Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be fed up with floods and think it's climate change?

185 replies

malificent7 · 05/01/2024 00:26

Live and work in Somerset. Can't get home due to floods. This is the 3rd time in 2 months that the commute has been dangerous. Aibu to think that this is climate change and to be scared and pissed off about it? Yes...i am a contributor to the oroblem. I know.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
cakeorwine · 05/01/2024 18:13

Climate change is going to bring more wet weather in winter.

Couple that with building on flood plains, poor maintenance etc and you wonder why floods are more likely to happen.

AnneElliott · 05/01/2024 18:10

Please post a link to a reputable source that confirms your assertion @LightSwerve. CSP has not been cut by 40% in real terms.

I'm also interested to know how you've accounted for the formula changes in 13/14 since that comparison is something we struggle with at work. If you have a source that calculates the changes since 2010 I'd be very genuinely interested in seeing it.

AnneElliott · 05/01/2024 18:06

What District council did you work for @Cattenberg? I'm not aware of any Districts that don't get RSG or Business Rates but if you say who they are I can look them up on the DLUHC published pages and confirm that.

Cattenberg · 05/01/2024 17:37

I read about an effect called ice-albedo feedback which accelerates this process. Basically, ice is effective at reflecting solar energy back up into the atmosphere, so as it melts, the ground absorbs more solar energy and warms up, causing more ice to melt.

beguilingeyes · 05/01/2024 17:03

Just watch David Attenborough's latest series for a sobering update. Polar bears ans penguins aren't running out of ice because of clogged drains.

Macramepotholder · 05/01/2024 16:00

Erm Beavers aren't causing climate change! They're exacerbating the impact by adapting to human-made climate change which is forcing them to migrate north.

Poor beavers.

thenarcissistssister · 05/01/2024 15:14

Macramepotholder · 05/01/2024 12:35

It's getting wetter and warmer with climate change. This compounds a problem the UK has been storing up for 100 years around increasingly poor management of river catchments (for example, culverting rivers, straightening them, taking out hedges and woodland and 'messy' areas of farmland), concreting over everything (parking in front gardens anyone?) and building on flood plains. The loss of native species like beavers which perform natural land management.

My understanding is that dredging shouldn't be necessary if land is correctly managed and is a sticking plaster on another problem.

I grew up in a seaside village at the bottom of a wooded river valley. It flooded regularly on a spring tide, and the buildings in the flooded area were designed to cope with that. When they culverted the river and built a massive concrete carpark over the valley it flooded much harder, faster and higher. Most of the country has done idiotic things like that.

The loss of native species like beavers which perform natural land management.

Meanwhile, in Canada, beavers are contributing to climate change by migrating north as the weather warms and buildings dams that are melting the permafrost

https://amp.theguardian.com/world/2024/jan/02/global-heating-beavers-alaska-northern-canada

its a car crash on a global scale, everywhere you look

Beaver ponds may exacerbate warming in Arctic, scientists say | Animals | The Guardian

Rising temperatures have spurred an influx of beavers to Alaska and northern Canada ‘on a huge scale’

https://amp.theguardian.com/world/2024/jan/02/global-heating-beavers-alaska-northern-canada

EasternStandard · 05/01/2024 15:07

LightSwerve · 05/01/2024 14:43

Just heard on the news that some areas have already had 60% of their average January rainfall - it is only 5th!

LMAO at the idea there is no more wanter than usual Hmm

Yep

Areyouthereorhere · 05/01/2024 15:06

Alcyoneus · 05/01/2024 01:12

No, it’s about blocked drains actually. And building on flood plains.

Climate is changing as it’s always done. Blaming everything on it is basically either a grift to steal from the taxpayer or excuse political corruption/incompetence.

You are completely misinformed. So much so that I can’t even be bothered to tell in what ways. Just actually look for the scientific consensus documents rather than relying on social media algorithms.

OP you are right to think this is climate change and that we are causing it. It is only going going to get worse. We do still have time to avert the worst consequences but we are so stupid we continue with our collective heads buried in the sand. The film ‘Don’t Look Up’ is about right. We are idiots.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 05/01/2024 15:02

This. Blaming it on not being able to dredge and blocked drains (which probably contribute to a minor extent) is indeed for the flat earthers

If our local council bothered to clear our drains then the water would actually have somewhere to run to. Our road floods with one shower, let alone prolonged rain. It's the same for a lot of roads around here, nothing has changed since the bad flooding 10 years ago.

I asked the council what they intended to do about the drains and was told they can't afford their own machinery, they need to borrow it from a neighbouring council. This was several years ago nothing has been done. It clearly won't solve all the problems but it could mean the poor people who were flooded last time might not be again.

Crumpleton · 05/01/2024 14:55

No, it’s about blocked drains actually. And building on flood plains.

This.
Basic road/drain maintenance/clearance by our local authority has really suffered over the years, not to mention when relaying new tarmac the contractors don't have the basic knowledge to know that coving the drains with the stuff shouldn't be part of the job.

Also agree re floodplains, it's pretty obvious that houses should never have been built on areas that are know to flood, but still they do.

LightSwerve · 05/01/2024 14:43

Just heard on the news that some areas have already had 60% of their average January rainfall - it is only 5th!

LMAO at the idea there is no more wanter than usual Hmm

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 05/01/2024 14:40

Weather here has been so disruptive - windy, rainy, windy and rainy, and on and on.
Lots of boats been cancelled, which disrupts people and goods getting off the land, flooded fields, surface water on roads.....

Locutus2000 · 05/01/2024 14:36

Is all the radiation emitted by 3G, 4G and 5G (in which the whole of the U.K. is currently bathed) not in any way contributing to climate change?

It is not.

LakieLady · 05/01/2024 14:11

VolvoFan · 05/01/2024 10:33

They're not underfunded, they're incompetent and mismanage everything they get involved in. Why do you think councils have gone bankrupt?

Because of cuts in the central government grant to local councils, and little room for cuts in the 2 biggest spending services (education and adult social care). The smaller services where there is more discretion re spending are therefore the first to get cut, and highway maintenance is one of them.

Cattenberg · 05/01/2024 14:03

EasternStandard · 05/01/2024 13:46

It’s going to be interesting when pp expect Labour will make these issues go away

Because I used to work for the finance dept. of a District Council and back in 2019 (or early 2020), the Chief Exec informed us in an all-staff meeting that this was the first year we would receive no funding from central government. Apparently councils were now supposed to be “self-funding”. In fact, he said we’d actually had to pay central government a fee of about £100,000 for some service or other.

I admit that when I posted, it didn’t occur to me that County Councils and Unitaries might still receive some funding. My mistake. It’s nowhere near enough, though.

We now have a Unitary Council and Social Care takes up almost 2/3 of the Council’s budget, That’s huge. Needless to say, the Council has had to cut other services, but they aren’t allowed to simply transfer savings made within one budget to another budget.

Anyway, my main point is that councils often get blamed for problems which are actually the fault of central government. And I have no doubt that this is exactly how our current government likes it.

Janieforever · 05/01/2024 14:03

Op of course it’s climate change, the world’s climate has changed for centuries. From ice ages on, it’s a natural phenomenon that has always, always occurred.

im always surprised when people ask is it climate change, like something weird and nefarious is going on, its really common knowledge the worlds climate changes, we study it at school , everyone knows for example about the ice ages, or how land masses have split apart, how it does this.

RampantIvy · 05/01/2024 14:02

Unabletomitigate · 05/01/2024 08:57

Poor land managament.
Poor water management.

There is not any more water than there used to be, but the land it is falling on has changed, and we have messed up the water cycle.

Have you been living under a rock?
We have had the wettest year since records began where I live.
The fields are so sodden that there is nowhere for the water to go.

Daftasabroom · 05/01/2024 13:58

BogRollBOGOF · 05/01/2024 08:59

Things can have more than one cause.

A lot of the disruption near me has been run-off from the fields overflowing on to roads. The way the land is used (now often equestrian rather than farmed) has changed, and drainage ditches by the hedgrows (and often poor management of those) aren't maintained mean that water rapidly flows off the fields, on to roads and the silt rapidly fills the drainage and suddenly where there used to be puddles are now outright floods requiring road closures.

There is a change in weather patterns, but at a local scale, it's often the way that land is used and managed (or not) that affects the direct impact.

There's the added complication that it rained pretty consistently for over month so land that would have absorbed the rain is water logged.

MandyMotherOfBrian · 05/01/2024 13:57

Well we’ve definitely had way more rain than usual here, it’s been insane the last week but tbh it’s been so much wetter than usual here since September. And that’s possibly climate change. However, a few months back (when it was still dryish) me and DH drove down a main route in to our nearest city and for long stretch every single drain at the side of the road had weeds growing out of them - some had quite large buddleias! I commented then I wonder if they were going to be cleared before winter - they weren’t. And another issue, I live rurally but right on the edge of the rural boundary with the coast one side and the encroaching town the other. Building is ever moving towards us and the latest huge housing estate has been built on what used to be an extensive golf course that meandered through an area of marshland. When it was a golf course they left the natural marsh drains where they naturally occurred. Now it’s been built over and they have attempted to move the drains and create manmade marsh drains at the edges of the housing estate. Nature doesn’t work that way though and so it’s unsurprising it’s flooding the roads and gardens 🤷‍♀️

EasternStandard · 05/01/2024 13:57

Although much less water than there used to be which might be happening in other countries doesn’t sound great either

Daftasabroom · 05/01/2024 13:55

Unabletomitigate · 05/01/2024 08:57

Poor land managament.
Poor water management.

There is not any more water than there used to be, but the land it is falling on has changed, and we have messed up the water cycle.

There's much more water than there used to be.

Angrymum22 · 05/01/2024 13:54

A huge flood defence scheme was built in Worcester about 15yrs ago. Businesses and commuters were all delighted that the main bridge would remain open even with the highest flood levels. Unfortunately some duck head got the calculations wrong and it ended up 2-3cm lower than designed, so the main roads still flood. Then they came up with the idea of raising the road which took 18mnths of traffic disruption.
For the actual amount of time the roads are closed it really wasn’t worth the disruption. It would have been far better to put in a new bridge at a point where the access road wouldn’t flood. For anyone who knows the area they actually did build a flood proof bridge but it was single carriageway. They recently completed a scheme to make it dual carriageway. Never has the phrase “do it well do it once” been more apt for Worcester Council.
Living in an area that floods regularly and has done for centuries, we haven’t managed to beat the record floods of the last century yet.
There is no denying that global warming is a thing but flooding will always be a problem if you live near a river or the sea. Water is a powerful beast and should always be given the greatest respect.

LakieLady · 05/01/2024 13:48

dutysuite · 05/01/2024 01:25

Blocked drains, the roads where I live are full of tarmac or leaves.

I suspect that cuts in road maintenance are part of the problem, too. The council used to clear the gullies on our rural roads twice a year, they've reduced it to once now. More rainfall and a reduction in the amount of drainage will inevitably lead to flooding.

Also more building. Fields soak up a fair amount of water. When you build houses, roads and business parks on them, the volume that can be absorbed is massively reduced.

Of course, this wouldn't matter if it wasn't so fucking wet, and I'm sure that's due to climate change. Autumns just seem to be wet now, the cold, frosty autumn mornings of my (1960s) childhood seem to be a thing of the past.

EasternStandard · 05/01/2024 13:46

AnneElliott · 05/01/2024 13:10

That wasn't the comment I was responding to @LightSwerve . A poster above claimed that local councils don't get central Government funding - they do. And I've posted the link to confirm it.

Really odd why people are so happy making bold claims that aren't just wrong but are easily to confirm through Google!

Yes local government funding from the central allocation has been reduced over a number of years. But their core spending power (ie total funding including council tax in one) hasn't been cut by 40% in real terms over that period.

The main issue with council funding is the huge increase in the costs of social care and the numbers of people needing it. We need as a county to have an urgent solution to that otherwise councils are going to be sustainable.

It’s going to be interesting when pp expect Labour will make these issues go away