Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Children don’t need car seats?

136 replies

IcarusFlies · 06/01/2024 07:46

Am I completely misunderstanding this? We have DC3 on the way and I’m trying to find a way to have three car seats in the back.

One will be 4.5yo, the other 6.5yo when baby comes. DC1 is over 22kg but under 125cm so, I thought, needs a high backed booster or a booster cushion from before 2017 / after growing to 125cm.

But the Gov website is saying “Children aged 3 or older can sit in the back using an adult belt, if there’s no space for a third seat”?? So I don’t need a third car seat at all, if the whole family of five travels together?

https://www.gov.uk/child-car-seats-the-rules/when-a-child-can-travel-without-a-car-seat

NOT debating the safety or wisdom of this, just trying to get my head around the regulations… Surely this can’t be right?

Child car seats: the law

The rules for child car seats and booster seats - height, weight, age, type of vehicle, car, minibus, licensed taxi

https://www.gov.uk/child-car-seats-the-rules/when-a-child-can-travel-without-a-car-seat

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Bainbridgemews · 06/01/2024 10:46

mollycobb · 06/01/2024 09:35

Genuine question (as my DDs are older now) can you now get seats to rear face at 6.5 yo 125cm like the OP's DC? I can't visualise it.

Most adults, unless significantly overweight can shoehorn themselves into the middle space OP. It's far from comfortable and may require them getting in before fitting the second car seat but should be possible. Inconvenient but if changing car not possible may be a good temp solution until DC1 is over 135 to take that middle space.

I just don't think that's true most adults can shoe-horn themselves in. My husband and father in law can't even get close so I'm guessing the majority of men couldn't. As before, I'm smaller than average with a bigger car than average (have a rear facing and front facing seat for full disclosure). I can get my hips in, just, but my shoulders physically won't go in the gap.

Outthedoor24 · 06/01/2024 10:45

DragonFly98 · 06/01/2024 10:35

A backless booster again is legal but not safe. Change your car or have a squashed adult they are the only choices if you value your children's lives.

If Op can't fit a car seat in the middle she probably can't fit an adult in either.

Have you ever tried to get in the gap between seats?

Sturnidae · 06/01/2024 10:40

Gunpowder · 06/01/2024 08:14

I would try one of the specialist car seat fitting places. They are experts at which seats will fit in your car.

https://incarsafetycentre.co.uk/contact

you can call them if there isn’t a branch near you.

Seconding these guys, they are absolutely fantastic! I've called them a few times and they will spend ages talking you through options on the phone, and we went instore once and they spent about an hour actually installing seats in our car to check things would fit. We buy all of our car seats from them now too, they are absolutely brilliant people and passionate about car seat safety!

FigTreeInEurope · 06/01/2024 10:39

Come to the south of Italy, where babies are transported on dashboards, whilst toddlers jump about like monkeys in the back. How they manage to hold a phone conversation at the same time is beyond me.

yesihavenamechangedforthis · 06/01/2024 10:36

wombat1a · 06/01/2024 10:18

I do question the wisdom of shoehorning the 2nd adult into the middle seat at the back. The main purpose of child-seats as I understand it is to hold the child secure in the event of an accident. In the event of an accident having the 2nd adult stuck between two child-seats and possibly completely unable to help/help remove a child/get out of the car until one of the child-seats is removed (what if there is a fire, they are totally unable to help) doesn't seem too wise to me.

A bigger car seems more sensible instead.

That's exactly what I was thinking, not a good idea at all

DragonFly98 · 06/01/2024 10:35

IcarusFlies · 06/01/2024 09:49

Thanks @Madameprof, I think your summary is right. It’s just taking me a while to accept it!

I think the challenge is that the period during which eldest can’t go on a backless booster at the back is going to be about 6 months… in the longer term we need to think about whether we want to change car, I suppose. I guess I should buy a backless booster and check that it fits with two seats at the back, to be sure.

A backless booster again is legal but not safe. Change your car or have a squashed adult they are the only choices if you value your children's lives.

BertieBotts · 06/01/2024 10:28

If you don't have a full sized seat in the centre, then it's often better to put one child seat in the centre (if manual allows) and one on the side and then the adult on the other side.

The whole "adult won't be able to help" is a bit moot because it's not like you have to carry a second adult with you on every journey? But if the adult is totally wedged in between the two seats, then I suppose theoretically there is a chance that the adult's body is going to put the whole adult weight of pressure on the seat, which it definitely isn't designed to take. It's not an ideal solution anyway and not just for comfort reasons.

This is definitely a situation with lots of non-ideal solutions where you have to pick the best of a bad lot. Unfortunately I do think some of the car safety groups/pages seem to have this attitude of ideal safety at all times and I don't think that's helpful. Sometimes you do have to weigh up some non-ideal solutions. Not discussing these at all means that you end up without clear discussions of totally unsafe solutions (e.g. letting 6yo put the seatbelt under her arm so it doesn't rub her neck as she is boosterless - OP I know you did not suggest this - just an example of a solution many innocently think is safe and logical).

Muchtoomuchtodo · 06/01/2024 10:27

Surely the focus point of any thinking around car seats is the safety of the children? just being able to squeeze second or third choice seats in, moving to booster seats rather than HBB, youngsters being in the front rather than the back of the car etc all compromise their safety should an accident happen.

This won’t just be a problem for a few months until your oldest grows a little taller. Don’t forget that you’re likely to start having friends round for tea, sharing lifts for activities etc before very long so the more adaptable your car the better.

i’m another one singing the praises of cars that have 3 separate seats in the back. They offer the most choice, flexibility and therefore safety. We have had a Ford Galaxy and now have a Peugeot 5008. The boot seats aren’t used all that often but when they are they too can accommodate forward facing car seats if needed.

JaninaDuszejko · 06/01/2024 10:23

We initially managed with our youngest in a rear facing seat and our older two in forward facing 5 point seats in our Nissan Almera Tino (they haven't made these since 2006 but might be worth checking a Qashqai). The big issue was when our elder two went into HBB and our youngest went into the forward facing 5 point seat because although they fitted (just) it was impossible for the kids to do their own seatbelts so DH spent a Saturday going round all the car dealers trying out fitting our car seats in the back of the cars. Most 7 seaters are too narrow to have 3 comfortably in the second row but the Ford S-Max was OK (the Galaxy has more leg room but as a short family this is less of an issue for us). If you are happy to use the third row of seats you have more options but boot space is also important with 3DC so we wanted them all in the second row.

wombat1a · 06/01/2024 10:18

I do question the wisdom of shoehorning the 2nd adult into the middle seat at the back. The main purpose of child-seats as I understand it is to hold the child secure in the event of an accident. In the event of an accident having the 2nd adult stuck between two child-seats and possibly completely unable to help/help remove a child/get out of the car until one of the child-seats is removed (what if there is a fire, they are totally unable to help) doesn't seem too wise to me.

A bigger car seems more sensible instead.

Ovaltiner · 06/01/2024 10:18

I second those who have said a new car may be inevitable. We had an Audi A4 (basically a Skoda Octavia) and changed for a Ford Galaxy when DC3 came along, as the back seat wasn't great for three people without car seats, let alone with. Not much bigger to drive (and it drives like a car, not a truck), but so much more space and a safe way to get 3 seats in. As the seats are separate in the back, it also avoids complaints about someone's leg 'being on my side of the line....'

Also not exactly glamorous but few 7 seaters are. Great on motorways, we regularly do a 6 hour drive to my parents'.

We have since swapped for a VW sharan (had the galaxy for 11 years) and I would hugely recommend the sliding doors!

It also is ideal when they get rid of the car seats and suddenly leg room is a more pressing issue, which comes around incredibly quickly.

BertieBotts · 06/01/2024 10:15

OP you are correct about the exception for three children in the middle.

However you are (slightly) wrong about the min age/height for backless booster seats. The 125cm / 22kg only applies to new model approvals. The design of backless boosters really hasn't changed very much if at all since the 1980s, so this isn't a category where new models are being approved all the time (like for example infant carrier seats).

There are dozens of models already on sale which were approved before 2016 and so are legal to use from 15kg upwards. Generally I would not advise this and would say you should stick with the 125cm/22kg anyway, but this is a good example of an exception to that rule, because backless booster is better than no booster.

There is also a sort of unwritten rule that says if the law says you can legally do a less-protective solution, then there's nothing stopping you from using the more protective solution if everything fits.

Lastly I doubt police officers are carrying around a tape measure. If you get stopped they will see the outer two children in child seats, the middle child in a seatbelt, tick a box and wave you off. It would be different if it was a toddler bouncing around in the middle with no seat - they would likely stop you then. But nobody is going to quibble over 1-2cm.

But I do agree with others that if we can help you find a solution with three proper seats maybe that would be better? Someone recently told me on another thread they managed to fit Kinderkraft Junior in between two other child seats. It's not a seat I'd normally look at, but for the middle, the most important thing is the belt positioning, not the side impact protection.

Maxi Cosi seats are also very slim. You may actually find that a backless booster doesn't help because the problem is the bases of the other two seats, not the shoulder part.

There are some infant carrier car seats which have belt fitted bases. This was the key that I found when we had to fit Group 1 seat + infant carrier + teenager/adult in the back of a similar sized car.

Is your 4.5yo in a high back or harness?

Multimac is not as disastrous as a lot of people say - I don't know why it's suddenly attracted a load of ire. That might well be a good solution in your situation as your older two children are over 4 (so would be fine forward facing) and the baby can rear face up to 13kg in the baby seat which is usually over 2 - I did have a photo of a small 3 year old in it. It is probably a lot of money if you were to then stop using it after 2 years though. There are definitely some downsides, the low rear facing time, the baby seat is not really portable and won't go on a pushchair, the belt fit for children who have outgrown the harness isn't fantastic. It's 15+ years old so it's never going to give you the protection of 3x cutting edge modern seats. But it did use the best safety features available at the time and therefore is better than 3x basic/cheap separate seats that you can buy today, which are probably using the safety features of 20+ years ago.

Outthedoor24 · 06/01/2024 10:12

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 06/01/2024 08:41

Just put an adult in the back.

Few adults will fit between the seats and it needs to be a fairly big car to have a hope.

My mum is a tiny lady, (she really is tiny fits in a HBB) we shoe horn her in the gap between the seats for local 10-15 min journeys. But much more than that we put oldest in the front with seat Mum and I in the back with youngest.

Topofthemountain · 06/01/2024 10:09

I don't think they sell the Adventure anymore, but it is the base size that is important, for example the Graco has a wide, solid base so probably won't fit.

The baby seat also had to be belt fitted.

SecondHandFurniture · 06/01/2024 10:08

Topofthemountain · 06/01/2024 10:02

If middle child is 20kg he shouldn't be in a group 1 with harness, he is over the weight limit.

We had an Audi A3 when #3 arrived and our big two were very similar ages, baby in the middle in a group 0 and a Britax Adventure on the other two seats so they kind of jigsawed. The adventure was one of the narrowest on the market.

I was about to say that I'm not sure DS is 20kg now at 5 and a half. 18ish? He's been in a HBB for ages.

Topofthemountain · 06/01/2024 10:02

If middle child is 20kg he shouldn't be in a group 1 with harness, he is over the weight limit.

We had an Audi A3 when #3 arrived and our big two were very similar ages, baby in the middle in a group 0 and a Britax Adventure on the other two seats so they kind of jigsawed. The adventure was one of the narrowest on the market.

PurpleNebula84 · 06/01/2024 10:02

IcarusFlies · 06/01/2024 08:04

Thanks all, we tend to only need to worry about:

a) school run (can put eldest in high backed booster at the front with airbags off), 20mph on urban roads the whole way
b) weekend trips to shops, could put eldest in the middle I guess…
c) 1h drive to family along the motorway, where we tend to go all together so definitely the highest risk journeys. Government solution unacceptable to me.

We have a Skoda Octavia estate.

You don't need to turn the air bag off for a forward facing seat... Just put the seat as far back on the runners as possible. The airbag only needs to be turned off/deactivated for a rearward facing seat.

CUDet · 06/01/2024 09:59

We fitted 3 seats in the back of a Nissan Note and Toyota Verso. 2 high backed boosters and baby seat.

Outthedoor24 · 06/01/2024 09:59

The exception is there to avoid making people criminals for not being able to afford a bigger car, or if you only have 3 kids in occasionally (Granny, second car). Few cars can fit three seats.

Technically the middle of the back seat is the safest place to be in a car. Furthest away from all impacts and the child would get some protection from the seats either side of them

The safest option is to upgrade your car to one with space for 3 seats, and 3 isofix points. I-size seats are narrower than the older seats so your more likely to be able to get 3 in.

BertieBotts · 06/01/2024 09:58

mollycobb · 06/01/2024 09:35

Genuine question (as my DDs are older now) can you now get seats to rear face at 6.5 yo 125cm like the OP's DC? I can't visualise it.

Most adults, unless significantly overweight can shoehorn themselves into the middle space OP. It's far from comfortable and may require them getting in before fitting the second car seat but should be possible. Inconvenient but if changing car not possible may be a good temp solution until DC1 is over 135 to take that middle space.

You can, though they are right at the limit of those seats, so not much sense getting one.

Here is a picture for example - this is the Besafe Stretch.

Children don’t need car seats?
childrensward · 06/01/2024 09:54

What car seats are the 2 in at the minute, and height/weights of children? Maybe someone can suggest alternative seats.

IcarusFlies · 06/01/2024 09:49

Thanks @Madameprof, I think your summary is right. It’s just taking me a while to accept it!

I think the challenge is that the period during which eldest can’t go on a backless booster at the back is going to be about 6 months… in the longer term we need to think about whether we want to change car, I suppose. I guess I should buy a backless booster and check that it fits with two seats at the back, to be sure.

OP posts:
Madameprof · 06/01/2024 09:46

As you don't want to change car or allow 6 year to travel without a booster (sensible) the only solution is to put the eldest in the front and one adult in the middle seat at the back. Most adults don't like this which is why a lot of families of 5 (is included) upgrade to a 7 seater. We could fit five car seats in the back of our Seat Alhambra. I've never seen a five seat car that has a full size middle seat. But Alhambra/Galaxy etc have three full size separate seats across the middle.

gillyweed · 06/01/2024 09:44

We had the same problem, possibly smaller age gap, and my eldest was slight so I wanted to keep her in a seat.

My dad has a Skoda Octavia, and you cannot get 3 seats across the back. Halfords actually refused to even try as they 'knew' they couldn't. You can't.

We had to change cars, there are less than 10 cars in the UK that take 3 across the back (and I ruled out a fair few based on crazy prices!). We bought an smax, 3 full size seats across back (plenty of room plus 2 smaller seats in boot if wanted) love it, it's been amazing and one of the best buys I've ever made.

Feellikeafailurenow · 06/01/2024 09:43

We also had to change cars to fit 3 in - i had twins so had 2 baby seats & large extended rear facing seats (rf til 5) & then 2 large rear facing ones & the high back booster. I still have my twins in high backed boosters at 8 & now my oldest has none.

we can’t fit any combination of our seats including an adult in the middle of the hbbs (i’m 5”3 size 8 & can’t) unless its a 7 seat car with individual seats. My friend fit 3 narrow hbbs (turned her kids forward at 18 months and fully out of them at 6 so a lot earlier than me) & by not being fussed on brand she got the 3 in the back of a vw touran.

my husband used to have an octavia and it wasn’t doable nor was it in a discovery sport so i got a new car. we have have had both vw sharan & now c4 grande picasso. We had a kia sorrento as a courtesy car last year and with 2 seats in the back couldn’t fit someone in between. My oldest had to squeeze in the back boot seats so although 7 seats not as good as the ones with individual back seats you can move. Without changing car you will struggle but if you aren’t fussy there are doable options which someone specialist can hopefully advise on or others on the car seat forums who have managed it but for me it wasn’t worth the risk and so i got rid of the car i love to drive massive 7 seats which have plenty of space!