Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Woman’s shoes are too narrow?

131 replies

ThanksAntsThants23 · 06/01/2024 13:21

I am a woman with quite wide feet and high arches. I have never been able to buy shoes that really fit properly. I run a lot and buying running shoes has away a been difficult, I also work outdoors and have never been able to find a pair of boots that fit so I spend my entire life flaunting risk assessments and having very wet feet by wearing my running shoes to work as they are generally the only thing that I can walk in relatively comfortably.

This year I have developed a bunion and Even the widest trainers I can feasibly buy are now too narrow for one of my feet. I’m seriously beginning to consider just walking everywhere in socks.

The thing is that I know I’m not the only woman who finds woman’s shoes too narrow, I hear it from a lot of woman, especially other runners. Lost of people say they just buy men’s shoes but thats not an option if, like me you have feet smaller than a uk 6. I’m starting to get quite enraged by the lack of shoes available for wider feet.

Are standard woman’s shoes too narrow for the average woman’s foot.

YANBU -standard woman’s shoes are too narrow for the average foot

YABU - standard woman’s shoe width is fine for the average woman and you have no business expecting your weird troll feet and bunion to fit in shoes made for delicate ladies.

OP posts:
Simd1 · 06/01/2024 14:32

NeverDropYourMooncup · 06/01/2024 14:24

Roughly 12 posts from people who have wide feet and would agree or sympathise with the OP and the rest are people falling over their tiny, delicate little glass slippered toes to tell MN how terribly massive shoes are - and even one bordering on 'We've lost sight of what normal feet look like'.

If wearing a larger (ie, Men's 6) shoe plus an orthotic - hence the larger size - doesn't work, OP, perhaps looking at specialist shops would help? There's one called DC Wide Fit from memory, which might give you some ideas for other brands.

I've got average width feet and find most women's shoes fine in width, so would disagree with the OP's theory, yet as a size 9 I definitely can't claim to have tiny, delicate, glass-slippered toes unfortunately.

greengreengrass25 · 06/01/2024 14:32

Gettingcolder · 06/01/2024 14:30

I have narrow feet and cannot buy any shoes from standard shops. Average shoe widths sold in the shops have got wider over the last 20 years. I could get size C in some shops back in the 1970s/80s but not anymore. Even D widths are rare now.

So true

I'm sure they still do width fitting for dc so what changes

I tend to buy lace ups or Mark Jane styles or Boots but slip ons are not great on me

Hotter did narrow shoes then stopped which was frustrating

BrownTableMat · 06/01/2024 14:31

YABU. I’m far from a delicate fairy in physique but I have narrow feet and most shoes are too wide for me. It’s particularly difficult as I really need specialist shoes due to dodgy ankles and arthritic toes, and all the models I can find are wide fitting as if they assume that if you’ve got foot problems you must have wide feet. But then, I’ve got a friend (who also isn’t a sylph) who can’t wear the vast majority of British shoe brands at all as they’re all too wide, and ends up buying hers from the US.

I agree that it’d be great to have a much greater variety of widths on offer, but it simply isn’t true to say that those of us with narrow feet are fine on the high street (or even with specialist brands) - quite the opposite in my experience.

Poppins2016 · 06/01/2024 14:31

NeverDropYourMooncup · 06/01/2024 14:24

Roughly 12 posts from people who have wide feet and would agree or sympathise with the OP and the rest are people falling over their tiny, delicate little glass slippered toes to tell MN how terribly massive shoes are - and even one bordering on 'We've lost sight of what normal feet look like'.

If wearing a larger (ie, Men's 6) shoe plus an orthotic - hence the larger size - doesn't work, OP, perhaps looking at specialist shops would help? There's one called DC Wide Fit from memory, which might give you some ideas for other brands.

Well... the thread title is the question "women's shoes are too narrow?" and therefore I naturally clicked on the thread because I wanted to answer the question with my view (I don't think they are too narrow).

However, that doesn't mean that I don't think the OP has a valid point... there is certainly an issue with shoe sizing and more options are needed.

novhange · 06/01/2024 14:31

NeverDropYourMooncup · 06/01/2024 14:24

Roughly 12 posts from people who have wide feet and would agree or sympathise with the OP and the rest are people falling over their tiny, delicate little glass slippered toes to tell MN how terribly massive shoes are - and even one bordering on 'We've lost sight of what normal feet look like'.

If wearing a larger (ie, Men's 6) shoe plus an orthotic - hence the larger size - doesn't work, OP, perhaps looking at specialist shops would help? There's one called DC Wide Fit from memory, which might give you some ideas for other brands.

Why would I vote for standardising shoes for wide feet? It would be like turkeys voting for Christmas.

Of course people who fit into standard shoes will want them to stay the same. People will always want what’s best and easiest and cheapest for them.

The ideal is all shoes in a variety of sizes and widths.

Gettingcolder · 06/01/2024 14:30

I have narrow feet and cannot buy any shoes from standard shops. Average shoe widths sold in the shops have got wider over the last 20 years. I could get size C in some shops back in the 1970s/80s but not anymore. Even D widths are rare now.

2024sNewName · 06/01/2024 14:30

HunterHearstHelmsley · 06/01/2024 13:44

I don't have particularly dainty feet. I've found shoes are becoming wider. It's been a nightmare to buy trainers for the gym lately as they seem huge. Flats (ballet pump style) always seem to flop off! I've never had a problem previously. Recently I've been saying I think shops are doing vanity sizes for shoes now, as well as shoes being wide, I've also apparently shrunk a shoe size... But all my old shoes still fit..

Same, I'm a definite 3 now whereas I used to be a 4 and previously, 25 yrs ago, sometimes a 5.

Jacopo · 06/01/2024 14:29

‘Roughly 12 posts from people who have wide feet and would agree or sympathise with the OP and the rest are people falling over their tiny, delicate little glass slippered toes to tell MN how terribly massive shoes are - and even one bordering on 'We've lost sight of what normal feet look like'.’

How rude. I’m not tiny and delicate nor am I trying to shame other people’s feet. It used to be possible to buy shoes that fit me, now I can’t because manufacturers are catering for wider feet. If you’re sympathetic to wider-footed people that’s fine, but believe me it’s just as difficult trying to find narrow fitting shoes!

spanishviola · 06/01/2024 14:29

I have narrow feet but need a wide toe box for bunion/prevention of bunion purposes. I also have very high arches. It’s impossible to find shoes that fit.

Natsku · 06/01/2024 14:28

I find them too wide in parts but too tight in the toes, its very difficult to find shoes that fit me right. Had to get safety shoes and the ones that fit well enough that my feet don't slide at the heel when I walk are just a bit too tight in the toes, alright for a few hours but by the end of the day they are quite uncomfortable.

thankyouforthedayz · 06/01/2024 14:26

HeadNorth · 06/01/2024 14:11

Why do people keep suggesting the OP buy men’s running shoes when she explicitly states her feet are too small for men’s shoes? It is so annoying, as I am size 4 so men’s shoes are not a solution for my hobbit feet. But it does raise the obvious question - why are men’s shoes wider than women’s? Is there any proof all men have wider feet or is is a sexist assumption that women’s feet should be ‘daintier’.

Men's feet tend to be longer and wider.

Kwasi · 06/01/2024 14:26

NeverDropYourMooncup · 06/01/2024 14:24

Roughly 12 posts from people who have wide feet and would agree or sympathise with the OP and the rest are people falling over their tiny, delicate little glass slippered toes to tell MN how terribly massive shoes are - and even one bordering on 'We've lost sight of what normal feet look like'.

If wearing a larger (ie, Men's 6) shoe plus an orthotic - hence the larger size - doesn't work, OP, perhaps looking at specialist shops would help? There's one called DC Wide Fit from memory, which might give you some ideas for other brands.

My mum always complains about her narrow feet. At least she can wear shoes without her circulation being cut off!

Jacopo · 06/01/2024 14:25

YABVVU because manufacturers have reduced the range of narrow shoes available and have increased the range of wide fittings!!!
I presume they think that because the population overall is getting bigger/fatter people’s feet are getting wider.
I have narrow feet and it’s incredibly difficult to get shoes that fit unless one is prepared to pay £££££££££££!!!!!

NeverDropYourMooncup · 06/01/2024 14:24

Roughly 12 posts from people who have wide feet and would agree or sympathise with the OP and the rest are people falling over their tiny, delicate little glass slippered toes to tell MN how terribly massive shoes are - and even one bordering on 'We've lost sight of what normal feet look like'.

If wearing a larger (ie, Men's 6) shoe plus an orthotic - hence the larger size - doesn't work, OP, perhaps looking at specialist shops would help? There's one called DC Wide Fit from memory, which might give you some ideas for other brands.

Onabench · 06/01/2024 14:22

Shoes are too narrow and do not cater the the real shape of feet, unless you go out of your way to find them. People with narrower feet don’t really find an issue with putting their toes into these shoes. But if you have slightly wider feet it can be hard. I think most retailers are moving towards wider shoes, but in the same narrow style and not shoes that actually fit feet.

PeppermintParty · 06/01/2024 14:20

Cosyfeet make really wide shoes, but the styles seem to be aimed at older people, not current fashion, but you might be able to get walking boots from them.

DollyDaydreamW · 06/01/2024 14:19

@ThanksAntsThants23 Birkenstock also do safety boots, nonslip work shoes, steel toe caps etc if you need ones that are suitable for safety/work. Hopefully they'd be small and wide enough! Not sure how small their sizes go.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 06/01/2024 14:19

I run a lot and have bunions on both feet. I can fit in normal running shoes generally with looser lacing, although the quite severe bunion on my right foot means that this shoe wears very quickly and tends to 'split' around the seam near the bunion. I wear Skechers in men's size 7 for work (on my feet) and Muck Boots in size 8 (to get the width) with extra socks for outdoor work.

Mens's shoes tend to be wider, so I buy those in size 7. I'm a size 6.5 but find women's shoes in that size tend to be pinchy.

Kwasi · 06/01/2024 14:18

Oh, and Vionic for wide fit trainers/running shoes.

FairytaleOfKent · 06/01/2024 14:17

I have wide feet and ASICS are my go-to trainers. My mum has bunions too and fits in ASICS.

In general I would say that shoes are getting wider, probably because women are opting for more comfortable shoes than previous generations. We're also getting larger as a population, which results in a higher demand for wider shoes. I'm not saying everyone with wide feet is overweight by the way - I'm not overweight.

Kwasi · 06/01/2024 14:15

I have small but extremely broad feet.

I wear Fly London, as they're wide fitting. Converse also do their basic colours in a wider fit.

I buy junior Timberland's, as they're much wider than women's. I can't even get women's Timberland's on.

DollyDaydreamW · 06/01/2024 14:12

I wear bare foot shoes/boots, usually with Birkenstock arch support insoles added in them. Or just regular fit Birkenstocks which are both supportive and wide (in the "regular" width fitting, which confusingly is the wide fit).

I've now had to get rid of all my other shoes, my feet have changed shape due to wearing these (and stopped hurting as much since my toes have had enough room to be proper toes 😁)

Good seamless walking socks with wool and arch support also help me loads. I'm pretty evangelical about birks and bare foots nowadays afte years of literally deforming my feet in pretty shoes. Never again!

HeadNorth · 06/01/2024 14:11

Why do people keep suggesting the OP buy men’s running shoes when she explicitly states her feet are too small for men’s shoes? It is so annoying, as I am size 4 so men’s shoes are not a solution for my hobbit feet. But it does raise the obvious question - why are men’s shoes wider than women’s? Is there any proof all men have wider feet or is is a sexist assumption that women’s feet should be ‘daintier’.

Vinorosso74 · 06/01/2024 14:10

Another narrow footed one here! I never buy shoes as they are always too wide. Sandals aren't so bad but they can be tricky.
I generally wear Converse or other trainers as they can be tightened, occasionally boots.
DD has inherited my narrow feet. Thankfully she doesn't have a school uniform as when she did for a few weeks (changed school) trying to get suitable black shoes was a nightmare!
There should be more variety of widths and half sizes along with different lengths in clothing!

Naptrappedmummy · 06/01/2024 14:04

DelilahBucket · 06/01/2024 13:26

These days I find women's shoes too wide for my feet. I have narrow feet anyway and everywhere seems to cater for a much wider fitting.
Have you tried men's running trainers? You might get a better fit.

I agree. People’s feet have got wider, almost every shop does wide fit shoes now so you shouldn’t have a problem? Narrow shoes are like hens teeth.