Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why the hate for boys?

807 replies

Numberttwotwo · 06/01/2024 07:14

I know this has probably been discussed before. But I seem to come across something every day that makes me feel less worthy, someone to pity and just a bit shit.
I have 2 boys. They are kind, gentle, loving and the best of friends.
So why are my friends (really ‘good’ very longstanding friends) and strangers making comments that make me feel like this. Granted they’re comments about ‘boys’ and not MY boys.
I’ve been told (by a friend with one of each) that mums of boys won’t matter when they’re married and sons will be closer to the in laws.
I was told by a friend’s husband they HAD to find out the sex at 20 weeks because they’d have been soooo disappointed if it was a boy. (In front of my boys)
I was told yesterday (also in front of them) that my friend had been put off EVER having a boy by the behaviour of her nephew.
And this is not including all mentions of trying for a girl whenever we talk about possibly having a third.
I wish I had better ways of responding in the moment but for some reason I always bite my tongue.

YABU - boys are the worst and I pity anyone with more than one.
YANBU - the world should just parent their children and stop with the stupid comments based on nothing more than genitals

Rant over.

OP posts:
Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 06/01/2024 10:45

Sherrystrull · 06/01/2024 10:39

@Ohhelpicantthinkofaname
Why do you think your preference was always girls?

I honestly didn't care less.

Because I personally have always found the majority of primary school aged boys I’ve met pretty irritating and those years seemed like something I would have had to get through had I had boys. Also because of the mother and daughter adult relationship which appealed to me. Not saying everyone gets that, but you’re allowed to have an ideal in your head.

my sister in law always wanted the rough and tumble life she envisioned with having boys. Not saying all boys are like that, but it was the picture she had and wanted pre kids.

everyone is allowed a preference, but preferences don’t have to be the same and one preference isn’t more or less than another’s. They’re personal.

healthadvice123 · 06/01/2024 10:45

@Fairyliz because that is changing admit that? As society changes so is the gender in crimes, we have more women prisons now ? You implied people don’t wnat a son as they may be a criminal, when 95% of crimes currently ( not sure how old data is) may be by men but that isn’t 95% of men is it ? How we bring up our children , can sometimes influence this as well( certainly not always) mens MH is often ignored even more than womens for example. There is so much more to it than just a gender issue

SleepingStandingUp · 06/01/2024 10:44

Having a preference and keeping it to yourself or discussing it before kids etc is fine.
I think the issue is standing in front of a parent and discussing why you'd never want the kind of child they have, uugghh, imagine!! I'd be soooo disappointed if I'd had what you'd have. You know they'll grow up to be X, Y, Z.

I've got a son with additional needs, and then twin boys. So my above thing about insensitive comments includes the "oh I couldn't do it" when actually very few people have their disabled baby / twins adopted, or my personal favourite "omg I'd have killed myself if I'd had twins".

Theladybirdthatheard · 06/01/2024 10:44

I could rant about this all day long.

When I was pregnant with DS1, we found out he was a boy, people were generally positive and he was the first grandchild on both sides, so people were excited regardless.

When I was pregnant with DS2, 90% of the comments I got were. "Oh poor you, another boy? Are you going to try for a third to have a girl?"

I don't know why people feel the need to voice these opinions. I was just happy to have a healthy baby after suffering a miscarriage a few months earlier.

Now of course my brother and his wife are expecting and it's a little girl. And my own mother litterally said to me, "Oh thank god it's a girl! I have been praying everyday for one!" And then couldn't understand why I was annoyed by that.

If one or two people occasionally made ignorant comments, I don't think it would bother me as much. But it's constant! And a lot of time, said infront of my DS1 who is old enough to understand.

I will tell you this, my two boys are absolutely wonderful, and I love being their mum.

Pelham678 · 06/01/2024 10:42

milkywinterdisorder · 06/01/2024 09:43

@Pelham678 You only have to be on MN for a short time to see there are a substantial minority of women on here who think it's okay to prioritise their blood family over their husband's family in their family life.

I am in this substantial minority. Why would I not prioritise people who love me and care about me and have done so all my life over people who frequently act like I don’t even exist?

Well that's a your in-laws thing rather than a general all in-laws are like that thing.

It's an awful thing to do to deliberately cut out your in-laws if they've been perfectly nice to you though. How would you feel if you had sons and you were just excluded from their family life just because their wives preferred their family?

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 06/01/2024 10:42

In many cultures it’s the opposite. I’d never had an engagement ring, so right after dd2 was born, dh bought me a lovely ring.

Immediate comment from non-Brit neighbour (Mediterranean culture), ‘You got that for a GIRL?’

Dh (from an all-boy family) and I have always been very happy with our girls, and contrary to what I so often read on here (teen girls are always a nightmare!) ours absolutely never were.

I did get broody again for a while when dd2 was very little, but it wasn’t because I wanted a boy - I just wanted another baby. (But it did wear off!).

healthadvice123 · 06/01/2024 10:41

@VanityDiesHard exactly and i think womens serious crimes are on the up. Read much more often serious crimes where a women was involved now than ever used to. The stats in 10 years may be very different. In working environent i actually have always preferred to work for men as the few women bosses i have had , have been really awful, treated staff horrendously. I would obviously still work for a women again as i accept just unfortunate that the two/three i have worked for have been horrendous, and i have been lucky with the male bosses too. Thats the thing judging people purely based on their sex and sterotypes isn’t always the best way.

Sherrystrull · 06/01/2024 10:39

@Ohhelpicantthinkofaname
Why do you think your preference was always girls?

I honestly didn't care less.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 06/01/2024 10:38

milkywinterdisorder · 06/01/2024 09:43

@Pelham678 You only have to be on MN for a short time to see there are a substantial minority of women on here who think it's okay to prioritise their blood family over their husband's family in their family life.

I am in this substantial minority. Why would I not prioritise people who love me and care about me and have done so all my life over people who frequently act like I don’t even exist?

But you'd feel differently if they treated you like one of the family.

And, why shouldn't a child get to spend time with the people who loved and cared for their father his whole life? How is it different?

VanityDiesHard · 06/01/2024 10:38

I am maybe a bit of a hypocrite because while I TOTALLY agree with you, OP, I am sort of the opposite of these people. I don't have kids, and part of the reason is that I would not want to have a girl under any circumstances. If I could have been 100% guaranteed to have a son, I would maybe have made different life choices (not that being childfree causes me any pain, I'm more than happy with my beloved cat) I don't dislike girl children, but when I think of the children that I know that I love in a very deep and protective way, they are ALL male and I'm sure that would have been the same had I had my own children. Anyway, boys are awesome and ignore the misandrist fools.

TooOldForThisNonsense · 06/01/2024 10:37

It’s just a ridiculous prejudice. As if “boys” are some sort of homogenous mass. I have 2 boys and they are my world and also couldn’t be more different. I take my responsibility to raise 2 decent men very seriously as did my MIL hence the male role model I chose to father them.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 06/01/2024 10:36

Sherrystrull · 06/01/2024 10:31

@Ohhelpicantthinkofaname

I am grateful for my boys. I would be grateful for any healthy child. I was responding to the poster who stating they were so happy to have girls. I think any form of preference is wrong.

I think you can have a preference for yourself. I think most people do on the quiet. The problem lies when you think everyone’s preference should be the same as yours. People are different and the families they imagine are different.

also though my preference was always girls, I knew I would have loved sons if I’d have had them and I’m sure that in practice there aren’t many people who continue to be disappointed by the sex of their offspring once they’re born. (Expect for one friend who’s children are teens and to this day is bitter about the fact she didn’t get the sex of children she wanted. But I think she’s an outlier).

GatoradeMeBitch · 06/01/2024 10:36

That's life. If you had daughters you'd be annoyed about people saying they were happier to have sons.

Littlewhitecat · 06/01/2024 10:36

I love my DCs equally - have one of each and didn't find out they're sex until i gave birth. My son is growing into a good man because his dad is also a good man and we've raised him well. My DH treats his mum very well and I expect my son to treat me the same. All those of you saying you don't like boys I'm assuming your daughters were fathered by a man? You liked him enough to get pregnant.

healthadvice123 · 06/01/2024 10:35

@SleepingStandingUp maybe your forcing your girls into it to. My mum used to try and get me to wear skirts and dresses and she could when little but by 7/8 i refused as i hated pink and glittery and preferred trackies and trainers much easier to climb and play footie witH. As an older women i now wear dresses a bit more than I ever had for comfort/ fit and I can’t climb trees mow, but your assuming all girls want the pink filly life , many don’t. Why can’t people let kids just be kids, my ds had a toy hoover and pushchair , because thats what he wanted, I gave zero shit what anyone else thought. My kids always chose what they liked to do.

5128gap · 06/01/2024 10:35

But that's the whole point @87SPD unless she is in a same sex relationship which the odds remain against, a woman never has to 'share' her daughter with another woman, does she? A mother with a close relationship with her daughter can be quietly confident that no one is ever going to come along and try to reduce their contact, criticise her for overstepping if she cooks for her or helps her with washing, call her daughter a woman child or a mummy's girl if she wants to spend a lot of time with her. The majority of mums of girls can expect their relationship to be largely unchanged by the presence of their SiL. This is typically not the case for mothers of sons and if they miss the closeness they're 'toxic'. It's a different and much harder role to navigate.

MsCactus · 06/01/2024 10:35

tokesqueen · 06/01/2024 07:26

Because this is a female site. A male forum would read very differently.
Stats show most men want boys, and are far more likely to leave the family unit if their offspring are solely female.

Yeah, agree with this. I had a preference for daughters, my DH had a preference to have sons.

But this is a female site mainly, so you'll see more of a preference for girls.

IHatesMeecesToPieces · 06/01/2024 10:33

It's normal to want what you're familiar with, I think. I think a lot of men actually do want a son.

I'm from a family of all (many) girls.

Before I had children I could only imagine having girls myself. I didn't really know anything about boys 😂

I did have a girl first - and then had a boy, and it was an utter joy!

He was so much easier to deal with as a teenager than the girls and is now a lovely, loving adult and a wonderful son.

mottytotty · 06/01/2024 10:32

There isn’t hate for boys, you need better friends.

I was told by a friend’s husband they HAD to find out the sex at 20 weeks because they’d have been soooo disappointed if it was a boy. (In front of my boys)

Did you not say anything? What a good example to your sons if you had said something like ‘you would be lucky to have a boy, my sons are wonderful and I have never missed not having a girl’.

VanityDiesHard · 06/01/2024 10:32

crostini · 06/01/2024 07:23

I love little boys and think either sex of baby is a gift and their temperament is likely due to personality rather than because they are boys or girls.

However, something that I was aware of whilst pregnant with my kids and perhaps could explain why some women have a preference for girls, is that their are so many terrible men. The older I get the more I distrust men and prefer to be around women. So the pressure to raise a good, gentle, respectful man, i feel would be immense. Especially with the amount of porn and violence that has been normalised and consumed within society.

People say this a lot on here but I just don't agree. There are terrible men in life, yes. But there are also terrible women! It is true that men are more likely to commit crimes of violence, but just in day to day life I find the genders equally nice/nasty. Perhaps I am biased: I have been seriously sexually assaulted once in my life and it was by a (cis) woman so I don't go around with this idea that all women are safe.

Sherrystrull · 06/01/2024 10:31

@Ohhelpicantthinkofaname

I am grateful for my boys. I would be grateful for any healthy child. I was responding to the poster who stating they were so happy to have girls. I think any form of preference is wrong.

Glasgowlass93 · 06/01/2024 10:30

My neighbours DIL recently had a baby and my neighbour was DESPERATE for it to be a boy. My neighbours are Asian and they want boys in the family to continue the family business. The girls are the home makers. So i think its a cultural thing and different cultures will prefer one of the other. Obviously some people are happy with either but as a generalisation.

Nevermind31 · 06/01/2024 10:29

87SPD · 06/01/2024 10:21

I think it’s down to outdated expectations of how they can do ‘girly’ things with daughters and that a daughter is for life but a boy ‘is for life until he meets his wife’ blah blah! It’s quite ridiculous, I have two girls and trying my best to raise them without any stereotypical pressures and I would have done the same if I had boys.

A lot of it is actually toxic mothers who don’t like sharing their sons with another woman and this includes their grandchildren. Whereas mothers of sons who respect their daughter in law and welcome her like they would a son in law will retain that closeness.

I have male cousins who have beautiful relationships with their mothers, go for afternoon teas, football together, walks etc their children are close with both paternal and maternal grandparents.

Your friends sound ignorant, prejudiced and disrespectful imo. YANBU

Absolutely this.

BiscuitDreams · 06/01/2024 10:28

It's just different personalities and nothing to do what sex the kids are isn't it. MIL has two daughters and one son and the daughters are horrible and abusive and their relationship is sour. Her son (my DH) is very close to his mum and they have a lovely relationship. I'm close to MIL too and she enjoys coming over and seeing us all. Not sure why people say you lose your son to their partner. 🤷🏻‍♀️ My brother is probably closer to my mum than I am too, and she is very close to all of her grandchildren.

I like boys and I like girls. Would be happy with either.

Chanhedforthis · 06/01/2024 10:26

It's all a load of stereotypical nonsense most of the time.

I have 2 girls and am over the moon to be having a little boy next.

Swipe left for the next trending thread