Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

18 yr old new drivers/ long distance

111 replies

Jennyjojo5 · 06/01/2024 17:40

My son and a group of 18 yr olds are planning to drive long distance (2.5/3 hours) this evening, for an event tomorrow.

the problem is that the two boys driving have only recently passed their test and I’m
very nervous about my 18 yr old getting in the car with them for this long journey, in the dark, along the motorway, when they are such inexperienced drivers, with a car full of their friends.

I’ve never been a particularly strict mum and never wrapped my kids in cotton wool but I’m genuinely very worried about letting him do this. They are all good kids but they are inexperienced drivers; one of them being a bit of a show off in general and can be a bit ‘silly’ (still a good kid, just immature).

AIBU if I tell him he can’t go? I’m so worried about the risk of the driving. Just to add, that although he would be upset with me, he would do as I told him to do (he’s a very nice young boy and we have an extremely close relationship). But at the same time I know I’ll feel guilt from stopping him going,

I’d like to hear the perspectives from other parents whose kids are the same age please.

OP posts:
ImperialCrusade · 06/01/2024 18:38

I would describe myself as a pretty easy going parent but this is one of the things I strongly discourage.

Inexperienced drivers carrying peer passengers at night is really high risk (distraction, showing off, driving too fast on windy, unlit roads).

There's too many news reports of fatal car accidents involving groups of teens.

CrapBucket · 06/01/2024 18:30

My son is 18 and a lot of his friends drive him places in a group. I don’t know how carefully they drive or when they passed their tests but they are all adults. I try to expect the best of people rather than the worst, I hope I DS would speak up if he thought they were driving badly, he knows he has his independence but can call me in an emergency/if he was stranded etc. He tells me his friends are all better drivers than me!!!

Jennyjojo5 · 06/01/2024 18:25

Whydoiwearsomuchleopardprint · 06/01/2024 18:23

Personally I think this should not be allowed. New drivers should be made to have lessons on motorway and experience driving at night before being let loose with a load of teenagers in back. I actually cannot understand any parent who thinks this is a good idea. 2.5 hours is crazy amount to drive on motorway when you have just passed test. One small error could be fatal, very different from taking your test around a town doing 30/40 mph!

thank you and totally agree!

OP posts:
Whydoiwearsomuchleopardprint · 06/01/2024 18:23

Personally I think this should not be allowed. New drivers should be made to have lessons on motorway and experience driving at night before being let loose with a load of teenagers in back. I actually cannot understand any parent who thinks this is a good idea. 2.5 hours is crazy amount to drive on motorway when you have just passed test. One small error could be fatal, very different from taking your test around a town doing 30/40 mph!

Infertilitylady · 06/01/2024 18:22

@Jennyjojo5 yep , you are right to be worried now that you have given more details , friends racing , specially being new drivers ! So yes ! Don’t let your son go with them for safely reasons , if the other teenager want to go , then that’s on their parents to educate them . As long as your son is safe that’s all it matters to you ! X

Jennyjojo5 · 06/01/2024 18:19

whowhatwerewhy · 06/01/2024 18:14

Thanks for clarifying the insurance, I misread and thought it was two drivers and one car 🤦‍♀️ .
I would definitely be looking at a train the two drivers might try to keep up with each other or even race / show off.

@whowhatwerewhy exactly.. my son said the other day how one of the boys tried to race the other one at the traffic lights the other day..

OP posts:
Jennyjojo5 · 06/01/2024 18:17

EndofDaze · 06/01/2024 18:13

I let me son drive about 200 miles to a holiday activity when he was just 18 with his sister (16) in the car.
We agreed the route and scheduled in several stops for rest and contacting me to let me know they’re safe. DD acted as navigator.
Cant say it was easy to let them go. If they coped admirably and felt a sense of achievement in being independent.

Yes I understand and I’d let him do the same with his brother but just not at night time. I kind of trust him more if he was doing the driving (probably naive!); it’s harder to trust other 18 yr olds when they are the ones driving, even more so when one of them only passed 2 weeks ago x

OP posts:
Infertilitylady · 06/01/2024 18:17

@Jennyjojo5 why are his friends having a go at someone who is trying to be safe and responsible ? Who cares if he goes on train or in the car , he will still be there at the end of the day and meet the friends at the place at the right time ! But I do know what teenagers are like , they wanna mess around in the car and have maybe few little drinks ? And have a laugh before they even get there . It’s a bit like pre drinking when you go out clubbing to get in the mood . But oh well , they will get over it ! It’s not like your son said he’s not going at all ! So what’s the problem ! 🫡 tell your son to tell his friends , he will meet the friends there and full stop . No more arguing! Well done to your son 🙏🏻👍👏🏾

Jennyjojo5 · 06/01/2024 18:15

Onelifeonly · 06/01/2024 18:04

Well, they can never become experienced if they never try it, can they? I understand your concern, but even if you stop it today, it'll come up again eventually. And it's just one risk of many that you are focusing on here. They have to go out in the world.

A 2.5 to 3 hours journey isn't excessively long, presuming it's one way only/ the whole journey. And motorways are the safest roads to drive on

My brother passed his driving test at 17 when our parents were away on holiday abroad- this meant he had free access to the car for a couple of weeks. He was never the most careful person, but he survived, despite their fears.

Just make sure he wears a seatbelt - some years back I knew a 17 year old killed during a short lift home from school in a car driven by his friend. He went through the windscreen. The other 3 occupants survived unscathed.

I agree to some extent but I just don’t want my son in the car being part of that first ever experience, on a long journey, in the dark! They can learn and get experienced themselves, they don’t need a car full of other kids to do that

OP posts:
whowhatwerewhy · 06/01/2024 18:14

Thanks for clarifying the insurance, I misread and thought it was two drivers and one car 🤦‍♀️ .
I would definitely be looking at a train the two drivers might try to keep up with each other or even race / show off.

EndofDaze · 06/01/2024 18:13

I let me son drive about 200 miles to a holiday activity when he was just 18 with his sister (16) in the car.
We agreed the route and scheduled in several stops for rest and contacting me to let me know they’re safe. DD acted as navigator.
Cant say it was easy to let them go. If they coped admirably and felt a sense of achievement in being independent.

Jennyjojo5 · 06/01/2024 18:12

@ShoesoftheWorld thank you, yes one of the boys only passed his test 2 weeks ago and I know hasn’t been on a motorway yet, let alone at night and with a car full of his mates

OP posts:
Jennyjojo5 · 06/01/2024 18:11

@whowhatwerewhy yes the two boys doing the driving (in their own cars) and so are both insured on their own cars etc

OP posts:
ShoesoftheWorld · 06/01/2024 18:11

This would be a no from me (yes he's 18 etc etc but I would be advising him very strongly not to go), My ds1 is 18 and a fairly new driver. Where we are, motorway lessons are compulsory. He's also driven the family on the motorway in the family car (after passing his test). We're fine with him taking friends on short runs (drop them at the station etc after being at ours), but he wouldn't be doing this.

whowhatwerewhy · 06/01/2024 18:10

I think a train is far more sensible, I also wonder about car insurance, are the two young drivers on the policy?

Infertilitylady · 06/01/2024 18:09

@Onelifeonly they can become experienced with time just doing city driving and short motorway driving , the first one doesn’t have to be 3 hours long for inexperienced driver , but over time , he will become quite experienced and he won’t have any fears about motorway anymore :)

Jennyjojo5 · 06/01/2024 18:09

@ohtowinthelottery yes both cars are small Vauxhall corsas

OP posts:
Jennyjojo5 · 06/01/2024 18:08

Infertilitylady · 06/01/2024 18:04

@Jennyjojo5 yay I’m so happy for you that you’re son is such a good and loving son that he knows when you’re worried and he will change things around just for you because he loves you so much and he doesn’t want you to worry ! He knows as long as he gets there , it’s not a big deal , train or bus - no problem . He will still get there :) glad he understand ! 💕🤝🫶

Thank you so much! Unfortunately, his friends now are having a right go at him about not going In the car with them 🙄

OP posts:
ohtowinthelottery · 06/01/2024 18:07

@Jennyjojo5 I think the cars involved are often small hatchbacks too which will handle completely differently with 4 or 5 teenagers in compared to the 2 adults that they will have learned to drive with. Also these small cars rarely fare well in a collision.
You are right to be worried.

Onelifeonly · 06/01/2024 18:07

Train is better for sure x

GrazingSheep · 06/01/2024 18:06

Train is a good idea.

Infertilitylady · 06/01/2024 18:04

@Jennyjojo5 yay I’m so happy for you that you’re son is such a good and loving son that he knows when you’re worried and he will change things around just for you because he loves you so much and he doesn’t want you to worry ! He knows as long as he gets there , it’s not a big deal , train or bus - no problem . He will still get there :) glad he understand ! 💕🤝🫶

Onelifeonly · 06/01/2024 18:04

Well, they can never become experienced if they never try it, can they? I understand your concern, but even if you stop it today, it'll come up again eventually. And it's just one risk of many that you are focusing on here. They have to go out in the world.

A 2.5 to 3 hours journey isn't excessively long, presuming it's one way only/ the whole journey. And motorways are the safest roads to drive on

My brother passed his driving test at 17 when our parents were away on holiday abroad- this meant he had free access to the car for a couple of weeks. He was never the most careful person, but he survived, despite their fears.

Just make sure he wears a seatbelt - some years back I knew a 17 year old killed during a short lift home from school in a car driven by his friend. He went through the windscreen. The other 3 occupants survived unscathed.

Whydoiwearsomuchleopardprint · 06/01/2024 18:04

No I wouldn’t like this at all, way too much for a young inexperienced driver to take a car full of teenagers on motorway in dark. Train would be the only option!

Jennyjojo5 · 06/01/2024 18:04

@SilverGlitterBaubles thank you for understanding :-)

OP posts: