Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think they are ‘𝘳𝘪𝘤𝘩’

293 replies

HansBanan · 06/01/2024 20:07

Okay, I know it's subjective but I'm some what bored of my in-laws down playing this.
My SIL is 28, well educated, 2 children, lives in London. She's married, husband is about 40, a little older maybe, a high earner (250k ish - chief investment officer for a wealth management company).
They are mortgage free, in a large beautiful house (I'm not sure of the logistics of how this is the case but know they are). 1 car, owned outright. They have credit cards but I'm sure they pay them off monthly and mainly use them for the benefits and rewards.
Their children are young so not school age yet, but it's very clearly they sill be privately educated. I'm not sure how much the bonus her husband receives would be but let's assume it's anywhere between 25k - 125k depending on the firm.
They holiday several times a year, almost always business class.

AIBU to think that is ‘𝘳𝘪𝘤𝘩’? My in-laws are all insisting that in London this is just comfortable but I don't buy it! Especially not with their mortgage free home!
I know it's not my business but it irks me

OP posts:
PeanutsArentNuts · 06/01/2024 22:05

Alcyoneus · 06/01/2024 21:51

No one on PAYE is rich. The rich don’t work for other people.

The bar for what is considered is rich in this country is low as people have just accepted low pay and declining lifestyle as a given in the last 25 years due to the mismanagement of the economy.

Spot-on.
Business class, as the name suggests, used to be for business travel. The rich flew first class or privately. It's just that decades of racing to the bottom has now taken business class travel out of the reach of the comfortable middle class.

juicyfruitmtume · 06/01/2024 22:00

It's definitely not rich, especially in London.

However, it's "very comfortable"!

Klcak · 06/01/2024 21:58

Yes they are well off at the moment.

However, if you consider their outgoings, then they are going to have to spend a fuck load of the net salary to afford the private school fees and all the other stuff they're paying. Private school might be £60k per year for 2 kids. And his £250k salary will be chopped down substantially by tax - like almost cut in half. Subtracting the private school fees and the business class holidays (several) from the net salary actually isn't going to leave a gigantic amount. I imagine their council tax is a lot, a family needs a lot of food/heating/clothes and there are car expenses even if it's paid off. Plus house improvements/costs. With their lifestyle, they could very easily burn up that entire salary and save less than a person with a modest salary who is more frugal and doesn't live in London. Or they could easily save none of that.

The thought and worry of those future costs would make me feel sick.
I'm inclined to agree with your MIL.

If I was BIL/SIL, I'd be moving out of London, to a place where he could reasonably commute by train/work from home and near to an excellent state school - as they can easily afford a house in the best location. There are plenty of places where people have £million+++ houses and as a result get a brilliant state education. And then pretend their kid goes to a "bog standard state school" and they are the salt of the earth. But anyway, that's what I'd do.

teddycoat · 06/01/2024 21:55

Alcyoneus · 06/01/2024 21:51

No one on PAYE is rich. The rich don’t work for other people.

The bar for what is considered is rich in this country is low as people have just accepted low pay and declining lifestyle as a given in the last 25 years due to the mismanagement of the economy.

This is exactly where my thoughts are on this. Spot on.

Catslovenip · 06/01/2024 21:52

Only rich people would consider flying business class several times a year and a £500 child's outfit as normal or expected. They might not want to admit it but they are rich.

alltootired · 06/01/2024 21:52

If you are rich, you never think you are rich unless you are in the top 10 rich people in the world.

Alcyoneus · 06/01/2024 21:51

No one on PAYE is rich. The rich don’t work for other people.

The bar for what is considered is rich in this country is low as people have just accepted low pay and declining lifestyle as a given in the last 25 years due to the mismanagement of the economy.

MILTOBE · 06/01/2024 21:49

I wouldn't say they were rich, but I would say they were very well off.

I would stop any comparisons made by your in laws. They are obviously too thick to work things out for themselves.

Jl2014 · 06/01/2024 21:49

Also some of these family comments are just stupid/ unbelievable. No matter how much money I had I would not buy a young child Ralph Lauren clothes. Very wasteful. Has annyobe actually ever said you have to wear outfits above a certain value?? I find this hard to believe. It’s so demonstrably rude there would be no challenge in going back hard on such a comment.

AGoingConcern · 06/01/2024 21:48

In 2023 I would definitely call that very comfortable but not rich. But then I don’t get why the label matters.

Stop engaging in conversation about finances with your in-laws. No talk of their money, no comparisons, no justifications of how you spend money for your nuclear family.

Put down clear boundaries - “I’m not going to discuss our finances or theirs.” If they continue to do so, leave the room or end the conversation. The response to repetitive questions about why you don’t do private school or whatever other expense is “That’s not a something that works for our family budget” and if they keep at it, end the conversation. Don’t bring up your SIL’s finances, don’t complain about yours.

therealcookiemonster · 06/01/2024 21:47

@HansBanan OP as you know already the amount of moola in your sil and bills pockets is irrelevant. your real problem are the very rude comments from pil. in your place I would shut those comments right down without using money as the reason. "its what we prefer" is good or just grey rock them. 🪨 nod and smile, change topic. nod and smile and see something non committal.

if you can be bit of a cow like I am, you can go for offence as defence mode. talk about how much harder it is to get into good unis from private school these days. or how giving children expensive things from a young age can mean they can become materialistic. etc etc question her, doesn't she think its unethical to be jetting here there and everywhere with no consideration for the environment? why waste money in business when it literally takes you to the same place and you can give that money to charity? etc. etc. these are not necessarily my beliefs but might just shut the pil up

CaramelMac · 06/01/2024 21:46

Next time they bring it up why don’t you say to them “well, why don’t you buy it for us then, if it’s so affordable?” It’s a bit rude but sometimes you have to be a bit rude when people aren’t understanding what you’re telling them.

And yes, I would consider them to be rich, I wouldn’t make the distinction between comfortable, well off and rich.

tachetastic · 06/01/2024 21:46

HansBanan · 06/01/2024 20:07

Okay, I know it's subjective but I'm some what bored of my in-laws down playing this.
My SIL is 28, well educated, 2 children, lives in London. She's married, husband is about 40, a little older maybe, a high earner (250k ish - chief investment officer for a wealth management company).
They are mortgage free, in a large beautiful house (I'm not sure of the logistics of how this is the case but know they are). 1 car, owned outright. They have credit cards but I'm sure they pay them off monthly and mainly use them for the benefits and rewards.
Their children are young so not school age yet, but it's very clearly they sill be privately educated. I'm not sure how much the bonus her husband receives would be but let's assume it's anywhere between 25k - 125k depending on the firm.
They holiday several times a year, almost always business class.

AIBU to think that is ‘𝘳𝘪𝘤𝘩’? My in-laws are all insisting that in London this is just comfortable but I don't buy it! Especially not with their mortgage free home!
I know it's not my business but it irks me

I would say they were well off, or very comfortable. To me, "rich" means asset wealth, not income. Your SIL has paid off their mortgage which means they have a very important asset, but everything else you describe could disappear in three months if the UK entered a recession and they lost their jobs. Many people I know earn more than you describe but have very little left at the end of the month.

I also suspect that your SIL and her husband mix with people who have equivalent income. "Rich" is a relative term, and if they have the same disposable income as their peers then I see why they wouldn't consider themselves rich.

This is not knocking your SIL and her husband. I think it sounds like they have worked really hard for a great life, but I understand their description of their position.

Jl2014 · 06/01/2024 21:46

Not rich based on salary but definitely very comfortable. Especially if it’s all disposable income. Also ,if he’s on that salary in wealth mgmt then very unlikely his bonus is as low as 25k. Will be much higher.

EmmaEmerald · 06/01/2024 21:43

HansBanan · 06/01/2024 20:24

It comes up in terms of
"SIL can privately educate her children why can't you"
"SILs children frequently wear outfits totalling over £500 why can't you"
"SILs girls had these lovely Ralph Lauren dresses for Christmas you should have got one for DD so they matched"
"SIL is travelling business for cousins wedding you should do the same"
When I say we make less we can't afford it, it's all "oh but they have to battle London pricing they are only just comfortable".

That would piss me off enough to tell them to stop being muppets.

VanityDiesHard · 06/01/2024 21:39

ThisOldThang · 06/01/2024 21:30

If they could afford that lifestyle without working another day in their lives, they'd be rich.

I'd consider them to be very well off - not rich and certainly not wealthy.

This. People really don't seem to understand what counts as wealthy. If they spent time with actually wealthy people, they'd find out. It is a whole different way of looking at the world.

RobertaFirmino · 06/01/2024 21:37

Are they polite and friendly? That's the important thing, not how much money they have.

Don't envy anyone who has inherited a house - that means a loved one has died. Many people would rather live in a bedsit and have their relative back - I know I would.

Whatwouldnanado · 06/01/2024 21:37

How would you feel if SIL was chattering and speculating about your private business? Next time mil brings it up tell her it’s none of anyone else’s beeswax. Nor is it any of her concern what you choose to spend your money on. For the record our income is similar, mortgage free. No £500 outfits.

Spomsored · 06/01/2024 21:35

I'm not sure why the label matters, they sound bloody wealthy to me. Are you "irked" by the different definition of comfortable/wealthy or by the frequent references to it? I suggest just shutting down all comparisons or discussion, perhaps a reminder that talking about money is "rather vulgar, regardless of how much you have". Your income and how you spend it is private to your family and nobody else's concern.

Lesina · 06/01/2024 21:34

Why does it matter? Due to a mix of good luck and hard work my brother is rich…. Very rich… doesn’t change him one bit. Stilll the irritating bollox I grew up with and still one of my favourite people to have a pint with 😂

theduchessofspork · 06/01/2024 21:34

Very well off

To me rich is having enough money that you can maintain a very well off lifestyle without having to work. Doesn’t sound like that’s the case here, which means a change in circumstance could change their lifestyle, although they likely have enough investments and insurance they’d always be pretty well off.

SiobhanSharpe · 06/01/2024 21:32

Savoury · 06/01/2024 20:36

If your BIL is a chief investment officer for an investment firm, he may well earn that in base salary but his bonus is more likely to be multiples of his salary.
That is easier to tally with their lifestyle.

Yes, I think his bonus could be well in excess of your estimates, OP. If the firm is doing well it could be seven figures. Plus share options or similar.

Tiredmumofthreekids · 06/01/2024 21:31

does you SIL work too? or the joint income just his salary: 250K+bonus? if they are mortgage free and your SIL is SAHM (so no childcare cost) they have no expenses (except food and hols) and can splash out, so technically yes they are quite well off. however if their kids start private school this will be a massive expense and will eat a massive chunk of their salary, so they wont be able to save a lot. How much does their house worth and do they live in comfortable area or do they need to move up the ladder subsequently?

many jobs in e.g., London city pays well (you dont need to be a chief of something), investment banking, finance and IT and there are many families that live on these sort of joint income. which part of the country do they live? e.g., London is v expensive and 250K joint income with 2-3 kids educated privately is not as much as it sounds.

ThisOldThang · 06/01/2024 21:30

If they could afford that lifestyle without working another day in their lives, they'd be rich.

I'd consider them to be very well off - not rich and certainly not wealthy.

LdnReno · 06/01/2024 21:30

I'd say well-off but not rich.
To me rich is multi-millionaire lifestyle, can choose to work or be retired.

You do sound jealous though.