Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why the hate for boys?

807 replies

Numberttwotwo · 06/01/2024 07:14

I know this has probably been discussed before. But I seem to come across something every day that makes me feel less worthy, someone to pity and just a bit shit.
I have 2 boys. They are kind, gentle, loving and the best of friends.
So why are my friends (really ‘good’ very longstanding friends) and strangers making comments that make me feel like this. Granted they’re comments about ‘boys’ and not MY boys.
I’ve been told (by a friend with one of each) that mums of boys won’t matter when they’re married and sons will be closer to the in laws.
I was told by a friend’s husband they HAD to find out the sex at 20 weeks because they’d have been soooo disappointed if it was a boy. (In front of my boys)
I was told yesterday (also in front of them) that my friend had been put off EVER having a boy by the behaviour of her nephew.
And this is not including all mentions of trying for a girl whenever we talk about possibly having a third.
I wish I had better ways of responding in the moment but for some reason I always bite my tongue.

YABU - boys are the worst and I pity anyone with more than one.
YANBU - the world should just parent their children and stop with the stupid comments based on nothing more than genitals

Rant over.

OP posts:
decisionssmecisions · 06/01/2024 11:16

No OF COURSE porn damages girls. But it's the boys who grow into men who watch the porn that damage the girls who might also watch it and think they have to agree to things they don't want to do. Things that hurt them and traumatise them.Look, "boymoms" don't want to hear this, but there is a generation of boys growing up exposed to porn who will be unable to form relationships and a generation of girls growing up who very understandably won't want to have a relationship with them.

I have both & think it’s way more nuanced than the above. At the moment I certainly worry far more for my dds in a culture with social media where plastic surgery & posing suggestively half naked is encouraged. My 14 yr old niece hates herself because she feels she doesn’t look like an insta model. I sometimes work with teenagers & the girls have so much pressure to look a certain way, it’s really sad.

VanityDiesHard · 06/01/2024 11:15

monkeyspaw · 06/01/2024 10:57

Pretty sure you know the statistics from the way you've jumped in. What are they again? Something like 50% of "transwomen" are incarcerated for sexual crimes while 8% of males are? Tiny.

That still doesn't mean that there are enough trans women to shift the dial to the extent that you are implying. They are quite simply not a large enough population, and it is highly disingenuous to imply otherwise. People who obsess about violent trans women and imagine that they are lurking under every bush are unhinged.

TheaBrandt · 06/01/2024 11:14

Thinking about it the only time I’ve heard this type of comment is from mothers of boys themselves saying these things and fretting about it when all our were kids babies /toddlers. It was mothers of boys being quite defensive and coming out with oddly sexist comments about girls which was odd as most of them previously were not like that at all.

paddyclampofthethirdkind · 06/01/2024 11:11

I Have one of each and they are both amazing. They’re grown up now.

Have you read some of the nasty comments about girls on here?! Usually triggered by a woman posting about how disappointed she is to be having a boy. So everyone piles on and says boys are so wonderful but girls are bitchy, like pink glittery shit, are more complicated etc. Really pisses me off it does!

anyolddinosaur · 06/01/2024 11:10

If people are saying this in front of your sons it is unkind - and you should say you love having boys. But perhaps your sons are not the paragons of virtue you perceive them to be?

Some parents seem to think their offspring are a delight when they are actually pretty obnoxious. Mothers of sons more often seem to be blind to their offspring's faults IME. Of course it's not universal and I have had to try and explain to a mother than the reason no-one would play with her daughter was because of the girl's behaviour. Still far more common with boys.

wateringcanface · 06/01/2024 11:09

I've got mixed feelings.

I'd be thrilled with either gender, but I'd have more anxieties about having boys than girls.

These are based on my personal experience of boys.

I know these are not the 'rule' and it is completely possible to have exceptions to these cases, but it is just something objectively I've observed that makes me feel a bit sad.

  1. The misogyny, my friend had to do a workshop on the rise of the andrew tate effect to a bunch of 13-16 year olds. She left almost in tears, the sniggering, the belittlement, the obnoxious opinions, all coming from boys.

I've got a friend with 2 teenage sons (one absolutely lovely) and the younger one who Is just a misogynist to his core, the language and demands he makes to his mother are vile.

I'm on twitter a lot, and the amount of teenage boys discussing content like how all rape accusations are 'fake', they only want a subservient wife etc. Its scary.

Again, I emphasis this isn't every boy, I know that, I know plenty of boys who aren't like that, the issue is I don't know a female equivalent risk that compares.

And I don't think its fair to say good parenting can prevent this, external pressures can be just too overpowering.

  1. The adult relationships. My parents live far away, but they call most days, and either I'll go stay with them a few days every 8 weeks, or they come to me. We go to the beach, go on hikes, day drips, city trips, meals out etc. My husband has a good relationship with his mum, she lives 5 minutes away, but I couldn't tell you the last time they did an activity together just them whereas his sister on the other hand is always going for lunch and drinks with her.

Again, not a rule, and I can think of some male friends who do spend time doing nice things like country walks, meals out etc one on one (or with partner) with their parents, I can just think of more who don't have that relationship than do, whereas it's the opposite for daughters.

In terms of the baby/toddler/child stage, the gender makes no difference to me

monkeyspaw · 06/01/2024 11:08

decisionssmecisions · 06/01/2024 10:58

Better keep him away from porn then, which he's likely to see by the age of 8. Won't matter how "gently" you raise him if he sees women brutalised and objectified when he's forming his lifelong sexual preferences from watching violent porn. If you really want him to be a good man...don't give him a phone/internet as a child

But surely the above applies to girls too or are you saying porn only damages boys? Tbh I think hiding it is unrealistic, far better to have discussions about it.

No OF COURSE porn damages girls. But it's the boys who grow into men who watch the porn that damage the girls who might also watch it and think they have to agree to things they don't want to do. Things that hurt them and traumatise them.
Look, "boymoms" don't want to hear this, but there is a generation of boys growing up exposed to porn who will be unable to form relationships and a generation of girls growing up who very understandably won't want to have a relationship with them.

Redlarge · 06/01/2024 11:08

Babla · 06/01/2024 11:05

The bottom line is it depends on the personality of the child not the sex

This. Looking at my kids classmates its not just boys or girls that are the horrors. And its the parents to blame.

decisionssmecisions · 06/01/2024 11:08

Whether we like it or not, more people conform to gender stereotypes than don't. You only need to consider the children and adults you know and see round and about to know that division of interests, jobs, behaviour, family roles and lifestyle based on sex is still very much alive and well, so I think its understandable that a person having a child of a particular sex will have certain expectations as to what parenting them may be like.

I don’t understand the above. Whats a typically female interest or lifestyle? I have female friends & family that are surgeons, accountants, solicitors, teachers, GPs, tech people. I also know males in those roles.

DiaNaranja · 06/01/2024 11:07

crostini · 06/01/2024 07:23

I love little boys and think either sex of baby is a gift and their temperament is likely due to personality rather than because they are boys or girls.

However, something that I was aware of whilst pregnant with my kids and perhaps could explain why some women have a preference for girls, is that their are so many terrible men. The older I get the more I distrust men and prefer to be around women. So the pressure to raise a good, gentle, respectful man, i feel would be immense. Especially with the amount of porn and violence that has been normalised and consumed within society.

I think this explains alot of it. There's no denying the fact, the vast majority of people who do terrible terrible things are men. Not to say there aren't women who do terrible things too, but on the whole, murder, violence, terrorism, abuse, usually falls at the hands of men. 93% of the prison population is male. And I think many women worry about raising another statistic. Alot feel it is safer and easier to raise stereotypically kind, caring daughters than to be able to do the same with boys. BUT on the flip side, I have two daughters, and I actually sometimes wish I'd had boys, as I worry about the type of relationships they may end up in (if they grow up to be hetrosexual), seeing what some of my friends put up with, and the low level abuse they receive from their partners. My husband is extremely kind, gentle and loving, and I just pray there are more men like him in the world as my daughters grow up.

Myncnow · 06/01/2024 11:06

FrankieStein403 · 06/01/2024 11:02

>all of the terrible things happening, 95% of which is caused by men.

Yet we are told most children are still raised by their mothers - so it's all their fault the boys turn out evil isn't it?

This may have been meant ironically but I do think it’s symptomatic of the attitude that raising children is just a matter of raising them to be X and then they will be Y. It isn’t. It’s unclear how much is societal and how much is inherent but it definitely isn’t solely about upbringing.

NOTANUM · 06/01/2024 11:06

This is a weird thread. When I was pregnant in the 00s it was still 50/50 as to whether people found out the gender and didn’t seem to care as much as this thread suggests. The only discussed win was the “pair” - one of each, but that wasn’t even a big deal as it was offset by the “best friends” aspect in having two the same gender.
Is it Instagram/SM and the photograph opportunity in dressing up that is driving this new phenomenon?

Benibidibici · 06/01/2024 11:05

No one i know is like this?

5128gap · 06/01/2024 11:05

Whether we like it or not, more people conform to gender stereotypes than don't. You only need to consider the children and adults you know and see round and about to know that division of interests, jobs, behaviour, family roles and lifestyle based on sex is still very much alive and well, so I think its understandable that a person having a child of a particular sex will have certain expectations as to what parenting them may be like. If not in childhood, when the difference is less marked, then certainly as they mature, when by far the likelihood is that your child will conform to many of the stereotypes for their sex. And this won't be your 'fault'.

Babla · 06/01/2024 11:05

The bottom line is it depends on the personality of the child not the sex

K8ate · 06/01/2024 11:04

Orangebadger · 06/01/2024 10:59

Yes I work in ante natal care. It's quite awful sometimes. The other day I had a patient in clinic who had just found out her 2nd was a boy. She was distraught about it, this, in front of her 5 yr old son. Bellowing, I don't want another boy!! I want a girl!

Terrible people regardless of which sex the baby was.
These people simply aren’t fit to be parents in my opinion.
It’s hardly surprising there’s so much shit in the world when children are being brought up and influenced by these type of parents.

Orangebadger · 06/01/2024 11:04

Fern95 · 06/01/2024 10:47

I'm a criminologist so the statistics do horrify me. It's mostly males who do the worst things, it's undeniable. Add in personal experiences of domestic violence, assault and sexual harassment (even in school uniform, bleh) and it doesn't paint a great picture. I'm pregnant with my second and don't have a preference because I believe the problem isn't inherently men and boys, the problems stem from toxic masculinity and patriarchal society! I have a daughter and she likes trains, cars, football and Pokémon. She also likes princesses and makeup. I think most people are happy to have a child who can have it all without judgement which is why you get people wanting girls.

Totally agree. I have a girl who can be who she wants. But my 6 yr old boy who loves nail varnish is unlikely to not get the piss ripped out of him at some point!

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 06/01/2024 11:03

@milkywinterdisorder I get that your relationship with your family is your priority, and it should be. Mine is.

By my daughters relationship with both sets of grandparents is also something I prioritise. Provided they're at least civil to me, in front of her, I don't see how what I feel towards them should impact her having a great relationship with anyone who wants to be in her life. My MIL can be difficult, I'll admit that, and I'm definitely the luckiest of her three DiLs with her because she actually has some respect for me. But I wouldn't leave my daughters relationship with her family down to just my DH to manage. In the same way that he wouldn't leave her relationship with my family solely to me.

His family are now mine by extension, and vice versa, and they're all my daughters.

If they're vile to you and can't treat you with basic respect, then I get it, you don't want to have your child witness that. But otherwise, it's about the child. Not the parents.

Babla · 06/01/2024 11:03

YANBU I have 3 lovely boys

decisionssmecisions · 06/01/2024 11:02

The bottom line is that you can be as close as anything to your son, but once married it appears that in some cases it is possible that sons may drift away a little and spend more time with their wife’s family. I’m like to think I’m close to my son but now he’s married I’m usually the one who makes the effort to maintain regular contact. My daughters however contact me probably every day by FaceTime or text and are also very close to each other. They love their brother and he loves them, but he doesn’t seem to need regular contact with family as much as they do.

My DH is much closer to his mum than I am to mine. I also know so many women who have very complex relationships with their mums whereas I don't know any men that do.

Whyyoulyingfor · 06/01/2024 11:02

Eleganz · 06/01/2024 10:52

Sadly I feel the attitudes about baby boys sit alongside a "boys will be boys" attitude later on where problematic behaviour (violence and aggression) is not effectively dealt with during formative years.

My own view is that boys really need positive relationships with their fathers to develop well. Sadly many men are not capable of that due to the failures in their own upbringing.

What about boys raised in same sex female relationships? Are they doomed from birth?

You can raise boys to respect women and others by being a strong woman with boundaries and clear consequences. You don’t need a penis to do that.

FrankieStein403 · 06/01/2024 11:02

>all of the terrible things happening, 95% of which is caused by men.

Yet we are told most children are still raised by their mothers - so it's all their fault the boys turn out evil isn't it?

Myncnow · 06/01/2024 11:01

It is also the case when relationships end or if a man is widowed. He remarries or gets into a new relationship and the kids from his deceased or separated partner are not as important as the ones in the new family.

decisionssmecisions · 06/01/2024 11:01

I hated boys and didn't want them only because I had a friend who had two feral children. I didn't realise that it was just her children who were like that, and not all children. They were so awful that I thought all boys were like that, until other friends started having children. I have a DS who is the best child, absolutely everyone including his friends parents let me know this all the time. My dd on the other hand lol. My friend with the feral kids, well I just realised it was the parenting not the children.

So your DD isn't the best? As you say maybe it's the parenting! 😄

Indiseven · 06/01/2024 11:00

The bottom line is that you can be as close as anything to your son, but once married it appears that in some cases it is possible that sons may drift away a little and spend more time with their wife’s family. I’m like to think I’m close to my son but now he’s married I’m usually the one who makes the effort to maintain regular contact. My daughters however contact me probably every day by FaceTime or text and are also very close to each other. They love their brother and he loves them, but he doesn’t seem to need regular contact with family as much as they do.

I make this comment because I think this may be the main reason that some women want daughters. It’s not so much to do with bringing up sons, it’s about what happens after that. Having said this, I have friends with sons who are married and who have great relationships with their sons and DsIL. Their sons are always phoning them and wanting to visit so each case is individual.

it goes without saying that the crass and insensitive comments experienced by OP are inexcusable.