Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Children don’t need car seats?

136 replies

IcarusFlies · 06/01/2024 07:46

Am I completely misunderstanding this? We have DC3 on the way and I’m trying to find a way to have three car seats in the back.

One will be 4.5yo, the other 6.5yo when baby comes. DC1 is over 22kg but under 125cm so, I thought, needs a high backed booster or a booster cushion from before 2017 / after growing to 125cm.

But the Gov website is saying “Children aged 3 or older can sit in the back using an adult belt, if there’s no space for a third seat”?? So I don’t need a third car seat at all, if the whole family of five travels together?

https://www.gov.uk/child-car-seats-the-rules/when-a-child-can-travel-without-a-car-seat

NOT debating the safety or wisdom of this, just trying to get my head around the regulations… Surely this can’t be right?

Child car seats: the law

The rules for child car seats and booster seats - height, weight, age, type of vehicle, car, minibus, licensed taxi

https://www.gov.uk/child-car-seats-the-rules/when-a-child-can-travel-without-a-car-seat

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
NZBride · 07/01/2024 19:05

I was also going to say what about an adult in middle seat.. not ideal but at least you’d have all DC in proper safe seats and could feel happier about travelling.

CantFindMyMarbles · 07/01/2024 18:25

IcarusFlies · 06/01/2024 08:04

Thanks all, we tend to only need to worry about:

a) school run (can put eldest in high backed booster at the front with airbags off), 20mph on urban roads the whole way
b) weekend trips to shops, could put eldest in the middle I guess…
c) 1h drive to family along the motorway, where we tend to go all together so definitely the highest risk journeys. Government solution unacceptable to me.

We have a Skoda Octavia estate.

Unless the child is rear facing you shouldn’t turn airbags off. My daughter has sat in the front since she was 6 due to various medical reasons.

GlasgowGal82 · 07/01/2024 18:16

OP - it's actually 135cm that a child should use a booster seat, not 125cm (I am blown away that you can legally get away with that if you have three kids too!). It's worth noting that in most of Europe kids need to be 150cm before they can go without a booster. My DC is 9 and a couple of cm taller than 135cm, but I really don't think the seatbelt fits him properly without a booster.

In terms of car seat advice I'd really recommend the In Car Safety Centre that others have already suggested. I found them really useful in helping me find suitable seats for various unusual situations! There also used to be a couple of really helpful Facebook groups with people who are great car seat problem solvers so worth looking into that too.

Sleepytiredyawn · 07/01/2024 18:03

I would put the 6.5 year old in the front with me and if you have another adult travelling with you an odd time, I would either get them to squeeze in between the 2 car seats in the back or let my 6.5 year old use the adult seat belt. If my son, same age needs collecting from school and it’s a quick drive then he will be picked up with no car seat, use an adult seat belt and sit in the back.

Ive just recently got my son a new booster seat, and with his height and weight, he could have just had the booster but we decided on the high back for head safety. Maybe see if you can get a slimline high back booster or just have the booster if one will fit and put some cushioning on the side of the existing car seats hear his head.

Nanof8 · 07/01/2024 17:54

My son has his 3 boys in Diono seats that will fit 3 across in his car. The seats he has are good until the kids are about 120#. They were also able to have one of them rear facing with the other 2 forward facing.

IcarusFlies · 07/01/2024 16:59

We don’t use isofix at all at the moment, actually. I think I’ll have a go with our three existing seats tonight once the kids are in bed…

OP posts:
Topofthemountain · 07/01/2024 13:12

@IcarusFlies I'm pleased that the advice was more useful by the end. Good luck, remember non isofix and narrow bases are generally the key.

IcarusFlies · 07/01/2024 13:04

Thanks all! Am feeling very optimistic that I can have a play around and find an option that works for us… @BertieBotts you’re spot on. Thank you!

OP posts:
BertieBotts · 07/01/2024 10:10

A lot of people have also mentioned the in car safety centre which is good for finding 3x seats which all fit together.

If you're not close enough to them to allow this another option is to look for an ERF specialist as most of them also sell high backed booster seats and will be able to offer the same thing. Most of them stock Axkid so you can use Axkid's retailer search:

https://axkid.com/uk/find-a-retailer-near-you/

Or just pick any popular brand, look for retailers and then start with any that is not a chain:

https://joiebaby.com/uk/store-locator

Here you can buy Axkid products | Find our retailers | Axkid

Do you want to buy a car seat or other accessory from Axkid? We have created a map where you can easily find your nearest store.

https://axkid.com/uk/find-a-retailer-near-you

BertieBotts · 07/01/2024 10:06

I think, looking at the pictures on FB groups of Octavia 3-across set ups, it's non isofix which is the key. The isofix points are likely set slightly further towards the centre seat.

With whatever seats you have you can likely do some trial and error with different set ups. Maybe ask around friends and family to see if anyone has a belt fitted seat you can borrow to see what the width is like. You'll find you get a slightly different fit on the left and right sides, due to position of seatbelt and you might also get a difference depending on which seat you fit first. I'd probably try fitting the middle seat first, but you can check.

Any high backed booster is allowed to be fitted without isofix even if it has the isofix connectors.

Multi-stage seats that do different jobs (e.g. rear and forward facing or forward facing and booster) are often very wide - there are a few exceptions e.g. Joie Tilt is slim as others have said (but it's probably not great for a newborn).

When you're trying different configurations it's worth thinking about stuff like can you actually reach the buckle to plug boostered child in, if baby seat goes on a belted base this may be fine in the middle, but if baby seat is belt fitted, then you might prefer this on a side so that you can leave baby on pram or place temporarily in front while you help older two into their seats, then strap baby's seat in last etc. If you have two buckles together, ensure that an older child doing their own seatbelt does not accidentally unbuckle the baby's base for example. (You could use a buckle guard for this which are available on amazon).

VladimirVsVolodymyr · 06/01/2024 22:40

Can you not put the baby in a Joie tilt (one of the smallest non isofix car seat) and the other two forward facing? That's what I did in my Vauxhall Astra when my third was born. The other two were aged 5.5 and 8 and in high back boosters, they're still in HBB now aged 10 (almost 11) and 8, baby is 2.5. I bought the Besafe HBB for the older kids because our Britax are very wide and bulky. I can fit in the middle seat between baby and middle child which helps as well.
I'm surprised you're struggling as the Octavia are slightly bigger than the average 5 seaters.

We did upgrade to a 5008 last year but I hated driving diesel so we swapped for a five seater ID 5 as my nearly 11 will only need to be in a car seat for another year to 18 months (he's quite light at 36kg and 144cm) here you have to be in car seat until 150cm.

The aircross as mentioned above does have 3 separate seats so you are almost swapping similar cars and the C5 is a big car. Take the car to incarsafety and they can try different seats. Congrats and best of luck.

HoneyMustard · 06/01/2024 22:25

We had a third last year and had to upgrade our car. It's not the sexiest car we've ever had but the Peugeot 5008 is great as fits 3 car seats and has a great size boot (with 2 extra seats that fold down).

LoveFridayNights · 06/01/2024 22:21

They need a car seat or booster until 12 or 135cm (not 125cm)

VillageLite · 06/01/2024 21:05

To be honest, if this is only going to be an issue for 6 months, for motorway journeys that you only do every 3 weeks (so 8 occasions?) I would just hire a big 7 seater for those journeys, wouldn’t that be more affordable than replacing your car?

IcarusFlies · 06/01/2024 20:53

I need to check exactly what the car seat and situation is for the middle child currently, and whether he needs to now go without the harness - will check that tomorrow.

The Facebook group has multiple examples of people fitting three seats in the back of a Skoda Octavia?! So maybe I just need to get a bit more creative and give it a go… I put the Pebble between the other two (still strapped in) as a rough test and it was a joke, couldn’t get even close, so I assumed that was that. Maybe there are some options!

OP posts:
BungleandGeorge · 06/01/2024 20:44

If you can’t fit a 3rd seat in the back you can’t fit it though? It’s then safer to be belted than no belt at all. I don’t think it’s legislation aimed towards parents who can plan to change seats or cars. A child on a booster cushion doesn’t sound safe either given their heat will be next to the hard shell of the car seats and side impacts are common (perhaps more common in the lower speed journeys through town that you’re considering using it for?). Honestly I’d either change the car or change the seats. Failing that adult goes in the back. Tbh probably easiest to change the car given that your children should all be in car seats a fair bit longer

Iscreamtea · 06/01/2024 20:25

Finding a car to comfortably fit three in the back is a bit of a nightmare OP. A lot of cars it's just not possible. Since having our 3rd we've stuck with Citroëns because they have three full seats in the back so you don't have to choose a least favourite child to squish in the middle. Also, although they may initially take up less space when they outgrow the child seat, they have a nasty habit of growing bigger. Then they need more space again.

TiptoeThroughTheToadstools · 06/01/2024 20:17

I went from 1 DC to 3 (twins) and invested in a bigger car. I'd never put them in with no car seat or even just a booster. If you Google crash test dummy with car seats you'll see why high backed seats are an absolute necessity

BertieBotts · 06/01/2024 20:00

a Group 0-3 one that goes through to 12 yo

These are generally pretty massive so might be worth looking at changing this. Single stages tend to be better for slimness. If your DC is 20kg though I'm guessing it's either Joie Bold or Cozy n Safe something. Do you def need the harness? Most children at 4.5yo are OK without.

The 55cm gap is a thing, but it's not 55cm in front of the seat. It's measured from right back at the back of the seat and considering the seat depth is about 50-53cm in many cars, it's really not as massive a gap as people go on about. The Octavia isn't miniscule so you'll be fine putting one child in the front and one in the back if that's the solution you go for. These limits are just part of the legal standard - basically when they crash test the seat, the dummy's head isn't allowed to come past the 55cm mark. Actually r129 seats are stricter and it's only 50cm. It's not really a limit that consumers are supposed to be aware of or use to make decisions. Useful info if you are wondering whether there is enough space, perhaps, but since real life crashes don't happen to laboratory conditions, not to be taken as a hard limit.

IcarusFlies · 06/01/2024 17:08

55cm gap?! This topic is the gift that keeps on giving!

OP posts:
ShoePalaver · 06/01/2024 16:02

PurpleNebula84 · 06/01/2024 15:51

Yes, as I said, it depends on the car. The advice you have linked specifically says to avoid putting children in forward facing car seats in a seat with an airbag!

You won't be able to put the seat right back if there's a rear facing child behind. And a forward facing child seat behind also needs a 55 cm gap so it isn't going to be possible to safely put a forward facing car seat in the front with airbag on for op.

ShoePalaver · 06/01/2024 15:57

IcarusFlies · 06/01/2024 09:36

Eldest is already in HBB. Middle child is 20kg so can’t go into HBB yet, is in a five point harness forward facing car seat.

I think I need to try a few iterations and see… could put the baby in the front, rear facing. I’m not worried about the trips with me plus 3 kids to be honest, someone (baby or eldest) can go in the front for at least a year… at which point eldest can switch to backless booster and go at the back in the middle, I reckon.

The issue is if all 5 of us need to travel, which is every weekend locally (London) and probably once every 3 weeks at least further afield involving a dual carriage way or motorway.

I’m waiting for an admin to approve me into the Fb group so will ask there too.

Hbb is from 15 kg legal minimum, or 18 kg and age 4.5 advised minimum

Outthedoor24 · 06/01/2024 15:54

Flossflower · 06/01/2024 13:47

If your seating proves less than ideal you should think of cutting down your car journeys. You can get shopping delivered and your family can come to you. Cut out the motorway completely.
We are GPs with a fairly wide car. We can only fit 2 car seats in the back. Me and the grandchildren’s Mum took turns to sit sideways in the back once on a 2 hour journey. Me size 10 and Mum size 8.

We found it easier to put a child in carseat in front and me and my mum in the back together rather than squeezing between the seats.

PurpleNebula84 · 06/01/2024 15:51

ShoePalaver · 06/01/2024 15:27

Not true, it depends on the car. Children have been killed by airbags

Probably because they haven't put the seat far enough back or checked the compatibility in the manual. This is the advice from ROSPA and the AA.

https://www.childcarseats.org.uk/choosing-using/faqs/#:~:text=If%20you%20must%20put%20a,the%20child%20and%20the%20airbag.

https://www.theaa.com/driving-advice/safety/child-safety/car-seats#:~:text=It's%20OK%20to%20leave%20the,size%20and%20performance%20does%20vary.

Children don’t need car seats?
Children don’t need car seats?
ShoePalaver · 06/01/2024 15:50

IcarusFlies · 06/01/2024 13:05

Some absolute corkers here, among the helpful advice. The chances of being in a car crash are not high in themselves. Life is a risk assessment. Honestly…

We’ve agreed to go and look at some 7 seaters, as an educational exercise. Noted re the front airbag. We’ve got a MaxiCosi pebble for the baby, can’t remember the other two seats but I’ll check DC2’s one - I think it’s a Group 0-3 one that goes through to 12 yo, but will check I’m using it correctly. Thanks for all the advice!

Most of not all group 0-3 seats you can only use the harness to 18 kg and then it's seat belt only.

Swipe left for the next trending thread