Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can anyone explain to me why some people feel so passionate about hating Harry and Meghan, or vice versa?

342 replies

whyptho · 04/01/2024 22:49

Why do people love Harry and Meghan and Hate William and Catherine so strongly. or the other way round?

I don't mean - what is their stated rationale for it, I mean what kind of psychology is behind this massive investment in total strangers?

The Dianna public grieving was a strange time, but it at least made sense - death of someone in the prime of her life, a huge loss to her family.

But why are some members of the general public so invested in picking sides in a family feud?

OP posts:
NonPlayerCharacter · 06/01/2024 17:52

I want to know what they said (don't we all). They may not be the most in touch people in the world but I can't believe they wouldn't realise something like "ooh, hope the baby isn't too black" would be incredibly offensive.

Whatafustercluck · 06/01/2024 17:45

KarenNotAKaren · 06/01/2024 14:39

No I don’t like him. Why would I? He’s a racist and he has a loose grasp of the truth. I don’t care how posh or wealthy someone is, racist liars aren’t really my sort of folk.

Their claims of racism are so vague, it’s all about an unspecified remark by an unnamed individual. I don’t tend to wholly believe half-stories and I’m amazed at anyone who does. I’m even LESS likely to believe half stories of racism from someone who they themselves are racist and have a fondness for telling porkie pies.

I think a large part of the culture clash was to do with the fact she is American. She didn’t ‘get’ the RF - and why the hell would she, it’s really a very odd thing for a country to have - and they didn’t get someone so very outside of their aristocratic sphere. It was almost destined to fail. Which is a shame really - so many people were so happy when they got married. I don’t blame them for scarpering TBH, but if they’d just scarpered they wouldn’t be disliked. It’s the fact they (well, he) have left and then moaned for 4 years about it all. Between him and his uncle they’re an embarrassment, and I suspect the PR brief is leverage the less offensive members of the family for damage limitation.

I thought everyone now knew it was the now King and Princess of Wales who asked about the baby's skin colour. Lovely, wholesome Kate and the most sovereign man in the UK and commonwealth. How do you feel about them?

LutonBeds · 06/01/2024 17:17

squigglygiggly · 05/01/2024 17:36

Wow. His mother died in a horrific way and the media hounded him. If you think money saves people from all life's ills then you are of limited capacity

Of course it doesn’t but many, many people suffer similar to him. They have to carry on working etc though. There was a thread the other day about how much time off you got for a death in the family. I worked for a company where it was 1 day (wish I still had the handbook detailing this). There’s also one about a lady who is living in substandard housing and no one will do anything for her.

I have lived in substandard housing, nothing I could do and no one would help me. Money would have meant I had better housing choices and therefore better health. It was damp and mouldy and I was always ill with coughs/colds.

Money provides a very nice cushion, particularly when you have so much that you will never have to do a days work/worry about bills/having time off (some people won’t get paid until SSP kicks in).

KarenNotAKaren · 06/01/2024 15:56

@Roussette i must have missed that but then again I don’t hang around the RF boards, it’s a scary place 😂

BTW I meant whore not white in that post 🤦🏼‍♀️

Roussette · 06/01/2024 15:54

KarenNotAKaren · 06/01/2024 15:43

@AppleCrispMacchiato people on MN called Meghan Markle and slut and a white because she once wore a crop top? Really?

Im not saying her and all female members of the RF don’t experience outrageous sexism from the press but I’d be very surprised with such language on MN about clothing choices.

Edited

You haven't lived!

I've seen FAR FAR worse on here than that

KarenNotAKaren · 06/01/2024 15:50

x2boys · 06/01/2024 15:07

You know nothing about them or their relationship
And I don't think two years is rushing into anything
I married my dh,after being wit him just six months now that is rushing in!
I think some people are just desperate for their relationship to fail.

Unless your DH is the member of a world renowned high profile family that has a very specific set of archaic rules and customs, it’s not remotely the same.

KarenNotAKaren · 06/01/2024 15:49

Roussette · 06/01/2024 15:00

and a pretty bad husband. Partly because he was so desperate for the wife and kids that he rushed into it big time, in ways that were damaging for them both

Who are you to say that?
I rushed big time too, decades later, still married
I think he'd be a caring kind husband to Meghan. But I don't know. Nor do you

He certainly didn’t prepare her for what Royal life would look like. Not even close - she said herself she was totally unprepared. Why wouldn’t he help her? I think that’s being a very bad partner.

KarenNotAKaren · 06/01/2024 15:48

And I’ll say it now and dig it up in 15 years if I must - whoever George picks to be his life partner will be despised and hated by the press no doubt. I hope his family look out for him and have learnt from their experiences.

KarenNotAKaren · 06/01/2024 15:45

@thecatsthecats yrs people either didn’t notice of forget how much Kate was absolutely despised and had her every waking moment criticises in the press.

When a new woman came along to pick on, that’s only when the press stopped. IMO. The same way the hate for Camilla ceased when Kate came along.

At least for Kate and Camilla they kind of would have known to expect the hate. I bet Harry told Meghan she’d be adored the world over and glossed over the British press’s misogyny towards the RF.

KarenNotAKaren · 06/01/2024 15:43

@AppleCrispMacchiato people on MN called Meghan Markle and slut and a white because she once wore a crop top? Really?

Im not saying her and all female members of the RF don’t experience outrageous sexism from the press but I’d be very surprised with such language on MN about clothing choices.

KarenNotAKaren · 06/01/2024 15:41

x2boys · 06/01/2024 14:51

Is it only Harry you don't like being racist?
Is it ok that they expressed concerns about an unborn ,child's skin colour?
Or what about Prince Philips many many racist remarks over the years ?

Sorry…I’m confused…you want me to validate my anger about racism by listing all the people I find racist?? Do you always minimise the feelings of minorities this way?

I told you my feelings about the so-called skin colour discussion.

What I find disturbing is YOU are more concerned with an alleged private conversation, the details of which are entirely unknown, than you are with the fact a very prominent famous person made racist choices and remarks that had a real life impact on many, many people who already suffer enough. Why is that? I do feel like you’re trying to justify Harry’s racism. The fact his grandad was racist is neither here nor there.

thecatsthecats · 06/01/2024 15:31

x2boys · 06/01/2024 15:07

You know nothing about them or their relationship
And I don't think two years is rushing into anything
I married my dh,after being wit him just six months now that is rushing in!
I think some people are just desperate for their relationship to fail.

I don't want them to fail. On the long list of things I want or don't want, they don't feature. Which is not to say that as a person and a history graduate, I don't have an opinion.

And I know plenty of things about their relationship that are a matter of public record, or primary accounts from the couple themselves. So you're incorrect to say that I know nothing.

And a reminder - it doesn't matter if I'm wrong, you know. I'm in no way asserting that what I say is fact, or that my opinion is worth more or less than anyone else's.

Back to opinion - two years of mostly long distance dating is a rather short time to prepare to "hit the ground running".

x2boys · 06/01/2024 15:07

thecatsthecats · 06/01/2024 14:57

This is often cited, but I don't think it's a slam dunk case.

For one, Kate's deification by the press only came very late in her tenure, post-kids. Meghan simply didn't have the time to go through the (absolutely unfair) hazing that royal brides get.

Two, a fair few of those articles aren't strictly drawing negative inferences. They're just making comment.

Three, some of them come afterwards and in the context of, their departure from the Royal Family, so aren't why they left.

In general my headline attitude is that Harry is a messed up guy, an incredibly bad strategist, and a pretty bad husband. Partly because he was so desperate for the wife and kids that he rushed into it big time, in ways that were damaging for them both. And for Meghan, well I'm not a fan of the California yoga type, but her main crime is naivity followed by a persistent inability to see that there are two sides to every story.

You know nothing about them or their relationship
And I don't think two years is rushing into anything
I married my dh,after being wit him just six months now that is rushing in!
I think some people are just desperate for their relationship to fail.

thecatsthecats · 06/01/2024 15:06

Roussette · 06/01/2024 15:00

and a pretty bad husband. Partly because he was so desperate for the wife and kids that he rushed into it big time, in ways that were damaging for them both

Who are you to say that?
I rushed big time too, decades later, still married
I think he'd be a caring kind husband to Meghan. But I don't know. Nor do you

I'm a random human being on the internet. I experienced a severe burnout and mental health breakdown in 2021. I come from a family with very messy personal connections and fallouts.

And I look at Harry's own words and actions about the events and think he did a piss poor job of getting the best and happiest life for his wife. There are so many things he could have been smarter or more proactive about to help her (for example none of this hit the ground running nonsense).

That's an opinion, which as far as I'm aware I'm allowed to have, right or wrong. Argue with it if you like, but arguing with my right to have it is pretty daft.

Roussette · 06/01/2024 15:00

and a pretty bad husband. Partly because he was so desperate for the wife and kids that he rushed into it big time, in ways that were damaging for them both

Who are you to say that?
I rushed big time too, decades later, still married
I think he'd be a caring kind husband to Meghan. But I don't know. Nor do you

thecatsthecats · 06/01/2024 14:57

FrostJack · 05/01/2024 07:02

I mean, did you ever see this comparison of Meghan v's Kate press coverage where Kate is praised and Meghan is criticised for the exact same behaviour? It's ridiculous and blatant that they are just portrayed differently by the press, and that's a very big lens.

https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/ellievhall/meghan-markle-kate-middleton-double-standards-royal

This is often cited, but I don't think it's a slam dunk case.

For one, Kate's deification by the press only came very late in her tenure, post-kids. Meghan simply didn't have the time to go through the (absolutely unfair) hazing that royal brides get.

Two, a fair few of those articles aren't strictly drawing negative inferences. They're just making comment.

Three, some of them come afterwards and in the context of, their departure from the Royal Family, so aren't why they left.

In general my headline attitude is that Harry is a messed up guy, an incredibly bad strategist, and a pretty bad husband. Partly because he was so desperate for the wife and kids that he rushed into it big time, in ways that were damaging for them both. And for Meghan, well I'm not a fan of the California yoga type, but her main crime is naivity followed by a persistent inability to see that there are two sides to every story.

Roussette · 06/01/2024 14:55

@AppleCrispMacchiato

Your post is spot on. And let's not forget the dreadful threads when she actually did have Archie. His appearance was mocked endlessly, threads about how she didn't know how to read a book to him or carry him in a papoose. I am not talking about a couple of posts but thread after thread after thread. She was mocked and sneered at. So was Archie

I would like to repeat some of the disgusting things written about her but will refrain. I promise you, some of you would not believe what has been written in the past. And it was still ongoing on the vile endgame six threads

Do some people just enjoy hating?

x2boys · 06/01/2024 14:51

KarenNotAKaren · 06/01/2024 14:39

No I don’t like him. Why would I? He’s a racist and he has a loose grasp of the truth. I don’t care how posh or wealthy someone is, racist liars aren’t really my sort of folk.

Their claims of racism are so vague, it’s all about an unspecified remark by an unnamed individual. I don’t tend to wholly believe half-stories and I’m amazed at anyone who does. I’m even LESS likely to believe half stories of racism from someone who they themselves are racist and have a fondness for telling porkie pies.

I think a large part of the culture clash was to do with the fact she is American. She didn’t ‘get’ the RF - and why the hell would she, it’s really a very odd thing for a country to have - and they didn’t get someone so very outside of their aristocratic sphere. It was almost destined to fail. Which is a shame really - so many people were so happy when they got married. I don’t blame them for scarpering TBH, but if they’d just scarpered they wouldn’t be disliked. It’s the fact they (well, he) have left and then moaned for 4 years about it all. Between him and his uncle they’re an embarrassment, and I suspect the PR brief is leverage the less offensive members of the family for damage limitation.

Is it only Harry you don't like being racist?
Is it ok that they expressed concerns about an unborn ,child's skin colour?
Or what about Prince Philips many many racist remarks over the years ?

AppleCrispMacchiato · 06/01/2024 14:49

This thread is supposed to be about analysing the obsession that royals inspire in some people, so typical that it's turned into the trillionth thread about how awful Harry and Meghan are. Why? If you don't like them, just ignore them.

I've never seen any "hate" about William and Kate here even Andrew gets defended on here, the only iffy things about Kate have been threads about her weight. But you can't proffer even the mildest critical opinion without their fans getting outraged and mass reporting to try to censor anything critical.

Posters can call Meghan racial slurs and claim she used to be a prostitute, call her fans n**r and c*t and that's fine. But if you say "In my opinion William's low number of work engagements compared to the elderly members of his family means that he has a poor work ethic" all hell breaks lose.

I remember once a tabloid published a thing Meghan had done as a professional actress where she'd worn a white shirt tied up to reveal a bit of her midriff which of course generated in MN threads calling her a slut, a whore, an attention-seeker, unladylike, lots of unflattering comparisons to "ladylike and modest" Kate, and another poster posted something like "that's a bit rich considering Kate was papped topless on a balcony, and the magazine editor testified in court that they'd also taken footage of her giving William a outdoor blowjob" and another poster claimed to have reported them to the police for libelling Kate.

I remember someone starting a thread about Kate where the OP was something like, "I love Kate's style but I think it was a mistake for her to wear such expensive jewelry to meet NHS nurses, what do others thing?" and it was almost immediately deleted because it got mass reported. Yet the comment where a poster wrote the N word in all caps was up for more than 12 hours without a single person reporting it.

There's no way Harry or Meghan could win because the whole royal forum has been so thoroughly taken over by ardent pro-royalists.

KarenNotAKaren · 06/01/2024 14:39

x2boys · 06/01/2024 14:31

You clearly don't like Harry so have decided that everything he says is a lie
So because of your dislike of Harry have dismissed his concerns about his own family making racist remarks about his unborn child , I think your judgement is somewhat clouded

No I don’t like him. Why would I? He’s a racist and he has a loose grasp of the truth. I don’t care how posh or wealthy someone is, racist liars aren’t really my sort of folk.

Their claims of racism are so vague, it’s all about an unspecified remark by an unnamed individual. I don’t tend to wholly believe half-stories and I’m amazed at anyone who does. I’m even LESS likely to believe half stories of racism from someone who they themselves are racist and have a fondness for telling porkie pies.

I think a large part of the culture clash was to do with the fact she is American. She didn’t ‘get’ the RF - and why the hell would she, it’s really a very odd thing for a country to have - and they didn’t get someone so very outside of their aristocratic sphere. It was almost destined to fail. Which is a shame really - so many people were so happy when they got married. I don’t blame them for scarpering TBH, but if they’d just scarpered they wouldn’t be disliked. It’s the fact they (well, he) have left and then moaned for 4 years about it all. Between him and his uncle they’re an embarrassment, and I suspect the PR brief is leverage the less offensive members of the family for damage limitation.

x2boys · 06/01/2024 14:31

KarenNotAKaren · 06/01/2024 14:21

Well that goes for anything anyone says doesn’t it. I’m using my judgement and also a healthy dose of common sense.

Yes I am deeply concerned that Harry was glorifying Nazis (wether he meant to or not, he is a world renowned Prince and what he does matters, and that’s what he did) as a Jewish person. This was also at a time where Holocaust denial was starting to really take pace in society. It was racist, pure and simple. We all saw it. Jewish people were affected by it. An Alleged private family conversation with unknown members that may or may not have been racist, is NOT the same and shame on anyone who thinks it is. There’s also different accounts from H&M as to when this conversation happened - but I’m afraid I find it very difficult to believe someone took Harry aside and ‘expressed concern’ about the colour of his baby. This is a man with a history of making racist statements and a very loose grasp of the truth. Pardon me if I don’t jump to believe him or trust him.

You clearly don't like Harry so have decided that everything he says is a lie
So because of your dislike of Harry have dismissed his concerns about his own family making racist remarks about his unborn child , I think your judgement is somewhat clouded

KarenNotAKaren · 06/01/2024 14:31

TheKeatingFive · 05/01/2024 19:50

And the editor thinking it was OK to publish that vile piece from Clarkson is also terrible.

Yup. And didn't Camilla have lunch with him a couple of weeks later?

No, they were at the same event a few days before.

AppleCrispMacchiato · 06/01/2024 14:30

unbelieveable22 · 06/01/2024 12:25

Yet another personal attack on @Roussette .

I notice the claims about sides come from certain posters.
It seems to be acceptable to post about all aspects of Harry, Meghan and their family life , everything but real reason they had to leave the UK. The deflections continues.

Exactly. If you say anything that's positive or even neutral about Meghan you get insane levels of abuse and bullying, literally followed around Mumsnet with nasty attacks made on everything you post until you name change. That's not normal, that's psychotic.

This is not about posters behaviour on here and I don't remember anyone being called that horrible term, nor would I have laughed at it. Why would I laugh at someone being called the c word?

I don't know what the deleted post said but the only time the C word has been said in Royal Chat has been against Meghan and Meghan fans. There used to be a black poster who used to defend Meghan and she was called both the C word and the N word on here and ultimately was bullied away from Mumsnet.

The hate is just disproportionate to any level of annoyance that a reasonable person might feel for Meghan. It's not normal to create 50 sockpuppet accounts to keep spreading hate against a celeb you've never met, it's not normal to call strangers online ct and n*r just because they object to using racial smears.

The year Harry and Meghan met, there were over 15 separate threads about the "allegation" that Meghan was a prostitute and that there was a sex tape of her that the royals had covered up. Hundreds of racists comments about Doria and that one racially-charged conspiracy theory that the haters were pushing about Doria. People forget or are pretending to forget how off the scale the racism and hate were during their engagement and marriage, and pretend the dislike is due to their actions since leaving. Actually Meghan is much less hated since she left, though Harry is more hated.

The threads on here when Meghan was pregnant with Archie were the worst I've ever seen on Mumsnet, ever.

KarenNotAKaren · 06/01/2024 14:29

cardibach · 06/01/2024 11:34

@Snork11 you wrote In media, Kate and William carry themselves with poise and dignity
And you honestly can’t see that that’s the media presentation? You only see them behave like that because that’s all you are shown.

I don’t think William and Kate are swearing, being loutish and smoking fags in front of cameras and the media just aren’t showing it.

The RF press team book photo opps, various bland members turn up in pretty clothes, kiss babies and behave blandly, then go home.

William and Kate understand the ‘be bland’ brief and they’re consistent. I’m sure, like any celebrity, their persona behind closed doors is different but really who gives a shit. I don’t want to get to know the personalities of the RF personally, they aren’t celebs in the traditional fashion, they’re advocates for an institution that had an expiry date, and if they want that date to be a long one they needs to glide by being inoffensive. Harry can afford to not quite abide by that sentiment but his brother certainly can’t

KarenNotAKaren · 06/01/2024 14:24

Suddenlychrimbo · 06/01/2024 12:03

Culture wars stirred up by tabloid scum like the 'Mail Online'.

No-one should care as it really doesn't affect any of us.

However, I'll say this..I only have to think of those smirking women blanking Meghan Markle as she went over to thank the crowd at the Queens funeral to get a feeling of rage.

Such a petty, pathetic act..really embarrassing and unnecessary.

Which smirking women?

I don’t think Meghan Markle thanked any crowds at the Queen’s funeral? It would have been extremely inappropriate and she’s doesn’t come across as having bad manners.