Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be fed up with floods and think it's climate change?

185 replies

malificent7 · 05/01/2024 00:26

Live and work in Somerset. Can't get home due to floods. This is the 3rd time in 2 months that the commute has been dangerous. Aibu to think that this is climate change and to be scared and pissed off about it? Yes...i am a contributor to the oroblem. I know.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
BodenCardiganNot · 05/01/2024 09:04

There is not any more water than there used to be,

There is.
The world is getting rainier — and no wonder. As the climate warms, the atmosphere can hold and release more moisture, meaning torrential downpours are on the rise around the planet.
“There is a crystal-clear analysis that shows, decade by decade, we have more of these extremes,” said Simon Papalexiou, a professor of civil, geological and environmental engineering at the University of Saskatchewan in Saskatoon, Canada, and the lead author of a new study showing an ominous rise in the frequency of heavy rainstorms.
The new study, published June 3 in the journal Water Resources Research, shows that heavy downpours have become more common since the middle of the last century, when global warming started to intensify.

LightSwerve · 05/01/2024 09:04

Unabletomitigate · 05/01/2024 08:57

Poor land managament.
Poor water management.

There is not any more water than there used to be, but the land it is falling on has changed, and we have messed up the water cycle.

There is more rain than there used to be.

Cattenberg · 05/01/2024 09:03

I’m also from Somerset. It’s noticeable that in some parts of the county, “once every 50 years” flooding events are now happening almost every year.

The winters are also becoming warmer. Christmas Day this year felt unnaturally
mild. Which was nice, but …

LightSwerve · 05/01/2024 09:03

RedPony1 · 05/01/2024 08:48

Our river is about 12m narrower than it was 30 years ago. absolutely it would make a huge difference if it was returned to its original size.

Didnt a farmer get put in hail not long ago for dredging a river? it instantly cured the local village flooding but he still got jailed.

It just moves the flooding a bit further down.

Read the science. Dredging doesn't work.

BodenCardiganNot · 05/01/2024 09:02

*@RedPony1 Today 08:48

Didnt a farmer get put in hail not long ago for dredging a river? it instantly cured the local village flooding but he still got jailed.*

He got jailed for the destruction of a river bank and for the pollution of the river. He pleaded guilty to all the offences. Google 'John Price' and 'River Lugg' and you will see the destruction.

CormorantStrikesBack · 05/01/2024 08:59

How many new houses are being built? Loads of new estates just in my previously small village. Then people patio their gardens. Combined with increased rainfall due to global warming its not good. It’ll get worse, a lot worse.

BogRollBOGOF · 05/01/2024 08:59

Things can have more than one cause.

A lot of the disruption near me has been run-off from the fields overflowing on to roads. The way the land is used (now often equestrian rather than farmed) has changed, and drainage ditches by the hedgrows (and often poor management of those) aren't maintained mean that water rapidly flows off the fields, on to roads and the silt rapidly fills the drainage and suddenly where there used to be puddles are now outright floods requiring road closures.

There is a change in weather patterns, but at a local scale, it's often the way that land is used and managed (or not) that affects the direct impact.

Beautiful3 · 05/01/2024 08:58

Where I live over the past 15 years, we can see a direct cause. We have many trees in the area, one part has removed alot of trees to build housing, now that part gets flooded quite often. The fire department comes and siphons the water off the road. We never had that problem before, when there were more trees there instead of the housing.

Unabletomitigate · 05/01/2024 08:57

Poor land managament.
Poor water management.

There is not any more water than there used to be, but the land it is falling on has changed, and we have messed up the water cycle.

Daftasabroom · 05/01/2024 08:54

Of course it's linked to climate change. The Atlantic Ocean last year was incredibly warm, this means more water evaporation which means more rain. Climate change also means that weather is more stable, last month is was wetter for longer.

You can't blame unusual rainfall on blocked drains.

NovemberRainy · 05/01/2024 08:53

@RedPony1 might make it better for you but likely to hit the next downstream settlement much harder

BearTrap · 05/01/2024 08:49

Alcyoneus · 05/01/2024 01:12

No, it’s about blocked drains actually. And building on flood plains.

Climate is changing as it’s always done. Blaming everything on it is basically either a grift to steal from the taxpayer or excuse political corruption/incompetence.

Totally agree! Everyone is banging the drum about climate change but if you look more closely, the areas flooding near me are those that have been intensively built on. A few other areas it turns out were that the drains were blocked because the council didnt clear them, it took members of the public to do that (when homes have been flooded and cars wrecked, something so simple could’ve avoided it). On a particular area, the new estate is being built, the overflow pond was empty but the next village was underwater 🤦🏻‍♀️

Ginmonkeyagain · 05/01/2024 08:48

It is both. Climate change means more intense rainfall and we have not adapted the UK infrastructure to deal with that.

I was skating across massive lakes of rainwater sitting on the roads and pavements in central London yesterday. Mediterreanan cities, where intense rain storms have been a thing for centuries, often have drain culverts in the centre of roads with a soft cambre both sides of the road so water can run down to them. They also have down pipes with wide ending that spit out on to the road rather than in to drains.

So a bit of drains bht mainly climate change.

RedPony1 · 05/01/2024 08:48

Our river is about 12m narrower than it was 30 years ago. absolutely it would make a huge difference if it was returned to its original size.

Didnt a farmer get put in hail not long ago for dredging a river? it instantly cured the local village flooding but he still got jailed.

aSwarmOfMidgies · 05/01/2024 08:43

If you have climate change leading to unusual weather patterns then you need to spend a lot more on everything from cleaning drains and ditches to changing hard surfaces to porous ones

No one wanted the cost of preventing climate change and no one wants to cost of adaptation

LightSwerve · 05/01/2024 08:43

RedPony1 · 05/01/2024 08:33

The floods around here are purely only happening due to piss poor ditch management and river dredging being banned by the EU.

if they could dredge the river by my stables, which is about half the width (& probably depth) it used to be, there would be zero flooding around us.

Dredging doesn't stop flooding. In some cases it is known to make it worse. In some cases it provides limited benefit.

In some cases dredging did reduce the water levels of rivers, but this did not lead to reductions in flooding risk during extreme flows because other features such as infrastructure upon the floodplain increasingly affect water levels rather than the capacity or shape of the river channel itself. In some cases, dredging actually increased the flood risk further downstream.

https://www.britishecologicalsociety.org/is-dredging-a-sustainable-solution-for-managing-uk-floods/

Dredging doesn't really work. It sounds simple so it appeals to some people, especially climate change deniers, but like all science it's complicated.

Is dredging a sustainable solution for managing UK floods? - British Ecological Society

In a recent report by the Chartered Institution for Water and Environmental Management, the UK Government’s recent proposals for increased dredging activity to take place in order to reduce future flooding impacts have been labelled as ‘a cruel offer o...

https://www.britishecologicalsociety.org/is-dredging-a-sustainable-solution-for-managing-uk-floods

Okaygoahead · 05/01/2024 08:42

Thank you @PoppyFleur , you saved me having to counter the bonkers “it’s the EU’s fault” nonsense upthread.

oldcrinkle · 05/01/2024 08:40

I'm near Worcester and floods are nothing new. What has changed is the water coming up over roads it didn't before probably due to flood barriers upstream, new developments and badly planned roads.

PoppyFleur · 05/01/2024 08:39

RedPony1 · 05/01/2024 08:33

The floods around here are purely only happening due to piss poor ditch management and river dredging being banned by the EU.

if they could dredge the river by my stables, which is about half the width (& probably depth) it used to be, there would be zero flooding around us.

The EU has not banned river dredging.

https://fullfact.org/online/EU-dredging-floods/

EU regulations on dredging did not cause recent flooding - Full Fact

There is no specific EU law on banning dredging, but while some governance does affect it, it does not prevent it.

https://fullfact.org/online/EU-dredging-floods/

user1469207397 · 05/01/2024 08:36

It's caused by blocked drains.
I've reported two close to my house to the council.. They respond a couple of days later to say engineers have checked them and there is no problem apparently even though water is running out of the drains themselves.
Concrete blocks placed temporarily across our drive last night to prevent flooding but it's no way to live when you've worried to go to sleep at night. If we hadn't been at home the house would have been flooded for the second time.
The council just isn't interested.

LightSwerve · 05/01/2024 08:35

Flooding events are already more common due to climate change and will increase going forwards.

Those pretending it is just leaves down the drain are flatearthers.

We can increase drainage and defences, but that doesn't change the science even if it protects us from (some of) the flooding.

YANBU to be concerned, climate change is going to fuck a lot of things up.

Walkden · 05/01/2024 08:35

Back at school 30 years ago I remember by wing taught about global warming presented as a theoretical thing. Nowadays we can point to 1 in 100 year events happening over and over and it is difficult to ignore the reality that the air and sea are warmer so extreme floods stronger storms heatwaves are now more common.

On top of that long term austerity and lack of investment in this country means that all public services are crumbling ( literally in some cases ) which of course includes councils the environment agencies etc so drains flood defences are neglected too which makes things worse.

RedPony1 · 05/01/2024 08:33

The floods around here are purely only happening due to piss poor ditch management and river dredging being banned by the EU.

if they could dredge the river by my stables, which is about half the width (& probably depth) it used to be, there would be zero flooding around us.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 05/01/2024 08:30

It can be a combination of things (drainage issue is getting worse in a lot of places as lots of drains are still victoriana and not designed for modern living eg houses with multiple showers in use multiple times a day, dishwashers, washing machines etc) and more new houses feeding into them.

However:

  • drainage normally affects flash flooding (surface runoff), poor drainage doesnt normally cause rivers to burst their banks
  • it's also accepted that winters are getting wetter and warmer than in the past, and summers are drier but when it does rain, its more intense. There are loads of articles about this on the met Office. Both of these changes mean that flooding is more likely, irrespective of drainage issues.

So although people are right that these areas have always flooded, they are likely to be flooding more frequently and more severely, than they would have in the absence of climate change

Londonrach1 · 05/01/2024 08:29

I grow up in somerset in the 80s it always floods..has done for centuries. It's why they crafts are as they are. Some idiot built houses on the flood plains when I was growing up there and everywhere shocked the houses flooded.

Swipe left for the next trending thread