Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we wouldn't have as many MH problems if we lived differently

305 replies

Ginlette · 06/01/2024 09:03

Panic attacks, anxiety, depression...

How much of this is happening because of the way our society is set up?

If we all lived in fairly small communities and had good relationships with friends and family near by, would we have these issues? If we had stable work that didn't feel like an impossible workload and paid fairly?

I'm even beginning to wonder whether "positives" of modern living are actually subtly undermining our MH as a society.

  • The obvious examples being the Internet and phones, but also..
  • Mobility: looks good on paper, but maybe the idea of the world being your oyster subconsciously is anxiety inducing?
  • Travel: fun but frequent travel again contributes
  • Home ownership and improvements, style & beauty inprovements: again this idea of we have choice, but is it contributing to a low level sense of always chasing?
  • More freedom of partner and freedom to have children or be childfree: but does it create a "What if?" sensation past generations wouldn't have had fluttering at the edges of their mind?
  • Remote working/self employed: I have done this for over a decade but does it maybe contribute to a sense of no base, no community?
OP posts:
RM2013 · 06/01/2024 16:59

Such a thought provoking thread. There have always been MH issues even going way back in time. Is it more prevalent now or just that it’s more diagnosed and talked about now and we are (mostly) more accepting of MH.

I agree that in many ways life was simpler when I was growing up (mid 70’s onwards) no SM, less TV channels, no internet, landlines only and people seemed happier but there was still crime, poverty, domestic violence etc etc

i think generations have changed - as a society I think j we are more demanding (because we have more than we did), inpatients (because things are quicker than they were anyone who remembers dial up internet connection will understand!!)

I long for a simpler and less stressed life but I think we are just too used to what we have now

InShockHusbandLeaving · 06/01/2024 16:47

gannett · 06/01/2024 15:57

God people really like to spout regressive it-was-better-in-the-old-days nonsense.

My mental health would certainly be a million times worse if I hadn't had access to the internet growing up, if I couldn't leave my unpleasant small rural village as soon as was humanly possible, if I couldn't see as much of our amazing world as I have, if I'd been socially pressured to have children I was unsuited for, and if I had to herd myself into a stressful open-plan office to work every day for 40 years rather than getting on with what I like to do in an environment I enjoy (my home).

Constant home improvements and beauty pressures are something I've benefited from bowing out of, yes, but it wasn't that hard.

Your post interests me. What made your small rural village so unpleasant? I also grew up in a small rural village but I loved it and, after years of living in towns and cities both here and abroad, have returned willingly to village life.

Also, who was pressuring you into having children you were unsuited to having? I don’t understand that part of your post. You also mention pressures from working, improving your home and carrying out beauty treatments (forgive me if I’ve misunderstood anything and please correct me) but I’m not sure who was applying the pressure?

I’ve no time for beauty rituals and wouldn’t tack a PVCu conservatory onto my house for any money but absolutely no-one’s pressuring me to do those things. I’ve got free choice and I exercise it.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 06/01/2024 16:36

margotrose · 06/01/2024 16:33

Yep, I totally agree.

I just get a bit fed up of people harking back to the "good old days" where we apparently all chatted nicely in person and nobody ever gossiped or spread rumours or said anything unkind Grin

Rose tinted spectacles spring to mind.

margotrose · 06/01/2024 16:33

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 06/01/2024 16:25

I think that different people will have different views on how they prefer to interact, it may change depending on the situation, and I'm not sure any method is absolutely the best for everyone. I do think that technology which helps people keep in touch better, especially with those living further away, is a very good development.

Yep, I totally agree.

I just get a bit fed up of people harking back to the "good old days" where we apparently all chatted nicely in person and nobody ever gossiped or spread rumours or said anything unkind Grin

DipsAndSplits · 06/01/2024 16:33

It's pandered to nowadays.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 06/01/2024 16:25

margotrose · 06/01/2024 16:09

The same as social media, then.

Talking in person isn't inherently any better than talking online.

I think that different people will have different views on how they prefer to interact, it may change depending on the situation, and I'm not sure any method is absolutely the best for everyone. I do think that technology which helps people keep in touch better, especially with those living further away, is a very good development.

margotrose · 06/01/2024 16:09

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 06/01/2024 16:07

A element of gossip?
Genuine caring about each others wellbeing?
A bit of both?

The same as social media, then.

Talking in person isn't inherently any better than talking online.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 06/01/2024 16:07

margotrose · 06/01/2024 16:03

But would it be about anything positive, or would it be just be the same negativity that's currently on social media?

A element of gossip?
Genuine caring about each others wellbeing?
A bit of both?

margotrose · 06/01/2024 16:03

Comedycook · 06/01/2024 15:23

But they'd be far more likely to be talking each other whilst having a fag

But would it be about anything positive, or would it be just be the same negativity that's currently on social media?

SomeCatFromJapan · 06/01/2024 16:01

I do however, appreciate that if I were a medieval peasant, scratching a substance existence from the land, rather than having a Sainsbury's delivery every week, it might not have gone so well for me

I have Thoughts on this. Life would presumably have been short, harsh and miserable, not to mention cold and muddy, but I wonder how much fretting time and energy they actually had, after trying to sustain themselves growing turnips, dipping reeds in mutton fat to make stinking light sources, and other such medieval peasant activities?

Then again people did seem quite worked up about hellfire and eternal damnation round about then, so maybe that channelled their neurosis.

gannett · 06/01/2024 15:57

God people really like to spout regressive it-was-better-in-the-old-days nonsense.

My mental health would certainly be a million times worse if I hadn't had access to the internet growing up, if I couldn't leave my unpleasant small rural village as soon as was humanly possible, if I couldn't see as much of our amazing world as I have, if I'd been socially pressured to have children I was unsuited for, and if I had to herd myself into a stressful open-plan office to work every day for 40 years rather than getting on with what I like to do in an environment I enjoy (my home).

Constant home improvements and beauty pressures are something I've benefited from bowing out of, yes, but it wasn't that hard.

Pinkdelight3 · 06/01/2024 15:52

Indeed look at us all chatting on here. There are darker sides of course, but there's also a ton of help on here for MH and many other issues women face that they used to have to face alone.

Pinkdelight3 · 06/01/2024 15:51

And they still do talk to each other in some places. Where I come from up north, everyone chats to each other. Where I moved to down south, less so. I prefer the latter, but it's horses for courses. There's still plenty of places to live where people pop in for cuppas etc, but it's not everyone's cuppa either. And people are chatting on their phones and connected with more people like them online than they'd find in a local community so there's a lot of pro's as well as cons. My kids play online games with friends from all over the world instead of being stuck with the kids on the same street like I was.

inamarina · 06/01/2024 15:50

InShockHusbandLeaving · 06/01/2024 12:39

I think today’s unwillingness to debate societal issues is causing a lot of mental health issues for people. Tribalism is rife and neither side is prepared to listen to the other side or, as I’ve seen in many instances, one side simply refuses to debate despite the other side being willing to listen and argue their point. Living in such a back and white world is unhealthy in my opinion and I think we’d benefit from acknowledging shades of grey.

Narcissism is also encouraged, not simply tolerated, in modern life which leads people to show off (as it used to be called) and eventually they seem to come a cropper when the ideal family lives they portray for their followers are exposed as abusive etc. Again, this obsession with being better than others, striving for perfection is bound to cause anxiety, amongst other mental health disorders.

Fully agree with this. The black and white thinking, the tribalism, the debate-terminating mechanisms…

I like this thread, because it’s thought provoking. I don’t agree with everything OP said, but I think she makes some very interesting points. Reading through the replies shows how many different views there are out there and how people can perceive the same situation very differently.

I think if more people felt they can discuss societal issues in a similar manner, it would be quite beneficial for the society as a whole.

Pinkdelight3 · 06/01/2024 15:47

But they'd be far more likely to be talking each other whilst having a fag

Ha ha, but less likely to be talking to each other when they're in an early grave. Just urging for fewer rose tinted views.

TedMullins · 06/01/2024 15:36

Iwasafool · 06/01/2024 15:21

Well done on getting away. I can't bear the thought that I will die here.

This bit I could be whoever I wanted to be. really resonates with me.

Agree wholeheartedly. hated the small town I grew up in for how narrow minded and homogenous it was. I had different tastes and aspirations so I didn’t fit in, didn’t feEl part of a community or make lifelong friends. I do feel part of a community in London though and find it much easier to make friends here

phoenixrosehere · 06/01/2024 15:32

inamarina · 06/01/2024 15:15

This. I also wonder if the posters who say that we should get rid of SM would be happy with a similar degree of government control in other areas of their life.
I mean, ban Instagram because some people who use it end up unhappy after comparing themselves to others? Really?
I’m not saying SM isn’t affecting some people in a negative way, but people are also responsible for their own behaviour.

Posters on MN have said how ridiculous it would be if alcohol was banned (and how it worked out for the States) despite it being a known and accepted poison and detrimental in a lot of ways especially to MH and it argued that it is down to the individual yet SM needs to be banned and saying this using SM.

It’s all in how you choose to use it.

The things used against SM have mostly always existed beforehand. People compared themselves to others, people shared photos and videos of each other, their families, and their travels, news, etc.

It’s a personal problem if one cannot differentiate between what they see on SM and what they see outside of it in their own environment.

Iwasafool · 06/01/2024 15:25

Flyhigher · 06/01/2024 11:20

@Iwasafool bizarre how places dependent on tourism become anti outsiders. Anywhere that's not a city does this though. Small towns in Herts are similar. Anywhere where degree education rates are lower. Then the educated ones all leave, so then it leaves a big gap. It's the same in Spain too.

Yes this is so true, all the bright kids disappear at 18 never to return.

Sometimes it is so ridiculous I have to laugh. As well as the horror of "the immigrants" and "the East Europeans" there is a local horror of anyone from Liverpool which is really odd. If there is ever a planning application for some new houses the outcry is always "they will be full of Liverpudlians on the dole." How these Liverpudlians all manage to get 5 bedroomed "executive" homes while on the dole puzzles me but apparently it is true although I have to say I rarely hear a Liverpudlian accent.

In case any Liverpudlians are offended they are nearly as bad about Brummies.

Comedycook · 06/01/2024 15:23

Pinkdelight3 · 06/01/2024 15:19

Theres about 10/12 mums waiting outside, no one talks to each other or even looks up..every single one looking at their phone. So depressing

Before people looked at their phones, they were often smoking fags instead. There isn't some halcyon age where humans were happy and sorted.

But they'd be far more likely to be talking each other whilst having a fag

Iwasafool · 06/01/2024 15:21

EmpressSoleil · 06/01/2024 11:19

I hate it, I find it far more isolating than the city I grew up in

I do think people have an idealised image of "community". For sure there can be some benefits. But there can be a lot of small mindedness, petty fallings out, gossip etc. It's not a utopia.

I did the opposite, went from a small village in the SW to a large city. The sense of freedom was amazing. I could be whoever I wanted to be. You couldn't pay me enough money to ever go back.

Well done on getting away. I can't bear the thought that I will die here.

This bit I could be whoever I wanted to be. really resonates with me.

Botflymary67 · 06/01/2024 15:20

WindmillOfMyMind · 06/01/2024 14:14

Many people live in an absolute state of fear and many of the posts on here prove that. If you took the fear factor out, they're would be very few posts on this forum.
Scared of being judged, scared of doing the wrong thing, scared of making a personal decision, scared of dogs, scared of being a bad parent, scared of growing old, scared of being stuck in loveless marriage, scared of being alone forever, scared of dating, the list goes on.
So is it any wonder really out younger generation are struggling so much with MH.
You get the ignorants on here who have the absolute audacity to point the finger at our younger generation , shaming them, when we are a culture addicted to alcohol, drugs, anti depressants, gambling, anything that will temporarily numb away the uncomfortable feelings.
Nobody wants to put the work in to improving their own mental health because that takes effort. Much easier to make excuses and blame everything else.
I know many people who suffer with low,mood, anxiety, depression etc.
Not one has ever read a self help book, looked for information on a forum, listened to a podcast changed diet, started exercising more. Looked into ways of changing thought, mindset and perspectives. No one wants to work on themselves.
They still manage to get their nails and hair done regularly, but not in the least bit interested in how to improve their MH.

I agree with you about the state of fear that everyone is living in but I think it’s harsh to blame people for a lack of resilience when virtually every second article you read in the newspaper, or documentary you watch, is about how we are eating the wrong things, living in the wrong way, not exercising enough, not managing our time correctly, we are not even folding our pants the right way fhs!

This stuff is pumped out 24/7 on the internet because there’s money to be made out of books and documentaries that make us fearful and products that we all buy to fix a supposed problem that wasn’t really a problem in the first place.

No profit in being grateful and content and relatively happy with who you are. Oh no we all have to constantly renew our jobs, bodies, clothes, exercise regimes etc and homes. We are all the potential victims of unfettered capitalism unless we look at the bigger picture with a hugely critical eye.

I had the privilege of growing up in a fairly modest home in the seventies in the north of England and believe me it was bleak. No central heating. Ice on the inside of the windows. Nothing much in terms of entertainment and household appliances were limited too. Little choice in food unless it was tinned. Hardly any travel. Our parents had been evacuated as teens in the Second World War. Poor education, there were only three of us who made it in my class to university and we were the first members of our families to attend.

But I am grateful I had that experience as I can now fully appreciate how things have improved since - NOT for everyone I know - but very generally speaking overall, children benefit from better technology, better drugs, a wider choice of food, better travel and educational opportunities, central heating, better plumbing and cars. Of course there are still far too many who have slipped below the poverty line and to our shame have fallen through the nets of NHS and SS.

What we lack now is related more to a lack of trust between institutions and those they are supposed to serve. Increasing inequality. Lack of clarity about which news sources are trustworthy. Lack of physical closeness between family and friends. And frankly, without wishing to sound really old😀, a lack of recognition of the important of character: honesty, integrity, independence, resilience, selflessness, curiosity, and humility.

Sorry this is beginning to sound like a sermon ^^ 😀

I agree though that there seems to be a prevailing narrative that “someone else” will come along and take care of my problems. That if I call an ambulance because I am upset or lonely, or even if I am mildly depressed, I will be “taken away and fixed by someone else” when in reality that is the exact opposite of what will happen. I am not talking about people with serious mh diagnoses here btw but people who are just feeling ordinarily “blue”.

I don’t think that expectation is necessarily their fault though. They’ve been exposed to decades of sentimental claptrap about the NHS (I know it is really terrific in some areas btw) and decades of soap operas about caring nurses and doctors who will go the extra mile for them. They have not been taught to be proud of themselves for becoming quietly self-reliant.

Pinkdelight3 · 06/01/2024 15:19

Theres about 10/12 mums waiting outside, no one talks to each other or even looks up..every single one looking at their phone. So depressing

Before people looked at their phones, they were often smoking fags instead. There isn't some halcyon age where humans were happy and sorted.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 06/01/2024 15:17

Yanbu

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 06/01/2024 15:17

Nah I’d be happy living in the middle of no where no neighbours or anyone else, go to work see my friends and family when I want and when suits us all as I do now. Everyone is different and what would work for some won’t work for others which in itself could cause issues

Emotionalsupportviper · 06/01/2024 15:16

inamarina · 06/01/2024 15:04

I find it strange too, but I wonder if this attitude is more prevalent on MN than in real life?
Where I live people seem generally much more relaxed about It.

I talk to strangers.

All the time - any - and everyone. Like it. I don't need to socialise if I don't want to (or if they don't) and I can enjoy chatting without even having to think about whether I would really like this person if I knew them properly.

I can just chat amicably to strangers and find out all about their lives, and tell them all about mine, and there it is.

But then, I am in t' North. Grin