Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

18 yr old new drivers/ long distance

111 replies

Jennyjojo5 · 06/01/2024 17:40

My son and a group of 18 yr olds are planning to drive long distance (2.5/3 hours) this evening, for an event tomorrow.

the problem is that the two boys driving have only recently passed their test and I’m
very nervous about my 18 yr old getting in the car with them for this long journey, in the dark, along the motorway, when they are such inexperienced drivers, with a car full of their friends.

I’ve never been a particularly strict mum and never wrapped my kids in cotton wool but I’m genuinely very worried about letting him do this. They are all good kids but they are inexperienced drivers; one of them being a bit of a show off in general and can be a bit ‘silly’ (still a good kid, just immature).

AIBU if I tell him he can’t go? I’m so worried about the risk of the driving. Just to add, that although he would be upset with me, he would do as I told him to do (he’s a very nice young boy and we have an extremely close relationship). But at the same time I know I’ll feel guilt from stopping him going,

I’d like to hear the perspectives from other parents whose kids are the same age please.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WombatChocolate · 12/02/2024 16:09

The problem isn’t the motorway driving, but a long drive with a carload of friends. It’s particularly this latter point of the carload of friends. New drivers don’t realise how distracting friends chatting and laughing and playing music are. They aren’t intending to distract but that’s the effect they have - and new drivers need to fully concentrate.

I’ve known people say ‘no giving lifts to friends’ for 3 months, or no night driving for a couple of months, or no journey above a certain length for a couple of months. It’s all about building up experience in a safe environment - that is where they are on their own or with a family member so they can concentrate.

Yes, they need to practice motorway driving and night driving and in rain etc. having a go at these things without friends to start with is important. You can’t expect a carload of teenage lads going g on a big night out to sit silently as passengers for 3 hours. They are likely to laugh, mess about and play loud music. It’s exactly the recipe for an accident.

I’d also say that schools and colleges cover this in their OSHE programmes for sixth form students - there’s stuff about what puts you at risk of an accident - driving late at night, long journeys and particularly groups of friends. The scenario Op spoke of seemed to have all these elements and she was right to be concerned. These lads will get to be experienced drivers and able to cope with the long journey at night and with friends…but right now isn’t the moment.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 08/01/2024 10:28

@user68901 - no, not 16. Some states are 17 now and will be going up to 18 to match the other states which are already 18.

They also have to do a minimum number of hours of driving before sitting their test in varying conditions. 75 driving hours with 15 of them being night time driving in SA, which is one of the lower requirements, other states have 120 hours.

user68901 · 07/01/2024 18:27

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 06/01/2024 23:53

In South Australia provisional licences last for 2 years, and in the first year the following rule applies:

"If you are under the age of 25 years, you must not drive:
◦ between midnight and 5am, or
◦ with more than one passenger aged 16 to 20 years (excluding immediate family members)
◦ unless a Qualified Supervising Driver is seated next to you or you meet the exemption criteriaa_."

There is a REASON for these rules. In their first year of driving there are a horrific number of deaths when teenage boys drive with their friends in the car.

A lot of places have similar rules. I think the UK are quite backward about not introducing these types of rules.

Yes - I agree this makes sense however one of the reasons Australia has this rule is that Australians can pass their test at 16 which I personally feel is too young.

We could copy the rule and make the additional rules apply for 1 year perhaps.

FishTheRiver · 07/01/2024 15:24

OP
also, if I’m quite honest, all these ‘you can’t stop him he’s 18’, in theory you’re all right. But he’s not the sort of boy where I would have to lock him up in his bedroom to stop him doing something like this 🤣that’s the benefit of having a super close relationship; you listen to each other’s perspectives, come to a compromise on things you feel particularly strong about. He’s also very young for his age and appreciates my guidance. Also, he has very high EQ and therefore takes other peoples feelings on things very seriously and understands their point of view.

He doesn't sound young for his age, he sounds mature.

I'd have done the same as you OP. There are a few things that are genuinely a bit risky and a newly qualified teen drive and a car of teens is one of them. I'd have paid his train ticket too.

justsomepandq · 07/01/2024 07:39

I'm very pleased that this would not be allowed where I live as new drivers in their first year are only allowed to carry one passenger aged 16-22.
Train sounds much better idea.

user1477391263 · 07/01/2024 02:00

Seen your update, OP: good result and he sounds like a sensible boy!

user1477391263 · 07/01/2024 01:54

In some countries, there are laws forbidding young drivers under 20 or 21 from driving in cars with other teenagers the same age in there. I wish the UK would consider introducing similar laws, as this would avoid these dilemmas of "I'm worried but not sure what I can do about it as they are technically an adult." There are seldom any essential reasons why teenagers need to drive other teenagers about - it's usually about nights out and jollies.

Well, they can never become experienced if they never try it, can they?

This is a silly argument. In countries which have laws about this kind of thing, young drivers build up experience by doing less risky driving, ie not with a pack of their mates in the car. They move on to driving about with friends once they are a bit older and have more experience.

HollaHolla · 07/01/2024 01:42

Also, when I lived in New Zealand, I was struck by their restrictions on new drivers (also in Australia, I understand). There’s restrictions on speed, passengers, driving at night, and on alcohol levels (zero).
I reckon it wouldn’t be a bad idea here too. I know it certainly took me a good few months post passing my test, to be fully competent.
Even now, I need to turn the radio off, to look for an address!! 🤣🤣🤣
(I’ve been driving almost 30 years….)

HollaHolla · 07/01/2024 01:39

We had similar terrible accidents locally, when I was 16/17/18. Kids I knew from school were killed, when one was driving his dad’s high powered BMW, when they hit a tree. It was awful. Big part of why my siblings and I weren’t allowed to drive the ‘big’ family car, or take carloads of folks around (distractions). I remember it being a Uni open day, and I had just passed my test the month before, so would have been 17, and my brother and his mate wanted to go. It was only about an hour drive from home, but our mum wouldn’t let me take his two mates, because she thought there might be nonsense, which would distract me as a new driver.

Sounds like you had a really sensible conversation with your lovely boy, and came to a compromise. He sounds as if he understands the concerns; and it’s not about saying he can’t do it, but young adults often need the perspective of someone more mature, to help them get to their own conclusions. It would be worse if you didn’t care at all.
hope he has a great time!

Twofurrycats · 07/01/2024 01:07

From the road safety charity Brake.

18 yr old new drivers/ long distance
BabyPapa · 07/01/2024 00:55

Im a Driving Instructor and I always offer my students a motorway lesson after they have passed just so I can make sure they are safe.

No pressure to accept obviously and I get about a 50/50 up take on it.

Usually if they have driven on a dual carriageway they will be fine on a Motorway .
For what its worth I dont think your being over the top of unreasonable! Sounds like a terrifying situation for a parent! (mines only 7 months so cant begin to fully understand)

Dobbyismyabsolutefav · 07/01/2024 00:54

@CurlyhairedAssassin So true. I visited my DD at uni beginning of December and due to flooding and torrential rain the 200 mile journey took me 6 hours. It was so stressful and I've been driving for 35 years.

Dobbyismyabsolutefav · 07/01/2024 00:48

YANBU especially after the recent tragedy in Wales. A car full of young males with no motorway experience makes me shudder especially if one of them has a tendency to show off.

My DD passed her test and then went straight to uni so whilst a competent driver hadn't had time to practise on a motorway. When she decided to take her car to uni I went as a passenger and then got the train home. My DH did the same when she came home at the end of term. DD drove the 200+ miles home on her own at Christmas and I had to keep myself busy until she was home safely. Probably not helped as my DH had a fairly recent serious car crash on one of the motorways that DD had to travel on. I know our YP are adults but as a parent their safety is always a priority.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 07/01/2024 00:33

You took the right approach. I’ve been driving for over 30 years, never had any kind of accident. At the beginning of December I drove to collect my son from uni, 150 miles there and same back the same day so I left early morning when it was still dark. Usually a very easy motorway journey.

the journey was probably the most terrifying I’ve ever had. There was very heavy rain most of the way, I’ve never seen so much standing water on the motorway. The advice across most of the country was not to travel unless absolutely necessary. Despite this, traffic was denser than expected presumably because everyone was driving slower. The spray from the heavies as I overtook them was awful. It stayed dark so late in the morning too. I had a massive headache from the stress of concentrating by the time I got there and was just pleased that I wasn’t one of 2 cars I saw who had had an accident going through basically a pond in the fast lane. They obviously didn’t see it till it was too late and must have aquaplaned or swerved to avoid or something because the accident crew were there and the lane was closed.

At one point on the journey back in daylight (still gloomy though) a HGV must have driven in a dip with a big puddle because literally it was like someone poured a massive bucket of water over the windscreen and despite the wipers being on the fastest setting I literally couldn’t see out the windscreen for a couple of seconds. Just had to hope for the best and pray!

I was shattered by the time we got home. It was a completely different experience to last year’s uni pick up when it was a crisp sunny day with no rain and the motorway was quiet - the drive was actually enjoyable.

So no matter what a driver’s experience is, some driving conditions on the motorway are simply more dangerous anyway, because of the weather, especially this time of year. There’s nothing you can do about the weather and you won’t know how it will be till the day. For a planned event it would have been difficult for boys that age to admit to their friends on the day “actually my experience isn’t good enough for driving in these conditions”.

Whydoiwearsomuchleopardprint · 07/01/2024 00:00

Klcak · 06/01/2024 23:55

Agree

I 100 per cent support this and wish we had it in the UK , makes so much sense to me.

JMSA · 07/01/2024 00:00

Your son sounds so lovely, and I understand your concerns.

Klcak · 06/01/2024 23:55

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 06/01/2024 23:53

In South Australia provisional licences last for 2 years, and in the first year the following rule applies:

"If you are under the age of 25 years, you must not drive:
◦ between midnight and 5am, or
◦ with more than one passenger aged 16 to 20 years (excluding immediate family members)
◦ unless a Qualified Supervising Driver is seated next to you or you meet the exemption criteriaa_."

There is a REASON for these rules. In their first year of driving there are a horrific number of deaths when teenage boys drive with their friends in the car.

A lot of places have similar rules. I think the UK are quite backward about not introducing these types of rules.

Agree

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 06/01/2024 23:53

In South Australia provisional licences last for 2 years, and in the first year the following rule applies:

"If you are under the age of 25 years, you must not drive:
◦ between midnight and 5am, or
◦ with more than one passenger aged 16 to 20 years (excluding immediate family members)
◦ unless a Qualified Supervising Driver is seated next to you or you meet the exemption criteriaa_."

There is a REASON for these rules. In their first year of driving there are a horrific number of deaths when teenage boys drive with their friends in the car.

A lot of places have similar rules. I think the UK are quite backward about not introducing these types of rules.

StSwithinsDay · 06/01/2024 23:47

@Aliaolo
Were you 18?

bozzabollix · 06/01/2024 23:45

Driving instructor here. The stats back you up, a huge 20% of new drivers have a serious accident in their first two hundred hours of driving. This increases in risk with multiple people in the car and the later it is. Think about insurance companies, they price exactly for these conditions with the black box late night curfew discount, I’ve even read two seaters aren’t as expensive as you’d think as it removes the risk of peer pressure.

I know at 18 he’s an adult but I would have your same worry. Fingers crossed on the train scenario.

However I do have some 17yo learners who are even more sensible than me, if that makes you feel better.

Tumbleweed101 · 06/01/2024 23:40

My daughter was the first of her friend group to pass her test. I told her I didn't want anyone in the car with her (friend wise) until she'd had a couple weeks driving alone (no peers) locally. She passed end of August and has done some longer drives now but I've been completely freaked out each time she does a new long drive (would never let her know) but at least I know her and can anticipate her reactions to a certain extent. I'd be more worried once she travels in the car of.peers as they start to pass.

It's a worrying time and we need to let them know our concerns with a light hand so they listen and hopefully make a sensible choice.

Aliaolo · 06/01/2024 21:44

I suppose it differs depending on the person. I passed my test on a Wednesday and did a similar length of trip on the Friday, returning Monday. My passenger was a non-driver, hadn't so much as taken one lesson, and it was fine.

Nishky32 · 06/01/2024 21:40

Nishky32 · 06/01/2024 21:40

Don’t be so ridiculous

Or maybe read the thread and understand the context of comments

Nishky32 · 06/01/2024 21:40

PonyPatter44 · 06/01/2024 20:41

Well that's the scenario we're talking about, isn't it, dear? So using other people's expertise to back up a completely unrelated situation makes you look a bit... daft?

Don’t be so ridiculous

Jennyjojo5 · 06/01/2024 20:57

@Cas112 I trust him but don’t trust his friend who was driving only 2 weeks after passing the test.

also, if I’m quite honest, all these ‘you can’t stop him he’s 18’, in theory you’re all right. But he’s not the sort of boy where I would have to lock him up in his bedroom to stop him doing something like this 🤣that’s the benefit of having a super close relationship; you listen to each other’s perspectives, come to a compromise on things you feel particularly strong about. He’s also very young for his age and appreciates my guidance. Also, he has very high EQ and therefore takes other peoples feelings on things very seriously and understands their point of view.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread