Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not tell his wife?

171 replies

Catsandbootsandcatsandboots · 06/01/2024 17:01

Scenario is group of friends all know each other and each others DHs. But drifted due to friend b’s odd views and that became more pronounced over time, the world is jealous of me sort. Her husband also had an air about him and made a lot of snide comments to us that frankly made everyone feel uncomfortable.

Friend A got divorced about a year ago and decided to put herself back out there and found friend b’s husband on a dating app. It’s definitely him as the app verifies identify and he has a premium profile that is paid for (it’s indicated on the page)

friend a hasn’t spoken to friend b since prior to the pandemic. Few reasons aside from the drifting isolation caused. B turned her back on a when she was going through her divorce and because it was too much for her, lot of comments came through her and b’s dh that A would be jealous of them and basically be a hater and wish bad things on them. All bollocks of course. It was those sort of comments that caused me to take a step back from B too.

so all in all barely spoken since the pandemic

a has found b’s husband on a dating app. She did do screenshots.

should A or I tell b? They definitely don’t have an open mariage

i don’t know why but I think that B’s dh would probably lash out if he found out it was us. Also who knows what he’s like behind closed doors as some of his views were very red pill ‘alpha’ sort

whilst I would want to know it is was me. I don’t think she’ll take it well and then there’s him

OP posts:
LonelynSad · 06/01/2024 23:42

@lifelongwhatever Why would you share something like that about your friend, online??

LonelynSad · 06/01/2024 23:41

lifelongwhatever · 06/01/2024 18:08

Tell the wife.

He’s a serial cheat.

She could literally die as a result of his cheating ( I know someone who is).

She has a right to know and no one else will tell her.

you should do the right thing because it’s the right thing. Not because you like the person you are doing the right thing by.

Edited

She could literally die as a result of his cheating ( I know someone who is).

Huh? 🤔

Catsandbootsandcatsandboots · 06/01/2024 23:01

Jamesclaton007 · 06/01/2024 22:40

@Catsandbootsandcatsandboots based on previous threads they could be "together" yet having separate lives ?

This is my first thread, im normally a reader and not a poster.

i would say it’s unlikely due to certain religious convictions and the impression one would have from brief conversations and social media and their relationship when I knew them much more BUT behind closed doors shrug

OP posts:
Jamesclaton007 · 06/01/2024 22:41

some would say they would like to know x but then the messenger is the one that also gets blamed at times, its a thankless endevor.

Jamesclaton007 · 06/01/2024 22:40

@Catsandbootsandcatsandboots based on previous threads they could be "together" yet having separate lives ?

Allfur · 06/01/2024 21:32

Agree, i would want to know

GreyCarpet · 06/01/2024 20:59

Cardinal sin, I know butbI haven't RTFT.

Anyway, I would tell tbh.

I can understand people staying quiet when there is a close friendship group to blow apart. But I would want to know and would appreciate someone telling me.

NonPlayerCharacter · 06/01/2024 20:57

Catsandbootsandcatsandboots · 06/01/2024 20:50

taking these specific individuals out of the equation, that’s just a mind boggling stand point. If it were me, I’d always want to know than to waste my life and I wouldn’t consider the person who told me, someone policing monogamy but rather someone who saw something that impacted me and thought it was my right to know.

but back to this specific situation, it’s too messy and we aren’t close enough, neither is A plus if A said it could always be brushed away with the jealousy factor. So that’s just that. If she does find out if won’t be from us

If it were me, I’d always want to know

Not everyone does. I won't get into it now because it always offends people, but it is a fact that not everyone wants to know and not everyone would thank you. They would indeed see it as you being intrusive and policing someone and something that was not your business to police.

I'm glad you won't be getting involved in this, as it sounds even worse than the "usual" situation. If he's this stupid and indiscreet, he'll get found out eventually. I even wonder if she already knows, with him being so blatant about it. Who knows. Not anyone else's concern.

Catsandbootsandcatsandboots · 06/01/2024 20:50

NonPlayerCharacter · 06/01/2024 20:45

like i couldn’t care if they were poly or swingers or on a break

Yes, but as it is they're not and that's why you're considering policing his monogamy. But don't.

taking these specific individuals out of the equation, that’s just a mind boggling stand point. If it were me, I’d always want to know than to waste my life and I wouldn’t consider the person who told me, someone policing monogamy but rather someone who saw something that impacted me and thought it was my right to know.

but back to this specific situation, it’s too messy and we aren’t close enough, neither is A plus if A said it could always be brushed away with the jealousy factor. So that’s just that. If she does find out if won’t be from us

OP posts:
Namerequired · 06/01/2024 20:47

Falkenburg · 06/01/2024 20:24

She's not a close friend so there is nothing about wanting to be nice to by telling her and it's a form of gloating if any of you tell her.

It’s a big jump from she’s not a close friend so you are gloating if you tell her. Yes she’s not as obligated to tell her if she’s not a close friend, but that doesn’t mean she doesn’t still feel for her. Or can’t still want to do it for the right reasons. I would want a stranger on the street to tell me rather than not find out.

NonPlayerCharacter · 06/01/2024 20:45

Catsandbootsandcatsandboots · 06/01/2024 20:20

It’s weird the monogamy police line being spun. Granted this situation isn’t straight forward but then much more generally I wouldn’t say it’s about policing someone’s relationship, like i couldn’t care if they were poly or swingers or on a break, it’s not about a moral view but a factual one. and if it were me, 100% of the time I’d want to know rather than be humiliated by a not so subtle cheater

like i couldn’t care if they were poly or swingers or on a break

Yes, but as it is they're not and that's why you're considering policing his monogamy. But don't.

Firefly2009 · 06/01/2024 20:37

So don't tell her then. The end.

Catsandbootsandcatsandboots · 06/01/2024 20:29

Falkenburg · 06/01/2024 20:24

She's not a close friend so there is nothing about wanting to be nice to by telling her and it's a form of gloating if any of you tell her.

Not sure how it would be gloating? But ok

OP posts:
Tighginn · 06/01/2024 20:27

Print off the screenshot, post it to her work, parents, type of a thing.

Catsandbootsandcatsandboots · 06/01/2024 20:24

Firefly2009 · 06/01/2024 20:21

So go ahead and tell her then.

If we were closer and if he weren’t him and I didn’t have concerns for everyone’s safety I can see it would be the right thing to do. But here like a good number have said, it’s not the right call.

OP posts:
Falkenburg · 06/01/2024 20:24

She's not a close friend so there is nothing about wanting to be nice to by telling her and it's a form of gloating if any of you tell her.

Catsandbootsandcatsandboots · 06/01/2024 20:22

Janieforever · 06/01/2024 20:18

Op you come across, and I’m mot sure if you’re aware of it, but you come across as desperate to get involved in this, but know deep down you shouldn’t.

its ok to enjoy drama or be a sspiteful person. But curb it, stay out.

Is it ok to be a spiteful person? Does anyone actually think this?

hardly. My second post was I really don’t think I should say, for both of our safety.

OP posts:
Firefly2009 · 06/01/2024 20:21

So go ahead and tell her then.

Catsandbootsandcatsandboots · 06/01/2024 20:20

It’s weird the monogamy police line being spun. Granted this situation isn’t straight forward but then much more generally I wouldn’t say it’s about policing someone’s relationship, like i couldn’t care if they were poly or swingers or on a break, it’s not about a moral view but a factual one. and if it were me, 100% of the time I’d want to know rather than be humiliated by a not so subtle cheater

OP posts:
Janieforever · 06/01/2024 20:18

Op you come across, and I’m mot sure if you’re aware of it, but you come across as desperate to get involved in this, but know deep down you shouldn’t.

its ok to enjoy drama or be a sspiteful person. But curb it, stay out.

NonPlayerCharacter · 06/01/2024 20:10

Anonymous telling is so horrible. It creates paranoia - who told me and why? - but it also suggests that you think this concerns you enough to get actively involved, but you're the only one who should be protected from any consequences.

Either it's your business or it's not. It's not, but if you think it is, take your consequences with everyone else. And if you fear that those consequences would mean harm to you, you shouldn't be setting such a dangerous person on someone else.

As PP said, you aren't the monogamy police and it sounds like the guy is a thug so stay out of it.

Sallyh87 · 06/01/2024 19:55

Catsandbootsandcatsandboots · 06/01/2024 19:41

i don’t really know, he told a story once about how he got someone beaten up for crossing him, and whilst I’ve not concrete proof there’s certain things he said that made me think either he’s involved in some potentially drug related activity

Well then definitely stay out of it! 😬

Woodworm2020 · 06/01/2024 19:47

Don’t get involved. Given everything she has said and done, I doubt she will appreciate it and there will definitely be a shooting of the messenger. I’m sure you don’t want or need this drama in your life!

Catsandbootsandcatsandboots · 06/01/2024 19:44

YouOKHun · 06/01/2024 19:36

friend a hasn’t spoken to friend b since the pandemic. B turned her back on A when she was going through her divorce
B said A would be jealous of them and basically be a hater and wish bad things on them
^this caused me to take a step back from B too.

so all in all barely spoken since the pandemic

a has found b’s husband on a dating app. She did do screenshots.

should A or I tell b?

I agree with a previous PP that A should be examining her motives for telling B. To me it sounds motivated by A’s dislike of B and her DH and a triumphant delight in telling her that her marriage and “enviable” life is a sham. Then once the touch paper is lit, stand back and enjoy the show. The only spanner in the works being aggression from the DH.

It doesn’t seem like the right motivation to blow her world apart (assuming she doesn’t already know) given that it doesn’t sound like either of you are going to offer her unswerving support. As it sounds like your friendship is pretty much in the past and A hasn’t spoken to B for years, it’s better to leave it be and absolutely don’t share it further. I think I would only tell someone about cheating if they were a very good friend and I was prepared to closely support them in a genuine way in the longer term.

I don’t think that’s a fair assessment of A at all… just because she’s divorced and dating doesn’t mean she wants anyone’s marriage to end. I think that’s a mighty big inference

OP posts:
Rewis · 06/01/2024 19:42

I wouldn't go the anonymous route. He'll talk himself out of it and she'll be in a limbo. Imagine getting an anonymous message from finsta sayng your husband is a cheater and thats it. Either you or A tells her or you won't tell.

What are you actually scared of? Are you worried he'll become violent towards you or his wife? If you're worried door your own safety then don't do it. If for the wife's then you'll have to tell her and give her resources