Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can anyone explain to me why some people feel so passionate about hating Harry and Meghan, or vice versa?

342 replies

whyptho · 04/01/2024 22:49

Why do people love Harry and Meghan and Hate William and Catherine so strongly. or the other way round?

I don't mean - what is their stated rationale for it, I mean what kind of psychology is behind this massive investment in total strangers?

The Dianna public grieving was a strange time, but it at least made sense - death of someone in the prime of her life, a huge loss to her family.

But why are some members of the general public so invested in picking sides in a family feud?

OP posts:
Roussette · 06/01/2024 10:12

@unbelieveable22

I agree. I was taken aback that, apart from one poster, no one even commented on the link.

This is the son and the grandson of the Monarch of the UK ... men jailed for wanting them executed and not a squeak on MN, apart from one poster. They had a podcast and a radio station and they called Archie 'a creature' who should be put down.

You only have to google it to see China, US, Europe reporting on it but on MN nowt.
Why?
It leads me to a very dark train of thought so I will leave it there.

unbelieveable22 · 06/01/2024 09:54

happyasaseagullstealingchips · 06/01/2024 00:31

@unbelieveable22 what does me defending Meghan and Harry tell you about how awful a person I am? It should have been front page and all over the internet, it wasn't.

I am not sure if you have misquoted me but I agree with you. My point was you put up a post drawing attention to Gibbons and Walsh and other than @Roussette not one other poster commented.
That may be shocking elsewhere but not here. It is par for the course. Oprah, Spare can be talked about ad infinitum but dare you mention the threats to kill Harry and Meghan, it's look and comment on anything else time.

If any poster described any child on any forum, especially a parenting forum, as an 'abomination that should be put down' there would be over 8,000 posts on here rightly condemning them. Instead we have over 8,000 posts on the way Meghan smiles. what Harry did or did not put in his book, what Omid wrote, the way Meghan flicks her hair, holds her hand, and on and on. When such statements as that above are ignored then those ignoring or deflecting are part of the problem. Shame on them all.

It's not as if Gibbons and Walsh were the first to be jailed or found guilty of threats against Harry, Meghan and family. There have been ongoing convictions for the past few years. Last one before Gibbons and Walsh was December 2023.

For those claiming there are two sides. I couldn't give a fiddlers about who people are, have no interest in any family but do care when I see someone being torn to shreds for being themselves. Yes, mistakes were made but who doesn't do that? It's not as if we are all perfect but perhaps some think they are.

CurlewKate · 06/01/2024 03:18

@KarenNotAKaren "To then have the fucking nerve to school others on racism when he himself displayed racist behaviour, is an absolute joke"

Funny how some people are forgiven their youthful follies and some aren't.

Snork11 · 06/01/2024 02:31

cardibach · 05/01/2024 22:34

So what you’re saying is you like W and K because the media tell you nice things about them and you dislike H and M because the media tells you bad things about them. Totally rational…
Also doesn’t answer the question in the OP.

What a weird way to read something.

As I identified, I live in the US and have not and do not ever expect to have a personal relationship or contact with anyone in the RF. Therefore, of course, the only knowledge I have of them is through media. That doesn't mean media tells me what to think, it just means what little I know of these personalities comes through facts reported in media. If you expect me to form an opinion based on personal knowledge of how they treat their butlers, I can't possibly have that. I'll venture to guess that people who do have that personal knowledge, aren't posting about it on Mumsnet (but I might be wrong).

In media, Kate and William carry themselves with poise and dignity and are generally feel-good news. Nothing to dislike there. In media, Harry and Meghan act as publicity hungry, insufferable, overprivileged whiners. In their own words and actions, they come across as shallow, self-absorbed and completely lacking awareness of their immense privilege. Mine, and as far as I know, the general reaction of my social circle to H&M's names popping up is a little like what I imagine the world feels when Florida pops up in the news - oh God, now what - followed by an eye roll. If they disappeared from the news, I'd never give them a second thought.

Thus, the short answer to the OP's question is that I don't know anyone in real life who cares to any appreciable extent but given that this thread is now 10 pages with some really passionate posters, it does appear that some people are crazy invested in personalities they've never met!

happyasaseagullstealingchips · 06/01/2024 00:31

@unbelieveable22 what does me defending Meghan and Harry tell you about how awful a person I am? It should have been front page and all over the internet, it wasn't.

happyasaseagullstealingchips · 06/01/2024 00:22

Maybe I wasn't very clear. I think it's disgusting that the case hasn't been reported on.

KarenNotAKaren · 05/01/2024 23:53

I would also like to point out that Harry - who let’s face it is the absolute epitome of white privilege - has himself portrayed very racist behaviour. Dressing as a Nazi was unforgivable IMO - I don’t care that he ‘spoke to a Rabbi’ after it, the fact he got away with it through the medium of being a ‘cheeky chappy’ is one thing. To then have the fucking nerve to school others on racism when he himself displayed racist behaviour, is an absolute joke

KarenNotAKaren · 05/01/2024 23:52

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 05/01/2024 22:30

More importantly why is there so much negativity towards H&M while Andrew Windsor seems to get a fee pass from the same people?

Who is Andrew Windsor?

Josette77 · 05/01/2024 22:37

But H and M have talked to the media. They have complained a lot from their own lips. It seems reasonable some people don't like them because of their own actions, nothing to do with the media.

Many people didn't like the Oprah interview. That was all them, not media interpretation.

cardibach · 05/01/2024 22:34

Snork11 · 04/01/2024 23:30

From the perspective of someone in the US, I hardly have an opinion on William and Kate, and what little opinion I have is favorable. They seem nice, they have adorable kids and every time I see them in the news it's inevitably a feel-good story of some kind. I'm a firm believer we need more feel good stories so, when I think about it more closely, I can say I like them, the way I like, say, pandas.

I don't hate Harry and Meghan. Hate is a strong word and seems like a waste of emotion, but I do find them immensely annoying, and really wish I never had to hear of them again. If they just stayed on their bazillion dollar compounds doing whatever it is vapid California celebrities do, I would not give them a second thought, but the news involving them get constantly shoved down my throat. I cringe instinctively when I see "Harry and Meghan" flash across my screen because I already know it's going to be another installment of pompous, annoying, self-involved, unaware, pretentious and totally fake whinging. Waaaaah, waaaaah, waaaaah.

So what you’re saying is you like W and K because the media tell you nice things about them and you dislike H and M because the media tells you bad things about them. Totally rational…
Also doesn’t answer the question in the OP.

cardibach · 05/01/2024 22:33

ItAintGonnaGoDownEasyIfItAintCheezy · 04/01/2024 23:47

In Harry and meagains case, it's because they are hypocrites, liars and scheming backstabbers.

How often do you meet them, to come to this conclusion?

Josette77 · 05/01/2024 22:33

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 05/01/2024 22:30

More importantly why is there so much negativity towards H&M while Andrew Windsor seems to get a fee pass from the same people?

Where do you see this? I don't know anyone who likes Andrew. Again I'm in Canada but everyone I know is grossed out by the whole thing.

It seems disingenuous to say people who don't like h and m are fine with a rapist.

Josette77 · 05/01/2024 22:31

I think given they have gone on Oprah, did a documentary, and he wrote a book, it's not surprising some people don't like them.

Yes you can argue none of us really know them, but they have gone out of their way to make themselves fairly known.

And some of the things they have said have rubbed people the wrong way. That's the nature of putting your business in the media.

They have not only put their own business out there, but they have handed his family over on a silver platter as well. I think a lot of people have trouble accepting him gossiping about his family.

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 05/01/2024 22:30

More importantly why is there so much negativity towards H&M while Andrew Windsor seems to get a fee pass from the same people?

KarenNotAKaren · 05/01/2024 22:21

Purplebunnie · 05/01/2024 18:34

My opinion, for what little it is worth, is that Harry didn't really prepare Meghan for well anything really. Shame as I thought they could be a real asset to the Royal Family

I agree with this. I was baffled when she complained that no one “on the institution” prepared her on how to be a Royal. If Oprah Winfrey was a half decent interviewer she’d have asked Harry why HE didn’t prepare her.

I suspect he didn’t because he didn’t want her to run a mile.

KarenNotAKaren · 05/01/2024 22:14

I’d find it hard to hate any celebrities. IME hate is very close to love and I don’t have those kind of feelings for people I don’t know.

But H&M are v annoying. The incessant whining from the over privileged millionaires is nauseating. I mean the man seriously sat there at almost 40 years of age and complained how daddy cut him off. Then he has the nerve to school others about white privilege. Prick. Meghan - she just comes across as very California, nothing wrong with that but a bad fit for the RF. she’s a victim of her husband not schooling her properly on royalty more than anything. I don’t think she’s a purposeful liar as such but in her USA Hollywood world, celebs embellish and exaggerate for entertainment purposes and she is clearly following that Kardashian style formula and got affronted when it turns out the RF weren’t about that.

Kate and William seem nice but terribly dull. But I suppose the any monarch-to-be SHOULD be dull and love an uneventful life. The Queen, dare I say it, was a little dull.

newnamethanks · 05/01/2024 22:03

Reported in Guardian. And maybe in the Mail?

Sisterpita · 05/01/2024 21:39

The Jeremy Clarkson article was vile. I have always said the media are racist, misogynistic and homophobic and I can understand why Meghan did not want them to have a photo of Archie.

Sadly social media allows people to say things they never would say face to face. Meghan and Kate have both had vile posts about them as sadly have a lot of women in the public eye.

Thank you for the article @Roussette, I am glad they were caught and jailed. You are correct the media haven’t reported this because it doesn’t suit their narrative.

MargaretThursday · 05/01/2024 21:25

And exactly the same thing has happened here as happens on most of the royal family threads in recent years, making the board pretty much unreadable. It's a pity because it would be nice to have had a reasonable discussion as this thread started out. It might have allowed both sides to get less nuanced views and try and understand others' pov.

It's like a klaxon is sounded:
A group of posters arrive at around the same time saying "I don't really support H&M; I only support them because how everyone else is nasty to them", backing each other up by either tagging @whoever or quoting whole posts with a clap or "I agree" at the end. Then you get the posts about what has been said in the past, linking newspaper articles and then saying "why aren't people talking about this?" because that isn't what the thread's about. Start your own separate thread about that if you want.

And that is why you get the impression that people love them or hate them. Because by taking an extreme view each group pushes the other further.
If both sides would stop the nastiness then you'd see far less of the extreme views.

ZebraDanios · 05/01/2024 21:13

GrouchyKiwi · 05/01/2024 19:25

And the editor thinking it was OK to publish that vile piece from Clarkson is also terrible.

And so many people being outraged when he was called out for it because “he’s allowed to say what he thinks”…

TheKeatingFive · 05/01/2024 19:50

And the editor thinking it was OK to publish that vile piece from Clarkson is also terrible.

Yup. And didn't Camilla have lunch with him a couple of weeks later?

GrouchyKiwi · 05/01/2024 19:25

TheKeatingFive · 05/01/2024 19:08

This is almost exactly what Jeremy Clarkson said about Meghan: “I hate her. Not like I hate Nicola Sturgeon or Rose West. I hate her on a cellular level.”

And then of course he went on to talk about imagining her being paraded through the streets naked while having shit thrown at her.

Exactly. This is just utterly weird.

What's behind this level of hatred for a women he hasn't met? And hasn't done anything even remotely criminal?

And the editor thinking it was OK to publish that vile piece from Clarkson is also terrible.

TheKeatingFive · 05/01/2024 19:08

This is almost exactly what Jeremy Clarkson said about Meghan: “I hate her. Not like I hate Nicola Sturgeon or Rose West. I hate her on a cellular level.”

And then of course he went on to talk about imagining her being paraded through the streets naked while having shit thrown at her.

Exactly. This is just utterly weird.

What's behind this level of hatred for a women he hasn't met? And hasn't done anything even remotely criminal?

CurlewKate · 05/01/2024 19:06

@Kalevala ". I just think it's sad that the focus was on the 'little boy' like it was perfectly fine for his brother to have been put in that position just because he was slightly older and looked like a young man."

I was the one that mentioned this-I said it was appalling for both of them. I think I used the word abusive. But this thread is about what made Harry the man he is today.

Kalevala · 05/01/2024 18:44

beguilingeyes · 05/01/2024 10:56

It was three years and I think there's quite a jump from 12 to 15. It was horrible for both of them though.

There's only two years and a couple of months between them. I just think it's sad that the focus was on the 'little boy' like it was perfectly fine for his brother to have been put in that position just because he was slightly older and looked like a young man.