Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be fed up with floods and think it's climate change?

185 replies

malificent7 · 05/01/2024 00:26

Live and work in Somerset. Can't get home due to floods. This is the 3rd time in 2 months that the commute has been dangerous. Aibu to think that this is climate change and to be scared and pissed off about it? Yes...i am a contributor to the oroblem. I know.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
RampantIvy · 05/01/2024 13:44

StillWantingADog · 05/01/2024 11:22

This. Blaming it on not being able to dredge and blocked drains (which probably contribute to a minor extent) is indeed for the flat earthers.

that all said another contributor is poor urban planning eg building houses on flood plains. And as happened near me building a flashy new road with inadequate drainage. Guess which road floods every single time there is heavy rain? Council has admitted it was poor planning and there is no affordable solution.

I agree with this ^^

The garage down the road from us has flooded three times over the last few weeks a) because we have had the second wettest December since records began and the wettest autumn since records began, and b) The new owners haven't been clearing the culvert that runs underneath the forecourt.

The number of people who have fake grass in their back gardens or pave them over, the number of houses built on flood plains - Catcliffe in Sheffield is a good example, and the lack of dredging and keeping drains and other waterways clear have all contributed.

On to climate change - more people using their own vehicles to commute and go to places because public transport is dire. It's all so depressing.

LightSwerve · 05/01/2024 13:44

But their core spending power (ie total funding including council tax in one) hasn't been cut by 40% in real terms over that period.

Spending pressure/proximity to bankruptcy varies massively council to council, but what we can say with absolute certainty is the Tories have in 13 years almost destroyed local government by cutting their grants whilst doing fuck all about the social care crisis, and have transferred an increasing council tax burden to us all as an added insult.

AnneElliott · 05/01/2024 13:10

That wasn't the comment I was responding to @LightSwerve . A poster above claimed that local councils don't get central Government funding - they do. And I've posted the link to confirm it.

Really odd why people are so happy making bold claims that aren't just wrong but are easily to confirm through Google!

Yes local government funding from the central allocation has been reduced over a number of years. But their core spending power (ie total funding including council tax in one) hasn't been cut by 40% in real terms over that period.

The main issue with council funding is the huge increase in the costs of social care and the numbers of people needing it. We need as a county to have an urgent solution to that otherwise councils are going to be sustainable.

NotTerfNorCis · 05/01/2024 13:06

Alcyoneus · 05/01/2024 01:12

No, it’s about blocked drains actually. And building on flood plains.

Climate is changing as it’s always done. Blaming everything on it is basically either a grift to steal from the taxpayer or excuse political corruption/incompetence.

Yes, climate changes whether we contribute to it or not. However, we are certainly contributing to it, and speeding it up in a way that's already causing problems.

LightSwerve · 05/01/2024 13:04

AnneElliott · 05/01/2024 12:59

Councils absolutely do receive funding from central Government - the provisional settlement for 24/25 was published in December. And they can increase council tax by an extra 2% a year (on top of the 3% referendum limit) purely for social care costs.

The Tories have cut council funding by huge percentages - over 40% in real terms since 2010.

AnneElliott · 05/01/2024 12:59

Councils absolutely do receive funding from central Government - the provisional settlement for 24/25 was published in December. And they can increase council tax by an extra 2% a year (on top of the 3% referendum limit) purely for social care costs.

countrygirl99 · 05/01/2024 12:55

According to the UK Centre for Ecology and Hydrology UK autumn rainfall between September and November was 22% above average and in some areas December was 70% above average.
January is starting in the same vein. So we are having a very wet winter falling on ground with a very limited capacity to store any more.

ClassicBBQ · 05/01/2024 12:53

It doesn't help that the water simply has nowhere to go. I live in a town that has had 7 massive housing developments put up in the past 5 years. All in all, around 1500 new homes and the roads that go with it has decimated the trees, grasses and plants that used to soak up the majority of the water. Everyone is shocked that these houses are now surrounded by giant puddles that don't seem to shifting, but where else are they meant to go 🙄

Macramepotholder · 05/01/2024 12:45

@JubileeJumps Huge parts of Florida are, famously, a swamp. It's also been enormously overdeveloped. If people are going to build on a swamp, it's not surprising they can't get insurance. Places like Florida need to think very carefully about their climate change adaptation planning, which is likely going to have to accept that current areas in use for housing and commercial use will have to be lost.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 05/01/2024 12:41

I definitely think climate change is contributing to it. But also, where I live, all the places where water used to be absorbed and held have now been concreted over, and the water is pooling nearby where it never pooled a few years ago before the concreting over. I don't think we can pin that on climate change.

Sartre · 05/01/2024 12:36

We are an island and I’m pretty sure floods happen every single year without fail, I certainly remember lots of news stories about them when I was a child so 20+ years ago. Nothing new.

Macramepotholder · 05/01/2024 12:35

It's getting wetter and warmer with climate change. This compounds a problem the UK has been storing up for 100 years around increasingly poor management of river catchments (for example, culverting rivers, straightening them, taking out hedges and woodland and 'messy' areas of farmland), concreting over everything (parking in front gardens anyone?) and building on flood plains. The loss of native species like beavers which perform natural land management.

My understanding is that dredging shouldn't be necessary if land is correctly managed and is a sticking plaster on another problem.

I grew up in a seaside village at the bottom of a wooded river valley. It flooded regularly on a spring tide, and the buildings in the flooded area were designed to cope with that. When they culverted the river and built a massive concrete carpark over the valley it flooded much harder, faster and higher. Most of the country has done idiotic things like that.

viques · 05/01/2024 12:21

Poorly maintained and ancient, inadequate drains that can’t cope with modern demands in urban areas,

poorly maintained canals/ rivers/ drainage ditches ,

proliferation of houses, shopping centres, industrial parks, roads etc built in areas known to be in danger of flooding,

concreting over of gardens to provide parking spaces so surface water can’t drain naturally and is pushed into already over stretched drains (see above.)

EasternStandard · 05/01/2024 12:21

I’m not convinced building proposals that are incoming are a good idea

Surely we need green spaces, trees and what management we have

TooBigForMyBoots · 05/01/2024 12:13

Yes its Climate Change @malificent7. We knew this was coming but it was cheaper to convince people it wasn't real than to take the measures necessary to deal with it.

And now we have Climate Change with all the issues it brings and a further problem with Reality Deniers.

TheNoonBell · 05/01/2024 12:04

One of the pubs round here has a door marking all the flood levels and years. Floods are a constant and peaks really do vary over the decades.

It's currently flooded and just over half way up the door.

To be fed up with floods and think it's climate change?
MintJulia · 05/01/2024 11:58

To answer the question, why are the drainage ditches no longer maintained, when the land was farmed, the farmers maintained the ditches to ensure their spring grazing. Centuries of knowledge of how to deal with floods. Their livelihoods depended on it.

Then the land is bought by developers, who build houses, put in as little flood management as they can get away with and then absolve themselves of all responsibility.

The new owners don't know what is needed, the land isn't publicly owned so the councils aren't responsible and are generally unaware, and so it floods.

Our parish employs a full time lengthsman, whose job is to clear ditches, advise home owners on what is needed etc. He spends his year reminding and advising groups of home owners to clear the ditches on their estates, organising working parties, monitoring drains and culverts, arranging for fallen trees & branches to be cleared and new ones planted etc.

Sleepsleepsleep123 · 05/01/2024 11:56

You'd only be unreasonable if you claimed it wasn't connected to climate change.

TheClitterati · 05/01/2024 11:47

Flood plains are going to flood.

EasternStandard · 05/01/2024 11:42

YourDiscoNeedsYou · 05/01/2024 11:30

Same in my area (or we live in the same town). We aren’t on a flood plain, the river is a few miles away. The flooding we have is caused by run off from the fields, heading too quickly into a series of dykes, or straight onto the roads into town. The roads look like rivers in heavy rainfall. It means we get flooded regularly, 3 times since end of October, and the whole town is cut off for a day or two until the water works its way to the river.

Currently the river has burst its banks. It’s always a couple of days after the rain, as the water works its way along the system, and there are lots of houses and businesses near the flood plains that have now been flooded by that too.

It’s just a fact that warmer climate means more water (science of evaporation), and we’re not really tacking the issue very well, which leads to more and more flooding incidents. Yes, we’re building in flood plains, but also building more in general, and water runs off concrete much faster than forest/grass etc. We really need a comprehensive national plan for land management to make sure our land has the right characteristics to hold/slow down water to prevent the massive swelling of the rivers.

Yes we need trees and planning. Trees are also good for heat if it gets back to those 40 days at any point

Stop building over everything and conserve and manage

Imo the part that will make people notice climate change is fast rising insurance premiums or lack of altogether

Zandrazanzara · 05/01/2024 11:39

Is all the radiation emitted by 3G, 4G and 5G (in which the whole of the U.K. is currently bathed) not in any way contributing to climate change? Humans are destroying the planet for themselves. Prehistoric climate changes led to mass extinctions. New, better adapted species evolved which included us humans...but now we’re destroying ourselves and the planet. Would be better off left to less “intelligent” species.

YourDiscoNeedsYou · 05/01/2024 11:30

BogRollBOGOF · 05/01/2024 08:59

Things can have more than one cause.

A lot of the disruption near me has been run-off from the fields overflowing on to roads. The way the land is used (now often equestrian rather than farmed) has changed, and drainage ditches by the hedgrows (and often poor management of those) aren't maintained mean that water rapidly flows off the fields, on to roads and the silt rapidly fills the drainage and suddenly where there used to be puddles are now outright floods requiring road closures.

There is a change in weather patterns, but at a local scale, it's often the way that land is used and managed (or not) that affects the direct impact.

Same in my area (or we live in the same town). We aren’t on a flood plain, the river is a few miles away. The flooding we have is caused by run off from the fields, heading too quickly into a series of dykes, or straight onto the roads into town. The roads look like rivers in heavy rainfall. It means we get flooded regularly, 3 times since end of October, and the whole town is cut off for a day or two until the water works its way to the river.

Currently the river has burst its banks. It’s always a couple of days after the rain, as the water works its way along the system, and there are lots of houses and businesses near the flood plains that have now been flooded by that too.

It’s just a fact that warmer climate means more water (science of evaporation), and we’re not really tacking the issue very well, which leads to more and more flooding incidents. Yes, we’re building in flood plains, but also building more in general, and water runs off concrete much faster than forest/grass etc. We really need a comprehensive national plan for land management to make sure our land has the right characteristics to hold/slow down water to prevent the massive swelling of the rivers.

StillWantingADog · 05/01/2024 11:22

LightSwerve · 05/01/2024 08:35

Flooding events are already more common due to climate change and will increase going forwards.

Those pretending it is just leaves down the drain are flatearthers.

We can increase drainage and defences, but that doesn't change the science even if it protects us from (some of) the flooding.

YANBU to be concerned, climate change is going to fuck a lot of things up.

This. Blaming it on not being able to dredge and blocked drains (which probably contribute to a minor extent) is indeed for the flat earthers.

that all said another contributor is poor urban planning eg building houses on flood plains. And as happened near me building a flashy new road with inadequate drainage. Guess which road floods every single time there is heavy rain? Council has admitted it was poor planning and there is no affordable solution.

EasternStandard · 05/01/2024 11:19

It’s probably both. Drains and other urbanisation changes plus climate related

I remember someone posting climate would increase the three fs

Flooding being one