Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

unruly kids

110 replies

xxxJess123xxx · 06/01/2024 21:05

hi all my kids are just turned 8 and just turned 5, oldest girl and youngest boy.

their behaviour is actually driving me to depression and I genuinely cannot cope.
it starts from the moment they wake. DD won't get out of bed, dressed, teeth you name it, so won't do it. iv tried numerous punishments and it works for an hour then back to square one. She can be rude, defiant and answers back. Pushes the boundaries constantly. Talks in an annoying deep loud voice (purposely) when over excited, which is constantly.
Is apparently an angel at school and doing well in all areas, excelling actually so its obviously just me.

DS is an absolute nightmare. Taking him to the shops sees him run off, pick things up from the shelves, not listen, I tell him off or hold him hand so you throws himself around/on the floor and screams blue murder. I have had people tut and huff and stare at me which is actually soul destroying.
Indoors he runs full pelt everywhere, does front flips on the sofa, is so loud and doesn't listen to a word I say. Again I have tried all sorts of punishments, time out in room, taking toys away, taking weekend screen time away (not allowed any Monday to Friday as makes behaviour 10x worse) but again nothing works.
I have even tried the over the top love bombing parenting but it only works for a short time and it just back fires in my face.

Together, they fight constantly, with hitting, kicking, shoving and slamming doors in faces. Just before bed is the worse, with them genuinely acting possessed running and fighting.

No one wants to come round and see me.
I hate taking them anywhere
I hate being at home.
im so embarrassed by how much I have failed as a parent.
I just feel like I am slowly loosing my mind.
I have a husband, he works long hours. I work school hours. They behave the exact same for him.

Im so sorry for the essay and writing it all on here but I don't know how to carry on xx

OP posts:
momentumneeded · 08/01/2024 14:20

It's really hard parenting and working when the other parent is largely absent. So important to try and carve out some time for yourself on your own to recharge batteries. It's exhausting and relentless.

Couple of things jump out at me though (speaking as a parent/ educator) :

'Catch the good behaviour' - label and praise it. Often. Pick your battles with the bad behaviour - don't 'notice' everything but be consistent about consequences when a boundary is crossed. Give them responsibility - tasks in the home at this age. Finally - structure - they are less likely to question or fight back against strong routines. Counterbalance with a fun evening once a week when things more relaxed - maybe Fri.

I would also hugely recommend a structured team activity to embed values of teamwork and abiding by rules. Rugby is brilliant for this, especially for boys who need a physical outlet. Swimming also. You do have to physically tire them out to some degree. Maybe cubs another option as it's so value driven and outdoorsy. I would probably get them to pick one each and then that can become their 'thing'.

AnneElliott · 08/01/2024 13:24

I agree with taking them outside. I think boys in particular are like labradors who need two good walks a day in order to be able to settle.

I only have 1 so there was no sibling fighting but DS was a ball of energy that needed directing into something positive.

I also agree about finding something to praise. Don't take them to the supermarket either - it's boring for adults let alone kids! Do it online or go alone when your partner is at home.

And yes natural consequences. Bad behaviour at an event/ day out they get 1 warning and then you take them home. It's a punishment for you normally but I think I only had to do it twice.

N4ish · 08/01/2024 12:56

xxxJess123xxx · 07/01/2024 22:59

Their reaction to the praise tbh was really good. They had huge smiles. I think it’s going to take a lot of getting used to as default I just have to correct bad behaviour all day long and miss any tiny bits of good which I should be praising

my own childhood was shouting and being hit unfortunately. I shout but have never hit my kids

That's a lovely update! Hope things continue to improve. I think it's very easy to get dragged down into a negative spiral and it's takes time to learn to try and look at things in a more positive light.

TadpolesInPool · 08/01/2024 11:21

I have 2 boys with hyperactive ADHD. Once diagnosed we were appalled looking back how negative we had been with them. Always getting at them for little things (like how they hold cutlery - turns out they're dyspraxic too). No wonder they would explode every so often.

They were lovely at school but manic outside. Its the cola bottle analogy. They hold themselves so tightly at school (bottle being shaken) that when out they explode (lid taken off).

We lived in a flat and it was so hard. They had school 8am to 4pm (not UK). Then 1-2 hours in the park (depending on when it shut - hated the winter cos it shut at 5pm!). Then home. Weekends we took them out every morning and every afternoon no matter the weather (only exception was heatwave).

I highly recommend getting them out as much as possible especially allowing a run around after school. Your son needs to decompress after a hard day of sitting still and listening and obeying.

Also, decide what to have a hard line on and a soft. We let go of anything that wasn't particularly important (cutlery holding, making bed, etc) but a hard line on rough behaviour like pushing.

MamaMode · 08/01/2024 11:17

xxxJess123xxx · 06/01/2024 22:39

where would I find these parenting courses?
of course a 5 year old needs punishment. If he is hitting or punching or being rude or not listening in shops, that needs punishing

Consequences as opposed to punishment I'd say.

00100001 · 08/01/2024 11:00

But the kids are constantly punished and no improvement in behaviour is seen. Because they actually need some actual positive reinforcement. Not constant punishment.

Littlecatonthefence · 08/01/2024 10:47

00100001 · 08/01/2024 10:34

Ugh again with the focus on punishment... That clearly isn't working.also you have to give warnings of consequence, not just randomly decide what will happen.

Imagine if you never knew the consequences were any time you were late to work for any reason at all.

And in your world, they lose an iPad for an entire day for not brushing teeth? What incentive do they have to behave if they've lost the high value item over something so small???

Jesus Christ.

It's much easier to say "brush your teeth then you can play on iPad until 9:30". (In 45 minutes time) So if they spend 15 minutes brushing their teeth, then they have a natural consequence of having less time on the iPad... Something they can easily control the next time. They might be inclined to spend 3 minutes brushing teeth.

Either way the teeth are clean, there's a definite limit and no need to "punish"

But initially its trying to get a balance,

It's much easier to say "brush your teeth then you can play on iPad until 9:30". (In 45 minutes time)

This doesnt work if your rushing to get out the door for school and they need to brush teeth, pack bag, get dressed and have breakfast then walk to school all for 9am, school mornings no ipads allowed.

And yes of course we are focusing on punishment first because their behavior is quite frankly atrocious and it needs to be matched with a rather extreme push back whilst also ensuring positive praise and recognition as and when required.

Kids are not stupid, they understand bad behavior.

Imagine if you never knew the consequences were any time you were late to work for any reason at all.

Refusing to brush teeth once isnt the end of the world but this isnt what OP is talking about, shes talking about consistent bad behavior to the point its affecting her daily life....if your late to work every day you naturally know your going to get sacked.

00100001 · 08/01/2024 10:34

Littlecatonthefence · 08/01/2024 10:28

Op its really about going back to basics here.

Firstly cut out sweets, chocolate, sugar juice etc.

They now need to start understanding the consequences of their actions, for example thats fine if you dont eat your dinner/lunch/breakfast but there is absolutely nothing else to eat.

Do they have IPADS, if so use that as a punishment, eg, you dont want to brush our teeth, ok you have lost your ipad for 1 day.

Do they have any clubs/hobbies they do, try and find something they are good at and get them into a club, gymnastics/dancing/tennis/running, these clubs are a privilege so behavior permits whether they go etc.

Its really about following through on absolutely everything and being quite strict to start off with.

"Your behavior this week has been awful so you will not be going to X birthday party"

Whilst you may feel its extreme to start off with you will also need to provide alot of love and positive praise when things do go well.

" you helped mummy so much in the shops today why dont you pick a wee sweet"

"since we have had such a great week why dont we have a movie night tonight"

Ugh again with the focus on punishment... That clearly isn't working.also you have to give warnings of consequence, not just randomly decide what will happen.

Imagine if you never knew the consequences were any time you were late to work for any reason at all.

And in your world, they lose an iPad for an entire day for not brushing teeth? What incentive do they have to behave if they've lost the high value item over something so small???

Jesus Christ.

It's much easier to say "brush your teeth then you can play on iPad until 9:30". (In 45 minutes time) So if they spend 15 minutes brushing their teeth, then they have a natural consequence of having less time on the iPad... Something they can easily control the next time. They might be inclined to spend 3 minutes brushing teeth.

Either way the teeth are clean, there's a definite limit and no need to "punish"

Littlecatonthefence · 08/01/2024 10:28

Op its really about going back to basics here.

Firstly cut out sweets, chocolate, sugar juice etc.

They now need to start understanding the consequences of their actions, for example thats fine if you dont eat your dinner/lunch/breakfast but there is absolutely nothing else to eat.

Do they have IPADS, if so use that as a punishment, eg, you dont want to brush our teeth, ok you have lost your ipad for 1 day.

Do they have any clubs/hobbies they do, try and find something they are good at and get them into a club, gymnastics/dancing/tennis/running, these clubs are a privilege so behavior permits whether they go etc.

Its really about following through on absolutely everything and being quite strict to start off with.

"Your behavior this week has been awful so you will not be going to X birthday party"

Whilst you may feel its extreme to start off with you will also need to provide alot of love and positive praise when things do go well.

" you helped mummy so much in the shops today why dont you pick a wee sweet"

"since we have had such a great week why dont we have a movie night tonight"

25yearstilretirement · 08/01/2024 10:17

We have friends who have 2 kids just like this and I'm sorry to say that I am the friend who avoids seeing them when the kids are around for the same reasons.

The mum in that case is actually a primary school teacher with an excellent reputation for classroom control so I just wanted to share that it's not your fault and can happen to anyone.

They have tried parenting classes, therapy, a nanny and even time away from the kids. None of it worked. One of the kids is, however, starting to get better as he gets older - less rudeness and insane destructive behaviour coming from him these days (though the fighting and arguing back is still horrific) now he is 10. Its' not an ideal answer but it does go to show that it can improve.

hope you find a solution soon.

xxxJess123xxx · 08/01/2024 09:28

dragon, yes it feels very unfamiliar atm and probably weird for them too lol but if it helps the behaviour, im all for trying.

converse, my DD does Art Club, she's not very sporty in the slightest and has shown no interest in gymnastics etc and I wouldn't force her to do something she doesnt like.

My son does an hour of footie on a Saturday

OP posts:
converseandjeans · 08/01/2024 08:15

@xxxJess123xxx

I think it would be a huge help if he could take them out & give you some space. So maybe they go out with him for an hour Saturday morning & then go out together in the afternoon & then you give him a break Sunday morning. Or something similar.

Do the kids do any activities? Footie? Gym? Swimming? I would say mine leant loads about sharing, queuing up, waiting their turn etc from those activities. I realise they're expensive though.

It sounds like you don't get much support & haven't had a great role model from your own parents.

Dragonflyhelper · 08/01/2024 07:48

@xxxJess123xxx it's great that you don't hit your kids, it shows how you have made positive choices to not repeat behavior you knew harmed you.

It may feel very unnatural and unfamiliar to give your kids positive reinforcement and praise, because it sounds like you didn't receive it yourself.

But the more you do it, the less it will feel like you are "on" and the more automatic it will be. Seeing them respond with big smiles also is positive reinforcement for you!

xxxJess123xxx · 08/01/2024 07:00

No he doesn’t

OP posts:
converseandjeans · 08/01/2024 00:07

@xxxJess123xxx

Does DH ever take both out to give you chance to catch up at home or get anything done for yourself? He could take both swimming or something active.

xxxJess123xxx · 07/01/2024 23:58

Converse, yes we have discussed today after seeing the replies about some one on one time occasionly
he doesn’t want it to be every weekend as he says he works all week and it’s family time. I think some of it might be that when we are all together, I do the brunt whereas if he had one it’s 50:50 if you see what I mean

OP posts:
converseandjeans · 07/01/2024 23:51

We used to do marbles & they would choose the list of rewards together & it would be things like going to shop to get sweets, comic, trip to museum, treat from Poundland etc

Routine - so for example they always go to same cafe on a Friday after school. Same routine in evening every night.

Lots of time limits for getting out the house. So it's not a sudden shock. Get everything lined up night before.

Keep them busy. It's less likely they will think about messing around. Anything to tire them out.

Can you sort out play date or activity for one and spend time with the other? Also get DH to take one & you take the other to do something. They can't argue & will get lots of attention too.

The teacher probably keeps them in same routine each day & so probably manages the class that way.

Might they be bored if you don't like taking them out?

xxxJess123xxx · 07/01/2024 23:48

001 yes I’m hoping like you say it will become easier as time goes on and second nature.

scarlet, I used to read but not so much anymore because of the carnage at home. Ironically, my daughter is above expectations at school for reading so maybe I could model sitting quietly with a book but how that would go down with the whirlwind I’m not sure lol

they do like colouring, well DS for a very short time and I actually love it lol so that could be another rainy day activity I could try and really big up the praise

i will mention the hair combing again to my son tomorrow and re praise

I really appreciate all the replies

OP posts:
00100001 · 07/01/2024 23:28

xxxJess123xxx · 07/01/2024 23:15

I am pleased but daunted slightly if that makes sense. It’s seems a lot and exhausting to be “on” constantly if you see what I mean. But I’m hoping it will get better, and more second nature eventually.
it did feel good saying well done to them for a change xx

It will get easier. It's hard now because you're just starting. It would be the same as ... Learning to drive... Lots to take in, lots to learn, things to notice. When you first start driving you're wondering "how in earth will I remember how to look at the road, my wing mirrors, rear view, change gear and do it all in time to join the roundabout without stalling...aaarrrggh" but a few months later you're sailing round the roundabout swearing at a driver who didn't indicate.

Just as they will learn to behave differently... So will you. It will become normal and this time next year it will be second nature.

Scarletttulips · 07/01/2024 23:23

It sounds like they have loads of excess energy, could you take them out to parks or sign them up to clubs to burn off some energy?

I think they need to learn to sit still. Try yoga classes or quiet activities like reading - do you sit and model reading? What about a jigsaw puzzle? Sit and play a game and after a few days withdraw slowly so they learn to play nicely together?

00100001 · 07/01/2024 23:18

What I also find helpa is a random compliment to a kid. Like "DS you're really funny!"

Minglingpringle · 07/01/2024 23:18

xxxJess123xxx · 07/01/2024 22:59

Their reaction to the praise tbh was really good. They had huge smiles. I think it’s going to take a lot of getting used to as default I just have to correct bad behaviour all day long and miss any tiny bits of good which I should be praising

my own childhood was shouting and being hit unfortunately. I shout but have never hit my kids

That’s amazing. Sounds like it’s a massive mental shift for you with your history but I agree with everyone on here, I think you’re doing the right thing.

When they’re arguing with each other, I would suggest that’s one of the things you can give low attention to, as long as nobody is really the victim or getting badly hurt and they’re both being as bad each other. just tell them calmly that they shouldn’t be fighting but don’t get drawn into it emotionally, especially if you’re stuck in the car at the time.

00100001 · 07/01/2024 23:18

Be sure to make sure they get all of your attention when doing something like colouring or whatever. So if they're sitting nicely, colouring, sit with them and colour too.

Or even start some colouring in/kids puzzle/set up a board game yourself in front of the kids... If necessary pretend to struggle with the puzzle. Usually kids can't help themselves but to be drawn in to the activity and you might find yourself having a lovely time solving that 48 piece puzzle together, get them to help pack it up (praise!) and you can say how lovely it was at the time (praise)... And mention it AGAIN at dinner or the next day at breakfast or whatever how much you enjoyed the puzzle and spending that time together. (Even if the puzzle was a tedious bore lol) it was about the time together not the actual activity IYSWIM?

xxxJess123xxx · 07/01/2024 23:15

I am pleased but daunted slightly if that makes sense. It’s seems a lot and exhausting to be “on” constantly if you see what I mean. But I’m hoping it will get better, and more second nature eventually.
it did feel good saying well done to them for a change xx

OP posts:
00100001 · 07/01/2024 23:12

Well done. You can see the immediate impact on the positive reinforcement - you'll soon notice the ongoing improvement in behaviour. :)

Whenever possible ignore/grey rock the unwanted behaviour.

Set clear expectations for them both and give easily identified warnings for things like leaving the park. So maybe "one last go in the roundabout - I'll give you five pushes and when it stops it's time to go" they have your attention (in playing with them) and a clear limit to the end of play. Even if you have to gee them up a bit to leave (old classic if racing to the car etc) if they show any hints of complaining/dragging at the end of roundabout.

Swipe left for the next trending thread