Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be fed up with floods and think it's climate change?

185 replies

malificent7 · 05/01/2024 00:26

Live and work in Somerset. Can't get home due to floods. This is the 3rd time in 2 months that the commute has been dangerous. Aibu to think that this is climate change and to be scared and pissed off about it? Yes...i am a contributor to the oroblem. I know.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
EasternStandard · 06/01/2024 09:30

Trees help with flooding and excess heat if / when we get it again

We need those green spaces intact

cakeorwine · 06/01/2024 09:28

Building on flood plains
Putting down concrete instead of keeping gardens.

Not a good way to prepare for climate change induced flooding.

justasking111 · 06/01/2024 09:28

Farming practices haven't helped. Farmers were paid to pull up hedges, trees to create huge fields those helped so much to absorb water when it rained. There's been a u turn and they want farmers to create hedges and put in trees again. Neither are the farmers fault. They do as they're told

wranty · 06/01/2024 09:23

Also in somerset and both my parents live rurally. It's been frightening at times.
I've absolutely no doubt extreme weather plays a part but my dads neighbor got his tractor out and dug a ditch and the flooding there went down. There isn't adequate drainage. Where we live they are building on flood plains constantly, we know friends who are builders who have real concerns about it. None of this helps.
Bloody love Somerset tho.

SallyWD · 06/01/2024 09:08

Britpop123 · 05/01/2024 11:11

I think I naively thought that climate change deniers were pretty much dying out, a very small minority of people wilfully denying scientific facts and outliers.

im genuinely surprised there are so many on this thread. It’s baffling how people can still hold the position that climate change (man made) isn’t real

flooding wise, yes of course climate change is having an impact. This is exacerbated by the fact we should be improving drainage and flood defences is the face of this, but in a lot of areas it’s gone backwards.

It's completely bizarre, isn't it? And why? Why do they deny it? They trot out arguments like "The climate has always changed, there have always been periods of hotter or colder weather, it's natural". Oh wow! I'm sure the thousands of climate scientists have never considered this!!! It never occurred to them for one second! OF COURSE, they have compared the natural climate change to what we're experiencing now and they can very clearly see the difference between natural and man made climate change. I'm sick of this ignorance, of people completely ignoring years of science for some bizarre reason. Just to be contrary.

LightSwerve · 06/01/2024 09:07

SallyWD · 06/01/2024 09:03

My DH is a professor in climate change. You can't look at a single episode of flooding and say its climate change. However you can look at the general increase in flooding events and say that's climate change. Wetter winters and increased flooding is what climate scientists have been predicting for years.

Yes absolutely this.

People seem to struggle with the bigger picture - when there is a cold week in August the thickos say 'thought we were supposed to be having global warming' and use it as evidence that climate change isn't happening Hmm

LightSwerve · 06/01/2024 09:05

RampantIvy · 06/01/2024 08:40

Interestingly the stats on our local reservoirs are similar. What's going on?

Reservoirs are affected by water levels over a long period, we had a very dry winter last year (I think) which brought them very low.

Don't forget the Telegraph is a right-wing climate change-denying paper, so everything they ever publish must be read with that in mind.

SallyWD · 06/01/2024 09:03

My DH is a professor in climate change. You can't look at a single episode of flooding and say its climate change. However you can look at the general increase in flooding events and say that's climate change. Wetter winters and increased flooding is what climate scientists have been predicting for years.

RampantIvy · 06/01/2024 08:40

Andante57 · 06/01/2024 08:33

It has been raining in the West Country since October, with all the associated inconveniences.
Yet on New Year’s Eve the water levels in our two major reservoirs, Roadford and Colliton, were at 81 per cent and 72 per cent respectively. There is something wrong here.

This was a letter in the Telegraph today which I thought was interesting. Can anyone throw any light on it?

Interestingly the stats on our local reservoirs are similar. What's going on?

Andante57 · 06/01/2024 08:33

It has been raining in the West Country since October, with all the associated inconveniences.
Yet on New Year’s Eve the water levels in our two major reservoirs, Roadford and Colliton, were at 81 per cent and 72 per cent respectively. There is something wrong here.

This was a letter in the Telegraph today which I thought was interesting. Can anyone throw any light on it?

Wannabegreenfingers · 06/01/2024 08:26

Road side drains are the responsibility of of local government.

EasternStandard · 06/01/2024 06:26

I know people are expecting Labour to fix everything and make funding issues go away but reading this thread and huge and growing social care costs, increased flooding and expectation gov will pay up when it happens, and extra building I can’t see it looking good

Climate issues such as excess rain, flooding and really high state dependency generally, it’s all going to be hard.

Plus I assume insurance rates will be impacted at some point

VeryGoodVeryNice · 06/01/2024 06:13

I also live in Somerset and a large part of the problem is the fact that ditches aren’t maintained anymore. Farmers used to be paid by the government to keep them clear but thanks to spending cuts that doesn’t happen anymore. So there’s nowhere for water to run off the roads too.

myairpods · 06/01/2024 05:56

Of course it's climate change and particularly other countries emissions directly affecting us. Look at how many days of heavy rainfall we have had since December and tell me if that's normal and yes we are a rainy country but not every single day. Yes our infrastructure is pretty shit just as how it would be shit if there was heavy snowfall as we wouldn't cope but the country wasn't designed for heavy snow as we don't get it nor was it designed for 40 days of non stop heavy rain but now we are getting it more and more every year due to climate change.

CurrentHun · 06/01/2024 02:54

Of course it’s climate change.

Theunamedcat · 06/01/2024 02:52

We used to dredge we no longer do we don't really maintain our waterways

we build on floodplains and are surprised when they flood

cut down trees and are surprised when the banks collapse

Locally we diverted a river but we arnt maintaining the diversion its a sharp bend mud sticks causing the river to bottle up at that point pushing more mud up the sides we now have an island the river is forced around this island and its eroding the banks (they removed the trees holding them together) causing more mud to travel downstream causing more blocks downstream in ten years we have gone from a healthy river to a disaster waiting to happen

Plus flood barriers push trouble down

Cattenberg · 06/01/2024 02:38

AnneElliott · 06/01/2024 00:49

Business Rates are collected by the billing authorities @Cattenberg but it's not as simple as them keeping what they collect. There are both top up and tariff authorities plus the pools which mean what's collected in an area isn't the income received by the authority. And before the changes to business rates in 13/14 this collection still happened it's just the baseline for business rates wasn't a public number but determined each year in the settlement.

But what you're saying then is if you ignore NNDR then there are district councils that don't get RSG?

No idea about RSG to be honest. I took our Chief Exec at his word. I’d suggest you have it out with him, but he has moved on. I’m relieved that I’ve also moved on, as apparently our Unitary authority might yet be forced to issue a section 114 notice. Desperate times.

AnneElliott · 06/01/2024 00:54

No reason why your sources wouldn't be good enough for me @LightSwerve. If the ONS or similar organisation has published that number I'd be very interested to see it. I'm just reasonably confident that no one has published that, as local government funding is something I'm pretty knowledgeable about - but I'm always happy to learn.

It's fine to have views on local government funding and central government decisions but it's annoying when posters make sweeping statements with actual numbers in that they can't back up. As a finance person I always want to know where the number has come from.

AnneElliott · 06/01/2024 00:49

Business Rates are collected by the billing authorities @Cattenberg but it's not as simple as them keeping what they collect. There are both top up and tariff authorities plus the pools which mean what's collected in an area isn't the income received by the authority. And before the changes to business rates in 13/14 this collection still happened it's just the baseline for business rates wasn't a public number but determined each year in the settlement.

But what you're saying then is if you ignore NNDR then there are district councils that don't get RSG?

Gruffallowhydidntyouknow · 05/01/2024 21:42

Building fewer houses would be a big help too. Keep the countryside and trees and flood plains.

Cattenberg · 05/01/2024 21:17

AnneElliott · 05/01/2024 18:06

What District council did you work for @Cattenberg? I'm not aware of any Districts that don't get RSG or Business Rates but if you say who they are I can look them up on the DLUHC published pages and confirm that.

It might be outing for me to post the council name as I know a few of my former colleagues are MNers, but it was a former Somerset DC.

I never claimed that our council didn’t get Business Rates/NDR. Businesses pay these charges to the council directly, in a very similar way to Council Tax. This income doesn’t come from the government.

EasternStandard · 05/01/2024 19:43

RhiWrites · 05/01/2024 19:21

It’s because the Tories don’t invest in flood defences.

Here’s an article from 2016 warning about future problems.
https://amp.theguardian.com/environment/2016/jan/02/tory-cuts-wrecking-uk-flood-defences

and here’s one from last month about 40% cuts
https://amp.theguardian.com/environment/2023/nov/15/flooding-defence-protection-england-properties-cut-nao

This government is all about kick backs to big business and tax havens for oligarchs. It doesn’t care about infrastructure. Probably the cabinet of millionaires would enjoy living behind a moat.

Do you think Labour’s building plans will help though?

RhiWrites · 05/01/2024 19:21

It’s because the Tories don’t invest in flood defences.

Here’s an article from 2016 warning about future problems.
https://amp.theguardian.com/environment/2016/jan/02/tory-cuts-wrecking-uk-flood-defences

and here’s one from last month about 40% cuts
https://amp.theguardian.com/environment/2023/nov/15/flooding-defence-protection-england-properties-cut-nao

This government is all about kick backs to big business and tax havens for oligarchs. It doesn’t care about infrastructure. Probably the cabinet of millionaires would enjoy living behind a moat.

Revealed: how Tory cuts are wrecking UK flood defences | Flooding | The Guardian

Document seen by ministers before recent storms warns that number of at-risk households will double

https://amp.theguardian.com/environment/2016/jan/02/tory-cuts-wrecking-uk-flood-defences

thenarcissistssister · 05/01/2024 18:44

Macramepotholder · 05/01/2024 16:00

Erm Beavers aren't causing climate change! They're exacerbating the impact by adapting to human-made climate change which is forcing them to migrate north.

Poor beavers.

Erm, yes that’s what I said

LightSwerve · 05/01/2024 18:18

AnneElliott · 05/01/2024 18:10

Please post a link to a reputable source that confirms your assertion @LightSwerve. CSP has not been cut by 40% in real terms.

I'm also interested to know how you've accounted for the formula changes in 13/14 since that comparison is something we struggle with at work. If you have a source that calculates the changes since 2010 I'd be very genuinely interested in seeing it.

Oh I wouldn't think my sources would be good enough for you @AnneElliott

What we do all know just by being alive today is what I posted upthread, which I'll repeat just because I'm so cross with the bloody state of everything: Spending pressure/proximity to bankruptcy varies massively council to council, but what we can say with absolute certainty is the Tories have in 13 years almost destroyed local government by cutting their grants whilst doing fuck all about the social care crisis, and have transferred an increasing council tax burden to us all as an added insult.

Swipe left for the next trending thread