Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think they are ‘𝘳𝘪𝘤𝘩’

293 replies

HansBanan · 06/01/2024 20:07

Okay, I know it's subjective but I'm some what bored of my in-laws down playing this.
My SIL is 28, well educated, 2 children, lives in London. She's married, husband is about 40, a little older maybe, a high earner (250k ish - chief investment officer for a wealth management company).
They are mortgage free, in a large beautiful house (I'm not sure of the logistics of how this is the case but know they are). 1 car, owned outright. They have credit cards but I'm sure they pay them off monthly and mainly use them for the benefits and rewards.
Their children are young so not school age yet, but it's very clearly they sill be privately educated. I'm not sure how much the bonus her husband receives would be but let's assume it's anywhere between 25k - 125k depending on the firm.
They holiday several times a year, almost always business class.

AIBU to think that is ‘𝘳𝘪𝘤𝘩’? My in-laws are all insisting that in London this is just comfortable but I don't buy it! Especially not with their mortgage free home!
I know it's not my business but it irks me

OP posts:
Strictlymad · 06/01/2024 21:29

Stinking if you ask me lol! Way more than comfortable! Having said that anyone can see them selves as ‘just about managing’ if they have high expectations and spend to the limits. If they perceive several business class holidays, designer clothes and private schooling as ‘essential’ to their lifestyle and happiness and that doesn’t leave anything at the end of the month then that will be their perception and what they tell others. I live in herts (just outside London) one wage of 36k one of 11k, 2 kids, 2 cars and a mortgage and I think we are comfortable. We have a roof, food and clothing. We are warm and can pay bills without debt. We haven’t had a holiday since 2017 but that isn’t essential, I am grateful for our health and lack of debt

Frabbits · 06/01/2024 21:29

freshgreen · 06/01/2024 21:23

I wouldn't call them rich. Comfortable, yes.

250k + probably another 100k in bonuses a year + owning property which is worth likely 1-2 million makes someone just 'comfortable'? Nah. They are absolutely loaded by any sensible yardstick.

SaturdayGiraffe · 06/01/2024 21:29

The house was a gift? So they didn’t have a mortgage and pay it off. Yes, I’d say having c10k pm spending money qualifies as well off.
But you’re bigger issue is asking what your family get out of making you feel bad in comparison? Because I suspect they know very well you aren’t in the same league.

Fluffywhitecloudsinthesky · 06/01/2024 21:27

Just keep saying 'I don't want to discuss money' with your IL's.

If someone told me to buy a £500 dress for my child, I would literally laugh at them.

Have confidence in yourself, bat away any remarks (or get your husband to have a word with his parents) and live your life. Ignore!

HippeePrincess · 06/01/2024 21:26

Yes they’re very well off/rich! So annoying with the false modesty, my ex FIL once claimed they were “getting by” at a family meal,business owner, joint salary of over £150k about 20 year ago, mortgage free, investment properties etc in midlands. Made me so fucking mad that I called it out and said he needed a reality check and he didn’t have a clue what it meant to be getting by. Utterly ridiculous.

VanityDiesHard · 06/01/2024 21:25

LeroyJenkinssss · 06/01/2024 21:20

I get what you’re saying but based on just his income (excluding bonuses) he’s in the top 5% of household income. His annual bonuses are likely to be multiples of the average salary. It’s disingenuous and rather insulting to pretend that you’re just about managing and not in a very privileged position.

I get that outgoings may be high but that is a choice. That’s what that money has bought - freedom of choice. They can choose to send their kids to private school, to holiday wherever etc etc. I’m also sure he works incredibly hard and earns that salary - as do millions of others who are on far far less.

If you’re in that kind of bracket, sure don’t brag about it but let’s not pretend that that income is anything less than exceptional (when compared to the UK as a whole).

Nobody said 'just about managing' though. They said 'comfortable'. It isn't about how hard someone works, nobody was making value judgements except the (infuriating) parents in law. We can pot-ay-toh pot-ah-toh this all day long, I suppose, but I do think that 'rich' implies a certain grandness of scale that isn't quite present with these people.

freshgreen · 06/01/2024 21:23

I wouldn't call them rich. Comfortable, yes.

VanityDiesHard · 06/01/2024 21:22

Gymnoob · 06/01/2024 21:15

Bonkers lol 😂

I live in one of the most expensive postcodes in the country. There’s a difference between rich and wealthy.

Op sil is defo rich. You’re talking about generational wealth.

Rich means generational wealth. Either that or as the PP says, multimillionaire. It does not mean top 10% of earners.

DonnaBanana · 06/01/2024 21:21

I don’t think you’re rich unless you could just stop working and not have your quality of life severely impacted.

LeroyJenkinssss · 06/01/2024 21:20

VanityDiesHard · 06/01/2024 21:08

I really don't think that 'comfortable' is quite as basic as you are implying. It's a tricky one because it is one of those euphemistic words. The way the OP and most others on this thread as using it is quite literal, so as you say, not being kept awake worrying about money. The way I use it, and most people who I know who would describe themselves as comfortable would use it, is much wealthier than that. More like the OP's BIL, in fact.

I get what you’re saying but based on just his income (excluding bonuses) he’s in the top 5% of household income. His annual bonuses are likely to be multiples of the average salary. It’s disingenuous and rather insulting to pretend that you’re just about managing and not in a very privileged position.

I get that outgoings may be high but that is a choice. That’s what that money has bought - freedom of choice. They can choose to send their kids to private school, to holiday wherever etc etc. I’m also sure he works incredibly hard and earns that salary - as do millions of others who are on far far less.

If you’re in that kind of bracket, sure don’t brag about it but let’s not pretend that that income is anything less than exceptional (when compared to the UK as a whole).

HoppingPavlova · 06/01/2024 21:20

That’s not rich, it’s well off.

godmum56 · 06/01/2024 21:19

HansBanan · 06/01/2024 20:24

It comes up in terms of
"SIL can privately educate her children why can't you"
"SILs children frequently wear outfits totalling over £500 why can't you"
"SILs girls had these lovely Ralph Lauren dresses for Christmas you should have got one for DD so they matched"
"SIL is travelling business for cousins wedding you should do the same"
When I say we make less we can't afford it, it's all "oh but they have to battle London pricing they are only just comfortable".

its easy. Tell the in laws to go and do one....or have your husband do it.

rainyskylight · 06/01/2024 21:18

His bonuses are much more than that, although it will depend on how well they do year on year. A £25k bonus is nothing in his position.

Frabbits · 06/01/2024 21:18

Easily in the top 1% of income worldwide and no mortgage?

Of course they are rich.

Ohnotyoutoo · 06/01/2024 21:18

I wouldn't say they're rich, but they're definitely well off.

Meowandthen · 06/01/2024 21:17

Whether they are rich depends on what other assets they have. Large pension funds, investments, other property etc.

They sound comfortable to me, not rich.

Also you just sound jealous.

Wordsmith · 06/01/2024 21:17

Yes, it's rich in my book.

Technically they'd probably be HNWIs - high net worth individuals.

The Abamovich's of this world are UHNWIs - the U standing for Ultra.

But really, anyone who doesn't have to worry too much is rich. We live on a modest income (around £50K between us) but have no mortgage and Have grown up kids. I've never felt richer.

Pipsquiggle · 06/01/2024 21:16

HansBanan · 06/01/2024 20:24

It comes up in terms of
"SIL can privately educate her children why can't you"
"SILs children frequently wear outfits totalling over £500 why can't you"
"SILs girls had these lovely Ralph Lauren dresses for Christmas you should have got one for DD so they matched"
"SIL is travelling business for cousins wedding you should do the same"
When I say we make less we can't afford it, it's all "oh but they have to battle London pricing they are only just comfortable".

@HansBanan
They don't have a clue do they.
You just need to keep to the facts
The average wage in London is about £45k.
SIL and her DH earn more than 5 times that. They are also mortgage free which most people aren't in their 20s or 40s.
That's why we and the majority of other people don't buy their DC any designer goods.
Rinse and repeat.

Gymnoob · 06/01/2024 21:15

PeloMom · 06/01/2024 20:32

In my view they are comfortable. Rich are people whose net worth is min £30-35mil after tax. Rich is, tomorrow they can decide they no longer want to work ever and don’t have to adjust their lifestyle to do that.

Edited

Bonkers lol 😂

I live in one of the most expensive postcodes in the country. There’s a difference between rich and wealthy.

Op sil is defo rich. You’re talking about generational wealth.

Princessfluffy · 06/01/2024 21:15

To me, comfortable implies that you can cover your mortgage and regular bills and also unexpected bills like a broken boiler. That you can have a foreign holiday
every year (not necessarily long haul). That if your car becomes unreliable you can replace it with another one (not a brand new luxury one, a mid range one maybe three years old). That you are paying into a pension.

Private school fees are beyond comfortable, you need to be well off for that.

teddycoat · 06/01/2024 21:15

zigzag716746zigzag · 06/01/2024 20:25

I think I would class them as “very well off”. Whereas to my mind “rich” would be family office, jet, probably £100M+

so:
“well off” = holidays several times a year in business class
”rich” = holidays whenever they want to by jet to private island or super-yacht

Yup- same here. OP's family sounds wealthy to me.

When I think of "rich" I think of millionaires- Elton John type level

PinkArt · 06/01/2024 21:14

MN and money is such a madness. He's in the top 1% of earners in the country and he doesn't have a mortgage. On what planet is that comfortable and not rich?! More money coming in than 99% of the rest of the country AND without the biggest outgoing cost.
My income fluctuates as I'm freelance but I'm on between £60-80k a year, in London, and would say I was more than comfortable.

Mimami · 06/01/2024 21:14

I can understand why they might be uncomfortable using the term rich but I don't understand why they keep comparing you as you say. Next time instead of saying you can't afford it you could say you have other priorities or that you think it's unnecessary to buy such expensive stuff and even obscene and that you would rather give to charity and that might shut them up!

HansBanan · 06/01/2024 21:14

INCredible2019 · 06/01/2024 21:06

Very comfortable.
Is your BIL a CIO (Investment) or CIO (IT)?
Is the company publicly listed?
If so, bonuses are usually 50% of salary, so plenty of opportunities to amass cash and liquid funds.
But also, lots of decision making responsibilities so lots of stress.
Anyone travelling regularly will amass aer mile points which quickly build up and transfer to business class upgrades etc. Is it worth the hassle?
OP, all these trappings of success come at a cost. Been here, done that.
Wishing you and your family well.

Investment - private bank I think

OP posts:
Eigen · 06/01/2024 21:13

HansBanan · 06/01/2024 20:07

Okay, I know it's subjective but I'm some what bored of my in-laws down playing this.
My SIL is 28, well educated, 2 children, lives in London. She's married, husband is about 40, a little older maybe, a high earner (250k ish - chief investment officer for a wealth management company).
They are mortgage free, in a large beautiful house (I'm not sure of the logistics of how this is the case but know they are). 1 car, owned outright. They have credit cards but I'm sure they pay them off monthly and mainly use them for the benefits and rewards.
Their children are young so not school age yet, but it's very clearly they sill be privately educated. I'm not sure how much the bonus her husband receives would be but let's assume it's anywhere between 25k - 125k depending on the firm.
They holiday several times a year, almost always business class.

AIBU to think that is ‘𝘳𝘪𝘤𝘩’? My in-laws are all insisting that in London this is just comfortable but I don't buy it! Especially not with their mortgage free home!
I know it's not my business but it irks me

If they were paying a London mortgage and childcare, I’d be more sympathetic to your in-laws’ view. But no mortgage? That’s 12k+ a month after tax (if 250k is base comp). That’s very healthy.

Then it depends on where they go to school - if they go for e.g. Dulwich College, I believe that’s something like 40k a year. (Correct me if I’m wrong there).