I popped into the shop yesterday to get a kettle as mine had broken that day.

the reward for listening is not getting bloody told off. He’s already been in his room this morning but smacking his sister in the face. Tell me how you gentle parent that

OP posts:
FannyFarts · 07/01/2024 09:02

Totally agree with the comments about giving them your full attention and listening, also employ and exhaust.

Fivebyfive2 · 07/01/2024 09:01

Taking a parenting course doesn't mean you have failed! I have a ds who is 4 and currently being assessed for autism. He's technically very well behaved, but has issues with anxiety, transitions, routine etc. He's very high energy and listening isn't always His strong suit. The nursery manager recommended a parenting course to us that she has taken a variation of 3 times to help with her kids through different stages of development. We looked into it and plan to sign up next month. I don't think we're failing as parents but we do sometimes feel out of our depth and maybe some different perspectives/extra advice could really help.

Dragonflyhelper · 07/01/2024 08:59

@rumbypumby or as my MIL used to say "I'll take them outside and run them".

rumbypumby · 07/01/2024 08:52

Just to add, I would make sure each gets at least 10 mins 121 with you most days. Actually listen to them when they talk about something they are interested in and engage. I felt like sometimes a lot of the behaviour was attention seeking and also notice when my kids feel close and connected the behaviour you describe is less so.

I would recommend the incredible years book, and also 15 minute parenting.

rumbypumby · 07/01/2024 08:50

Mine are similar ages and youngest has adhd so I can relate to that feeling of dread taking them anywhere.

My best days are when I "employ and exhaust" them - get them to help you with things, wear them out, get out even if it's raining (especially when it's raining for my kids! They love being in nature and getting dirty). Give them meaningful jobs in the house, give them tasks that involve helping each other etc.

In the shop let your 5yo use the scanner or carry something 'heavy' for you. Let your oldest read off the list and the little one gets the item puts it in the trolley.

Limit screen time and GET OUTSIDE. The weather doesn't stop us. Mine need to be walked at least once daily 😆

A big one that helped me was to say yes to everything you can, so they know you mean it when you say no. For example, whenever my kids asked to play with play doh or paint or go out and jump
In the puddles I would think of the mess and tidy up after and say no. Then it felt like i was always saying no and they didn't really hear "no" anymore. I now say yes to everything, they help with clean up and chores like hoovering, dishes, washing and cooking. It's worth it because now they know when I say no to something, i mean it. And if you set a punishment/consequence you MUST stick to it. Very very important.

RudolphsFriend · 07/01/2024 08:48

I know it’s not always a popular opinion but I’d watch a few Super Nanny episodes, there’s tons on YouTube.
Get some new ideas, get some techniques and see what works for you.

00100001 · 07/01/2024 08:44

xxxJess123xxx · 07/01/2024 00:23

I do give clear explanations before heading into the shops. I say, I would like you to be a good boy and hold mummy’s hand please when we are in the shop it just doesn’t go in.
I understand completely the mentality of positive parenting, but when your children are unruly nearly all the time, what is there to praise

They can't be naughty all the time.

They clearly do get dressed... Praise
They clearly sit down and eat dinner... Praise
They absolutely do have periods of quiet at some point... Praise
They obviously come with you to the shops and other places, so when they're sitting in car with seatbelts or whatever... Praise
Doing a nice bit of reading/colouring/craft/playtime... praise

You have to notice the small positives they do and heavily praise those. It's really hard. But every tiny thing they do right is to be praised.
Yes DD pissed around and took ages to get dressed, but she got dressed, so instead of punishing her for pissing around, remind yourself that she did what was asked, praise her. Be specific "thank you for getting dressed, now we're ready to go. Next time we'll hopefully have more time to do X"

Keep an eye out for it. And praise!

00100001 · 07/01/2024 08:40

xxxJess123xxx · 07/01/2024 00:23

I do give clear explanations before heading into the shops. I say, I would like you to be a good boy and hold mummy’s hand please when we are in the shop it just doesn’t go in.
I understand completely the mentality of positive parenting, but when your children are unruly nearly all the time, what is there to praise

So what's the 'reward' for listening?

You can't just punish all the damn time.

Imagine if that was your life, every single thing you did wrong got punished, but nothing you do right got rewarded in any way.

It's a change in mindset so, you need say things like "I need you to hold my hand, so we can shop quickly, then we will have enough time to go to the park" Rather than "you didn't hold my hand you can't go to the park"

FannyFarts · 07/01/2024 08:28

all behaviour is communication. The hitting and poor behaviour in shops is telling you something very clearly. What can you do differently? Can you have a break from visiting shops to break the negative routine and order online? After a couple of months break could you trial a short shop but ask him to help, make it into a game where he helps you find items from a very very short shopping list. Lots of praise. In and out of the shop quickly with 5 items.

Phopet · 07/01/2024 08:23

No advice but solidarity! 8 and 6 year old boys fight constantly, won’t do anything they’re asked and are a general nightmare at home and out. Add a 2 year old to the mix who has tantrum after tantrum. The 3 of them are like feral animals, jump all over the furniture and scream at each other all day long! I can’t cope, feel I’ve lost all control and just generally hate my life most days.

FannyFarts · 07/01/2024 08:16

Whatever the weather, come rain or shine get them outside for an hour or two daily. Wear waterproofs and jump in puddles. Also consider climbing lessons, bouldering, swimming, bowling, ice skating, also football and gymnastics clubs. Your boy needs to expel his energy. More exercise may make earlier bedtimes easier?

An earlier bedtime for the girl (not as a punishment but so she feels refreshed in the morning). An earlier start, so she can have a cuppa in bed and audible stories or cheerful radio music or radio chatter for half a hour snuggled in bed with any pets and the curtains just slightly open to let a little natural light in. Clothes on the radiator so they are warm to get into.

Bedtimes. Your husband does one child and you do the other. Bath, story, bed with lots of positive attention and chatter. Swap child each night.

Have quality 1:1 time with each child daily. Half an hour or whatever. Watching something together or baking or doing a jigsaw. Make the children feel treasured and held in positive regard. Start focusing on the things they do right. Say thsnkyou and show appreciation when they behave nicely.

Also consider how you both talk to the children and each other. A big emphasis on punishments is very negative and will naturally get a negative reaction from kids. Rewards may be more effective? A favourite tune, story, drink or programme once ready for bed. Remember to talk your children in a way that you would liked to be talked to.

Bladwdoda · 07/01/2024 07:45

xxxJess123xxx · 07/01/2024 00:46

Deep, I have read bits on ADHD which describe him to a t at home but he is perfect at school, is that the case that they can be fine at school and crazy at home x

I’ve asked for an assessment for my DD for ADHD too. I think much of our issues comes from her being very full on, very loud, but my DS being sensitive to noise and needed down now. So their needs clash and then they clash.