Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think they are ‘𝘳𝘪𝘤𝘩’

293 replies

HansBanan · 06/01/2024 20:07

Okay, I know it's subjective but I'm some what bored of my in-laws down playing this.
My SIL is 28, well educated, 2 children, lives in London. She's married, husband is about 40, a little older maybe, a high earner (250k ish - chief investment officer for a wealth management company).
They are mortgage free, in a large beautiful house (I'm not sure of the logistics of how this is the case but know they are). 1 car, owned outright. They have credit cards but I'm sure they pay them off monthly and mainly use them for the benefits and rewards.
Their children are young so not school age yet, but it's very clearly they sill be privately educated. I'm not sure how much the bonus her husband receives would be but let's assume it's anywhere between 25k - 125k depending on the firm.
They holiday several times a year, almost always business class.

AIBU to think that is ‘𝘳𝘪𝘤𝘩’? My in-laws are all insisting that in London this is just comfortable but I don't buy it! Especially not with their mortgage free home!
I know it's not my business but it irks me

OP posts:
Pallisers · 06/01/2024 22:48

Of course they are rich or wealthy or well off or whatever term you want to use. No, they are not russian oligarchs or Jeff Besos but come on ... are we now defining rich as that? Those are the super-wealthy. A chief investment officer for a wealth management company in London with a mortgage free house is of course rich - or he is a fool or CIO of the mickey mouse wealth management company.

Your problem is your PIL who, frankly, sound a bit dim. You have a range of options available to you when replying to them:

Omg you are right. Will you pay for our children's school fees/business class tickets/stupid dresses because life is so much cheaper for you here in Cumbria so you must be loaded?

or

Do you think SIL needs a bit of a hand-out? I mean parsnips cost 500 pounds each in London so it must be so hard for her to make ends meet. And sending parsnips won't help because London imposes a 500 pound tariff once they enter. How hard for her. I really worry about her.

or

MIL, could you please stop talking about money.

or - my favourite

Who do you fancy for the finals then?/lovely cheesecake Moira/I thought I saw a squirrel go by.

My own sister used to play the poor mouth with my mum all the time (no idea why I think it was reflexive - she wasn't trying to get money out of her - maybe she was afraid my mum would ask her for money). She was always telling her how little money they had and how hard it all was. They lived in a 5 bedroom house in the nicest part of our city, both had excellent jobs, their children went to private school, she saved the child benefit for them, and they owned a 4 bedroom holiday home in one of the most expensive areas of the country. Finally I said to my mum after the 100th "Do you think James' job is ok, your sister says things are very tough" that I didn't want to waste my time reassuring her that my well off sister was well off and could we for the love of god not talk about it anymore.

Frabbits · 06/01/2024 22:48

Only on mumsnet, where all perspective has been lost, is having assets likely worth in the region of £2 million or more + an annual income of likely touching 500k considered just "comfortable". Most people in the world dream of having 40k a year, let alone being able to waste that on school fees.

These people are rich. Not super, super wealthy, but they are absolutely rich.

Xmasbaby11 · 06/01/2024 22:46

Of course they are rich. It's not that subjective. Whether they feel rich is irrelevant but objectively they have a lot more money than you.

HansBanan · 06/01/2024 22:45

Just been talking to DH about it more.
I think I was underestimating earnings.

He says that the husband is making 300k - started at 250k but was several years ago and thinks he gets at least 100k in bonuses.
House probably worth around 5 million having had a look on instagram.
She doesn't work but easily could if she wanted she's very well educated and has good experience. I'm pretty sure they do the full £9000 a year in JISAs for their kids.
I think it's just pure insanity that in-laws think this is just comfortable.

OP posts:
Eigen · 06/01/2024 22:42

Thanks for the correction. I think I must have been thinking of the boarding fees.

Also agree with your last point!

eurochick · 06/01/2024 22:42

I would say well-off rather than rich, if a label is needed.

Our household income is in that ballpark. We have a mortgage to pay though. That plus school fees and childcare doesn't leave enough for business class holidays. Without the mortgage, presumably no childcare if sil isn't working (I don't recall you mentioning her job) and no school fees yet they will be very comfortable indeed.

Asifiwouldnt · 06/01/2024 22:31

Not rich no but definitely very comfortable.

OP with respect you do sound jealous. Regardless of your in laws making waves your comments about her marrying him for money etc are a bit of a give away that some of your opinions on their home life aren’t entirely objective.

Scottishgirl85 · 06/01/2024 22:31

@CharlotteBog our monthly take home is about 11k. We pay a lot of tax! We spend half and save half. Saving £5ish k a month is definitely a luxury, but it's not megabucks. Our children go to state school and we are very ordinary, but do live in a nice house.

CharlotteBog · 06/01/2024 22:25

Scottishgirl85 · 06/01/2024 22:19

You don't mention if she works too? A family income of £250k wouldn't be rich in my opinion. But being mortgage free is certainly a big factor. Our household income is about £270k ish, and I wouldn't say we are rich. Very comfortable, but not rich. Rich to me is when the cost of something does not need to be considered in any decision.

If you make £270,000 per year, your Monthly salary would be £22,500.

In October 2023 the top one percent of earners in the United Kingdom received an average pay of 15,082 British pounds per month

There aren't many people earning more than you.

tachetastic · 06/01/2024 22:22

HansBanan · 06/01/2024 20:56

I'd imagine money

Ouch! Guessing you don't like her husband much???

Could it be that she actually enjoys being with him? That he makes her happy, and not just by spending money on her?

Maybe (god forbid) she finds him attractive??? He's only 40 FFS!

I suspect this has already been discussed to death, but being in my forties myself I don't have enough time left to spend reading the entire thread.........

CharlotteBog · 06/01/2024 22:21

meganorks · 06/01/2024 22:14

Short answer, yes, they are rich. But it's all relative isn't it? I know a couple in a very similar position and they don't think they are rich, because they look at the company owner who is filthy rich. And then some of the clients they deal with are spectacularly wealthy too. So by comparison, they are not rich. But to anyone vaguely normal, they are loaded!

Well yes, but usually when people consider how comfortable they are they compare themselves to the rest of the country (give or take).
That's what the media, government, banks etc look at.

If someone had to clarify that they didn't think they were rich because they were comparing themselves to the monarchy or something I'd think they were a bit of a twit.

I think that people who get bonuses more than my annual salary are on a different financial stratum to me.

BIossomtoes · 06/01/2024 22:20

Jl2014 · 06/01/2024 21:49

Also some of these family comments are just stupid/ unbelievable. No matter how much money I had I would not buy a young child Ralph Lauren clothes. Very wasteful. Has annyobe actually ever said you have to wear outfits above a certain value?? I find this hard to believe. It’s so demonstrably rude there would be no challenge in going back hard on such a comment.

I bought our granddaughter a Ralph Lauren dress for Christmas - it was £25 from TK Maxx.

User5512 · 06/01/2024 22:19

How is that lifestyle even possible on £250k ?? Is that the base salary ?

Scottishgirl85 · 06/01/2024 22:19

You don't mention if she works too? A family income of £250k wouldn't be rich in my opinion. But being mortgage free is certainly a big factor. Our household income is about £270k ish, and I wouldn't say we are rich. Very comfortable, but not rich. Rich to me is when the cost of something does not need to be considered in any decision.

tachetastic · 06/01/2024 22:16

HansBanan · 06/01/2024 20:24

It comes up in terms of
"SIL can privately educate her children why can't you"
"SILs children frequently wear outfits totalling over £500 why can't you"
"SILs girls had these lovely Ralph Lauren dresses for Christmas you should have got one for DD so they matched"
"SIL is travelling business for cousins wedding you should do the same"
When I say we make less we can't afford it, it's all "oh but they have to battle London pricing they are only just comfortable".

You mean your in-laws literally tell you that your DCs should frequently be wearing outfits costing more than £500?

They are delusional.

I am a high income earner but would not consider myself rich. However I have friends who are rich (not Russian oligarch rich, but with hundreds of acres of land held in the family for centuries - in one case literally since the Doomsday Book) and they would not dress their kids at that price other than for special occasions.

People bang on about London pricing, but that only really applies to property, petrol/transport and the cost of eating out. And if they have paid off their mortgage then the biggest of these doesn't matter. Gas and electric cost the same wherever you live. So does the internet. I haven't seen Sky, Netflix or any other provider vary their prices by region within the UK, nor banks and credit card companies with the interest they charge. Tesco and the other big supermarkets prices are set nationally.

NalafromtheLionKing · 06/01/2024 22:15

Could you deliberately misunderstand their comments and thank them each time they make a comment eg thank you so much MIL, that would be so kind of you to treat us to [£500 outfit/business class flights/whatever else they are putting pressure on you to buy]?

RosesAndHellebores · 06/01/2024 22:14

I think they are more stupid than they are rich.

Our circs were similar butDD at nursery age wore mostly £3.99 summer frocks from George at Asda, a bit of Boden and possibly something nice from John Lewis for special occasions. Children's clothes were handed round friends all the time.

One thing I do wonder from the op's posts is whether "designer" children's clothes are being purchased abroad where they are often much cheaper or fakes. When DH was working a lot in NY, he brought Abercrombie and Fitch stuff back for the dc for far less than in the UK. It was cool 15-20 years ago.

meganorks · 06/01/2024 22:14

Short answer, yes, they are rich. But it's all relative isn't it? I know a couple in a very similar position and they don't think they are rich, because they look at the company owner who is filthy rich. And then some of the clients they deal with are spectacularly wealthy too. So by comparison, they are not rich. But to anyone vaguely normal, they are loaded!

mottytotty · 06/01/2024 22:13

DisforDarkChocolate · 06/01/2024 22:10

I would say comfortable. They are coming up to some very expensive years if they chose private school. Will they be able to fund university and house deposits without any issue? That would move you to rich for me.

As they’re mortgage free, and based on his salary/bonus, plus future salary growth and investments, I’d say they can comfortably afford private school, university and house deposits.

RogueFemale · 06/01/2024 22:12

They're comparing themselves to people much richer, therefore consider themselves merely comfortable, not rich.

Mikimoto · 06/01/2024 22:12

As a PP said....is SIL nice and pleasant?! If so...lucky old them! Be happy that someone close to you seems happy and comfortable.

MIL is another problem...

TheGander · 06/01/2024 22:12

I object to this tendency to associate London with wealth and silly salaries. The vast majority of people in London don’t have those assets or income. I’m a Londoner, humble mid ranking NHS clinician. I got a bonus once in my life, in the heady days of new labour and it was £5. Most people I know are working hard for salaries that are nowhere near that high. We’re not all working in the city.

DisforDarkChocolate · 06/01/2024 22:10

I would say comfortable. They are coming up to some very expensive years if they chose private school. Will they be able to fund university and house deposits without any issue? That would move you to rich for me.

WhereverIlaymycatthatsmyhome · 06/01/2024 22:08

Yes, they are rich/wealthy/whatever term anyone prefers.

I can understand why this stupid comparisons would irk you OP. Unfortunately, if PILS are as thick as you describe, there’s no point in trying to reason with them.

The only solution is to spend far less time with them/communicating with them and try to steer clear of discussing your plans/finances or of course SILS.

Gymnoob · 06/01/2024 22:05

VanityDiesHard · 06/01/2024 21:22

Rich means generational wealth. Either that or as the PP says, multimillionaire. It does not mean top 10% of earners.

Not where I’m from it doesn’t.