Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think it would be easier to lose weight if you had more time ?

268 replies

kitchenlover · 06/01/2024 12:11

I am really really struggling to sort myself out with this.

Are these all just excuses though ?

I have lost weight successfully in the past, but I've also been exhausted by the whole thing.

I need to be super strict and spend around 2 hours in the gym a day, ( 5 days a week at least ) in order to see a change in my body. It's exhausting.

I have a full time job, two preschool aged children and a completely absent H, due to his work.

I also suffer from a condition which causes fatigue. So I start off with less energy than most people anyway. That is not even taking account the fact that I do all night wakings with my kids.

I just can't do all of this AND spend the time shopping/ meal prepping and going to the gym a lot.

How do people manage ? I really need to get back to a healthy weight and the only way I can see this happening is if I just don't work for a bit. I can afford to do this and yes I posted about this the other day. However I keep thinking- what if I take some time out from work to sort myself out and then I don't even manage to lose weight ?

Am I just making excuses ? How do people with so many responsibilities do it ??

OP posts:
Riverlee · 06/01/2024 13:37

My advice would be to skip one gym session per week and use that time to meal plan for the next week or two.

Twinklewonderkins · 06/01/2024 13:37

I’m menopausal and have other health conditions, I’ve lost 3 stone (want to lose another 1) dieting . I have been pretty strict diet wise.
Not set foot in the gym, I’d quite like to but the local ones are all expensive (council one miles away across town). I just do Pilates on YouTube couple of times a week and a 10 min abs thing also on YouTube. I work full time in a fairly full on job, single mum with high school age dc.
weight loss is almost all diet.

Crushed23 · 06/01/2024 13:32

No, definitely not. Generally, the more time I have, the more likely I am to indulge in idle snacking. I gained weight during lockdown, for example. Having a busy, active life is one the main reasons I am thin (because I certainly love food!)

NeedToChangeName · 06/01/2024 13:31

Agree with PP, what you eat is more important than exercise, for weight loss

gamerchick · 06/01/2024 13:31

The way you're looking at it isn't favourable though. 30-40 minutes gym is enough and it isn't walking for miles on a treadmill. You have to eat. The sheer amount of food is the only complaint I have about gym going because food is bloody boring. Not eating properly means less energy. Not drinking enough means less energy. What's the point of doing that to yourself?

You're 'failing ' because it doesn't work. You would be better off joining a class with a PT and learn to fuel your body properly so you don't feel like you're punishing yourself.

withthischoice · 06/01/2024 13:30

Op reread your posts
it is just one excuse after another.

kitchenlover · 06/01/2024 13:26

I can't really do more walking to and from school, as it's over 6 miles one way.

I find that when I go to the gym at lunch etc, I'm just too knackered to then focus on work properly.

I did this for a while and started really falling behind. Doing walks etc at weekends is ok, as I don't need to then work afterwards.

I was really active on maternity leave and did well. All went to s* when I started work again. I'm much worse for it. I'm very uncomfortable in my body. I would literally give anything to be able to sort it out. Hence the pretty drastic step I'm thinking of taking. I'm just worried I'll fail again, as I've been failing so much at it.

OP posts:
Moonlightdust · 06/01/2024 13:25

kitchenlover · 06/01/2024 12:41

Well guys, I've lost weight before and really changed my body shape- and it needed at least 1 hour 30 minutes in the gym - 5 times a week at minimum.

I also ate very little and did intermittent fasting.

My body is very very very difficult to shit pounds from. I wish it was as easy as just skipping a meal for me, it's not.

Here lies the problem - you claim you ate very little. It sounds like your body was holding onto the few calories being consumed. In order to loose weight healthily your diet has to change. It’s not about starving yourself - it’s eating regular balanced meals. You shouldn’t be hungry if you are eating correctly. Make sure you are consuming enough protein if you are working out that much. But really 30 mins exercise a day is enough OP to see results.

mynameiscalypso · 06/01/2024 13:17

kitchenlover · 06/01/2024 13:15

Did you guys read how I described my workouts ?

I'm not going nuts for two hours. Two hours is the max time I spend in there. A lot of it is also spent just walking on the treadmill.

The workouts are slower and not intense as I can't do that. That's why it takes longer.

Does that make sense ? It's just how I prefer to do it and how it's worked for me in the past.

Could you incorporate walking more into your day to day life so you don't need to go to the gym to walk on the treadmill? Walking the school run (or some of it) or going out for a lunchtime walk if you're WFH? Going for a long walk at the weekend with the children? That kind of thing which becomes part of your life rather than needing to devote so much time to the gym?

NigelHarmansNewWife · 06/01/2024 13:17

@fastingworks - I do not think advising one meal a day to the OP is helpful. Seriously there is no need to cut out food groups, skip meals, deny yourself the things you like eating.

OP look at meal planning and batch cooking so you have healthy choices available you can quickly heat up. Buy frozen veg - it's higher in nutrients than fresh because it's chopped and frozen within a short time of being picked or dug up. You can even buy diced frozen onion, garlic and herbs. Less prep and use just what you need so less waste. You want your kids to have a good relationship with food and that starts with you and your DH modelling that.

UnaOfStormhold · 06/01/2024 13:16

Hmm, it definitely sounds like having a bit more time for yourself would be beneficial, but giving up work entirely can have long term consequences. Is there any way you can get more help? Can your spouse take a bit of time off to give you a break, or friends, or family, or paid childcare? Is there a gym creche? As for work, is it possible to cut your hours a bit or take longer lunch breaks so you can fit in exercise without dropping work entirely? I don't think trying to exercise full time is necessarily going to be good for you.

The other thing to consider is how to fit in exercise into your life more smoothly. For example, are there ways you could make your gym time more efficient so you get the same amount of work out of a shorter period of time? Say doing heavier weights for fewer reps, and pairing exercises into sets so you do e.g. a legs exercise while you rest from an arms exercise? Working out at home after the kids are asleep or before they wake might work too though I find those are the ones.

Another helpful thing is making your daily routine more active, say jogging to school while the kids scoot/cycle alongside, or going for a run etc while they are both at an activity (I squeezed in 25 mins in the gym while my son was at swimming this morning for example). I have also been known to do a few pull ups or jumps on the playground equipment! Also short bursts of activity can be surprisingly beneficial, say having a weight or resistance band in the kitchen so you can fit in a few reps while the kettle boils or the oven heats up. It all adds up.

But generally, give yourself a break mentally - you have a lot on your plate, struggle with fatigue and have 2 young kids to wrangle single-handed.

kitchenlover · 06/01/2024 13:15

Did you guys read how I described my workouts ?

I'm not going nuts for two hours. Two hours is the max time I spend in there. A lot of it is also spent just walking on the treadmill.

The workouts are slower and not intense as I can't do that. That's why it takes longer.

Does that make sense ? It's just how I prefer to do it and how it's worked for me in the past.

OP posts:
Dashel · 06/01/2024 13:15

I live too far away from a gym to make going practical. I have a bad back and can’t run or do HIIT as instructed by physio and doctors. I also struggle to loose weight.

So I got a spin bike and a Les Mills subscription and so RPM three or four days a week and every day I do Get Fit with Rick walking workouts on YouTube and I got some weights and a weight bench and and do strength training at home. Not the 1, 3 and 5kg sets but up to 15kg hex dumbbells and will be getting a bigger pair when ready.

All of this was second hand and for me it works along with hitting my 15k steps and not snacking and meal planning.

It is time consuming but a lunch time walk really helps to minimise I the time and an early start.

I would find something the kids Enjoy as well to exercise as a family. There is Shabam on Les mills which is danced based and stuff aimed at kids

Joeslaol19 · 06/01/2024 13:14

It is true that if you are busy there can be a tendency to eat convenience food but the exercise argument doesn’t require going to the gym. Go for a brisk walk ,swim ,run and cut out carbs . I am probably a lot older than you and have recently lost 12 kgs over 3 months just doing that !

gamerchick · 06/01/2024 13:13

kitchenlover · 06/01/2024 12:35

Yeah but if I don't go to the gym and do weights and cardio, I will just end up all saggy. I think you definitely need to combine a good diet with weights and cardio, as you need to maintain muscle mass.

You don't need to spend 2 hours a day in the gym for that though.

Watchkeys · 06/01/2024 13:11

I wish it was as easy as just skipping a meal for me, it's not

Just to take this to the extreme, and not at all suggesting you do this, but hypothetically, if you stopped eating altogether, what do you think would happen to your weight? Are the the one magical being who has learned to both conserve and use the same energy?

Have you had a medical examination and blood tests? It sounds like your body might be conserving energy rather than using it, so you retain excess but feel tired.

How long do you go between consuming calories? Are you eating/snacking/drinking on a regular basis, or do you have big gaps?

I'm a PT, and my advice would be that if there's nothing physiologically wrong with you, you absolutely do not need 2 hours in the gym on any day of the week, let alone on several. If there is something physiologically wrong, you need to get that fixed prior to trying to lose weight. So, either way, you never need 2 hours in the gym again.

kitchenlover · 06/01/2024 13:11

theriseandfallofFranklinSaint · 06/01/2024 13:08

I don't know about needing more time but in my experience, I do think you need more money.

I've always gone to the gym 4-5 x week as I enjoy it and use it to wind down after work however I've now got a PT and love my sessions and feel let down if I only manage 4 x week. However this costs £175 per month (monthly gym fee plus PT)

Due to now concentrating on weight lifting and not cardio, I've totally rehashed my diet and eat so much more protein than before but this isn't cheap. Our shopping now has so much more chicken, salmon, yoghurts, protein powder, etc. but that isn't cheap and our shopping bill has increased by quite a bit.

However I'm on my way to getting the toned body I used to have, I'm so much fitter and stronger and healthier too as my diet is better than it was. Buying food may cost more but I'd always prepped my lunches for work so I don't need more time in that respect.

Your health and wellbeing is the best thing you can spend that money on. Good for you.

OP posts:
theriseandfallofFranklinSaint · 06/01/2024 13:08

I don't know about needing more time but in my experience, I do think you need more money.

I've always gone to the gym 4-5 x week as I enjoy it and use it to wind down after work however I've now got a PT and love my sessions and feel let down if I only manage 4 x week. However this costs £175 per month (monthly gym fee plus PT)

Due to now concentrating on weight lifting and not cardio, I've totally rehashed my diet and eat so much more protein than before but this isn't cheap. Our shopping now has so much more chicken, salmon, yoghurts, protein powder, etc. but that isn't cheap and our shopping bill has increased by quite a bit.

However I'm on my way to getting the toned body I used to have, I'm so much fitter and stronger and healthier too as my diet is better than it was. Buying food may cost more but I'd always prepped my lunches for work so I don't need more time in that respect.

fastingworks · 06/01/2024 13:07

Look up Dr Eric Berg OMAD on YouTube.OMAD means one meal a day.The health benefits will be explained.
It will also save you time & money.
I have much more energy since I started intermittent fasting.

kitchenlover · 06/01/2024 13:06

minipie · 06/01/2024 13:02

*I have a full time job, two preschool aged children and a completely absent H, due to his work.

I also suffer from a condition which causes fatigue. So I start off with less energy than most people anyway. That is not even taking account the fact that I do all night wakings with my kids.*

I was in this position. I had put weight on but it wasn’t due to not exercising as I never did any exercise pre kids either 😳. It’s due to the stress and the exhaustion and reaching for quick comforting food as a pick me up. Also thyroid in my case (have you had yours tested?) which I suspect was exacerbated by stress.

The exercise is a red herring. The weight is a red herring too except that it’s a symptom of being overloaded. You need to reduce your load somehow or you will break.

Your H needs to share more of the load. He is working FT so are you, you are a parent so is he, why the hell are you doing all the night wakings and why does he get to be completely absent.

This is definitely true. The stress and exhaustion and reaching for quick food that's there.

I swear when my son was going through this stage when he was around 1, where he needed to be picked up around the clock, otherwise he'd scream - I would just quickly eat whatever was near and it would calm me down from the anxiety and stress of all the screaming.

It's better now, I am able to control myself a bit more as the screaming has stopped. Same with night time wakings.

Any attempts I've made at losing weight through diet alone have failed. Or only lasted a few months. I need a radical lifestyle change.

H cannot do more. It's just the situation right now.

OP posts:
devildeepbluesea · 06/01/2024 13:04

If you need to spend 5 x 2 hours per week in the gym, you’re doing the gym wrong. Ask a PT, lift heavier weights and halve your workout time

However I undoubtedly lose weight more easily if I have time to think about my diet more. My job is so bloody manic I never have time to make food (wfh) so end up snacking on crap all afternoon. I really need to focus more on prep.

NigelHarmansNewWife · 06/01/2024 13:04

If you already suffer from a condition which means you have fatigue then a long cardio session every day is sure fire way to get burn out and make it worse. It will also make you hungry without contributing very much at all to your weight loss.

Concentrate on lifting weights/bodyweight exercises and increase your walking where possible, no need to go mad. Consume fewer calories than you expend and you will lose weight whether you eat a diet with lean protein, veg and complex carbs or just eat several chocolate bars a day. Eating a varied diet, counting calories and macros will be easier and more enjoyable. Do not exclude foods you like because you think they are "bad", instead learn how to eat them as part of your diet.

kitchenlover · 06/01/2024 13:03

kitsuneghost · 06/01/2024 12:58

You said you did it before
You need to look at why you gave up
Was it unsustainable?
If it was unsustainable then it will be unsustainable now.

You say you don't get results without 2h at the gym daily. How long before you see results generally? Do you need a quick win? Maybe you need to change your mindset to slow, steady and sustainable.

Set your goal for next Christmas not next Tuesday.

I had two children and it was very difficult after that tbh. I just don't have enough energy to do it all and the gym stuff is what slipped.

OP posts:
minipie · 06/01/2024 13:02

*I have a full time job, two preschool aged children and a completely absent H, due to his work.

I also suffer from a condition which causes fatigue. So I start off with less energy than most people anyway. That is not even taking account the fact that I do all night wakings with my kids.*

I was in this position. I had put weight on but it wasn’t due to not exercising as I never did any exercise pre kids either 😳. It’s due to the stress and the exhaustion and reaching for quick comforting food as a pick me up. Also thyroid in my case (have you had yours tested?) which I suspect was exacerbated by stress.

The exercise is a red herring. The weight is a red herring too except that it’s a symptom of being overloaded. You need to reduce your load somehow or you will break.

Your H needs to share more of the load. He is working FT so are you, you are a parent so is he, why the hell are you doing all the night wakings and why does he get to be completely absent.

kitchenlover · 06/01/2024 13:01

5128gap · 06/01/2024 12:53

I only managed to lose the two stone extra I'd carried for ten years because of lockdown. Having nothing to do but focus on my diet and health as a 'project' was an absolute game changer. I had time to research the foods that were best for me, to look into the sort of excercise that would be most beneficial, to cook properly, to go on long walks, to get enough test and sleep. I've managed to keep all but 7lb of the weight off since normal life has resumed, but its a real struggle now I've less time and more to do.

Unfortunately this is how it's worked for me in the past. I find losing weight exhausting. It takes over everything. Once I've lost the weight, I find maintenance much more bearable.

I was doing well while on maternity leave, I was exercising a lot but since being back at work for about a year now, it's just so bad.

I work from home exclusively, so I'm used to being at home all the time. It doesn't help.

I would go to the gym after dropping kids off at nursery etc and then I plan to go to shops, come home and cook and then pick them up again. I would try not to eat anything ' big ' until I've picked them up. I may have a protein shake after the gym.

Just to reiterate the two hours gym thing- I am not in there for two hours at maximum effort level. I do slow and steady exercises as it's better for my body. So that will be maybe an hour of different weight exercises and then more LISS style cardio at the end.

Food wise, lots of lean protein.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread