Maths isn’t my strong “suite”? 🤣
If we’re going for ad hominem attacks, then English isn’t yours. It’s “suit” - the saying originates from card games. HTH.
Also maths isnt your strong suit. If I owned 50% how is 50% of the rent not mine ? So how could anyone have paid 75% esp when they kept all the rent for 20 years . Love to see an Einstein like you give 100% of the rent to anyone if you owned a property.
Of course 50% of the rent is theoretically yours. Which means 50% was hers. Theoretically (morally, if you like) not legally - as it was always legally your house.
So on Day 1, you have “paid” 50/50 - her from cash you from mortgage.
The rent is theoretically split 50/50, but she received it all.
You told us that the rent paid off the mortgage after 5 years.
So after 5 years, your 50% loan has been paid off. Half of it by your share of the rent. And half of it by her share of the rent.
Let’s make it easy for you 😉
Say the house cost £100K.
She paid £50K upfront.
You took out a mortgage for £50K.
The rent for 5 years totalled £50K.
£25K or that rent was theoretically yours.
£25K was theoretically hers.
It all paid off the mortgage.
She has now put £75K into the property being owned outright.
You have put £25K.
So she has contributed £75K of the original £100K cost.
Obviously I’ve left out interest, so I don’t hurt your brain 😭
You’ve end up with legal ownership of the entire house, having done nothing but pass a mortgage credit check.
And it actually sounds like you might have done it for a lovely reason - a bank loan that the property rent will pay off so no effort to you, and it helps turn your mum’s £50K into a good regular income. It was a kind thing, and mostly a good idea. And you still benefit: getting control of the entire house and selling for a huge profit when she dies or decides not to manage it for the income. (I’m not considering that forcing a sale was ever an option in a family set up)
What you did wrong, is not think through 25+ years ago what happens if she gets old and unable to manage it properly, but refuses to let go, and your siblings start sticking their beaks in.