Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think my friend is wrong and I would get more time if I wasn’t a single parent?

118 replies

Lasfhwinehour · 05/01/2024 15:03

I don’t know if my friend was trying to make me feel better or something but her comment has really bothered me. I am a single parent to dd, 19 months. I’ve been on my own with her since she was 3 months. I was v fortunate that I had quite a bit of money during maternity leave and could still socialise a lot. Now she is older and I am working, life feels hectic. I feel jealous of people in relationships and think they must have huge amounts of time as the care of their child is divided. My friend is adamant that I have more spare time than her as I can watch what I want in the evenings when dd sleeps, I have my lunch hours to do hair or nails etc and can take a day of annual leave now and then if I want a full day to myself. In comparison she is a stay at home parent and feels like she is constantly caring for dc and when her husband is home, even though he helps with things she is still involved. It’s not a competition I know but I feel so envious of what it must be like to have the father of you child around. It doesn’t feel fair. I know self pity is a horrible trait and I will snap out of it soon but I feel really low right now and not even understood by my closest friend.

OP posts:
Thatswhy11 · 05/01/2024 18:46

Does your ex pay CMS OP? You are a single parent and your friend isn't end of. You will have to outsource what you can it's tough really tough!

Would your ex do more? Once a month th is absolutely dire! Could you go down a court route to establish more contact?

Riverlee · 05/01/2024 18:41

As others have said, your are comparing different aspects of your lives,

Friend is envious of your child-free time such as lunch hours etc, plus not having to comply with person’s needs, ie husband. She probably feels that it’s all a bit relentless and she doesn’t have any ‘me time’. We don’t know how much input, if any, her dh dies.

However, you’re envious that there are two people carrying the load, has someone else bringing in money, helping to make decesions etc. You feel you’re always on the go and always responsible.

Different situations with different pressures.

Willyoujustbequiet · 05/01/2024 18:38

JemimaTiggywinkles · 05/01/2024 18:32

willyoujustbequiet you are being incredibly superior and you clearly have no idea how other people live. I don't have kids so no opinion on which is "harder" but some things can't be properly compared. So people don't find being a single parent that hard and others would rather be in a shitty relationship. There isn't always an objectively worse. Especially when you don't know the full back story of any poster's lives.

I didn't say single parent, I said lone parent of dc with additional needs. It's a 24/7 relentless soul destroying life and can't possibly be compared with a couple who can tag team so at least someone can sleep at some point, never mind the added income.

I did say abusive relationship aside. Or of course things like terminal illness.

Not acknowledging the burden of disabilities is ableist. Its absolutely not comparable.

MintJulia · 05/01/2024 18:35

I'm a single mum and I have far more time to myself, now I'm single.

I make simpler food, can keep the house cleaner and tidier, and waste much less time now ex is no longer around. But he was never a hands-on dad.

It depends on individual lifestyles and how much a partner helps.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 05/01/2024 18:32

willyoujustbequiet you are being incredibly superior and you clearly have no idea how other people live. I don't have kids so no opinion on which is "harder" but some things can't be properly compared. So people don't find being a single parent that hard and others would rather be in a shitty relationship. There isn't always an objectively worse. Especially when you don't know the full back story of any poster's lives.

Newyeareve · 05/01/2024 18:31

Kwasi · 05/01/2024 18:05

I recently tried to leave but simply can't afford it. I am gaining a good qualification, though, and should be in a position to leave in a year or two.

So sorry to hear this, hope you manage to get out soon. How to cope financially is one the problems for lone/single parents, they don’t generally have a choice and just have to make it work somehow.
Co parenting situations, where access is shared and maintenance is being paid, are obviously very different as well.
Abusive relationships are also very very different.

Willyoujustbequiet · 05/01/2024 18:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I'm not playing a victim. I'm stating a fact

You tried to compare yourself to a widow with 4 children with special needs when you're married and your husband works.

I'm so embarrassed for you. Literally cringing. Please don't engage further

flea101 · 05/01/2024 18:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Menomeno · 05/01/2024 18:17

I had more free time when I was a single parent (EOW). When we were together I did 100% of the childcare but never ever got a day off.

Willyoujustbequiet · 05/01/2024 18:17

flea101 · 05/01/2024 18:06

@Willyoujustbequiet excuse me? I don't see why it is in any way a competition, everyone has their own stuff going on. But buy saying that automatically single parents have it harder is insulting and extremely naive! It isn't worse or better, it is different but if you want to play that card of my life is worse go ahead, just sad for u

My life is harder as a lone parent of dc with additional needs than someone who is married (abusive marriage or terminal illness aside)

I used to think like you. Then the penny dropped. Trust me you are the one who is naive.

Asifiwouldnt · 05/01/2024 18:14

I have never been a lone parent but I can’t imagine it isn’t anything other than much harder and that is even more so when the non resident parent isn’t very involved.

My DH worked long days but I still had another adult I could ask to watch the kids in the evening/weekend even if only long enough for me to walk the dog or pop to the shop. If the kids were sick and up in the night there was another adult to care for them so I could catch some sleep the next day.

It’s just not comparable I would imagine unless maybe 50:50 childcare but even then the times they are with you you wouldn’t have any back up.

Willyoujustbequiet · 05/01/2024 18:14

Newyeareve · 05/01/2024 17:55

Sorry, I really didn’t mean to insult you. Does your partner provide financially? My point is you have a partner to hopefully in some way share some of the load be it mental or financial. I didn’t assume that you could work, I was just trying to say imagine this situation with also being totally on your own and trying to cope financially. This was my reality.
To answer your question ,yes, I have 4 children, 2 with SN. Lone parent due to being widowed.

Edited

Unless they have walked in your shoes they can't possibly understand how difficult it is to be a lone parent (mine have additional needs too).

I had no idea when I was married even though my dh worked away a lot. I really thought I had it hard. I'm honestly embarrassed looking back how clueless I was. It's a whole other level.

I have no idea how you juggle 4 bless you.

Marrongrass · 05/01/2024 18:12

LenaLamont · 05/01/2024 15:21

It's apples and oranges.

She gets not a second to herself with children all day every day, so a lunch hour away from children sounds like a luxury.

You have no one to share the load with in the evenings and weekends and the support of another person.

Both ways of life have their challenges. It's hard to see the disadvantages from the outside.

The difference is that she's not working, so doesn't have a lunch break or adult-time, which is very hard, but (depending on her circumstances, if she can work) this sounds like she could change the situation by working or finding part time childcare, whereas you can't easily find an adult to share evening childcare with.

Both have their own difficulties, but I think the stay at home parent is sometimes (not always) a choice (being a single parent is sometimes too, but rarely except as a last resort) and can change faster, e.g. when nursery free hours or school begin, if the children are able to go.

5128gap · 05/01/2024 18:11

A single parent working full time with a coparent who has the children for regular weekly contact has the most time to themselves. A SAHP with a spouse who believes that because they are the only person working they don't need to do anything else, has the least. Most people are somewhere in between.

flea101 · 05/01/2024 18:06

@Willyoujustbequiet excuse me? I don't see why it is in any way a competition, everyone has their own stuff going on. But buy saying that automatically single parents have it harder is insulting and extremely naive! It isn't worse or better, it is different but if you want to play that card of my life is worse go ahead, just sad for u

Kwasi · 05/01/2024 18:05

arethereanyleftatall · 05/01/2024 17:04

This isn't a partner vs no partner debate.

It's a shit partner vs no partner debate.

And, having been both sides, I'd advise any woman, if they logistically/financially can, to take the no partner option every single time.

I recently tried to leave but simply can't afford it. I am gaining a good qualification, though, and should be in a position to leave in a year or two.

Willyoujustbequiet · 05/01/2024 18:01

flea101 · 05/01/2024 17:41

@Newyeareve so because I am married that makes my life instantly better? My point is it is different situations- u don't have it "worse" because you are a single parent! Do your children have sn? Go to school? What makes u assume I can work? I can't because of our situation. Husband is out of the house from 5am-7pm and then is on call nights and weekends, so it falls to me! I'm not saying my life is worse, it is just different from yours but your insinuation is insulting

No it's not. Its insulting and incredibly naive to think it's comparable.

Newyeareve · 05/01/2024 17:55

flea101 · 05/01/2024 17:41

@Newyeareve so because I am married that makes my life instantly better? My point is it is different situations- u don't have it "worse" because you are a single parent! Do your children have sn? Go to school? What makes u assume I can work? I can't because of our situation. Husband is out of the house from 5am-7pm and then is on call nights and weekends, so it falls to me! I'm not saying my life is worse, it is just different from yours but your insinuation is insulting

Sorry, I really didn’t mean to insult you. Does your partner provide financially? My point is you have a partner to hopefully in some way share some of the load be it mental or financial. I didn’t assume that you could work, I was just trying to say imagine this situation with also being totally on your own and trying to cope financially. This was my reality.
To answer your question ,yes, I have 4 children, 2 with SN. Lone parent due to being widowed.

flea101 · 05/01/2024 17:41

@Newyeareve so because I am married that makes my life instantly better? My point is it is different situations- u don't have it "worse" because you are a single parent! Do your children have sn? Go to school? What makes u assume I can work? I can't because of our situation. Husband is out of the house from 5am-7pm and then is on call nights and weekends, so it falls to me! I'm not saying my life is worse, it is just different from yours but your insinuation is insulting

Willyoujustbequiet · 05/01/2024 17:38

Your friend is an idiot and quite frankly so is anyone in a couple that thinks it's comparable to being a lone parent.

Newyeareve · 05/01/2024 17:34

flea101 · 05/01/2024 17:11

I had a friend like that. Said I had it "easier" as I have a husband. Husband is out at work long hours, son is currently not in school due to unmet needs and won't leave my side so I am never on my own, i don't get a break such as a school day or anything! I pointed out that we have different lives, she is a single parent so different.

sorry to hear that you have this difficult situation but you have a partner who is providing financially and hopefully supporting you by sharing the mental load of being a parent. Imagine doing this as a lone parent and also not being able to work due to your child’s needs and worrying how you as a sole parent you are going to cope financially. This was my reality for a long time. It is best never to compare 2 parent families with lone/single parents, imo there is no comparison.

JadziaD · 05/01/2024 17:31

carrotsnparsnips · 05/01/2024 16:39

bit weird calling a strangers husband a wanker when you don’t even know him. neither of us get time to ourself, guess i’m a wanker too.

As a rule, if one partner is "guilt tripping" the other one, I consider that person to be a on the wanker-end of the scale. Guilt tripping is a pretty controlling tactic.

If you're happy, great, but if he's working away from home I bet he gets all that time that OP's friend is jealous of - time to do his own thing at lunch, or commuting time, or just time to go to the toilet alone while you, by the sounds of things, are not.

user159 · 05/01/2024 17:23

Depends totally on the relationships here.

My exh was incredibly hands off when we were married and I worked nearly full time and looked after our child, think all bedtimes and all mornings - he has a hobby which takes up one day of the weekend too.

Since we've split he is actually spending time with our child and I have time to myself to rest, do what I want, focus on my career - I have a busy job so in some ways this set up is working. I will forever be sad our child isn't with me everyday but this is better than the alternative for them, they are certainly happier and thriving.

Rudolphtherednoseddog · 05/01/2024 17:23

I’m a happily married SAHM and yes, it has its stresses when they’re little (though it’s great now they’re at school!) but it’s a choice.

I’d suggest not comparing, but if she insists on comparison I’d point out she could always go back to work and even split with her partner if that’s really what she prefers. She has choices that you probably don’t.

Newyeareve · 05/01/2024 17:19

I hate this, when someone who has a partner will try and compare their lot to a single parent. There is no comparison and it’s infuriating when people try to do this. I am a lone parent (widow) and understand completely the challenges of being on your own, having sole responsibility for everything to do with your child as well as sole financial responsibility. It can’t be underestimated, when I was ill, my children were ill or had issues and I had to go into school there was no one to help or provide support. Let alone the financial side of things. It’s tough, I would just ignore your friend. Even if her partner is working a lot, he is probably providing some sort of support be it financial or just being there to talk over the issues the children are having. The exception of course is abusive relationships.