Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we wouldn't have as many MH problems if we lived differently

305 replies

Ginlette · 06/01/2024 09:03

Panic attacks, anxiety, depression...

How much of this is happening because of the way our society is set up?

If we all lived in fairly small communities and had good relationships with friends and family near by, would we have these issues? If we had stable work that didn't feel like an impossible workload and paid fairly?

I'm even beginning to wonder whether "positives" of modern living are actually subtly undermining our MH as a society.

  • The obvious examples being the Internet and phones, but also..
  • Mobility: looks good on paper, but maybe the idea of the world being your oyster subconsciously is anxiety inducing?
  • Travel: fun but frequent travel again contributes
  • Home ownership and improvements, style & beauty inprovements: again this idea of we have choice, but is it contributing to a low level sense of always chasing?
  • More freedom of partner and freedom to have children or be childfree: but does it create a "What if?" sensation past generations wouldn't have had fluttering at the edges of their mind?
  • Remote working/self employed: I have done this for over a decade but does it maybe contribute to a sense of no base, no community?
OP posts:
Josieangel21 · 07/01/2024 19:35

I'm talking more now after 2020 shut downs, to people on dog walks, saying hi, smiling in shops. Some are thinking crazy, why is she acknowledging my existence, some are thinking you acknowledged me and I'm happy. Risk it, it's lovely and people find themselves speaking to you. X

sassyclassyandsmartassy · 07/01/2024 19:24

I agree with PP’s. As someone who doesn’t suffer with my MH, but with a relative and the odd friend that very much does I do very much see the difference in those that do and those that don’t.

SM and media has placed expectations upon us subconsciously and having too much time to invest in following all of this can have a seriously negative impact.

Worrying about what others are doing, keeping up with the Jones, being perfect enough, worrying about world affairs and over investing in them….

Honestly I have a relative literally trawls the internet to invest herself in things and if they aren’t worrying about themselves, putting themselves against others, what others may think of them, what they have/don’t have then they are literally worrying about things they can’t change (including things like Megan Markle and her affect on the dynamics of the Royal Family which I found just ludicrous the amount of time they invested in trawling the internet and worrying about this). Also dwelling on the past rather than learning to move on, that’s big.

Choices are everything. Good diet, good regular exercise, being out meeting people/building relationships, investing your time wisely is all part and parcel of good mental health. If you are working on living a good full life for yourself you are winning, and that’s not about how much you spend to achieve it, pleasure can be derived from the simplest things, like building relationships helping in your local communities.

We don’t all have to have fancy things and 2.4 children, etc. We really need to just take time to really think about our choices and what they mean and if we are happy with the consequences of those choices. If not we need to make a change.

Like a PP said above about young parents having to hard and not having family around to support you. It’s not your families job to accommodate your choices, when deciding to have children you need to think about really truly how that’s going to look and how affordable it is, if you still want to do it you then need to plan how and what that will look like. We need to be intentional in the things we do.

Differentstarts · 07/01/2024 19:17

MumblesParty · 06/01/2024 10:49

Social media has a lot to answer for I think.
Instagram, Facebook, all the “look at my wonderful life” stuff. It makes everyone feel like an inadequate failure.

But feeling like an inadequate failure isn't a mental illness. Human emotions are OK and normal. Having a mental illness will not be caused or cured by staying of social media or by any of the things op listed.

SpicyMoth · 07/01/2024 18:56

Humans are not built for modern society, we haven't evolved for it - it's impossible for us to as it's happened so bloody fast!

It's no surprise to me that so many are claiming UC rather than participate in the hellscape.

Modern life seems to only be good for those who prefer things over people, and who can afford to prefer things over people.
The happiest people these days are the ones with disposable income, but not everyone is capable of having disposable income for many many different reasons.

anon666 · 07/01/2024 18:44

In principle I agree with your premise - that the way we live today is why we are stressed. However, I would disagree with the factors you've identified about modern life. I think they are more fundamental.

Ridiculously high employer expectations - in professional jobs full timers regularly work many more than 60 hours per week, and there is an always on culture so even breaks can be interrupted by evening/weekend contacts or being "on call".

Apportionment of workload/childcare burdens at the wrong times of life. All the load of preschool and young children's' wrap around care falls to parents who are simultaneously trying to hold down two pressurised full time jobs on little sleep. They are also the most skint. It's miserable. IMO.

Meanwhile at retirement we slack off and have neither financial nor workload burdens. If I got to choose, I'd pay it forward for the sake of lightening the load on young parents.

Loss of social bonds and community - we've succumbed to the pressure to be a mobile workforce - instead of employers moving to the workforce, the workforce has had to move to them. Families are split across huge distances which doesn't help.woth the above two factors.

We've also allowed housing to become a commodity rather than a fundamental part of the social pact. Profiteering has predictably happened and left younger generations feeling hopeless.

There are so many things wrong at the moment but the main one is inequality has increased, meaning we have a lot of very rich people coasting on the efforts of a lot of very poor people. That's miserable for many.

MadeInYorkshire69 · 07/01/2024 18:22

MH just as bad in the “good old days”, particularly for women with no choices. Just not talked about or recognised.
Lots of factors now. Social media addiction. Hopeless futures for YP. Debt. Crappy boring school curriculum. Run down public services. No family support. DV. Adverse childhood experiences.
I worry for the future of young people. 😭😭

Ilovecleaning · 07/01/2024 18:12

YANBU. I’ve thought this for several years. Also, I think debts and money problems contribute a lot to poor MH.

margotrose · 07/01/2024 18:01

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 07/01/2024 10:45

I think this is true for most people, but I also think you can easily hide from that kind of stuff online too. You can block people who piss you off, or leave groups, or hide threads.

It's not as easy as that in real life and therefore the consequences and much more serious.

I'm not sure it's always
quite that easy online though, especially for teens and younger adukts who are used to a lot of their peer interaction being online, particularly after covid. I teach teenage girls. For them, withdrawing from social media due to problematic comments might mean total isolation from their peer group.

But those problematic comments wouldn't stop if the internet disappeared overnight - bullying and unpleasantness existed way before the invention of the internet and the popularity of social media.

When I was in school, it was in the form of nasty notes being passed around, verbal rumours being spread, or even people being beaten up on the bus or while walking to/from school.

I get what you're saying about the majority of teen interaction happening online but it's not the online aspect that's causing the unpleasantness.

MissyT987 · 07/01/2024 18:00

Life’s about choices? I didnt choose to be abused and years later lose my 18 year old son .
ive bipolar , anxiety and ptsd I don’t play it out on sm . I suffer in silence til I become so unwell I need extra help

plumpynoo · 07/01/2024 17:29

As a mental health professional I wholeheartedly agree. The more simple you make your life and concentrate on those things that actually serve you the better off you are.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 07/01/2024 10:45

I think this is true for most people, but I also think you can easily hide from that kind of stuff online too. You can block people who piss you off, or leave groups, or hide threads.

It's not as easy as that in real life and therefore the consequences and much more serious.

I'm not sure it's always
quite that easy online though, especially for teens and younger adukts who are used to a lot of their peer interaction being online, particularly after covid. I teach teenage girls. For them, withdrawing from social media due to problematic comments might mean total isolation from their peer group.

margotrose · 07/01/2024 09:20

I absolutely express views on MN that I wouldn't admit to in public, and engage in fairly robust debates about things I feel strongly about, which I would absolutely not enter into in person, especially with people I don't know.

I think this is true for most people, but I also think you can easily hide from that kind of stuff online too. You can block people who piss you off, or leave groups, or hide threads.

It's not as easy as that in real life and therefore the consequences and much more serious.

ZebraDanios · 07/01/2024 09:15

Fionaville · 06/01/2024 13:32

I think part of it is being able to live your life in a way that is comfortable to you. The remote working thing, some are at their happiest when at home. It's the constant pressure of having somewhere to be that causes anxiety.
For others, they need the stimulation of having plans and being out a lot. Which is why lockdowns suited some people more than others and peoples experiences of that time were polar opposites. I think the latter, the people who need to be out and around people, really can't understand the home birds, to the point that they get frustrated with them.
It all comes down to us as individuals needing and liking different things. Society pressures us into thinking that we should all want the Instagram life of travel, nights out and various other experiences/purchases. A simple, uncomplicated life that is spent close to home, with just a few loved ones, is frowned upon and discouraged. You need lots of friends, lots of stuff and lots of photo worthy experiences or you are failing at life. When it's just not possible and/or suited to most people. It's no wonder that so many people are struggling mentally.

This makes perfect sense to me.

Had it not been necessitated by the pandemic, which caused me huge anxiety, I would have loved lockdown. As a family we’re not massively sociable, and it was really lovely to spend all that time together without feeling like we were supposed to be out doing things and seeing people. My kids are always perfectly happy just about at home at weekends, but I always feel like I should be doing x activity with y people and that I’m a failure if I haven’t organised something - having calm and solitude forced on us, rather than it being my fault, was weirdly liberating.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 07/01/2024 09:07

I think it only appears to be more prevalent on social media because social media is worldwide.

I totally disagree. I think a high proportion of people interact quite differently online from in person, especially when they are anonymous. In a way it would be surprising if they didn't. I'm not suggesting they are all full-on trolls and bullies, but they are probably more forthright with their opinions and judgements, and possibly express views that they would not admit to irl. That then provokes more extreme reactions from other people, and you end up with very angry, polarised online spaces.

I'm neither a troll nor a bully, but I absolutely express views on MN that I wouldn't admit to in public, and engage in fairly robust debates about things I feel strongly about, which I would absolutely not enter into in person, especially with people I don't know. Part of the problem is that the people who are communicating with each other are often total strangers who know they will never meet irl, so they have no need to keep the peace.

margotrose · 07/01/2024 08:47

It's also worth remembering that social media works to an algorithm, so if you watch or engage with lots of posts about cats, or gardening, or trekking in Nepal, that's what will get pushed and what you'll see more of.

TikTok especially works like that - as soon as I engage with any creator on there, their stuff is really heavily pushed for a few days.

ImustLearn2Cook · 07/01/2024 06:55

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 06/01/2024 20:01

Do you genuinely believe that such things didn’t happen before social media?

Not nearly as much, no. People are a lot more likely to be confrontational and rude from the safety of their keyboard. I expect many of the MNers who make the nastiest comments on here are nice as pie to people's faces.

I think it only appears to be more prevalent on social media because social media is worldwide. When you come across confrontational, rude, aggressive people in your surrounding community or place that you are in at the time (like a workplace or a school) then you are only exposed to the population size of that community or place. That is a much smaller demographic than the World Wide Web.

Not to mention that multiple nasty posts under different usernames could just be one nasty person rather than it being many nasty people.

There are plenty of people who are openly abusive, nasty, hostile and aggressive in public. That is why anti bullying initiatives were started such as zero tolerance for bullying in the workplace policies. (Though I rarely see them enacted upon). It is also why some organisations dealing with the public will have signs on the reception area saying that they will not tolerate abusive or aggressive behaviour.

Hillsmakeyoustrong · 06/01/2024 20:43

I'm not surprised people are on their phones in their break. You only have to walk into a cafe to see whole families on their phones, DH and I are sat on our phones as I type this! Technology isn't inferior or wrong in itself but our response to it can bring about less than healthy outcomes. If you google phone addiction and its impact on mental health it is indisputable and its comparable to even drug addiction. The saying all things are permissable but not all things are wise springs to mind...

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 06/01/2024 20:01

Do you genuinely believe that such things didn’t happen before social media?

Not nearly as much, no. People are a lot more likely to be confrontational and rude from the safety of their keyboard. I expect many of the MNers who make the nastiest comments on here are nice as pie to people's faces.

Willmafrockfit · 06/01/2024 19:47

dog walkers pass the time of day, and get exercise, i recommend becoming a dog owner

Willmafrockfit · 06/01/2024 19:46

sitting in the smoking area at work so many people on their phones, otoh it was awkwardly positioned

VimtoVimto · 06/01/2024 17:28

Comedycook · 06/01/2024 15:12

I pick my dd up from her extra curricular activity once a week. Theres about 10/12 mums waiting outside, no one talks to each other or even looks up..every single one looking at their phone. So depressing

I used to pick my children up from activities 20-25 years ago and the parents would chat.

phoenixrosehere · 06/01/2024 17:22

Savedpassword · 06/01/2024 17:05

You genuinely believe that a face to face conversation would deteriorate into the vile exchanges that are so common on SM when two people have a different opinion?

Do you genuinely believe that such things didn’t happen before social media?

margotrose · 06/01/2024 17:16

Savedpassword · 06/01/2024 17:05

You genuinely believe that a face to face conversation would deteriorate into the vile exchanges that are so common on SM when two people have a different opinion?

Of course. It happens every single day.

Children are bullied and ostracised, adults get into fights and on the extreme end, people are beaten up, injured and even killed because of their opinions, or because an argument has gone wrong.

I grew up before social media and saw it happen. Nasty people are nasty people regardless of how they're able to communicate.

DojaPhat · 06/01/2024 17:11

There's a lot of nuance to it. Some of the things you list e.g. remote working, freedom of lifestyle choice have been the very things that have saved many people's mental health struggles. I think what a lot of people struggle with is having access to everything all the time by virtue of smartphone technology but a lot of this can be self-inflicted - nobody is forced to spend the night awake scrolling through Twitter.

Savedpassword · 06/01/2024 17:05

margotrose · 06/01/2024 16:03

But would it be about anything positive, or would it be just be the same negativity that's currently on social media?

You genuinely believe that a face to face conversation would deteriorate into the vile exchanges that are so common on SM when two people have a different opinion?