Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD4 said a girl at nursery is brown.. what to say ?

137 replies

vangh · 05/01/2024 04:48

I always ask my DD about her friends. I say stuff like ' who's your best friend ? ' ' who shall we invite to your birthday ? ' she is 4 in a few weeks.

I asked her about a girl in her class and she said ' yeah she's brown '..

Her nursery is pretty diverse and we've spoken about lots of other children before that aren't white, but she's never said anything like that.

I didn't really know what to say. I know that sounds really stupid probably. I think I said something like, everyone is a different colour.. not sure if that was the right thing to say.

I understand she'll notice that there are different skin colours but I'm a bit surprised she said that and I don't want to say the wrong thing.

For context, we don't ever talk about skin colour at home, so maybe we should. Maybe there are child friendly books that explain this ?

Has your child said something like this and what did you do ?

OP posts:
FranticHare · 05/01/2024 07:58

My (white) DD, when a similar age, assured me how her (black) friends hands weren’t dirty, and they had washed them, it’s just that their skin is a different colour to hers and the other white kids.

She was very earnest about it. Who knows what the conversation looked like at nursery as this was discussed amongst the kids / adults. And for the record she has close black extended family, and lived in a very diverse area..

I can guarantee there was zero malice behind these comments. It was just realisation that her friends were all are different in many many ways, and this was one of many differences they had worked out that day.

would it be an appropriate comment for an adult - of course not. But a toddler exploring the world - it will be one of many comments on appearance.

Katemax82 · 05/01/2024 07:56

What's wrong with saying she is brown? It's a child saying it like it is. My daughter has a friend who is mixed race (African and Greek) he said he has brown skin.

GeckoEcho · 05/01/2024 07:56

Shit that white people angst about.

Workingtomorrow · 05/01/2024 07:50

I am unsure which but you feel uncomfortable with. The fact that she used ‘brown’ or noticed that her friend had brown skin. Or that she mentioned it.

I think she probably mentioned it as she had just really noticed the difference and had been wondering about it.

I am mixed race. I remember when dd noticed. She was around the same age. I remember her looking at me for a while and then saying ‘mummy! You look like my friend. She is brown too. Will I turn brown?’ Like it was something she just noticed.

I explained why I was more (slightly) brown than her. And pointed out how my Dad was more brown than me. Don’t upset me. It wasn’t offensive. It was factual. Kids start noticing differences between people. We do talk about race at home. Where appropriate.

But then I also remember when she was about 2.5 and sat on my mums knee and all of a sudden noticed eyebrows and eyelashes and shouted ‘Nanny, you have eye hair’ then went round the room looking at everybody it’s then in a mirror at her own. She was blown away. She just noticed a detail.

Dd is now an adult and she is fiercely anti racist.

I think it’s really ok for kids to notice differences and describe them accurately. I think in certain context it’s ok to use them as a descriptor as adults.

My friends at work who would describe themselves as black women, would also refer to their skin as brown. If that’s your concern. I am south East Asian and white so someone else might clarify if that’s correct for wider groups. But, for example, we were looking for rights that matched our skin tone, in December. My friend told me the company she looked at didn’t have enough range for ‘my shade of brown’.

thechangling · 05/01/2024 07:49

Nothing to worry about. I've heard this from my DCs when they were trying to describe a friend too. It's simply a factual statement for them

JoyeuxNarwhal · 05/01/2024 07:48

Many years ago arranging dc's birthday party he wanted some friends from preschool (fine, I knew all of them as v small preschool) and also a few from nursery. He was specific about wanting "Leo in the brown skin. I don't want Leo in the pink skin because he pushed me off my bike". I had to explain that to his keyworker when I gave her the invitations to put in their bags.

Agree with a pp who said it's not that little ones don't notice colour, it's that they don't care.

Shelby2010 · 05/01/2024 07:47

GRex · 05/01/2024 07:38

We had this, I think it's when they do descriptive words in early learning. Within days, the brown friend was followed by loudly saying "mummy, look, this bus driver is very fat" and comments about passengers' pink hair, glasses or whatever else took his fancy in an unstoppable flow of words. Luckily the bus driver at least found it hilarious. My advice would be to explain that it's good to be able to describe people, but it isn't polite to talk about what people look like in public. And/or avoid buses for a few weeks until the phase passes.

This.

But with mine it was the supermarket. All around the aisles. ‘Look it’s that fat man again!’ ‘Why has that girl got green hair?’ etc etc

ohdamnitjanet · 05/01/2024 07:46

My son is brown. It’s fine and he’d agree.

QOD · 05/01/2024 07:45

Anahenzaris · 05/01/2024 05:36

Unless you were thinking should you clarify that she is black not brown I don’t see why you need to respond at all. There doesn’t appear to be any insult or negativity attached to the statement.

I was at a function and a staff member was looking for a particular person. The most distinctive description was that he was the black guy (male) in that group of people. That was how I directed them to him. He’s black, he describes himself as black, and the description doesn’t mean anything else but helped to I’d him quickly (they didn’t want to just call his name, an easier option).

If anything I think it important not to react in such a way that it implies that you shouldn’t say that because it’s an insult or something shameful. That although it is patently obvious, we have to pretend we don’t notice. That’s usually something we do when we consider something shameful.

If DC had said “Rose had curly hair”, or 1 leg, or 2 mums, or lives with her grandparents how would you have reacted? The same approach is likely warranted.

(disclaimer: white person currently living in a country with lots of white peoples, although previously lived in a country with very few. Not British, local culture is important. )

Bloody hard to get it right isn’t it?
i once had to describe one guy from our office of many guys to someone.
he is the one with the shaved head, brown eyes, facing this way, you know his girfriend, quite short, his desk faces this way, in the end I was nearly in tears of suppressed hysteria/nerves

turns out I could have just said ‘he’s the one with one arm’ but I was worried I’d be called out for using such an obvious descriptor.

political correctness is a killer

Umph · 05/01/2024 07:45

‘Yes, her skin is brown. People come in lots of different colours don’t they? What colour is your skin?’

And move on. Not a big deal.

Benibidibici · 05/01/2024 07:43

It's a factual description of the colour of her skin. Its like when they describe a red haired childs hair as "orange".

Its completely normal. Less normal at that age would be to describe a child as "black",

ItsMyPartyParty · 05/01/2024 07:41

We’ve got the usborne “all about” books - families, diversity, feelings, friends. Good for conversations about all sorts of things.

As a white mother of white kids, I think it is very important that I actively talk about race to my kids. There is a high chance that they’ll come across racism at some point, maybe even from someone they respect, and I want their first encounter with it to be me explaining what it is and that it is wrong. Looking back I can see that I was incredibly naive well in to my 20s because I had been so protected from the idea of racism that I didn’t recognise it when I saw it.

So for an age appropriate suggestion - DS and I read a book with all sorts of different people in it, I asked if DS (5yrs) knew anyone with brown skin (yes), and explained that sometimes people are mean to other people because they have different colour skin, what does he think about it? (Bad) And if he ever hears anything like that he should tell an adult, just like any other bullying. We’ll get more nuanced as he gets older. We also make sure we have plenty of diverse characters in books, dolls are a mix of races etc.

GRex · 05/01/2024 07:38

We had this, I think it's when they do descriptive words in early learning. Within days, the brown friend was followed by loudly saying "mummy, look, this bus driver is very fat" and comments about passengers' pink hair, glasses or whatever else took his fancy in an unstoppable flow of words. Luckily the bus driver at least found it hilarious. My advice would be to explain that it's good to be able to describe people, but it isn't polite to talk about what people look like in public. And/or avoid buses for a few weeks until the phase passes.

newnamethanks · 05/01/2024 07:37

"Yes, some people are, it's just skin".

Itwasserious · 05/01/2024 07:36

My ds (he has asd) went through a phase at 4/5 of talking about skin colour, I think it was triggered by another child talking about themselves as black and he was then fixated on the fact they weren’t and just how a lot of his friends were light brown / medium brown or dark brown but not black as he said nobody is actually black it went on for months the school were really
good they allowed him to get it out of his system . He did similar when someone once said water was blue and drew a picture as he knows it’s not actually blue !

CinnamonJellyBeans · 05/01/2024 07:36

Please don't be afraid of mentioning/talking about the fact that we have variation in skin colour. Your fear of the word "brown" could make it sound like a negative feature.

It always makes me wince when people have to use the word "black" and you get that microsecond pause before they say "black" and then you see them look at you for confirmation that this is OK.

ZenNudist · 05/01/2024 07:35

I have a friend who calls themselves brown and referred to rishi sunak as a fellow brown. He's south east Asian and his skin is not black it's brown.

Nonomono · 05/01/2024 07:34

Pusheen467 · 05/01/2024 07:24

@Gnomegnomegnome Oh god I can imagine! Actually I don't think I've ever discussed dwarfism with DD. The worst is walking sticks...she's totally fascinated by them and won't shut about them anytime someone walks by with one.

🤣🤣

PersephonePomegranate23 · 05/01/2024 07:34

Agree with all the PPs.

Of course people notice skin colour, same as we notice height, eye colour, hair colour or type. Noticing isn't a problem, it's the associations that sometimes go with people's features that are the problem. You did the right thing to remain neutral. Your daughter obviously doesn't hce any negative associations with her friend's colour, don't give her any reason to even question it.

Itsnotallaboutyoulikeyouthink · 05/01/2024 07:29

You are trying to be woke. The girl is brown like I am pasty white.

Sususudio · 05/01/2024 07:29

I am brown, and proud to be brown. I don't mind if a child refers to me that way.

TookTheBook · 05/01/2024 07:26

I'm a bit gobsmacked you don't have any books with non-white characters? How have you managed that by 2024? The most useful books will normalise and recognise different skin colours and ethnicities, not specifically discuss anti racism.

Pusheen467 · 05/01/2024 07:24

Oops I meant to tag @Nonomono

Helar · 05/01/2024 07:24

“Shades of People” by Shelley Rotner is a nice book.

Pusheen467 · 05/01/2024 07:24

@Gnomegnomegnome Oh god I can imagine! Actually I don't think I've ever discussed dwarfism with DD. The worst is walking sticks...she's totally fascinated by them and won't shut about them anytime someone walks by with one.

Swipe left for the next trending thread