Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think my friend is wrong and I would get more time if I wasn’t a single parent?

118 replies

Lasfhwinehour · 05/01/2024 15:03

I don’t know if my friend was trying to make me feel better or something but her comment has really bothered me. I am a single parent to dd, 19 months. I’ve been on my own with her since she was 3 months. I was v fortunate that I had quite a bit of money during maternity leave and could still socialise a lot. Now she is older and I am working, life feels hectic. I feel jealous of people in relationships and think they must have huge amounts of time as the care of their child is divided. My friend is adamant that I have more spare time than her as I can watch what I want in the evenings when dd sleeps, I have my lunch hours to do hair or nails etc and can take a day of annual leave now and then if I want a full day to myself. In comparison she is a stay at home parent and feels like she is constantly caring for dc and when her husband is home, even though he helps with things she is still involved. It’s not a competition I know but I feel so envious of what it must be like to have the father of you child around. It doesn’t feel fair. I know self pity is a horrible trait and I will snap out of it soon but I feel really low right now and not even understood by my closest friend.

OP posts:
tiredmama23 · 05/01/2024 17:15

I genuinely don't get what the obsession is with comparisons with others and the race to have it worse than x or y. Everyone, no matter their life circumstances, has shit in their life to deal with at some point. Why can't it just be that, we're all different but the thing we have in common is, at times life is a big pile of shit for us all, just for different reasons. Can't all struggles be equally valid and coexist without the need for a hierarchy of who has it worse?

Just my thoughts. 🤷‍♀️

Mairzydotes · 05/01/2024 17:15

Not all relationships are good relationships - some people rob their partners of solitude and provide no companionship.

I imagine your friend finds her oh takes up a lot of her time. There is also a bit of the grass always seems greener.

mathanxiety · 05/01/2024 17:13

Agree with @arethereanyleftatall

flea101 · 05/01/2024 17:11

I had a friend like that. Said I had it "easier" as I have a husband. Husband is out at work long hours, son is currently not in school due to unmet needs and won't leave my side so I am never on my own, i don't get a break such as a school day or anything! I pointed out that we have different lives, she is a single parent so different.

Terfosaurus · 05/01/2024 17:10

I don't really think it's helpful to compare tbh.
If you're married with a useless partner you might not get a lot of time to yourself.

If you're a single parent who's ex has the dc regularly then you might get a lot of time to yourself.
But actually most parenting falls between the 2.

My brother is adamant that him and his wife have it 'harder' as married parents of 3 than I did as a single parent of 2. His logic is that my mum used to have my dc a lot, and she doesn't have theirs so often.

If you base it just on that, then yes. I had more "free time".

But he forgets that my mum had my dc so I could work. Any time I was not at work I had them. If I wanted a bath I had to wait until they were asleep, or accept that they might join me. If I was sick and didn't feel up to cooking, tough. I couldn't have a lie in. Even when they did go to their dads (rarely) I was on call because he would bring them home when he felt like it.

Otoh he and his wife work shifts around each other. If they are sick they can share the load. If they want a bath the other one can amuse the dc. He probably wouldn't because he's a prick, but he could. Not to mention that his ILs have their dc most weekends so they can have a "break."

Does that mean I had it 'harder'? No not necessarily. But he certainly seems to have more 'me time' than I ever did.

Shopper727 · 05/01/2024 17:07

She’s made a choice, she too could go out to work….
take lunch for hair and nails and a day off to spend to herself. She’s chosen to stay at home. She needs to not compare herself to you. She has 2 incomes and a partner who sounds a bit like he could do more.

being a single parent - am one of 4 so know what it’s like is tough now mine are older I have much more freedom but it’s been a slog and that’s with an involved dad. Your little one is very young and it’s a lot to do whilst working full time everything on your shoulders.

BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 05/01/2024 17:07

If we want to play to trumps I'm a single parent whose child doesn't see the other parent. Think it took till she was 10 before I got a night away from her. But you know what I have good support and back up. I've a supportive family who would have helped if I needed and knowing they have my back meant I didn't need it.

It isn't always about having me time its about knowing someone has your back, a decent partner would have your back but if they don't that can be even more demoralising than not having a partner. That worry about being the only responsible person is a big issue. I have a major safety net in my family and I know no matter what they'd be there for me or my dd. I can't express how much peace of mind comes from that.

mathanxiety · 05/01/2024 17:05

pickledandpuzzled · 05/01/2024 16:42

Pandering to a partner can be just as demanding as having an extra child. When DH was away with work life was easier. When he was there I had to bear him in mind, plan around him.
When he’s away I was boss.

YYY to this.

Be careful what you wish for, OP.

A man can be a complete nuisance.

arethereanyleftatall · 05/01/2024 17:04

This isn't a partner vs no partner debate.

It's a shit partner vs no partner debate.

And, having been both sides, I'd advise any woman, if they logistically/financially can, to take the no partner option every single time.

Singleandproud · 05/01/2024 17:02

As a single parent of one child I found that whilst the early years were very full on I had a lot of time to myself once DD got older and became more independent. I can sit and watch what I want, read a book, go for a run or whatever else I want without taking anyone else into consideration. DD is in her mid teens - has plans with her friends tomorrow so other than dropping her off in the morning I am free all day to do as I please.

Now I'm sure there probably are benefits of being in a couple - I've been single since I was 23 and found out I was having DD so I wouldn't know what they were really but I'm sure they would not outweigh the benefits I now have of being single. I feel like the best of both worlds, I got to experience parenthood and raise a fantastic child and get to do as I please. The only downside is D is less willing to tag along to the things I want to do so a companion would be handy but I don't mind doing things alone.

carrotsnparsnips · 05/01/2024 17:01

@SleepingStandingUp 2 kids, their sleep is screwed so they’re up and down all night. it’s not a partner problem we’re both in the same boat and both get no free time. i get it - if i went out he’d be left with 2 screaming kids waking eachother up. i ask the same of him to not go out if he can avoid it.

Kwasi · 05/01/2024 16:55

I was a SAHM for 3 years. I had to do everything for him and DH. DH has never mucked in and his only input is criticism. It is thoroughly exhausting.

DS is 5 now. I work 4 days a week and have so much more energy because being out of the messy house is good for my mental health.

When DH goes away for work, my house is so much tidier, DS is much better behaved and I get to chill on the sofa in the evening and watch my TV. I would love for it to just be me and DS but it's not financially possible for another couple of years.

SleepingStandingUp · 05/01/2024 16:48

carrotsnparsnips · 05/01/2024 16:09

yabu. i’m a married sahm and i get zero me time. even when the kids are in bed if i want to go off and do something for myself i feel guilt tripped for not spending the little childfree time dh and i have together. it’s not a competition but having a partner doesn’t mean you get loads of help. i think it looks so much calmer being a single mum sometimes, don’t have to worry about anyone other than yourself and your kid.

Sorry but that sounds like a partner problem.

How many kids do you have? What time is the last one down for sleep? If he doesn't let you go out after bedtime without guilt tripping you, what about weekends / none work days?

Spendonsend · 05/01/2024 16:46

Being a mum is hard work and the thing that makes it easier is the right type of support at the right time. Some single parents have good support and some dont. Some sahm have good support and some dont.

SleepingStandingUp · 05/01/2024 16:43

It an unfair comparison.
She could get a job and then get her nails done in her lunch break. She could book a day of whilst the kids are in nursery. The issue is there's O'Day's off when you're a SAHP.

It sounds like her DH isn't very helpful and she feels quite constrained in the marriage so your "you time" which is their couple time feels amazing to get mind. The fact you couldn't do anything until you got DD to sleep whereas she could go out and leave DH to do it etc seems to have missed her.

I'm a SAHP to three. I have different pressures to working parents but I do have more independence that you do because I can leave them with their Dad. A single person with 50/50 custody would arguably have more free time than me but less freedom unless their ex is very flexible. A single parent who has the kids one weekend a fortnight obviously has the most

pickledandpuzzled · 05/01/2024 16:42

Pandering to a partner can be just as demanding as having an extra child. When DH was away with work life was easier. When he was there I had to bear him in mind, plan around him.
When he’s away I was boss.

TheQueenMakersDaughter · 05/01/2024 16:39

I have more free time now that (1) my dc are older and (2) I've split from their father and they visit EOW.

The two of you have very different lives but if she's as miserable as she sounds, she could choose option 2 while you wait it out and naturally arrive at option 1.

But you do need to carve out some time for yourself somehow. It doesn't need to be huge, just an extra 10 minutes in the car, sitting in the quiet, before collecting your child from nursery might help. You're already going to bed quite early, can you wake up 10 minutes earlier and read with a coffee?

It's tough, I know, but you need to make time for yourself. It's vital.

carrotsnparsnips · 05/01/2024 16:39

JadziaD · 05/01/2024 16:12

That's not because you're a married SAHM. it's because you apparently have a a wanker of a partner who doesn't seem to understand that you have the right to time to yourself.

bit weird calling a strangers husband a wanker when you don’t even know him. neither of us get time to ourself, guess i’m a wanker too.

Bemyclementine · 05/01/2024 16:31

Really depends on what the father of the child is like. Mine did sod all. Since we split up, he has the dc one day a week. 1 day that I get entirely to myself. Farmoretime than when we were together.

BetterWithPockets · 05/01/2024 16:28

Agree it’s not a competition, OP, but can say that when my DH was away for work (used to be at least a week a month, often two), I found parenting so much more tiring. It makes sense — in most relationships — that when there’s two of you, even if you don’t share the load 50:50, it’s easier than when everything is down to one person. Obviously there are always exceptions — but the thing is, none of us really know what it’s like to be in another person’s shoes. What would you like from your friend, OP? And would it really help if she agreed you had it harder? (Not trying to be provocative — just trying to understand.)

shieldmaiden7 · 05/01/2024 16:20

I've had both sides, single parent for 5 years now remarried with more children with my DH.
I had more time when I was single because my ex had the kids 3 days a week, I could watch what I wanted in the evenings, cook what I wanted, had a sneaky takeaway as I please, life was less hectic. But very lonely at times.
Now life is manic even though my older lot are teenagers, very independent with busy social lives - we live central so I'm not driving them everywhere., their dad now has them 3 hours a month so I don't have my quiet evenings unless preplanned we take it in turns to watch things or game, we take it in turns to cook. My youngest is 13 weeks old tomorrow. My husband does a lot to help with baby. Our toddler and my older children but I still didn't get to shower until 11.30 last night and did a quick hoover at 1am. I wouldn't change it for the world, I love my life but I definitely have less time now.

Jollyoldfruit · 05/01/2024 16:16

Your friend. is wrong imo.
Mum's like me, your friend and @carrotsnparsnips have no idea of the extra stress you have.
I have never been a single parent but of course its got to be harder when every decision, every crisis is yours alone.

People on here saying don't compare. It's your friend that shouldn't compare, she's very fortunate.

JadziaD · 05/01/2024 16:12

carrotsnparsnips · 05/01/2024 16:09

yabu. i’m a married sahm and i get zero me time. even when the kids are in bed if i want to go off and do something for myself i feel guilt tripped for not spending the little childfree time dh and i have together. it’s not a competition but having a partner doesn’t mean you get loads of help. i think it looks so much calmer being a single mum sometimes, don’t have to worry about anyone other than yourself and your kid.

That's not because you're a married SAHM. it's because you apparently have a a wanker of a partner who doesn't seem to understand that you have the right to time to yourself.

JadziaD · 05/01/2024 16:10

I am not a fan of comparison but her comparison does seem weird - if anything, she's comparing her life of a life of any working mother. You don't get a lunch break because you're a single mother, you get one because you work and, I assume, have childcare in place for while you're at work, including over lunch?

It actually sounds to me like she's struggling. And I wonder if she's in that classic trap of being a SAHM who's DH thinks that means he doesn't ever have to do the chores or childcare or whatever as that's her job with no consideration that no one should be working 24/7 and/or with no ability to sit down of an evening without either having to entertain him or deal with other child-related/home-related issues.

If it was me, I think I'd be gently raising it with her. eg, "I was a bit worried about what you said comparing our lifestyles the other day - just because you're a SAHM doesn't mean you shouldn't be getting some time out. Frankly, I find parenting completely relentless and miss having a partner to share the load with or spend time with or support me so I'm sure you can see why that's hard for me, but it's obvious things are really hard for you too."

carrotsnparsnips · 05/01/2024 16:09

yabu. i’m a married sahm and i get zero me time. even when the kids are in bed if i want to go off and do something for myself i feel guilt tripped for not spending the little childfree time dh and i have together. it’s not a competition but having a partner doesn’t mean you get loads of help. i think it looks so much calmer being a single mum sometimes, don’t have to worry about anyone other than yourself and your kid.