Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Children don’t need car seats?

136 replies

IcarusFlies · 06/01/2024 07:46

Am I completely misunderstanding this? We have DC3 on the way and I’m trying to find a way to have three car seats in the back.

One will be 4.5yo, the other 6.5yo when baby comes. DC1 is over 22kg but under 125cm so, I thought, needs a high backed booster or a booster cushion from before 2017 / after growing to 125cm.

But the Gov website is saying “Children aged 3 or older can sit in the back using an adult belt, if there’s no space for a third seat”?? So I don’t need a third car seat at all, if the whole family of five travels together?

https://www.gov.uk/child-car-seats-the-rules/when-a-child-can-travel-without-a-car-seat

NOT debating the safety or wisdom of this, just trying to get my head around the regulations… Surely this can’t be right?

Child car seats: the law

The rules for child car seats and booster seats - height, weight, age, type of vehicle, car, minibus, licensed taxi

https://www.gov.uk/child-car-seats-the-rules/when-a-child-can-travel-without-a-car-seat

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
Grrrrdarling · 10/01/2024 01:46

IcarusFlies · 06/01/2024 13:05

Some absolute corkers here, among the helpful advice. The chances of being in a car crash are not high in themselves. Life is a risk assessment. Honestly…

We’ve agreed to go and look at some 7 seaters, as an educational exercise. Noted re the front airbag. We’ve got a MaxiCosi pebble for the baby, can’t remember the other two seats but I’ll check DC2’s one - I think it’s a Group 0-3 one that goes through to 12 yo, but will check I’m using it correctly. Thanks for all the advice!

@IcarusFlies You don’t need to go 7 seater but it would give you more boot space & seating options for expanding family & stuff.
A Renault scenic & Citroen Picasso can & do fit 3 full car seats in the back seats. Potentially a Ford C-Max will too but I’ve jut had experience with that car.
It takes a little squeeze to get seats in & often have to help kids with last seat belt but they fit.
My next car will be a VW Touran or Grand Scenic as I need more space in boot as will as occasional 6th & 7th seat.

Personally I refuse to listen to government guidance on car safety because they are so incompetent they can’t even organise their own house!
My child stayed in a full backed seat until she was too tall for it, age 9 & a booster until she could no-longer sit comfortably in it, age 11. She is now 12yrs old, 5ft 3in & weighs 8.5stone so was well over the height & weight for booster for a while but for me it gave her an added level of protection.
Any friends travelling kids in my car must agree to kids riding in full backed seats until they are too tall for them or booster until that is unsuitable. My car my rules as their safety is my responsibility but the responsibility of statistics.

Excited101 · 08/01/2024 15:11

Get on the Extended Rear Facing (ERF)… group on facebook. There are so many experts on there who can advice by ages/sizes of children, car and budget. The car seat laws in this country and horrific and outdated.

Mumofsons87 · 08/01/2024 15:09

For toddlers and children on Facebook they have a list of cars that can take 3 seats accross the back.

Mumofsons87 · 08/01/2024 15:09

I think it is absolutely ridiculous that the vast majority of modern cars can't fit 3 carseats accross. I was discussing it last week as a o couldn't car less about aerodynamic fancy shape or an engine that can go faster that the 120km/h I will max go. I want flat seats in the back that can easily accommodate 3 car seats and aren't an absolute pain I'm the hole to buckle in. Get some mothers into the design room please!!!!!!
If you check out ireland rearfacing carseats for

Pinkfluff76 · 08/01/2024 11:15

Yes this is correct so you’re not breaking the law. But honestly unless you’re prepared to get a bigger vehicle that’s one of the reasons you shouldn’t have a third kid. How did you magically think they’d fit?!?

Sennelier1 · 08/01/2024 10:19

My youngest sister had similar issue. They put the oldest in the middle on a boosterseat. That always seemed the safest option to me and also following carsafety rules where we live. (We're not in the UK.)

Outthedoor24 · 08/01/2024 06:13

ToffeeMamma · 08/01/2024 02:15

I was told by a police officer that this means if you have two adults and three car seats. One seat must be put in front and car air bags disengaged and the second adult should travel in back with two car seats (whether squashed or not) as the kids are priority. However if you have 1 adult and 4 car seats then the oldest can be seated in a car seat belt in the back if they are over 3. It all makes me pleased I just have the one.

Police officer has given duff information, or information that doesn't apply to the UK.
The whole reason for the thread is the 3rd child can legally travel without a carseat in between the other two car seats.

The law is a reflection that most cars have 3 seat belts in the back but the middle seat is very narrow.
You need a fairly big car, and a fairly small adult to have any chance of getting them in between two child car seats.
If you could get a big adult in there, you could get a 3rd carseat or booster cushion in.

TempestTost · 08/01/2024 03:02

IcarusFlies · 06/01/2024 17:08

55cm gap?! This topic is the gift that keeps on giving!

I think that's quite literally true.

The thing is that it's always going to be possible to create a safer car seat, if you have no line that's "safe enough". And if car seat designers need to take up huge amounts of space to design the safer seat, they will. And people will then see this new level of safety as the minimum, if you aren't a horrible child killer, and we will have parents driving around in giant trucks to accommodate the car seats.

I am just waiting for the day people realize the safest thing by far is not to take your child in the car at all, and the best carseat becomes a nanny.

I'm being a little hyperbolic, obviously, but I do think it's appropriate to understand that driving is an inherently risky activity, and that no one is comfortable setting set a line - a real concrete number - about how safe is safe enough, because they feel they have to answer, of course there is no line on my child's safety. We all do in reality though.

ToffeeMamma · 08/01/2024 02:15

I was told by a police officer that this means if you have two adults and three car seats. One seat must be put in front and car air bags disengaged and the second adult should travel in back with two car seats (whether squashed or not) as the kids are priority. However if you have 1 adult and 4 car seats then the oldest can be seated in a car seat belt in the back if they are over 3. It all makes me pleased I just have the one.

Rainsdropskeepfalling · 07/01/2024 22:11

I'd swap cars - there are loads that have three full sized back seats. And when your kids are beyond the car seat stage they will be able to travel in comfort rather than stuffed together on the back seat.

LookingforMaryPoppins · 07/01/2024 21:55

We had the same problem when my youngest was born, it's hard to fit 3 isofix in one car! We ended up buying a Q7 - 5 Isofix points would you believe. Other cars that worked were the XC90 , Discovery, and people carrier type cars (SMax?). There are also narrow car seats available if you shop around.

We have a Defender now, no longer need three car seats but that would fit three. If you don't want to change your vehicle your best bet is googling narrow car seats.

Outthedoor24 · 07/01/2024 21:55

PeeblesPobble · 07/01/2024 19:26

So if the two adults are in the back together, presumably one of the kids is driving? 🤔

Hahaha - DH was driving.

It was a comment in reply to a poster who took turns with her Adult DD / DIL being shoe horned sideways, into the gap between the kids car seats (presumably her DH was also doing the driving).

It's more comfortable and safer to have a one child in booster in the front and two adults sitting properly in the with the other child in carseat than to be sitting wedged in sideways between the kids car seats.

Adults heads and necks matter too in the event of a crash. The headrests and seat belts won't do their job of protecting people if they are sitting sideways in a seat.

OhFFS96 · 07/01/2024 21:22

I've seen these advertised. They do a 4 seat version too https://www.multimac.com/p/multimac_1000_3_seater

Multimac 1000 (3 seater)

https://www.multimac.com/p/multimac_1000_3_seater

Amethystanddiamonds · 07/01/2024 21:04

I'm dubious that you can fit 3 across the back in an Octavia. I've never actually managed it. I couldn't squeeze in between the car seats at my thinnest (size 8/10) either so larger adults definitely couldn't. We ended up upgrading one of our Octavia's to a Touran.

birdglasspen · 07/01/2024 20:36

We have a vw touran can fit three in back, 2,4 and 6. It’s hard though!! 6 year old mostly infront as we live somewhere so rural and quiet that road safety isn’t the concern it is elsewhere. I guess in the middle the child is safer from side impact? So a booster seat might be ok? I think if you’re worried you have to update your car to give them all the seat you’d prefer to see them in. Rules seem crazy but then you can jump in a taxi with no car seat.

Christmaslastminute · 07/01/2024 20:34

I haven't checked the stats but I'd bet the bag of maltesers currently on my lap that the highest risk journey in your list in terms of the likelihood of an accident is the school run.

MsMaraschino · 07/01/2024 20:01

I’m afraid we upgraded to a seven seater when we had this issue.

OldPerson · 07/01/2024 19:54

It's a bit like driving a car under the alcohol limit or being absolutely sure you're stone cold sober when you drive. We all know which is safer. We all know children are safer in car seats. The seat belts keep them uniformly strapped in over both shoulders and legs - so they will survive with far fewer injuries than child with one seatbelt fastened over just one shoulder. There have even been stories of children in car seats flung out of cars, who have survived with no injuries. When you're too big for a car seat, you get a booster seat. This is because it is safer to have the single seat belt covering your chest and not cutting into your neck. But above all, you're most likely to survive the crash if you are restrained. Just a single seat belt will do it. You may get more injuries. But the broken bones will mend eventually and you'll live to tell the tale. Just a single seat belt will ensure that 99.9% of the time at a speed limit of 30 or 40 miles an hour - everyone lives. It's insurance - you weigh up how much risk you're willing to take against practical considerations of space and financial limitations or whether you need to trade your car in for a 6 or 7 seater, with extra safety for the kids.

Annatinks · 07/01/2024 19:43

We have the Citroen space tourer. It has 3 full size seats across the back which can all move forward and back independently of each other but it also has two more fold down seats in the boot. We rarely use them but in the meanwhile we appreciate the large boot space and pop them up when needed.

Wonderfulstuff · 07/01/2024 19:36

Defo give in car safety centre a call they are so helpful… and new car seats are much cheaper than a new car!

In DH’s stupidly awkward car we ended up with a britax kidfix hbb and they are slimmer than some others in the market. I know people who have 2 kidfix in the outer seats and then a maxi cosi infant seat secured by a belt in the middle…. Obvs depends on your car and if your middle dc is mature enough for a hbb.

Might be worth asking friends what they have and seeing if you could have a try fitting any of their seats in your car.

Anonymoususe · 07/01/2024 19:33

may I suggest a brilliant facebook group "Extended Rear Facing (ERF) Car Seat Safety" they give some amazing advice x

Fixyourself · 07/01/2024 19:29

I have baby in the front and 2 in the back. If all of us are in the car then an adult will sit in the middle seat. It's not really worth the risk.

PeeblesPobble · 07/01/2024 19:26

Outthedoor24 · 06/01/2024 15:54

We found it easier to put a child in carseat in front and me and my mum in the back together rather than squeezing between the seats.

So if the two adults are in the back together, presumably one of the kids is driving? 🤔

Feralgremlin · 07/01/2024 19:11

We had the same problem OP but without the baby, DS4, SD4 and SD2 (at the time) we had to buy a different car. Went with Citroen Picasso and then when they were older we got a Vauxhall Zafira which was a 7 seater. Prior to that we had tried “slimline” car seats but it just didn’t work. So grateful they are now all out of car seats!

EternalDreamer · 07/01/2024 19:05

We put our eldest (7yr old) in her car seat in the front (air bags off) then when we're all in the car together I squeeze inbetween the car seats in the back. Thankfully our youngest will be moving to a less bulky seat soon so I'm hoping for a bit more room! We have a Toyota Avensis estate.

Swipe left for the next trending thread