Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD4 said a girl at nursery is brown.. what to say ?

137 replies

vangh · 05/01/2024 04:48

I always ask my DD about her friends. I say stuff like ' who's your best friend ? ' ' who shall we invite to your birthday ? ' she is 4 in a few weeks.

I asked her about a girl in her class and she said ' yeah she's brown '..

Her nursery is pretty diverse and we've spoken about lots of other children before that aren't white, but she's never said anything like that.

I didn't really know what to say. I know that sounds really stupid probably. I think I said something like, everyone is a different colour.. not sure if that was the right thing to say.

I understand she'll notice that there are different skin colours but I'm a bit surprised she said that and I don't want to say the wrong thing.

For context, we don't ever talk about skin colour at home, so maybe we should. Maybe there are child friendly books that explain this ?

Has your child said something like this and what did you do ?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
zingally · 06/01/2024 11:33

TookTheBook · 06/01/2024 06:30

This is a dreadful "explanation" as the children will infer all brown people are recent immigrants from hot countries. Black and brown people have been here for generations now.

You're thinking waaaay too deep about the understanding level of 4yos.

But there's always someone ready to tell you how wrong you are. ;)

Workingtomorrow · 06/01/2024 07:17

Sartre · 06/01/2024 07:16

Colourblindness isn’t helpful and black people don’t want you to pretend you can’t see their skin colour. It’s something that makes us all different, much like hair or eye colour or anything else. At four, children have no concept of racism so your DD is merely pointing out a fact. Her friend does have brown skin and it isn’t offensive to say this, much like it isn’t offensive to say she has dark hair or eyes.

This^

Thank you

Sartre · 06/01/2024 07:16

Colourblindness isn’t helpful and black people don’t want you to pretend you can’t see their skin colour. It’s something that makes us all different, much like hair or eye colour or anything else. At four, children have no concept of racism so your DD is merely pointing out a fact. Her friend does have brown skin and it isn’t offensive to say this, much like it isn’t offensive to say she has dark hair or eyes.

Bournetilly · 06/01/2024 06:42

Maybe your DD and her friend had been talking to each other about their skin colours which is why she’s mentioned her friend being brown but not the other children. I think what you said was fine and you don’t need to make an issue out of this, she’s just stating what she’s seen.

EasternStandard · 06/01/2024 06:40

Young dc will usually pick up on using descriptive terms such as brown or peach, I can’t see that they should be told not to say what they’re seeing, the world is at interesting and learning stage including what people are like

I’m not sure how else they can talk about it innocently

TookTheBook · 06/01/2024 06:30

zingally · 05/01/2024 16:28

I wouldn't think anything much about it. My two were about that age when they first asked/commented on skin colour.

When I was a new teacher, one of my first reception classes had this come up. I was chit-chatting with a small group, and one of the white children asked "Why is Emmanuel brown?" I explained that at some point his family lived in a place that was much hotter, and darker skin does a better job at protecting you from the sun than lighter skin.
The assembled group silently took in this nugget of information, and it was never mentioned again.

This is a dreadful "explanation" as the children will infer all brown people are recent immigrants from hot countries. Black and brown people have been here for generations now.

zingally · 05/01/2024 16:28

I wouldn't think anything much about it. My two were about that age when they first asked/commented on skin colour.

When I was a new teacher, one of my first reception classes had this come up. I was chit-chatting with a small group, and one of the white children asked "Why is Emmanuel brown?" I explained that at some point his family lived in a place that was much hotter, and darker skin does a better job at protecting you from the sun than lighter skin.
The assembled group silently took in this nugget of information, and it was never mentioned again.

IhateHPSDeaneCnt · 05/01/2024 15:56

You could also ask using another identifier e.g 'do you mean the girl with pink wellies / Frozen rucksack'?

NoKnit · 05/01/2024 15:28

I reckon you are overthinking this.

My son was about 7 when George Floyd was murdered and I remember him asking about it as he'd seen it on the news. He couldn't work out what I meant when I referred to him as black. I then told him like 'XXX' in his class. His response then was 'what do you mean XXX is black ' the concept was fully lost on him and even now at almost 11 he really doesn't get the difference. We are all people! I'm more than happy for him to grow up this way and have no issue or discomfort with it.

ToddlerMumma · 05/01/2024 15:25

We have conversations about skin colour in our home, normalising it. I'm white and my husband is black and kids mixed. They say I'm pink (say what you see!) and use pink when drawing me and brown when drawing them. Kids aren't racist so don't worry about observations like that

PickledPegs · 05/01/2024 14:59

I talk to my 3yo often about how everyone looks different and how all bodies are good bodies. Some books I like that show bodily diversity (but aren’t all necessarily about bodily diversity) are:

We’re different we’re the same
Our little kitchen
Sulwe
Hair Love
perfectly imperfect Mira
what happened to you?
These hands

YoBeaches · 05/01/2024 14:34

mumsytoon · 05/01/2024 12:22

I think it's actually odd that she mentioned this. If it's a diverse school, then seeing kids of all races would be the norm and nothing that would stand out to her. Also if there are other kids of colour, why did she mention this particular child? I would try to get to the reason, as if she is pointing this out about one particular child it might cause some offence.

I don't agree with this it's normal development for children to recognise and identify what is different about themselves and each other. Being in a diverse nursery or school simplify amplifies this earlier than used to.

It doesn't mean 'I don't see race' which is proven to be untrue.

It means 'l acknowledge race as a difference between us' as a pre curser to learning that we shouldnt treat people differently as a result of that difference, which at nursery level isn't age appropriate yet.

vangh · 05/01/2024 12:30

mumsytoon · 05/01/2024 12:22

I think it's actually odd that she mentioned this. If it's a diverse school, then seeing kids of all races would be the norm and nothing that would stand out to her. Also if there are other kids of colour, why did she mention this particular child? I would try to get to the reason, as if she is pointing this out about one particular child it might cause some offence.

I agree. There are at least 4 other black kids in her class. She's never said they were brown or even mentioned it.

She says they're boys or girls or happy or sad usually. But nothing about skin colour.

OP posts:
moonshinepoursthroughmywindow · 05/01/2024 12:24

Sometimes someone's skin colour is the thing that makes them stand out in a particular group, and the most useful way of explaining who you mean. I honestly don't see this as racist or think it needs a big discussion. "Brown" is not the word an adult would use, but it's not an unusual choice for people of that age and unless the intention is obviously malicious, which it doesn't sound like here, I wouldn't do anything.

mumsytoon · 05/01/2024 12:22

I think it's actually odd that she mentioned this. If it's a diverse school, then seeing kids of all races would be the norm and nothing that would stand out to her. Also if there are other kids of colour, why did she mention this particular child? I would try to get to the reason, as if she is pointing this out about one particular child it might cause some offence.

DrMarshaFieldstone · 05/01/2024 12:18

@StrangeNew Not looking for a row. Small children make sense of the world from the micro and build towards the macro. If a child has only known a predominantly WBRI context it’s age-appropriate to use this as their initial frame of reference and ‘some’ ≠ anomaly.

Quite apart from the fact that many billions of people in the global majority wouldn’t describe themselves as either Black or brown.

StrangeNew · 05/01/2024 12:05

Nope. Not at all understanding why your preferred response is more age appropriate, @DrMarshaFieldstone. Grin

(Speaking as a member of said global majority I’d object to anyone giving their four year old the impression that I am some strange anomaly. Thanks.)

DrMarshaFieldstone · 05/01/2024 11:59

StrangeNew · 05/01/2024 11:35

Most people in the world are black or brown, no?

Most four-year-olds’ worlds are pretty small, and it’s fine to give an age-appropriate answer with ‘some’. They don’t need the full picture of global majority language just yet.

SmellyNelliey · 05/01/2024 11:41

I'd personally by some books that explains differences of skin hair ect and start reading so your child has a better understanding as they grow. All children notice different things skin,hair ect it's all apart of developing.

StrangeNew · 05/01/2024 11:35

newnamethanks · 05/01/2024 07:37

"Yes, some people are, it's just skin".

Most people in the world are black or brown, no?

Moonwatcher1234 · 05/01/2024 11:01

vangh · 05/01/2024 09:29

@housethatbuiltme I felt that mum was doing her best, but it be it did make me cringe.

What should she have done ? Just acknowledge that the man is in fact black ?

In my opinion, I would have explained to my child that we don't point out someone's skin colour.

In fact I felt like saying yesterday - yes your friend is brown, but it's not something we comment on. I don't want to shame her but I don't want her doing that in public to people. I think it's inappropriate and something she needs to learn is not OK to point out. Just like other physical characteristics. She should just learn it's not something that's polite to be pointing out. Whether that be glasses, hair colour, noses or weight. But I don't know if I'm being too much by saying that, hence I made this thread to get some other points of view. I don't want to be shaming her either but in the long run, she does need to learn not to comment on appearance.

It’s okay! Honestly it is. We are a “brown” family and all kids from around that age do start to notice things like this, whatever their background. It’s not done with malice and is just the natural curiosity of children. Please don’t make a big deal of it and make your child wonder what she’s done wrong. Your response was fine - as long as she is taught that the colour of someone’s skin is not important, that all people are beautiful regardless of colour and that character is what counts, then you’re doing a grand job.

Superfrog3 · 05/01/2024 10:44

"Oohh that's nice" or "does she have brown skin, that's nice" is fine.. My children's dad is brown and my kids have said "he's brown like daddy" , "he has curly hair like daddy" in the same way he will say "mummy's skin is really pale" 🙄 it's not a bad thing it's noticing differences. I think as long as your responding in a positive/ neutral way and teaching your daughter everyone is different then it's fine. Just don't make a big thing out of it, like don't make her be friends with somebody because theyre brown or treat them differently because she is brown, it's just normal.

Sugargliderwombat · 05/01/2024 10:43

I think where you are going wrong is wanting her not to acknowledge that people are from different races. It's almost like saying 'shhhh don't mention it!'. Would you tell her not to mention it if she said her friend had golden hair? It's just as factual.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 05/01/2024 10:35

I wouldn’t say anything. IMO you’re massively overthinking this. A 4 year old is just making an observation.

The only time a child’s race-related remark has really made me cringe was when I heard a girl of no more than 8, say of another, ‘Oh, she’s Eurasian.’ She’d evidently heard it from her parents, who were Australian.
It was said in a slightly disdainful tone, which was why it really made me cringe.

alltootired · 05/01/2024 10:29

Black and brown are now the accepted terms. No need to do anything.