Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we wouldn't have as many MH problems if we lived differently

305 replies

Ginlette · 06/01/2024 09:03

Panic attacks, anxiety, depression...

How much of this is happening because of the way our society is set up?

If we all lived in fairly small communities and had good relationships with friends and family near by, would we have these issues? If we had stable work that didn't feel like an impossible workload and paid fairly?

I'm even beginning to wonder whether "positives" of modern living are actually subtly undermining our MH as a society.

  • The obvious examples being the Internet and phones, but also..
  • Mobility: looks good on paper, but maybe the idea of the world being your oyster subconsciously is anxiety inducing?
  • Travel: fun but frequent travel again contributes
  • Home ownership and improvements, style & beauty inprovements: again this idea of we have choice, but is it contributing to a low level sense of always chasing?
  • More freedom of partner and freedom to have children or be childfree: but does it create a "What if?" sensation past generations wouldn't have had fluttering at the edges of their mind?
  • Remote working/self employed: I have done this for over a decade but does it maybe contribute to a sense of no base, no community?
OP posts:
phoenixrosehere · 06/01/2024 12:04

KvotheTheBloodless · 06/01/2024 11:48

No, you can't say it's personal choice once something becomes the norm in society.

Refusing to use social media or massively limiting it wouldn't work unless your friends and family did the same.

People can massively limit it though if they choose to and they can choose the people they talk to.

There are still personal choices made in its use regardless.

katepilar · 06/01/2024 12:01

DiaNaranja · 06/01/2024 09:26

I agree mostly, but I don't think the ability to travel creates mental health issues for most. I love travelling, and being on holiday with my family creates such a calm sense of wellbeing, and recharges us all for the next few months before we can get away again. We holiday in the UK and abroad, and everytime we come back feeling relaxed and happier

While for other it creates stress /about planning, finances, packing.../ and pressure to go somewhere and do things.

MikeRafone · 06/01/2024 12:01

I do remember in the 1960s and 1970s that MH was labelled differently, it was Mrs Robinson down the road suffers with her nerves, or Miss Lane has got a prescription for valium as she needs the help.

The asylums were full to bursting that people were moved from Liverpool to Warwick or out of London to different asylums as the sheer numbers were so very high. Looking through the asylum records of inmates of the 1880s there would be notes and you'd think they'd be given tablets now and live a relatively normal life.

Some didn't go to the asylum they literally walked into the canal to end it all, coroners inquest would take place and the witness often told of a man (most were men even back then) that was in a depressed state

The way we live is indeed a factor to our mental state but its not something new and proportionally do we have more people with MH or is it that its more spoken about

TheKeatingFive · 06/01/2024 11:58

Kind of. I suspect that to get back what suits humans best psychologically, you'd have to go way back - to hunter gatherer times.

Once we started getting relatively comfortable, it messes with our psyche a bit. Counter intuitive I know.

However it's not even in question that phones and social media have had a dire effect, on top of everything else. Particularly for young people. Engaging with our environments and the people physically around us is really important to our well being.

Grammarnut · 06/01/2024 11:58

So true about choice, most of it is illusory. It's freedom to dine at the Ritz - if you can afford to. But that choice is not really a choice we have. Just as choice in everything else is not a real choice. My DH lived on Shetland for nearly twenty years and was totally phazed to see 30 different types of orange squash in a supermarket. We do not need 30 types of orange squash! Too much choice is as disempowering as too little. I do not need to be able to choose which hospital I have my ears examined at, I need to be able to rely on my GP's referral. I need equality of opportunity for everyone and a safety net I cannot fall through - I do not need competitive electricity companies who all charge the same and whose offers are impossible to understand (a nationalized electricity board worked much better) and leave me no better off, whichever I choose; nor do I need competitive water companies that commodify what we all need - water - and cannot do without. These choices are also illusory because, in reality, we have no choice but to buy them. All this gives everyone a sense of freedom and then they discover that the important things they need are not within their freedom - a mother cannot afford to stay home with her children, a grandmother cannot afford to stop working at 65 (and is not allowed to, either, she'll lose pension benefit). Those are real choices. How many sorts of orange juice and the ability to have competitive water companies are a chimaera hiding our real lack of choice.

Savedpassword · 06/01/2024 11:57

Over medicalisation of normal feelings, emotions snd difficulties. Lack of family support when raising children. Lack of knowledge about managing simple childhood illnesses ( see regular MN threads about pyrexia in children and the rush to phone 111 attend A&E) Poor sleep and poor appetite/food intake in children being medicalised.
Parents and children rushing to label themselves with ‘social anxiety’

All much worse since Covid but I honestly despair for society. No resilience, no desire to self help and so many people living in utter misery.

Diagnosed depression and genuine mental health conditions are a completely different ballgame but the care and management of those conditions is being adversely affected by the soaring demands placed on services by the former.

daisychain01 · 06/01/2024 11:57

Having 32 types of bread and cereals (when it used to be white loaf, hovis loaf, cornflakes or weetabix) is the price we pay for capitalism, competition and choice. The consummerism nowadays is the scourge of society, the damnation of the environment but it lines the fat cats' pockets nicely.

Add social media on top and you have a toxic mix of FOMO, self-doubt and inadequacy to add into it.

I've rejected most of it a long time ago, I can think more clearly and zero feelings of FOMO, by ridding myself of the constant distraction and chatter of people who aren't real friends and sensationalist media that clamours for attention and destroyed my MH. The game changer is setting those healthy boundaries!

Ginlette · 06/01/2024 11:56

Willmafrockfit · 06/01/2024 11:52

that is true @Ginlette i would prefer a physical touch

Yeah, or say you had a messy break up... Just head to your aunts and stay over night. Feeling a bit down for no reason...Just pop over to your mums and slump on the sofa watching that god awful "one born every minute" she loves while listening to the sound of a dishwasher....Meet your brother for a pint last minute...
Those are the sort of casual interactions things like video calling can't replace for me, because with the latter you have to be very present. The former is about just being physically near people who love and support you (recognise this only works if you're close to your family)

OP posts:
Willmafrockfit · 06/01/2024 11:55

i had to work in lockdown, the anxiety of covid was like nothing else

inamarina · 06/01/2024 11:54

CharmedCult · 06/01/2024 09:26

Everyone is different and some peoples mental health would really suffer in different circumstances. The prime example being lockdown - some folk really thrived and found a huge improvement in their mental health, some became really mentally unwell.

I do think the vast majority of people see an improvement in their mental health when they come off social media though.

I think the lockdowns are a really good example.
Even when you compare people in similar life situations, like families with kids.
Some enjoyed the lockdowns because of the slower pace, more time together as a family etc, while others really struggled with having to juggle homeschooling and work, and also the general sense of being restricted.
Same goes for other groups.

TitaniasAss · 06/01/2024 11:53

lavenderphase · 06/01/2024 09:37

We've got a grossly unequal society where housing and work is insecure.
We can't trust the people who are supposed to lead us, protect us, care for us if we are unwell, educate our kids.
We still face racism, homophobia, misogyny, transphobia.
There's so much hate and division it's no wonder a huge amount of us are feeling anxious and depressed.

I think this has probably always been the case.

Willmafrockfit · 06/01/2024 11:52

that is true @Ginlette i would prefer a physical touch

Ginlette · 06/01/2024 11:51

Willmafrockfit · 06/01/2024 11:49

but social media/internet has made the world smaller, my dd travel/live abroad and i can speak to them, via video if i want like they are next door

I think that's the point and it really comes down to personality, but although my family are in touch daily by eg WhatsApp I don't see it as it being like they are next door at all.

OP posts:
Willmafrockfit · 06/01/2024 11:49

but social media/internet has made the world smaller, my dd travel/live abroad and i can speak to them, via video if i want like they are next door

stayathomer · 06/01/2024 11:49

Your list makes a lot of sense to me personally, and I know a lot of people who are miserable with wfh, but then I know others who are happier than they’ve ever been. The ‘you can do anything/go anywhere’ definitely has a LOT to answer for too! Great post op

Ginlette · 06/01/2024 11:48

For me personally the geographical mobility has been a blight. We grew up bouncing around countries and now my immediate family is scattered across 5 different countries, I also find it difficult to settle and keep bouncing around although what I actually crave is a hyper local family set up

OP posts:
KvotheTheBloodless · 06/01/2024 11:48

phoenixrosehere · 06/01/2024 11:38

*studies have shown that as humans. We must interact. Social media has stopped us talking face to face which has a HUGE part to do with mental health and how we work as humanity.

we need to get rid of social media which not only stops us talking but we are different behind a screen….this is a proven fact.*

I disagree. Social Media hasn’t stopped people from talking face to face. Where’s the personal responsibility?

People make the choice to use SM.

People make the choice on what they engage or not engage in on SM.

People make the choice on who they want to talk to face to face.

People are often different behind the screen because it is easier and more comfortable to say what they really think anonymously than it is in real life.

Why not question why people feel the need to be on SM vs talking face to face to those around them?

Getting rid of it would be detrimental to many imo because of the positive reasons people use it for.

No, you can't say it's personal choice once something becomes the norm in society.

Refusing to use social media or massively limiting it wouldn't work unless your friends and family did the same.

Ginlette · 06/01/2024 11:46

TempyBrennan · 06/01/2024 11:42

I remember watching a documentary about supermarkets, and the limited stock and variety they used to have and honestly I think that sounds great. Now it’s 32 different types of bread? Hurts my brain trying to do life sometimes and things like this really do work there way into my head 😂

It has definitely happened to me before where I want to buy say a serum, so I go to Boots, look at the 30 options available and leave empty handed. I'm wondering whether that's a bit of a symbol for life as some of us are currently experiencing it, I do recognise that's a privileged position and it's down to your personality too

OP posts:
Emotionalsupportviper · 06/01/2024 11:44

We'd have had different problems - not necessarily fewer.

GreenAppleCrumble · 06/01/2024 11:44

Sorry, haven’t read the whole thread yet but I agree with a lot of the OP.

I think the main thing that is ruining our MH is technology.

I think, in that regard, we were a lot better when you couldn’t hold a computer in the palm of your hand every minute of the day. Not saying I am some sort of Luddite who wants tv banned… but I think there was a sort of sweet spot when people watched what was on tv when it was on, phoned people when they were at home, sent the odd email perhaps. Unfortunately this sweet spot came at a time (mid 90s I’d say) when homophobia, sexism etc were still very prevalent and lots of people’s MH suffered in other ways.

Technology as it is now is an absolute blight on our lives. Even the simplest task is full of frustration, different log-ins, passwords, glitches etc. The technology giants are deliberately making it virtually impossible to share devices (whereas you could in the past easily log in and out of different accounts in the same device). Business software has become too clever for its own good and constantly tries to merge things and second-guess everything. It’s an absolute mess.

I know it sounds a bit ‘tin foil hat’ but I believe the companies running this have one aim in mind: everyone online all the time with their own (expensive) devices that become obsolete and unworkable at least every 12 months.

KvotheTheBloodless · 06/01/2024 11:43

Yes - modern life is very isolating. People interact through a screen rather than face to face, which means the shitty bits of life are filtered out and so everyone else seems to be managing better than you.

We're a very social species, it's harmful to have so few real interactions with others on a daily basis.

TempyBrennan · 06/01/2024 11:42

I remember watching a documentary about supermarkets, and the limited stock and variety they used to have and honestly I think that sounds great. Now it’s 32 different types of bread? Hurts my brain trying to do life sometimes and things like this really do work there way into my head 😂

Comedycook · 06/01/2024 11:41

I think people nowadays are really strange about talking to strangers...I've seen lots of threads were posters are very aggrieved that a random person in the shop queue or in a cafe dared to speak to them or make some innocuous comment about their baby etc etc. Its so strange

phoenixrosehere · 06/01/2024 11:38

*studies have shown that as humans. We must interact. Social media has stopped us talking face to face which has a HUGE part to do with mental health and how we work as humanity.

we need to get rid of social media which not only stops us talking but we are different behind a screen….this is a proven fact.*

I disagree. Social Media hasn’t stopped people from talking face to face. Where’s the personal responsibility?

People make the choice to use SM.

People make the choice on what they engage or not engage in on SM.

People make the choice on who they want to talk to face to face.

People are often different behind the screen because it is easier and more comfortable to say what they really think anonymously than it is in real life.

Why not question why people feel the need to be on SM vs talking face to face to those around them?

Getting rid of it would be detrimental to many imo because of the positive reasons people use it for.

penjil · 06/01/2024 11:37

I do sometimes think we should go living back like pre-historic people, like those remote tribes in the Amazon region of Brazil and also in the Sentinel Islands in the Indian Ocean.
Loin-cloths, bows and arrows and spears. Only traditional plant medicine. Fresh food you grow, catch or hunt. Small village communities. The outside world is of no consequence.