Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can anyone explain to me why some people feel so passionate about hating Harry and Meghan, or vice versa?

342 replies

whyptho · 04/01/2024 22:49

Why do people love Harry and Meghan and Hate William and Catherine so strongly. or the other way round?

I don't mean - what is their stated rationale for it, I mean what kind of psychology is behind this massive investment in total strangers?

The Dianna public grieving was a strange time, but it at least made sense - death of someone in the prime of her life, a huge loss to her family.

But why are some members of the general public so invested in picking sides in a family feud?

OP posts:
FrostJack · 05/01/2024 06:50

From a UK perspective: It's because the mainstream press paints them as absolute villains who want to bring down the royal family and spoilt cry babies every single day. I only see the front pages when I go to the supermarket and I'm honestly shocked at how much negative attention they get, despite doing very little. Many of the public buy this without question as it's like pantomime. It gets repeated as click bait and on social media. Splash in a bit of good old fashioned dog whistle racism with this, because how dare exotic Meghan cast her evil spell and charms on 'our' once innocent Prince Harry.

Why does the mainstream press do this?

Because Harry has taken them on and won in the High Court of England and Wales and proved that there was extensive and illegal phone hacking for the last few decades. He's got enough money and intense dislike of the British press to do this (R.I.P Diana) when tens, if not hundreds of other celebrities and normal people have had to settle with the press and not go all the way to a public High Court hearing as the financial risk is too high. The press hate him for this. If you haven't heard of this then it's because the mainstream press don't report on their own losses in court.

Harry and Meghan have been villified more than serial killers in the UK, if you compare daily coverage and column inches. We're just used to the press creating villains in the UK and people don't question it, because it's not that important in real life.

Jessiepaintyourpicture · 05/01/2024 06:48

People who are dissatisfied with their own lives relish the opportunity to rage against a common foe with other malcontents.

I think H&M have behaved badly so I ignore them but go on the Royal Family board and it's like the Daily Mail comments section. People absolutely frothing about two people that have no impact on their lives. It's sad.

I do like Kate with her swishy hair and gorgeous children. She looks like she really loves being a princess and a mum 🙂

AnonyLonnymouse · 05/01/2024 06:44

I really liked Meghan at the outset: strong, independent and well-educated.

I found it very peculiar that there were no friends or family members from her formative years, especially close female friends, at her wedding. These people know us in a way that later friends may not. Even if people don’t show a perfect image, a wedding is a time to be generous and include all those who genuinely wish you well.

I think Meghan was given a horrible time by the press and those who perpetrated it should be ashamed of themselves.

I thought the Oprah interview and the Netflix documentary were big mistakes and Meghan was very unfair in what she said about some members of the Royal Family, knowing that they had no ability to reply.

She has sensibly stayed pretty quiet in the last year or so and so has slightly risen again in my estimation for doing so. But I suspect that the story isn’t over and she will be the centre of news again at some point.

Kate seems pretty sensible and well rounded, not ever putting a foot wrong. I don’t think that anyone particularly believes that she treated Meghan badly (the lack of reaction to the racism leaks is a case in point), but they are quite different personalities and weren’t ever going to be close.

That’s all really, no strong feelings.

Isittimeformynapyet · 05/01/2024 06:34

QueenMegan · 05/01/2024 01:17

The media feed a polarised view of normal. Gossip scandal and rivalry sells. Its biblical.
They have no idea what the real RM are like.
Kate is very precious and her voice is so fake and Will is such a moody Minnie like his father. I am sincere but they refused to accept me. Fuck them🖕

What is RM?

GeckoEcho · 05/01/2024 06:19

They need a focus for their hatred and discontent with their own lives.

The media generously provide them with a range of targets to choose from (Harry and Meghan, XL bullies, Russia, a darts sensation's girlfriend....).

Now go forth and froth!

merrymelodies · 05/01/2024 06:19

You're being disingenuous, OP. 🙄

Thirdsummerofourdiscontent · 05/01/2024 06:14

I don’t like Harry purely because he broke the golden rule I actually agree with. - you don’t air your dirty laundry in public. I don’t like the kardashians or most reality tv either.

Kalevala · 05/01/2024 06:12

CurlewKate · 05/01/2024 04:37

@LutonBeds Personally, I'd abolish the lot of them tomorrow. But nobody who was around at the time can unsee that forlorn little boy walking behind his mother's coffin under the eyes of millions because that's what protocol demanded. I think that might scar a person....

I didn't think William was much older?

HellsToilet · 05/01/2024 06:10

I don't really follow it all but in general if the Daily Mail hates someone, I support them.

Bestyearever2024 · 05/01/2024 06:00

I really admire what Harry is doing in the Courts re phone tapping.

I wish he hadn't married Meghan because its all gone to shit since then and I loved watching William Kate and Harry being such good friends (I know, I'm an old softie)

I think the William and Kate touchy feely holdy handsy look William DID NOT have an affair act, is a bit 🤮 because I think he probably DID have an affair (whoops, not such an old softie, more of an old gossip!)

I get very very very bad vibes from Meghan. I so want to like her - strong vaguely black woman, intelligent yada yada, but I think she's nasty, jealous and very unpleasant

I loved the Queen. Adored her.

Can't stand Charles or Camilla and was a huge Diana fan.

So there we are

🙂

BethDuttonsTwin · 05/01/2024 05:46

LaurieStrode · 05/01/2024 03:26

I think some people who were pro H&M at the time of the wedding now feel hoodwinked.

This. I think they always planned to leave and told a load of fibs, related to current popular ideas around identity and “trauma” to smooth that path. It feels manipulative and most people don’t like being manipulated.

I am not a fan, though don’t hate them or anything and they’ve hardly been in the press over the last couple of weeks so haven’t given them much thought. It’s the silly pap strolls and claims of lethal car chases that piss people off. I don’t think they have enough talent and glamour to be the kinds of figureheads they clearly want to be and the constant playing the victim is so tired now. If they went quiet I don’t think people would care anymore.

As for W&C - I love Kate’s frocks, the kids are cute and they seem to just get on with stuff without whinging too much. That’s it really.

CurlewKate · 05/01/2024 04:37

@LutonBeds Personally, I'd abolish the lot of them tomorrow. But nobody who was around at the time can unsee that forlorn little boy walking behind his mother's coffin under the eyes of millions because that's what protocol demanded. I think that might scar a person....

LutonBeds · 05/01/2024 04:32

Harry had a horrible life 😂. Yeah, must be really difficult having access to all that money and privilege; never worrying about the costs of your mortgage/gas bill/petrol, having access to the best education money can buy, even though you’ll never have to work a day in your life. Literally being able to do whatever, whenever. Yeah, really horrible 🙄.

TroglodytesTroglodytes · 05/01/2024 04:26

Given that the wealth and privilege is publicly funded, they are not wholly private individuals. Therefore some people will not have any boundaries when offering up opinion on the royals. Even so, some of the hate on social media towards Harry and Meghan is bizarre.

The Royals are used to people bowing and scraping to them, they are indulged but have an extraordinary amount of attention. It’s not that surprising that this environment produces some deeply flawed characters. William and Kate (and the rest of the family) have a palace PR machine managing the publics opinion of them. Harry no longer has that so people have been able to see the real him. Firstly, he is isn’t bright. Secondly, due to his strange life and traumatic experiences he is not a balanced individual. He isn’t coming across well when left to his own devices.

Nofilteritwonthelp · 05/01/2024 04:07

Probably because they have no life 🤷🏼‍♀️

LaurieStrode · 05/01/2024 04:07

OlympicProcrastinator · 05/01/2024 03:54

I think most people are idiots and can’t believe anyone actually thinks they know anything about the situation enough to have any sort of opinion. They are complete strangers. We are only given biased, inaccurate information from press with a vested interest. How anyone forms an opinion based on that is beyond me.

Well, their own words are readily available. Spare, Oprah, their PR.

They have numerous platforms including that so-called documentary.

LaurieStrode · 05/01/2024 04:05

Agree, @FishBowlSwimmer

I championed them but the Oprah interview was the turning point.

FishBowlSwimmer · 05/01/2024 04:02

My interest started out as purely academic from a historical point of view. I'm interested in the current RF because I'm fascinated by Royal history. I actually spent a lot of time defending Meghan on the DM comment section right up until Oprah. I was sympathetic towards them both, but especially towards Meghan and how difficult it must be to fit in to an institution like the RF. Oprah just showed me they had no respect for the UK, the RF or the public. Had no appreciation for the massively privileged position they had, no respect for those who continue to do what they found so difficult. These were words from their own mouths that changed my opinion.

Catherine and William I quite like, they seem, humble, polite and respectful. I'm not a huge fan but I don't think they have done anything wrong.

OlympicProcrastinator · 05/01/2024 03:54

I think most people are idiots and can’t believe anyone actually thinks they know anything about the situation enough to have any sort of opinion. They are complete strangers. We are only given biased, inaccurate information from press with a vested interest. How anyone forms an opinion based on that is beyond me.

CurlewKate · 05/01/2024 03:45

They are often the same people who still defend Andrew. That I find truly baffling. If anyone brought the royal family into disrepute...,.,

LaurieStrode · 05/01/2024 03:26

I think some people who were pro H&M at the time of the wedding now feel hoodwinked.

AppleCrispMacchiato · 05/01/2024 02:56

LyingHereListening · 05/01/2024 01:44

I don’t know anyone in real life who has strong feelings either way about any of those 4. It’s only on mumsnet that I see the love and hate. I presume they’re trolls as it’s so weird how involved they get about people they don’t know.

Yeah, I agree. I think most of the Meghan hate is just a small number of mentally ill people using dozens if not hundreds of different accounts and usernames, which is being unfortunately ramped up and amplified by racists.

There was some study or survey that showed that several hundred anti-Meghan Twitter accounts were all owned by the same small handful of obsessed fans.

There was one poster on Mumsnet who bragged about having been banned more than dozen times for racially abusing Meghan, and bragged that she kept creating new email accounts so she could keep registering new accounts, because she was so determined to keep proselytising Meghan-hate. It really is like a religion to them.

There've been a few times when someone has started a Meghan thread at 1am or something and within minutes a dozen different usernames will all post identically worded rants about how terrible she is, making personal attacks on anyone who defends her. It's really obvious that there's a lot of sockpuppeting going on.

I remember back when Meghan was pregnant with Archie, there was an interesting thread here where someone had discovered that many of the same anti-Meghan threads had been copy pasted to a bunch of other forums. I don't mean that posters on those other forums had copy and pasted a thread from Mumsnet, I mean the OP had written some screed about why they didn't like Meghan, or the latest negative thing about Meghan, then spammed the same post to every forum and blog they could find. That's not someone who happens to find her a bit annoying, that's Mark David Chapman like levels of obsession.

I don't understand what they hope to achieve.

AppleCrispMacchiato · 05/01/2024 02:39

Meghan-hate is essentially a cult. People find belonging and communitas, and a sense of purpose. If you look at some of the stuff on Twitter and Tumblr, the more extreme elements act like they're fighting some kind of righteous war against a dangerous enemy, and that one day they'll 'win' and prove that Meghan is evil or whatever and Harry will renounce her and come home with his tail between his legs, and Meghan will be destroyed either lose her children or be exposed as having faked her pregnancies and the children aren't real. Some of the Meghan haters are even convinced that their campaigns will result in Meghan going to prison for treason! Just delusion and mental illness. It's very similar to the Benedict Cumberbatch "truthers" who obsessively stalk and hate his wife, and are convinced that they'll out her as a pregnancy-faking famewhore and that their Tumblr blogs will result in her going to prison.

It's some deep rooted psychological problem that causes women to become fixated on the wives and girlfriends of famous men.

It says everything that a thread asking why people are so obsessed with hating celebs immediately fills up with posters ranting about how terrible and awful Meghan is and attempting to justify the hate against her. (Which clearly isn't true, as the hate on Mumsnet was at its height during their engagement, before any of her supposed sins even happened.)

Most of the posters who have defended her in the past her aren't even fans of Meghan, just horrified by the extreme obsessive hate (and the frequent overt racial abuse) that has been aimed at Meghan on this forum ever since they first started dating. It's not a two-way thing, lovers and haters. It's entirely one-sided, hate and people horrified by hate.

I bet anything that within 24 hours this thread will be 20 pages of posters ranting about dreadful Meghan is and listing everything she's ever done wrong while simultaneously claiming not to hate her.

TempestTost · 05/01/2024 02:27

I tend to think it's the kind of people who get invested in celebrities in general.

In some cases the Meghan and Harry fans seem to be using them as a sort of signal for having certain values. They defend them because they see them as oppressed by the man for evil reasons.

I don't see many so attached to William and Kate, more like they like them because they hate Meghan and Harry.

MintJulia · 05/01/2024 02:15

It's the self indulgent, pity-me, attention seeking that I find so distasteful.

We all have good things and bad things in our lives. Most of us cope with them, on a great deal less income, and while actually working for a living.

I can't say I hate H&M, or think about them from one month to the next, but they are pretty embarrassing.