Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why the hate for boys?

807 replies

Numberttwotwo · 06/01/2024 07:14

I know this has probably been discussed before. But I seem to come across something every day that makes me feel less worthy, someone to pity and just a bit shit.
I have 2 boys. They are kind, gentle, loving and the best of friends.
So why are my friends (really ‘good’ very longstanding friends) and strangers making comments that make me feel like this. Granted they’re comments about ‘boys’ and not MY boys.
I’ve been told (by a friend with one of each) that mums of boys won’t matter when they’re married and sons will be closer to the in laws.
I was told by a friend’s husband they HAD to find out the sex at 20 weeks because they’d have been soooo disappointed if it was a boy. (In front of my boys)
I was told yesterday (also in front of them) that my friend had been put off EVER having a boy by the behaviour of her nephew.
And this is not including all mentions of trying for a girl whenever we talk about possibly having a third.
I wish I had better ways of responding in the moment but for some reason I always bite my tongue.

YABU - boys are the worst and I pity anyone with more than one.
YANBU - the world should just parent their children and stop with the stupid comments based on nothing more than genitals

Rant over.

OP posts:
Redlarge · 06/01/2024 11:40

Finti · 06/01/2024 11:34

In my family/culture it’s exactly the opposite! Those with girls are pitied. On giving birth to my sister, my mom was told “never mind, hopefully it will be a boy next time”

both notions are ridiculous. Thankfully, society is moving forward.

Yeah this is really sad. Hopefully they keep moving forward.

101Nutella · 06/01/2024 11:38

It’s odd people are saying this in front of you. I would ask them not to be unkind. It’s not right for your children’s self esteem. I think regardless of gender, your children won’t spend time with you if you are a toxic parent or mean to their partners so I can’t see that having a girl or boy makes any difference here.

I would parent boys differently however to ensure they aren’t victim to toxic masculinity culture or horrible stereotypes that seem to persist. Eg real men don’t cry, if a girl says no to a date it’s just coz you need to try harder etc etc. there are loads of proven cultural issues which feed in to this so as a parent of boys I would be working to protect my sons from that so they can be happy in their own skin. I don’t want them to have to be alpha gym bros only wearing blue if that’s not what works for them.

personally I felt if I had a girl I’d know a bit more what I’m doing as I am a female. However I feel more worried about their personal safety with the rise of incels and violence against women. I was grateful to have a healthy child. I think people who go on about it are likely going to inflict a load of stereotypes on their kid and continue the problem as they’ve already planned out life for their kid rather than getting to know their child as an individual. 🤷‍♀️

Lordofmyflies · 06/01/2024 11:38

People do spout a lot of rubbish and like to stereotype according to gender. Good parenting and teaching respect and kindness towards others is the most important factor contributing to the relationship you have with your child as an adult and the sort of person they become.
I have 2 boys, both are fantastic young men who still hug me daily when they are back home from Uni. They buy flowers for their girlfriend's mother on her birthday, pick up their female friends from the pub if they can't get a taxi. They are emotionally intelligent and kind humans, despite having a penis. You get out what you put in.

Kaz40s · 06/01/2024 11:37

Its really weird how people can be. They say these things sometimes without properly thinking (mindless chat), they lack awareness & some say out of underlying jealousy or spite, wanting a reaction or to suck your joy. Make sure your children hear you stand up for them & be proud of who they are in public though going forward!

I struggled with infertility & was over the moon to give birth to healthy babies without any preferences to sex. Every wee soul is deifferent, its how we look after them to help them grow that's important.DS & DD and my boy is much more loving & sensitive than the girl whos tough & independent, not girly at all which is fine. Be happy and thankful for your blessings & let NOBODY take away your joy.

katepilar · 06/01/2024 11:37

Back to your OP, its not because of their genitals, its because of their behaviour from what I understand.

hotpotlover · 06/01/2024 11:35

I don't get it either.

My 1st is a boy, my 2nd and 3rd are daughters.

I was delighted when my son was born and I love him very much.

anarchicparadise · 06/01/2024 11:35

Redlarge · 06/01/2024 11:29

I think it depends on the person. My daughter hasnt caused me one bit of bother ever. She's a brilliant sister and friend, kind, well-behaved, medium achiever but has other interests.
My friends daughter is evil incarnated. I honestly couldn't cope a day with her. Violent, disrespectful, bully, demanding, no manners, spoilt.
I personally don't think its a gender thing. I think its parenting and environmental... which the parents need to mitigate and educate about.

I suppose it’s a matter of opinion.

my mother was a primary school teacher for 44 years (42 in the same school) and would tell you that on the whole girls are more complex and, unfortunately, difficult to deal with. Again it’s anecdotal but if you’re dealing with children day in day out for 44 years then I’d tend to think that you’d have a pretty good understanding of them.

Blueskies3 · 06/01/2024 11:35

I have boys and the only but I worry about is if they marry a woman and have children. I know I would come second place to the daughter in law’s mother. I had better take up a whole lot of hobbies and learn to accept it

milkywinterdisorder · 06/01/2024 11:34

@IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos My in-laws aren’t difficult, as such, is just that they don’t really see in-laws as family. My DH’s sister, for instance, told him that my brother’s children don’t count as his nephews; until we had kids I wasn’t invited to family events; I’m not in their family group chat, etc etc.

So the way we do things is that my kids’ relationship with my family is solely my responsibility and their relationship with DH’s family is solely his responsibility. And as far as I can tell this would only be a problem if DH were one of those men who couldn’t be bothered to make the effort with his own family. I don’t see why it’s my job to foster my kids’ relationship with their paternal grandparents any more than it’s my husband’s job to foster their relationship with my parents - as long as someone’s doing the fostering…!

Finti · 06/01/2024 11:34

In my family/culture it’s exactly the opposite! Those with girls are pitied. On giving birth to my sister, my mom was told “never mind, hopefully it will be a boy next time”

both notions are ridiculous. Thankfully, society is moving forward.

Redlarge · 06/01/2024 11:33

user1477391263 · 06/01/2024 11:27

It seems to be shifting a lot worldwide. Developing a slight preference for daughters rather than sons seems to be a cultural universal as societies modernize.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/WPcap/1999-12/16/003r-121699-idx.html
Japan has had a slight overall preference for daughters since the 1990s or so. South Korea had made the shift around 15 years ago (the abortions of girls stopped around then). Even in China, more and more young urban families are preferring daughters.

Historically, women had little scope for their own tastes, and little say in family life. Sons were valued because a woman had little value of her own, and keeping her son emotionally tied to her was a way of having some power and influence in the family. Patrilocal marriage styles in many places, esp Asia, meant that women married “out” and tended to lose touch with their own families. It was not their preference, but they were forced to do it. A daughter-in-law was your servant and the one who waited on you in old age.

Nowadays, women have more choice and say in their lives, including in much of Asia. They’re refusing to move into their in-laws’ homes and insisting on having their own nuclear family households, and if possible tend to prioritize having their own relatives, not their in laws, nearby. Since they have more choice in who they’ll choose to support in old age, they’ll probably prioritize their own parents not their in laws, and they can’t be forced to do things they don’t want to any more. And with more and more women in the workforce, the bond between adult daughters and their mothers has become very important, as mum’s mum is often helping out with childcare. MILs can too, of course, but most women will favor their own mothers if possible.

Gender relations have - for the moment - remained more traditional on the Indian subcontinent than in other parts of Asia, but that won’t last much longer IMO.

Yes, again down to the parents.
I overheard my son talking to a friend who was asking could he play roblox with him later. When my son replied no im watching a film with my mum the other child ridiculed him. My son replied... you dont like chilling with your mum? ... i feel sorry for you mate.

NerdyIsMyMiddleName · 06/01/2024 11:31

Let's be honest - some boys are hard work. Some girls are self obsessed princesses. Most kids are just complicated.

They're nuanced people, like adults,not cardboard cutouts. I know adults who were really awful as children but are genuinely amazing, intuitive, kind people now. And gorgeous children who now have serious issues, and haven't fulfilled their early potential now they're adults.

Putting all people into two camps is just bullshit, whether they're under 18 or not.

Igniteyourbones · 06/01/2024 11:30

I assure you that it works both ways. We have 3 girls and people always say “oh poor Daddy” or “God help him when they are teenagers” right in front of the girls. And when I was pregnant with number three people constantly asked if we were trying for a third because we hadn’t had a boy. People are just insensitive idiots.

monkeyspaw · 06/01/2024 11:29

VanityDiesHard · 06/01/2024 11:15

That still doesn't mean that there are enough trans women to shift the dial to the extent that you are implying. They are quite simply not a large enough population, and it is highly disingenuous to imply otherwise. People who obsess about violent trans women and imagine that they are lurking under every bush are unhinged.

Well now you are being disingenuous aren't you? Because they are disproportionately represented in the crime statistics, both in the UK and the US.
There are so few of them, such a small population...but so many in (women's) prisons. Why is that? Are you one of those women who say "well, if a few women suffer so our poor oppressed "sisters" can live how they need to, then that is an acceptable price to pay.
Please take your libfem luxury beliefs and shove them.

Redlarge · 06/01/2024 11:29

anarchicparadise · 06/01/2024 11:25

I have two boys and I’d take them any day over girl tbh.

they’re straightforward and simple. From the stories I hear from my 10 yr old son’s class and from my friends with daughters, girls are more complex and a lot more difficult to deal with.

I think it depends on the person. My daughter hasnt caused me one bit of bother ever. She's a brilliant sister and friend, kind, well-behaved, medium achiever but has other interests.
My friends daughter is evil incarnated. I honestly couldn't cope a day with her. Violent, disrespectful, bully, demanding, no manners, spoilt.
I personally don't think its a gender thing. I think its parenting and environmental... which the parents need to mitigate and educate about.

user1477391263 · 06/01/2024 11:27

Pelham678 · 06/01/2024 09:33

You only have to be on MN for a short time to see there are a substantial minority of women on here who think it's okay to prioritise their blood family over their husband's family in their family life. I don't think it's true in all cultures that men are socialised not to be close to their mums - other cultures, like in southern Europe or Asian cultures don't seem to have this social conditioning.

We have this mummy's boy (how offensive is that - why aren't we allowed to be close to our mums just because we are male) mentality. Men are ridiculed for wanting to spend time with their mum, ringing their mum regularly in a way that women just aren't.

Many times I've heard that ' sons are yours til they get a wife, daughters are there for life' bilge. We need to change our attitudes to men who are close to their mums.

I've got two sons and I think they will still be involved when they get married and have their families but I would be lying to say it isn't something I never worry about. Having boys as children has been great fun, I would also love to have had girls.

It seems to be shifting a lot worldwide. Developing a slight preference for daughters rather than sons seems to be a cultural universal as societies modernize.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/WPcap/1999-12/16/003r-121699-idx.html
Japan has had a slight overall preference for daughters since the 1990s or so. South Korea had made the shift around 15 years ago (the abortions of girls stopped around then). Even in China, more and more young urban families are preferring daughters.

Historically, women had little scope for their own tastes, and little say in family life. Sons were valued because a woman had little value of her own, and keeping her son emotionally tied to her was a way of having some power and influence in the family. Patrilocal marriage styles in many places, esp Asia, meant that women married “out” and tended to lose touch with their own families. It was not their preference, but they were forced to do it. A daughter-in-law was your servant and the one who waited on you in old age.

Nowadays, women have more choice and say in their lives, including in much of Asia. They’re refusing to move into their in-laws’ homes and insisting on having their own nuclear family households, and if possible tend to prioritize having their own relatives, not their in laws, nearby. Since they have more choice in who they’ll choose to support in old age, they’ll probably prioritize their own parents not their in laws, and they can’t be forced to do things they don’t want to any more. And with more and more women in the workforce, the bond between adult daughters and their mothers has become very important, as mum’s mum is often helping out with childcare. MILs can too, of course, but most women will favor their own mothers if possible.

Gender relations have - for the moment - remained more traditional on the Indian subcontinent than in other parts of Asia, but that won’t last much longer IMO.

anarchicparadise · 06/01/2024 11:25

I have two boys and I’d take them any day over girl tbh.

they’re straightforward and simple. From the stories I hear from my 10 yr old son’s class and from my friends with daughters, girls are more complex and a lot more difficult to deal with.

5128gap · 06/01/2024 11:24

decisionssmecisions · 06/01/2024 11:08

Whether we like it or not, more people conform to gender stereotypes than don't. You only need to consider the children and adults you know and see round and about to know that division of interests, jobs, behaviour, family roles and lifestyle based on sex is still very much alive and well, so I think its understandable that a person having a child of a particular sex will have certain expectations as to what parenting them may be like.

I don’t understand the above. Whats a typically female interest or lifestyle? I have female friends & family that are surgeons, accountants, solicitors, teachers, GPs, tech people. I also know males in those roles.

Of course you do, as do we all. But if someone mentioned that one of their children was now a SAHP despite being a trained beautician, while the other is a firefighter who plays rugby at the weekend, how much would you be prepared to gamble on the former being a son and the latter a daughter? You may disagree with the idea that there are stereotypes around male and female interests, but I'd be surprised if you genuinely didn't know what was meant by it.

Namechange4448830938489 · 06/01/2024 11:24

There are some ridiculous things on here about boys. Some of you sound as if you belong in China or Hitler's Germany.

decisionssmecisions · 06/01/2024 11:21

But speaking generally men will usually act differently to women and girls will generally be closer to their mums iI adulthood than boys will- especially when it comes to having a baby.

Not sure it’s that relevant any more, have you seen the birth rates?! 😆

Redlarge · 06/01/2024 11:19

wateringcanface · 06/01/2024 11:09

I've got mixed feelings.

I'd be thrilled with either gender, but I'd have more anxieties about having boys than girls.

These are based on my personal experience of boys.

I know these are not the 'rule' and it is completely possible to have exceptions to these cases, but it is just something objectively I've observed that makes me feel a bit sad.

  1. The misogyny, my friend had to do a workshop on the rise of the andrew tate effect to a bunch of 13-16 year olds. She left almost in tears, the sniggering, the belittlement, the obnoxious opinions, all coming from boys.

I've got a friend with 2 teenage sons (one absolutely lovely) and the younger one who Is just a misogynist to his core, the language and demands he makes to his mother are vile.

I'm on twitter a lot, and the amount of teenage boys discussing content like how all rape accusations are 'fake', they only want a subservient wife etc. Its scary.

Again, I emphasis this isn't every boy, I know that, I know plenty of boys who aren't like that, the issue is I don't know a female equivalent risk that compares.

And I don't think its fair to say good parenting can prevent this, external pressures can be just too overpowering.

  1. The adult relationships. My parents live far away, but they call most days, and either I'll go stay with them a few days every 8 weeks, or they come to me. We go to the beach, go on hikes, day drips, city trips, meals out etc. My husband has a good relationship with his mum, she lives 5 minutes away, but I couldn't tell you the last time they did an activity together just them whereas his sister on the other hand is always going for lunch and drinks with her.

Again, not a rule, and I can think of some male friends who do spend time doing nice things like country walks, meals out etc one on one (or with partner) with their parents, I can just think of more who don't have that relationship than do, whereas it's the opposite for daughters.

In terms of the baby/toddler/child stage, the gender makes no difference to me

I think good parenting can overcome it. Im very very aware of the majority of men being offenders/abusers and the horrors of misogyny. from day one with my son ive made a conscious effort to make him question the views and behaviour of others. To be confident and assertive in his own views and things I've installed in him about society and right and wrong.

His father is a terrible person, and they dont have contact because of it . I've been very, very clear about why, how we have tried to fix it. How we can support each other, etc. I encourage him to ask questions if he feels something isn't right or if someone's behaviour makes him feel uncomfortable, and i tell him what's right and wrong.

He's an absolute gem, and i am so proud of him. School reports that whilst he's quiet, he's popular, and he will always do the right thing and not give in to peer pressure or bullies. I've made him very very aware that he does not have to agree with 'popular' views or trending, and ive also strongly made both my kids aware of social media, etc. I prob have exposed them to adult concerns a bit too young, but they aren't fearful of having their own opinion or saying no and long may that continue.

Salamander91 · 06/01/2024 11:18

I don't get the perception of boys at all. I have 3 boys and 1 girl and my boys are far easier most of the time 🙃

PurpleWisteria1 · 06/01/2024 11:18

SallyWD · 06/01/2024 10:06

Such an assumption to make. My brothers see my parents more than I do and my parents are very close to their children. My DH sees his mum all the time, they have weekends away, just the two of them. I know loads of middle aged men who are close to their mums, despite being married with kids. I know several women who have strained relationships with their mothers.
Stop buying in to all these exist stereotypes.

That’s lovely, but I was speaking in general.
Men and women are fundamentally different in general.
Pretending they are not is just made up 21st C crap. Of course both sexes can do whatever they want / behave in a non stereotypical way. No issue with that at all. But speaking generally men will usually act differently to women and girls will generally be closer to their mums iI adulthood than boys will- especially when it comes to having a baby.
You can argue that your family members don’t fit that- and that’s fine but for most it’s true.

Myncnow · 06/01/2024 11:17

People who obsess about violent trans women and imagine that they are lurking under every bush are unhinged.

It isn’t that they are lurking under every bush. It’s that they are being given access to previously safe spaces for women, making those spaces unsafe. But we digress.

SleepingStandingUp · 06/01/2024 11:17

CurlewKate · 06/01/2024 09:20

Is anyone interested in the issues around parenting the next generation of men?

I'd hope we're all interested in the issues of parenting the next generation of adults.

I wrote a very long answer but it comes down to a think society accepts women on a multitude of formats. The perfect woman can be many things. The perfect man is an impossible balance between someone sufficiently manly to not get abused for being "wet" but not so manly and that he's arrogant. He (obviously) can't be violent but god help him if he couldn't defend his woman. He has to be a good Dad but he can't want to reduce hours and spend more time with his kids cos that's a woman's perogative. If the relationship ends and wants 50/50 he's doing it for financial reasons and of he doesn't want 50/50 he's a shit Dad.

Obviously there are tons of complications with raising girls, who are vastly more at risk of predation from males. Neither job is easy. I only have to do one of them three times tho

Swipe left for the next trending thread