Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Please help me help dd (17) with friendships, I am unintentionally making things worse…

114 replies

Watermelon234 · 05/01/2024 10:51

I am at my wits end with worry about her. I was trying to help, but in worry and frustration have ended up telling her that I think her friend is toxic and I don’t think that has helped.

She is a very social person, loves going out and meeting friends. When she is doing this she is happy, bubbly and confident.

The problem is she doesn’t have a close/reliable group of friends to do this with, so socialising is very sporadic and has been worse over he past few months. Because of this her mood changes beyond recognition and she becomes very low and mopey.

She only gets to go out or meet friends if she is invited, doesn’t have a close friend to call on, even to hang out with in houses. She has tried to instigate meet ups but people are generally busy with others so decline. She doesn’t like to ask if she can join in.

This has been an ongoing problem over the years. She makes friends easily, has numerous acquaintances, but everyone of them seem to have closer friends that they do things with. She’s never really had that and I don’t know how to help her. It was fine when she was younger because we met up in groups, instigated by us parents, and the kids joined in but friendships have evolved without my dd.

The toxic friend is a girl my dd sees at college and they share a hobby. My dd sees her as a close friend. Unfortunately, it has become apparent to me that this friend is actually turning other friends against my dd. I have been a bit suspicious of this for a while, so have been watching from the sidelines while they do their hobby, as I didn’t get a good vibe from her at all. The friend has been very active socially over Christmas, and has invited some of my dd’s other friends from a different friend group out with her friend group, but my dd was not included. My dd has gone very quiet, withdrawn and subdued since she heard this. I am fuming, as she doesn’t need this at all at the moment with A levels looming. In my frustration and anger at my dd making excuses for her friend and accepting it as all part of life, I ranted that her friend was toxic.

Today I feel guilty about being angry and not being supportive, but I am so worried she will end up back where she was a few years ago, in a low place with no social options at all. The worry is eating me up. The problem is , because she is mopey, that is not exactly enticing to others, and the invites dry up. The past couple of years have been great in comparison, so I really need to get this right.

please help with any advice.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JMSA · 05/01/2024 18:51

Mikimoto · 05/01/2024 12:32

The others are probably saying "It's easier just to not invite the girl with the creepy stalky mother".

You're completely out of order.

OP, just ignore this person with the strange and negative mindset.

Evaka · 05/01/2024 18:23

YourDiscoNeedsYou · 05/01/2024 11:44

Sounds so similar to my child, though he is a couple of years younger. I was very worried about him a few years ago. He also had a toxic friend like your daughter’s.

After a few years of agonising, overstepping, really trying hard to solve his friendship problems, I read a book - it was called Hold on to your kids - that made me realise it wasn’t in my control. My child’s friendships, and the behaviour of other children, are not in my control, and neither should they be. The only thing I can control is my own relationship with my children, and the book made me realise that this was where I should put the effort in. Instead of pushing for her to ask her friends out, ask her out with you. Having a strong relationship at home will make any problems with friendships less impactful and ultimately give your child more confidence in relationships.

I’m sure the book isn’t for everyone, but that message was helpful for me (and I don’t think that was the main message of the book). If I look after my own relationships with my kids, it benefits their other relationships outside the house.

This is such a helpful and kind post. Great advice.

alltootired · 05/01/2024 18:08

If you felt brave enough. I would start to model opening up a bit and showing more of your true self. And explain to her why you are doing it.
And then leave her, she may not be ready to make this move herself yet, but you will be giving her some of the tools to use when she is ready.

alcohole · 05/01/2024 17:57

okay maybe leave her to find her own rhythm with friends and back away a tad. In the meantime focus on being friends with her eg take her to the cinema, spa, concert or dinner etc something to fill her social life up a little bit. It gives her something to talk about to her peers then too and builds her confidence

Watermelon234 · 05/01/2024 17:41

alcohole · 05/01/2024 17:02

I think maybe you’re rubbing your own experiences off on her if that makes sense. She’s modelling your own friendships. The language you use about friendships seems to focus on being nice and not saying a bad word etc

if you think about male friendships, they’re not always perfectly nice to each other - they might take the mick at the times, they might be super competitive eg sports, they might say a few choice words about other people etc - but simultaneously they are there for each other when needed. female friendships work exactly the same, there’s no need to be perfectly nice, you just let people get to know the real you without feeling like you need to put a front on in fear of causing offence. It’s okay to annoy each other. Maybe that’s why it’s difficult for you to leave the acquaintance zone and make close friendships?

some of my friends when I were 17 just felt like an extension of me, we spoke about anything and shared everything on our minds. If someone pissed my friend off, we probably did have a gossip session or a “you don’t need him” pep talk - it’s okay to say a “bad word” about someone or something that frustrates you. Equally we would check each other and put each other in our places if we were doing something silly, like if we over or under reacted to something. Because we were that comfortable with each other, it then came naturally to go to cinema or walks locally etc

Yes that makes sense, and you’re right I am exactly like this

OP posts:
Rachie1973 · 05/01/2024 17:41

Watermelon234 · 05/01/2024 11:03

I’ll happily stay out of it like I do with my other dcs who do not have any struggles in this area, but surely if your dc is unhappy it is your role as a parent to try and support them?

She does try very hard to instigate things, and sometimes this works ok, but other times it doesn’t. Surely you can understand that if she is trying to organise a meet up and people are busy, or have other priorities then it’s not that straightforward?

Being supportive doesn’t mean micromanaging her friendships.

it involves supporting her when she’s hurt or upset.

Levave her be, she’ll find her people in time.

Watermelon234 · 05/01/2024 17:37

alltootired · 05/01/2024 17:03

@Watermelon234 being a bit vanilla in response to difficulties is a common approach. But it mean she will not make close friends. Trust to show who you are is essential to making friends. That means rejection as well.

It makes sense she would be invited to big parties for example because she is nice and people think she is friendly and nice. But if she shows nothing of herself, there is nothing there to move beyond acquaintance level to close friends.

I think you are right and maybe this could be part of the problem

OP posts:
FourLeggedBuckers · 05/01/2024 17:26

I think, given some of your updates, I’d focus on trying to build her confidence sharing opinions, making jokes and generally letting her personality out, while building her resilience and the fact that it doesn’t matter if some people don’t like her because of that - those just aren’t her people.

Being nice is all well and good in moderation, but people don’t trust someone who seems “too nice” - they’re often seen as two-faced (even if she isnt, people may suspect she is), or if not, a bit over-eager, or dull or… many things she probably isn’t beneath the “nice” veneer.

Nice can be the enemy of fun, and friendships start with finding people good fun.

Watermelon234 · 05/01/2024 17:19

ActDottie · 05/01/2024 16:48

This my parents were definitely not involved in my friendships at 17.

That may be the case, and to be fair I would rather do the same (in fact I’m not really involved in them at all), but surely you realise that not everyone is the same and that some people require more support and guidance than others with friendships just like some need more support with schoolwork or finances etc?

I’m not fully sure if you’re trying to be helpful or goady with your post? Most people have been helpful, even if they don’t agree with my point of view or the actions I have taken. Does it make you feel good to be like this?

OP posts:
alltootired · 05/01/2024 17:03

@Watermelon234 being a bit vanilla in response to difficulties is a common approach. But it mean she will not make close friends. Trust to show who you are is essential to making friends. That means rejection as well.

It makes sense she would be invited to big parties for example because she is nice and people think she is friendly and nice. But if she shows nothing of herself, there is nothing there to move beyond acquaintance level to close friends.

alcohole · 05/01/2024 17:02

I think maybe you’re rubbing your own experiences off on her if that makes sense. She’s modelling your own friendships. The language you use about friendships seems to focus on being nice and not saying a bad word etc

if you think about male friendships, they’re not always perfectly nice to each other - they might take the mick at the times, they might be super competitive eg sports, they might say a few choice words about other people etc - but simultaneously they are there for each other when needed. female friendships work exactly the same, there’s no need to be perfectly nice, you just let people get to know the real you without feeling like you need to put a front on in fear of causing offence. It’s okay to annoy each other. Maybe that’s why it’s difficult for you to leave the acquaintance zone and make close friendships?

some of my friends when I were 17 just felt like an extension of me, we spoke about anything and shared everything on our minds. If someone pissed my friend off, we probably did have a gossip session or a “you don’t need him” pep talk - it’s okay to say a “bad word” about someone or something that frustrates you. Equally we would check each other and put each other in our places if we were doing something silly, like if we over or under reacted to something. Because we were that comfortable with each other, it then came naturally to go to cinema or walks locally etc

Watermelon234 · 05/01/2024 16:57

alcohole · 05/01/2024 12:54

Probably because she’s actively mixing different friend groups which both include my dd, but excluding my dd.

Ask your daughter why none of the other people are including her. You feel like 1 person is not involving your daughter, the reality is several people aren’t involving your daughter. Why does it all rest on this one person to invite her, do the others not want her there? Why happens when your daughter invites the others - do they decline? 17 year olds do everything together including quick and easy things like a walk or long FaceTime calls. You’re saying none of the others in the friend groups do these things with her, but that’s all the fault of this one person? It doesn’t add up.

Edited

I think they possibly just accept any social invitation and don’t think too much about who is going, possibly don’t even know who is going until they get there.

Sometimes they meet up when she instigates something, sometimes they don’t. She does have a social life and has been to quite a few parties etc this year, but usually as part of big groups or with the friends from the hobby. This was/is the main source of the socialising, but dynamics have changed a bit now some have turned 18 and are able to go out out and others (my dd included) haven’t. So her options have reduced a bit now.

OP posts:
SooticaTheWitchesCat · 05/01/2024 16:54

My daughter went through a similar thing when she was about the same age. Girl groups can be very toxic and she often felt left out. In the end she decided she had enough and found one friend who she would see only, who was actually nice.
Two years later she is best friends with this girl and very happy.
She still occasionally sees a few of the old group but only one on one.
Hopefully your daughter will find one good friend and then she wont' need to mix with the ones who leave her out.
It's a hard time being a teenager sometimes and we just have to be there for them when they ask for help.

ActDottie · 05/01/2024 16:48

araiwa · 05/01/2024 10:58

Jeebus, stay out if it

This my parents were definitely not involved in my friendships at 17.

Watermelon234 · 05/01/2024 16:43

alltootired · 05/01/2024 16:33

@Watermelon234 I used to struggle with this as well, my DP taught me. I wondered if you had the same issue, as we do learn friendship skills from our parents without even realising.
It might help your DD to post on an internet forum anonymously about friendship skills to create deeper bonds.
It is not too late to learn these skills for either of you, but she may benefit from some advice.

So my tips would be when inviting people do not make it a big thing at first. Just start with do you want to face time, or play an online game, go for a coffee after a lecture, something low key. You have to start small and make it one person or two at first.

You have to show your personality. You keep describing your DD as friendly, nice, never a bad word to say about anyone. But this is not enough to be a close friend. Is she fun? Witty? Interesting?

Don't assign roles like toxic or manipulative to someone without very very good evidence. These are all teenagers trying to find their way and having too high expectations is a highway to not being able to make friends. Your DD is not perfect and neither are these other teenagers.

I think you’re right about learning friendship skills, I wish there was an easy way to do it.

She is as I describe her. I think, to be honest, she has learnt to be a bit vanilla. She may have learnt it from me or may have worked it out for herself. Non confrontational and a bit safe/ not fully giving opinions, a bit on the fence.

I think if you have a bit of previous trauma around friendships, you possibly don’t want to put people off by having strong opinions, being controversial etc so stay safe, which could possibly seem a bit unusual?

OP posts:
Watermelon234 · 05/01/2024 16:36

waterrat · 05/01/2024 13:38

Hi op..is it possible your daughter is neurodiverse? You seem to describe an issue that has always been there for her of not quite understanding social rules and holding back because of this understanding (ie. Not saying oh can I join when there is a group activity)

I think if social issues have been a longstanding problem it may be she lacks some of the nuanced understanding of how to enter groups and how to cement friendships

I sympathisr as my daughter is autistic and struggles with friends

Maybe, there is definitely a struggle with social rules I think which is becoming more apparent with age. I’ve never really thought much about it because she’s generally great with general communication, she has a job she enjoys in a cafe and enjoys the interactions. School hasn’t been a problem, except for a tendency to put off revision or do the minimum to get by. But she still gets good grades. It’s just socially where something feels a bit off.

OP posts:
alltootired · 05/01/2024 16:33

@Watermelon234 I used to struggle with this as well, my DP taught me. I wondered if you had the same issue, as we do learn friendship skills from our parents without even realising.
It might help your DD to post on an internet forum anonymously about friendship skills to create deeper bonds.
It is not too late to learn these skills for either of you, but she may benefit from some advice.

So my tips would be when inviting people do not make it a big thing at first. Just start with do you want to face time, or play an online game, go for a coffee after a lecture, something low key. You have to start small and make it one person or two at first.

You have to show your personality. You keep describing your DD as friendly, nice, never a bad word to say about anyone. But this is not enough to be a close friend. Is she fun? Witty? Interesting?

Don't assign roles like toxic or manipulative to someone without very very good evidence. These are all teenagers trying to find their way and having too high expectations is a highway to not being able to make friends. Your DD is not perfect and neither are these other teenagers.

Watermelon234 · 05/01/2024 16:26

alltootired · 05/01/2024 12:25

@Watermelon234 support is listening, involvement is telling her what she should think and do about her friendships.

Friendship skills involve how to move from acquaintances to friends. It sounds like your DD may not have these skills.

And it is normal for people who are closer friends to socialise and not always invite acquaintances.

Yes you’re right, so is there a way to develop them? It seems not everyone has these skills and some may need a bit of help. Maybe I do too!

OP posts:
Watermelon234 · 05/01/2024 16:24

Mikimoto · 05/01/2024 12:32

The others are probably saying "It's easier just to not invite the girl with the creepy stalky mother".

Hmm you sound like a nice person

OP posts:
Watermelon234 · 05/01/2024 16:14

alltootired · 05/01/2024 12:13

It sounds like your DDs friendship skills could do with being developed, as you say she has never had a close friend.
I think you need to step back, but the best way of teaching about friendship is modelling good friend relationships yourself. Do you have friends that you regularly see?

Yes, I do have a lot of friends, a couple who are fairly close but quite a few long standing ones and lots of acquaintances. I do struggle a bit with developing really close bonds with people though.

How do they learn to develop close friendships though, it seems quite a hard skill for some people and doesn’t come naturally.

OP posts:
Watermelon234 · 05/01/2024 16:10

JMSA · 05/01/2024 12:12

A counsellor I saw years ago told me an interesting story. A teenage girl suddenly developed school-based anxiety. Until then, she had been happy and achieving at school. Her mum couldn't understand it. Turns out the mum had gone through very similar at her daughter's exact age. As her daughter approached the same age, the mum - without realising - passed her anxiety on to her daughter.
OP, you sound like a wonderful and caring mum. But you must be careful not to do the above. All you can do is be there to listen and support.

Yes this is a possibility, without going into too much detail, I did not have a good experience in the few months leading up to my a levels so am probably subconsciously a bit over sensitive .

OP posts:
Watermelon234 · 05/01/2024 16:05

FourLeggedBuckers · 05/01/2024 12:07

By telling her that the girl she perceives as a friend is toxic, you’re not supporting her, you’re projecting your understanding of the situation into her and burdening her with the parental pressure that she is being judged, either for not being socially successful enough or not being able to see the “toxicity” of her friend.

That won’t help her learn how to navigate friendships, but it will isolate her and make her more self-conscious. This is why you need to step back - not because you don’t care, or because you won’t be there to support her, without judgement when things go badly - but to give her the opportunity to learn how to deal with these situations by herself.

She may come to agree with you about her friend, or she may see things differently- and she may ultimately be better at managing friendships / interpreting social behaviour than you are, because she’s coming from her own perspective. Or she may not. But you need to give her the opportunity to learn for herself, and, even to fail, and learn from her mistakes. As hard as that is for you to watch.

Yes you are right, you have described exactly my thought process since yesterday and why I felt I haven’t helped things despite wanting to be supportive.

OP posts:
Watermelon234 · 05/01/2024 15:34

alcohole · 05/01/2024 12:01

you are way too invested in this.

im in my 20s and from my life, and from
observing eg people who were close at school - some friendships last forever, but the majority end up as acquaintances. That’s okay! There’s people I didn’t speak to much when I was 17 but we ended up getting closer as had a similar career path or interests as time went on.

when you’re 17, most of your friendships are just based on who’s local to you or who goes to your school or college - it’s not really about how similar you are, it’s just about convenience. And when you’re not seeing each other every day, you realise that this friend wasn’t the best match for you

Whereas when people start to go to university or work, their social circle naturally widens and they meet lots of people who accept them for who they are etc. it just seems like your daughter hasn’t found her people yet, but equally that will come naturally so why force it?

I think you’re right about convenience. I have had lots of friendships which worked well at certain times of my life when we had things in common and petered out or lessened later on.

I think the main issue here is not having anyone local to call on or hang out with or anyone to meet for a drink or go to the cinema with etc.

OP posts:
RichardsGear · 05/01/2024 15:29

Mikimoto · 05/01/2024 12:32

The others are probably saying "It's easier just to not invite the girl with the creepy stalky mother".

For fuck's sake don't be so fucking ridiculous.

OP I get it. And believe me for every ten struggling teens who eventually flourish and find 'their tribe' and all that shit there is one who ends up with serious difficulties. It doesn't always work out naturally and I don't blame you for wanting to help her.

Watermelon234 · 05/01/2024 15:26

DesuOwl · 05/01/2024 12:00

Hmm. Just thinking, if DD seems to often be the one being left out or without her own close friends, could there be anything about her behaviour that might lead to this?

Does she say or do anything that may make people not want to be around her? It might help to try to figure out why she repeatedly has these issues.

Yes I have often wondered why this is. The problem is I think I am/was similar so it’s difficult to understand why or to offer advice. I also have numerous acquaintances but much fewer close friends and this has always been the case.

She’s not at all confrontational or bitchy. I’ve never heard her say a bad word about anyone ever. She’s generally a very positive and lively person. She rarely complains about anything.

It could be that she doesn’t show vulnerability? Or ever show that she’s upset? Or that she has learnt her communication style from me? Perhaps she’s always a bit positive and that’s too much? (I always thought I would lose friends if I complained too much or moaned and she’s similar to me).

She is probably a bit quirky. Adults love her. Add/asd is a possibility but never been broached.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread