Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wife is the higher earner

308 replies

Notsureanymorepri · 06/01/2024 15:03

Husband has a decent salary (£70k gross), in the last 2 years my income has grown to 500-600k (mainly due to variable compensation) from around 110-130k. we have always split all expenses 50-50 and kept our finances separated. we have a relatively frugal lifestyle. No debt, mortgage paid off. The cost of nursery where we live in London is £2.4K/month for our only child and due to brexit he may have lost 10 years of pension contributions abroad so is in catch up mode and I agree this is a priority. he now feels under financial pressure at the prospect of booking holidays and did not sleep for days when we found out that the results of the state school we were aiming for have plummeted and we MAY need to consider private as an option in 2 years…i have spoken about me paying for the holidays or me contributing more to the joint account but he doesn’t seem keen. What options could I suggest to make it seem fair that we adjust our lifestyle a little bit if reasonably affordable at household income level without making him feel bad about himself (I am proud of his career and he does have an important job) please?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Justia · 10/01/2024 12:27

@Notsureanymorepri

This all sounds very sensible, sort the pension issue so his mental health recovers and you can enjoy life. Then Proportional contribution relative to income 👏

I agree entirely, pooling income is not a great idea!

WickDittington · 09/01/2024 19:57

Good luck, @Notsureanymorepri Uour situation shows just how much sex-based stereotypes still persist - no-one’s fault really, but still difficult to negotiate.

Notsureanymorepri · 09/01/2024 13:42

Thank you all for the insights and advice, very kind of you. I have managed to agree that I can contribute to his pension and maximise the benefits, a very rational thing to do so easy to accept. Next, I will introduce the possibility of a proportional contribution for non necessary spending like holidays etc. If we conclude that a pre-prep for is the way forward, I will propose a similar type of contribution as well, also because we are not entitled to any benefit just because of my income. Pooling the funds entirely is not an option, just too distant from a value perspective (financial independence is very important for me, I just could not cope with the anxiety of not having control over my finances and therefore my freedom) and also not very practical, but I can see why in many other cases it is the best choice. Thank you all again

OP posts:
Carpediemmakeitcount · 09/01/2024 12:13

WickDittington · 09/01/2024 11:14

Were they not aware of the bullying? After hating school himself why was your father so pig headed to keep you at a school where you were bullied?

@Clappity this was a long time ago when bullying was not well dealt with. My parents were concerned, particularly on the Sunday nights when I was in floods of tears about school on Monday. I was asked by concerned teachers about what I was doing that might have provoked the other pupils. They were not uncaring, but there were no tools back then for dealing with bullying.

And as upper middle class "rich" people (we weren't - there was affluence but not a lot of cash as such) I wasn't supposed to be a victim. It was just a total mismatch between class-based cultures.

But it made me very resilient once I realised I wasn't an unlikeable prat.

Bullying is still not dealt with today and there are no new tools in dealing with it. I homeschooled two of my children at home we used online schools because of the bullying my second child went through at school. She was self harming and blaming herself when it wasn't her fault. She is better now that she's older and she doesn't have to tolerate bullying or rudeness from anyone.

Carpediemmakeitcount · 09/01/2024 12:05

Notsureanymorepri · 08/01/2024 18:13

This is exactly my husband’s understanding that was challenged by many on this thread: kids at private school have an expensive lifestyle and if you are frugal/not as wealthy you are going to be feel inferior. Therefore we will feel the pressure to live the bankers’ life and feel not great about ourselves…yet many said no, every class is represented, it’s just an educational choice…any thoughts?

It's an educational choice that's it. I sent my daughter to a lovely private school we struggled and I think some of the mothers there thought I was the hired help. I don't give a hoot she is now studying to become a chiropractor. My daughter was always hard-working, but the thought of leaving her at the mercy of the state education system may have had a different outcome.

LardyCakeAgain · 09/01/2024 11:32

I'd be on your husbands side in this I'm afraid. Having been the lower earner and the higher earner, it was far more stressful as the lower earner when it came to spending decisions and financial commitments. If we couldn't afford it on just my own salary, we didn’t do it, as I had seen too many people getting overstretched before covid and then really suffered when their jobs went, or they got ill but not enough for disability payouts, etc. Commission-based salaries are unreliable and usually tank as soon as there's even a whiff or a recession on the horizon. The only thing we couldn't do on just my salary is the mortgage, and we still bought sonething far smaller than we could have with our budget to make it more manageable.

I'm glad we did it this way now - DH is going part-time for health reasons and my job is being cut, but I have savings & breathing room to find something else.

WickDittington · 09/01/2024 11:14

Were they not aware of the bullying? After hating school himself why was your father so pig headed to keep you at a school where you were bullied?

@Clappity this was a long time ago when bullying was not well dealt with. My parents were concerned, particularly on the Sunday nights when I was in floods of tears about school on Monday. I was asked by concerned teachers about what I was doing that might have provoked the other pupils. They were not uncaring, but there were no tools back then for dealing with bullying.

And as upper middle class "rich" people (we weren't - there was affluence but not a lot of cash as such) I wasn't supposed to be a victim. It was just a total mismatch between class-based cultures.

But it made me very resilient once I realised I wasn't an unlikeable prat.

Justia · 09/01/2024 09:26

@WickDittington
I can attest to the fact that the psychological damage to me, and my friends who experienced similar, is long lasting.

We weren’t near a private secondary level school, and my parents didn’t want to board me, but the contrast in behaviour and decency between my prep and state school was stark and I was wholly unprepared for it.

I imagine your parents decided to send you to the schools you went to to enable you to get on with everyone in life and because of their own negative experiences at private. But subjecting you to that environment when you were so different in background to all the other kids, it must have been very tough on you.

Justia · 09/01/2024 09:18

Mirabai · 08/01/2024 18:46

As I said, with respect to both @Justia and your DH, I think this is completely out of touch.

As I said there’s a big mix of backgrounds, cultures, wealth. At the more academic schools it’s cool to be clever not particularly to be rich. There will be a few super rich (whose parents may not have been from privileged backgrounds originally) and there will be students who have much less than yours. I never, nor did my kids, feel pressure to go on ski trips, dress expensively etc. If you model social confidence and your kids are secure in who they are, they can just be themselves.

@Notsureanymorepri

I completely agree with @Mirabai, those at private school are a mix of backgrounds. Yes there are some bankers and multimillionaires, but mostly professionals (nhs professionals/dentist/teacher/civil servant/lawyer/accountant) or people with their own business (plumber/electrician/shop or other service). What I experienced in prep was that there were a lot of sahms too but it was a long time ago!! I think your collective salary is more than ample. And I think you can afford school trips etc no problem too.

What I was talking about is a child who gets in on scholarship and is from an impoverished background or perhaps the parents are just about managing the fees, but have nothing left for anything else. Then they can’t go to birthday parties or afford even mid range (m&s type) clothes or attend after school activities etc.

I remember a few kids coming to our school late on who were from an estate, there was a lot of chat around it because none of us had ever heard of an estate before and pretty much all lived in 4-5 bed detached houses. They did settle in quite well though once the initial week or so was done.

Conversely, when I went to a non private school later, there was an issue with me living in a detached house and with my parents buying me new clothes twice a year…. Happened with a lot of my prep school friends too just awful abuse.

I don’t think your child is going to be impoverished and set aside from others in private school @Notsureanymorepri not in the least. But with your collective income after tax being in excess of a quarter of a million they will stand out from a lot of those in state school (unless it is a very posh area where catchment has pricey housing in which case it is effectively private anyway).

clappity · 08/01/2024 21:48

WickDittington · 08/01/2024 18:44

This is exactly my husband’s understanding that was challenged by many on this thread: kids at private school have an expensive lifestyle and if you are frugal/not as wealthy you are going to be feel inferior.

Hmmm, I long had this debate with my father. He went to one of the top English public schools; my mother similarly but educated abroad. They both hated their schools - my father's view on fagging is unprintable.

So they sent us to the local small primary school followed by the local bog standard comp. We lived in the country on the edge of a pretty down-trodden working class area which was the area for the local State schools. I was bullied physically & mentally from the age of 7 to 16 when thank god I did my A Levels and got out. Once at university I realised I wasn't a horrible person no-one liked, and that reading books wasn't a good reason to be punched or taunted.

The bullying was class-based, I'm pretty sure. We were known as "rich" because we read books, played tennis, and rode & sailed. All absolutely normal things to do in my family's background (yes, affluent country gentry types).

I'm philosophical about it - I'm pretty good at mixing with all sorts of people & the working-class comp rubbed the corners off me. But I wouldn't do it to a child of mine. The mental impact was something I still deal with 40 years later.

Edited

Were they not aware of the bullying? After hating school himself why was your father so pig headed to keep you at a school where you were bullied?

Justia · 08/01/2024 19:18

Flamesatmytoes · 08/01/2024 17:41

Or move to an affluent area. Plenty of CEO’s in my kids school. I think I’m the only one not driving a Range Rover or a 4x4 Bentley. I can tell you the Jones’ round here can certainly take a bit of keeping up with if that’s your thing.

True @Flamesatmytoes

It’s virtually the same thing; you pay for the property price or you pay for the private school, often both. We did former, we do not have a 4x4 though! (You’re right most parents have them at those sort of state schools!)

I obviously have a bad aftertaste from my own school experience which maybe makes me overly cautious. It was a great school, but the area surrounding had become dodgy so you had a mixed intake. Some kids had major social problems, parents alcoholic, abusive, in low paid jobs or not working… others had parents who were teachers, doctors, medium sized business owners. It was a weird mix and caused issues.

I guess OP and her DH will be able to assess the area surrounding state school if that’s what they go for.

In any event I hope she gets her things with DH resolved and he acquiesces to allow her to pay for more.

Mirabai · 08/01/2024 18:46

Notsureanymorepri · 08/01/2024 18:13

This is exactly my husband’s understanding that was challenged by many on this thread: kids at private school have an expensive lifestyle and if you are frugal/not as wealthy you are going to be feel inferior. Therefore we will feel the pressure to live the bankers’ life and feel not great about ourselves…yet many said no, every class is represented, it’s just an educational choice…any thoughts?

As I said, with respect to both @Justia and your DH, I think this is completely out of touch.

As I said there’s a big mix of backgrounds, cultures, wealth. At the more academic schools it’s cool to be clever not particularly to be rich. There will be a few super rich (whose parents may not have been from privileged backgrounds originally) and there will be students who have much less than yours. I never, nor did my kids, feel pressure to go on ski trips, dress expensively etc. If you model social confidence and your kids are secure in who they are, they can just be themselves.

WickDittington · 08/01/2024 18:44

This is exactly my husband’s understanding that was challenged by many on this thread: kids at private school have an expensive lifestyle and if you are frugal/not as wealthy you are going to be feel inferior.

Hmmm, I long had this debate with my father. He went to one of the top English public schools; my mother similarly but educated abroad. They both hated their schools - my father's view on fagging is unprintable.

So they sent us to the local small primary school followed by the local bog standard comp. We lived in the country on the edge of a pretty down-trodden working class area which was the area for the local State schools. I was bullied physically & mentally from the age of 7 to 16 when thank god I did my A Levels and got out. Once at university I realised I wasn't a horrible person no-one liked, and that reading books wasn't a good reason to be punched or taunted.

The bullying was class-based, I'm pretty sure. We were known as "rich" because we read books, played tennis, and rode & sailed. All absolutely normal things to do in my family's background (yes, affluent country gentry types).

I'm philosophical about it - I'm pretty good at mixing with all sorts of people & the working-class comp rubbed the corners off me. But I wouldn't do it to a child of mine. The mental impact was something I still deal with 40 years later.

0sci · 08/01/2024 18:41

Personally, if I were in the financial position OP is in I would not send DC to state school. You may as well stick a target on their back.

Oh yes you must keep her away from the riffraff! They're all horrible

justasking111 · 08/01/2024 18:37

I think it's somewhat regional. Our private school has farmers sons, del boys sons, builders sons, overseas sons, aristos sons. A real mixed bag.

Pick up at school, you'll find more clapped out cars than mercs, at the end of term.

saraclara · 08/01/2024 18:26

My kids didn't go to private school. But some of their friends did, and I work with people whose children go to private school. I simply don't recognise this 'keeping up with the holidays and expensive hobbies/clothes etc' thing. My friends earn less than OP and her husband, and are not remotely flashy with regard to holidays and clothes. In fact they seem similarly frugal to OP.

My daughter's best friend was transferred to private by her parents at 14. Again, no big fancy house or flashy cars. They were quiet intellectual types who had Oxbridge aspirations for her (she and my DD both interviewed, friend got in and DD didn't, so maybe their money was well spent!)

I think it entirely depends on which private school you choose. Expensive elite school? Yes, I can imagine those issues. But (and I don't live in London) I don't see it in the (pretty good) private schools near me.

Notsureanymorepri · 08/01/2024 18:15

Justia · 08/01/2024 14:55

@Sweetleftfood

I suffered physical assault at the hands of some Jodi’s. Other friends of mine had the same and/or bullying. None of us had anything like the OP’s wealth growing up, but enough for it to be an issue with some (others perfectly lovely).

Personally, if I were in the financial position OP is in I would not send DC to state school. You may as well stick a target on their back.

Sorry to hear that, must have been horrible.

OP posts:
Notsureanymorepri · 08/01/2024 18:13

Justia · 08/01/2024 14:41

@Notsureanymorepri

If a child’s parents cannot afford private school but they are bright and get a scholarship they can of course go. But they will run into problems because they won’t go on X holidays a year, they won’t be doing expensive hobbies or be able to afford the school ski trip, their clothes won’t be from xyz places. On short their standard of living is different and this can present problems with social cohesion and integration within the group.

Similarly you can expect same if OP’s child goes to a state school. They will have a different standard of living and will be at risk because of it.

In the former case there is motivation to take that risk of the child being ostracised socially because the pay of is increased academic opportunity and higher earning potential.

In the latter case, there is nothing to be gained for the child except a sense of moral superiority that they could have gone to the posh school but wanted to get along with all the rest.

I wouldn’t attempt to categorise anyone, but do you see what I’m saying - why set your child up for difficulty and ridicule if there is nothing to be gained?

This is exactly my husband’s understanding that was challenged by many on this thread: kids at private school have an expensive lifestyle and if you are frugal/not as wealthy you are going to be feel inferior. Therefore we will feel the pressure to live the bankers’ life and feel not great about ourselves…yet many said no, every class is represented, it’s just an educational choice…any thoughts?

OP posts:
Flamesatmytoes · 08/01/2024 17:41

Justia · 08/01/2024 14:55

@Sweetleftfood

I suffered physical assault at the hands of some Jodi’s. Other friends of mine had the same and/or bullying. None of us had anything like the OP’s wealth growing up, but enough for it to be an issue with some (others perfectly lovely).

Personally, if I were in the financial position OP is in I would not send DC to state school. You may as well stick a target on their back.

Or move to an affluent area. Plenty of CEO’s in my kids school. I think I’m the only one not driving a Range Rover or a 4x4 Bentley. I can tell you the Jones’ round here can certainly take a bit of keeping up with if that’s your thing.

kersh33 · 08/01/2024 16:58

As a bit of on aside OP, are you sure that the pensions contributions are lost? I moved the other way (before Brexit) and my understanding is that the years I paid in the UK will be considered to help me gain a higher pension in my current EU country (so in essence I won't have a reduction due to my number of worked years but will only get a pension pro-rata of the years I've paid in here). I'll also then get my pro-rata pension in the UK.

I would really double check that this isn't the case.

Justia · 08/01/2024 14:55

Sweetleftfood · 08/01/2024 14:24

This must be the most pathetic thing I have ever read on MN:
How exactly is a child who stands to have a multimillion inheritance going to get along with Jodi whose Mum works as a supervisor in Asda?

I think they would get along very well actually and if our stupid wealthy private educated ppl in government for instance had a few "common" friends, our country probably wouldn't be so pathetically shit

@Sweetleftfood

I suffered physical assault at the hands of some Jodi’s. Other friends of mine had the same and/or bullying. None of us had anything like the OP’s wealth growing up, but enough for it to be an issue with some (others perfectly lovely).

Personally, if I were in the financial position OP is in I would not send DC to state school. You may as well stick a target on their back.

Justia · 08/01/2024 14:41

Notsureanymorepri · 08/01/2024 12:11

Thank you for the detailed comment, Justia. would you expect the natural socioeconomic group to be for a family like ours to be found in a private school setting? Our aspiration for our child is that he gets the tools to thrive in a variety of settings, whether it’s here or abroad, curiosity, openness to others. I am probably an adult version of Jodi 😂

@Notsureanymorepri

If a child’s parents cannot afford private school but they are bright and get a scholarship they can of course go. But they will run into problems because they won’t go on X holidays a year, they won’t be doing expensive hobbies or be able to afford the school ski trip, their clothes won’t be from xyz places. On short their standard of living is different and this can present problems with social cohesion and integration within the group.

Similarly you can expect same if OP’s child goes to a state school. They will have a different standard of living and will be at risk because of it.

In the former case there is motivation to take that risk of the child being ostracised socially because the pay of is increased academic opportunity and higher earning potential.

In the latter case, there is nothing to be gained for the child except a sense of moral superiority that they could have gone to the posh school but wanted to get along with all the rest.

I wouldn’t attempt to categorise anyone, but do you see what I’m saying - why set your child up for difficulty and ridicule if there is nothing to be gained?

Sweetleftfood · 08/01/2024 14:24

This must be the most pathetic thing I have ever read on MN:
How exactly is a child who stands to have a multimillion inheritance going to get along with Jodi whose Mum works as a supervisor in Asda?

I think they would get along very well actually and if our stupid wealthy private educated ppl in government for instance had a few "common" friends, our country probably wouldn't be so pathetically shit

SkyFlyers · 08/01/2024 13:08

What exactly are the big extra expenses you have which he can’t fund on his £70k salary?

School fees…

Have you moved house and got a much larger mortgage?

Is it that you now want to go on £20k holidays?

I earn more than my DH and tbh I largely save it - plus some day-to-day expenses I don’t pay myself back for like food, kids clothes, household stuff, vet bills, flights:

TBH I’m not sure he’s even aware that I do the above. You could just pay for stuff and feign ignorance.

Otalask · 08/01/2024 13:05

Well use your excess income to buy a new house somewhere else.

How come you've not got a financial advisor to tell you all this stuff you're asking about on here? People who earn over half a million quid a year don't get finance tips from Mumsnet; it's pointless.

Swipe left for the next trending thread