Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Children don’t need car seats?

136 replies

IcarusFlies · 06/01/2024 07:46

Am I completely misunderstanding this? We have DC3 on the way and I’m trying to find a way to have three car seats in the back.

One will be 4.5yo, the other 6.5yo when baby comes. DC1 is over 22kg but under 125cm so, I thought, needs a high backed booster or a booster cushion from before 2017 / after growing to 125cm.

But the Gov website is saying “Children aged 3 or older can sit in the back using an adult belt, if there’s no space for a third seat”?? So I don’t need a third car seat at all, if the whole family of five travels together?

https://www.gov.uk/child-car-seats-the-rules/when-a-child-can-travel-without-a-car-seat

NOT debating the safety or wisdom of this, just trying to get my head around the regulations… Surely this can’t be right?

Child car seats: the law

The rules for child car seats and booster seats - height, weight, age, type of vehicle, car, minibus, licensed taxi

https://www.gov.uk/child-car-seats-the-rules/when-a-child-can-travel-without-a-car-seat

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
ShoePalaver · 06/01/2024 15:37

If it fits you could put a booster cushion with a belt guide in the middle. If the other two are in rear facing belt fitted seats it should fit. Sounds like your 4 year old is in a Joie bold which won't be helping as it's isofix if using with harness and quite wide. So get a belt fitted infant carrier with no base and an erf seat for the 4 year old to begin with, put the older in the middle. In the middle it's safer so the lack of side impact protection although not ideal isn't as much of a worry as on an outer seat. Once the baby is bigger, that can go in the middle rear facing either in carrier or erf seat and other two can go on outer seats.

If putting one in the front the safest option is a rear facing seat with airbag off. Not a child in a forward facing seat.

If choosing between no booster and booster for the oldest child, I wouldn't worry about the illegality of the booster. I would choose the safest option. You won't get done for it as it's a technicality.

ShoePalaver · 06/01/2024 15:27

PurpleNebula84 · 06/01/2024 10:02

You don't need to turn the air bag off for a forward facing seat... Just put the seat as far back on the runners as possible. The airbag only needs to be turned off/deactivated for a rearward facing seat.

Not true, it depends on the car. Children have been killed by airbags

Rowgtfc72 · 06/01/2024 15:27

Dd is an only so not sure if this is useful but she was a tall child so outgrew car seats very quickly. By 5 she was on a booster cushion. More so because most of her height was in her body and not legs. We couldn't physically wedge her shoulders in a high back booster at full extension. As a result she fit perfectly on a booster cushion with the seat belt correctly over her shoulder. Therefore completely safe and secure.
Is your dc long in body or leg?

meganorks · 06/01/2024 15:16

I think this is probably the government's way of acknowledging that not all cars fit 3 car seats and so they can't very well enforce fines etc. It contradicts their other rules that children must be in a high backed booster until 12 or 135cm. Although that was also caveats when introduced that you could carry on using a seat only booster if you already have that.

Lougle · 06/01/2024 15:13

Madameprof · 06/01/2024 09:46

As you don't want to change car or allow 6 year to travel without a booster (sensible) the only solution is to put the eldest in the front and one adult in the middle seat at the back. Most adults don't like this which is why a lot of families of 5 (is included) upgrade to a 7 seater. We could fit five car seats in the back of our Seat Alhambra. I've never seen a five seat car that has a full size middle seat. But Alhambra/Galaxy etc have three full size separate seats across the middle.

Citroen C5 Aircross does. I chose it because I have 3 teens with sensory difficulties. The seats are individual and move back and forth with a 15cm range.

Children don’t need car seats?
DonnatellaLyman · 06/01/2024 15:05

We have a medium sized hatchback and put 2 car seats in the back with an adult in the middle and the baby in the front.

I think it’s more comfortable if at least one is rear facing so you might want to put your 4yo in an ERF seat until your eldest can go in the middle.

Sparklybanana · 06/01/2024 14:34

If you don't want to change your car or choose which child you like least (joking) then you can get a 3 seater child seat that replaces the whole back seat with child seats. We have one and whilst I hate the seat belts with a passion - it does allow us to go anywhere as a family of 5. It's not cheap - £1k plus but relative to a new car it's cheap and has a good resale price. It's a multimac. No adults in the back.seat but fine until kids are older and we only require one seat or booster.
For what it's worth - I did travel with oldest squeezed between two car seats and she was so squashed in I doubt it was an issue! But that was a short journey- like you I'd not like to do that for most journeys.

Topofthemountain · 06/01/2024 14:04

but I appreciate too that isofix may be the safer option.

Isofix isn't safer as such, it significantly reduces the risk of the seat being fitted incorrectly, which is what increases the safety.

Eccle80 · 06/01/2024 13:53

I found it really surprising when we had 3 kids how few cars actually have a full size seat in the middle of the back. It’s really limiting, and I think the official rules are a reflection of that. My eldest was 7.5 when my youngest was born, and we had to go with a booster cushion in the middle, on the basis he had side protection from the other seats, and the cushion raised him to put the seatbelt in a better position. I’m not saying it was ideal, and it was also 8 years ago before booster cushion rules changed. Even doing that, a lot of booster cushions were too wide to fit.

Given the number of families I know with 3+ children, I wonder why manufacturers don’t offer more car models that can accommodate them. Seatbelt fitted seats may be a bit easier to accommodate than Isofix, but I appreciate too that isofix may be the safer option.

Flossflower · 06/01/2024 13:47

If your seating proves less than ideal you should think of cutting down your car journeys. You can get shopping delivered and your family can come to you. Cut out the motorway completely.
We are GPs with a fairly wide car. We can only fit 2 car seats in the back. Me and the grandchildren’s Mum took turns to sit sideways in the back once on a 2 hour journey. Me size 10 and Mum size 8.

BiffandChip1 · 06/01/2024 13:32

We have 3 under 4 so need 3 5 point seat belts and the adult goes in the middle. Baby in front as I've got isofix so her spin seat is there. Adult in the middle seems the best for you too?

Topofthemountain · 06/01/2024 13:27

IcarusFlies · 06/01/2024 13:14

Absolutely- and that’s why I’m here asking for advice on how best to manage risk within the constraints I have in life, and the law.

There will be a solution, as I said above we found one for the Audi A3, albeit 12 years ago.

I will add that this wasn't our main car, but I wanted a solution that worked if we needed to be in that car.

The fact you are here asking shows you do care about the safety of your children.

Sprogonthetyne · 06/01/2024 13:23

Boostapak are legal from 15kg (old style regs) and only 36cm wide. Not ideal but surely safer then nothing. My mum can fit 2 of these plus the narrowest toddler chair into the back of a Hindu i10.

IcarusFlies · 06/01/2024 13:14

Absolutely- and that’s why I’m here asking for advice on how best to manage risk within the constraints I have in life, and the law.

OP posts:
margotrose · 06/01/2024 13:06

The chances of being in a car crash are not high in themselves.

But the consequences of being in a crash can be fatal and/or life changing.

IcarusFlies · 06/01/2024 13:05

Some absolute corkers here, among the helpful advice. The chances of being in a car crash are not high in themselves. Life is a risk assessment. Honestly…

We’ve agreed to go and look at some 7 seaters, as an educational exercise. Noted re the front airbag. We’ve got a MaxiCosi pebble for the baby, can’t remember the other two seats but I’ll check DC2’s one - I think it’s a Group 0-3 one that goes through to 12 yo, but will check I’m using it correctly. Thanks for all the advice!

OP posts:
user1491396110 · 06/01/2024 12:49

There are some great car seat groups on facebook that are really helpful, esp the rear facing ones.

The multimac scores very poorly for safety. Im sure there will be a way to fit all three and you'll get some good specialist advice. I believe little peas is a good retailer who will offer a solution :) good luck

Shade17 · 06/01/2024 11:58

IcarusFlies · 06/01/2024 08:04

Thanks all, we tend to only need to worry about:

a) school run (can put eldest in high backed booster at the front with airbags off), 20mph on urban roads the whole way
b) weekend trips to shops, could put eldest in the middle I guess…
c) 1h drive to family along the motorway, where we tend to go all together so definitely the highest risk journeys. Government solution unacceptable to me.

We have a Skoda Octavia estate.

You need to leave the passenger airbag ON. Refer to your car’s manual.

DragonFly98 · 06/01/2024 11:38

Outthedoor24 · 06/01/2024 10:45

If Op can't fit a car seat in the middle she probably can't fit an adult in either.

Have you ever tried to get in the gap between seats?

I agree it's very difficult but the op won't buy a new car so it's that or put her dc life at risk.

Alainlechat · 06/01/2024 11:19

Would you prefer the law to say you have to change your car?

margotrose · 06/01/2024 11:15

You need to buy a car that fits your family, not expect your family to cram into a car that's no longer safe for them, no matter what the law says.

theconfidenceofwho · 06/01/2024 11:04

anothernamechangeagainsndagain · 06/01/2024 08:24

It's not a recommendation it's just a realisation that not all cars can fit a third seat, this exception only applies if there is no spare seat eg front passenger. If you can fit a cushion booster (no back) use that instead. Laws are to protect us but they are also realistic

This!

We had to change cars when we had our 3rd (got an S Max originally as you can fit 3 proper car seats across the back).

The law is a practical way to make it work, however the risk assessment sits with you & up to you how you decide to travel (but the law supports you travelling together in 1 car as a family.)

Topofthemountain · 06/01/2024 10:48

FfS just buying a new car is not a viable option for many people, parents also don't need a car that is adaptable for picking up school friends.

It should be possible to get a group 0 and two hbb in the back seat, no squished adults and no less value on my children's lives.

timetochangethering · 06/01/2024 10:48

Rather than trying to shoehorn 3 seats in an unsuitable car take the following approach.....

  1. Your kids need to be as safe as possible, so work out the "right" seats.
  2. Buy a car that fits the seats.

Because basically your choice is to buy smaller/less protective seats, or to change the car.