Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adult child not wanting to pay their way

491 replies

Cazzalou · 04/01/2024 20:23

18 months ago my daughter spilt up from the BF and moved back home with me.
We agreed that she would pay £500 a month for rent and bills. We live in London.
Now she and BF are back together and are hoping to buy somewhere out in Kent.
She would like to reduce her monthly payments to £300 a month so she can save for the deposit on a new home.
This could take a long time.
Should I agree the reduction or keep it at £500?
Is daughter taking me for a ride?
I'm an almost retired nurse and my monthly income has reduced as I have reduced my working hours to 30 per week.
Am I being mean if I say no?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Teder · 05/01/2024 19:00

I wish I had parents like some of you. I’d just rock up back “home” and announce “I’m still your child” and I could be living the high life!

coffeeaddict77 · 05/01/2024 18:58

verdantverdure · 05/01/2024 18:51

So if you added another person you'd need to charge them £250 then? Is that what you're saying @coffeeaddict77?

What if they ate more than you? Or different stuff to you? And the shopping bill went up? What if they cooked more than you?

What if they took baths more than you? Took much deeper baths than you? Stayed in there for ages topping up with hot water? Showered in the morning AND took baths at night?

What if they were at home using energy more than you? Or at different times to you so the heating was on for more hours. What if they liked the heating up hotter than you do? Used the dryer more than you do? Did laundry more than you? Changed their towels and sheets more often than you,

Had a visitor round eating and bathing about 12 days a month?

What if the person left things running and using energy more than you do,

What if the home in question is bigger than yours, draughtier than yours? And costs more to heat than yours?

And you lost the single person discount on your council tax?

It's £500 a month for you two to live exactly as you do. Other people's circumstances vary and lots of little additions mount up.

If she is eating different food to OP she is probably buying it herself. Regardless, I didn't say I would charge them £250. I would look at shopping bills and energy costs and compare to before she moved in before deciding but I would be very surprised if one person costs 500 extra.

verdantverdure · 05/01/2024 18:51

So if you added another person you'd need to charge them £250 then? Is that what you're saying @coffeeaddict77?

What if they ate more than you? Or different stuff to you? And the shopping bill went up? What if they cooked more than you?

What if they took baths more than you? Took much deeper baths than you? Stayed in there for ages topping up with hot water? Showered in the morning AND took baths at night?

What if they were at home using energy more than you? Or at different times to you so the heating was on for more hours. What if they liked the heating up hotter than you do? Used the dryer more than you do? Did laundry more than you? Changed their towels and sheets more often than you,

Had a visitor round eating and bathing about 12 days a month?

What if the person left things running and using energy more than you do,

What if the home in question is bigger than yours, draughtier than yours? And costs more to heat than yours?

And you lost the single person discount on your council tax?

It's £500 a month for you two to live exactly as you do. Other people's circumstances vary and lots of little additions mount up.

coffeeaddict77 · 05/01/2024 18:39

verdantverdure · 05/01/2024 18:29

Things tend to be more expensive in London @coffeeaddict77 Food, rent, internet, plumbers, insurance, service charges in blocks of flats, everything.

OP hasn't said she pays rent. She may well own the house outright if near retirement. Regardless it is a bill she was paying before her daughter moved in and she will be paying it afterwards so not an extra cost. Same with insurance, Internet, service charges., plumbers. Food, gas, electricity are extra costs but not much different to the rest of the country.

DillDanding · 05/01/2024 18:39

I’d far rather help them save for a deposit unless you’re desperate for the money.

coffeeaddict77 · 05/01/2024 18:32

verdantverdure · 05/01/2024 18:21

Depending on the details I think it's quite possible for the OP to be making a loss.

Prices have increased rather a lot in the last 18 months since this amount was agreed.

Really? DH don't spend much more than 500 pounds for food, electricity and gas between us so hard to see how one person can cost 500 pounds extra.

verdantverdure · 05/01/2024 18:29

Things tend to be more expensive in London @coffeeaddict77 Food, rent, internet, plumbers, insurance, service charges in blocks of flats, everything.

coffeeaddict77 · 05/01/2024 18:28

LuckySantangelo35 · 05/01/2024 18:18

@Shouldistayorshouldi

well not really - If she was in a shared house in that area she would be paying more than double what her mum is asking for. shes got a sweet deal - come on, admit it!!?

It's not a shared house though. OP hasn't said she pays a mortgage and it is quite possible she owns the property outright if close to retirement. The daughter living there will be adding to food and energy costs but charging more will mean she is profiting from her child.

verdantverdure · 05/01/2024 18:24

Shouldistayorshouldi · 05/01/2024 18:08

Yes you are being very mean. And she is certainly “paying her way”.

Then the daughter is perfectly free to go and pay £1000+ a month for a single room somewhere in a house of multiple occupancy.

The mum has already saved her thousands over the last 18 months. The big meanie.

verdantverdure · 05/01/2024 18:21

coffeeaddict77 · 05/01/2024 18:03

I would only charge her for the extra costs which can't be more than £300. I wouldn't try and make money out of my own children, especially nowadays when it is so hard to buy a property.

Depending on the details I think it's quite possible for the OP to be making a loss.

Prices have increased rather a lot in the last 18 months since this amount was agreed.

coffeeaddict77 · 05/01/2024 18:20

Ger1atricMillennial · 05/01/2024 18:09

For inclusive of bills this is a very small amount. Especially in London.

How would the extra costs be as much as 500 pounds and what difference does it make that she is in London?

babyproblems · 05/01/2024 18:20

I’ll be honest and say I think it’s a bit mean of you. I’m assuming you managed when she was living away before so unless you’re planning on a lodger I don’t see why you would insist she pays you £500. If she’s only saving 200 a month anyway it will take years and years and years. Even with two of them saving that it would still take years. I would be inclined to support her in the house purchase if you can afford to. If you can’t, well it’s different. If it’s just to teach her a lesson etc then I don’t think this is the time to teach it!

LuckySantangelo35 · 05/01/2024 18:18

Shouldistayorshouldi · 05/01/2024 18:08

Yes you are being very mean. And she is certainly “paying her way”.

@Shouldistayorshouldi

well not really - If she was in a shared house in that area she would be paying more than double what her mum is asking for. shes got a sweet deal - come on, admit it!!?

coffeeaddict77 · 05/01/2024 18:18

facepalmdaily · 05/01/2024 17:59

If you don't need or rely in the money then I'd still take the £500 but put £200 of it away for her. That way you know it's there for its future intended purpose.

Don't you think it a bit infantalising to save money for a 26 year old rather than let them save it themselves? She is a teacher so presumably is quite grown up and sensible.

Lookingforward01 · 05/01/2024 18:16

I don't think you are being a doormat charging £500 a month for your daughter to live in the family home. Times are hard for young people trying to get on in life.

That being said, if you are struggling financially, I think it is fine to communicate that. If not, I'd happily accept £300 (not including food).

Ger1atricMillennial · 05/01/2024 18:09

Middleagedspreadisreal · 05/01/2024 18:05

No, not a 40 year old. But £500 seems a huge amount for any age

For inclusive of bills this is a very small amount. Especially in London.

Shouldistayorshouldi · 05/01/2024 18:08

Yes you are being very mean. And she is certainly “paying her way”.

Ger1atricMillennial · 05/01/2024 18:07

Think of it this way, if you reduce it under the guise of helping her save, you will then become hyper-aware of how she spends her money.

500 is a good amount that has worked well and she is technically saving money because you haven't put it up in line with all the other rental properties.

coffeeaddict77 · 05/01/2024 18:07

Kisskiss · 05/01/2024 18:01

I think it depends on the situation really, I’m this case maybe a bit harsh on the OP as she doesn’t sound able to really help her daughter who is earning more than her.

I think people are confusing the idea of “helping family” with “parents helping kids”… it probably should be that the party who is able helps the other - so parents help their student age children and adult children help their retired parents.

in this case both parties seem quite financially balanced- one owns an asset and the other has higher income, so presumably nobody needs to subsidise anybody.( And 500/mth actually is a massive subsidy. You pay more to live in tiny sh!tty student dormitories in london)
In some cultures you actually start giving your parents money when you start earning a wage, even if you don’t live with them!

Not sure how you work out they are financially balanced. If OP has owned property in London for a few years she will have an asset worth a lot of money, and most of that will be due to luck.

Welshphoenix · 05/01/2024 18:06

EF2021 · 05/01/2024 17:40

@Flamingogirl08 this! It genuinely boggles my mind how many people are reluctant to help their own kids. It’s not like she’s living there rent free. London also impacts the daughter too, her own outgoings will be higher, just because she would struggle to rent somewhere else for that amount does not mean it’s the right thing to do.

I personally think kids these days need all the help they can get. And the comment below saying “it doesn’t prepare them for life” is a ridiculous one. Wanting your children to struggle so that they are used to struggling when out on their own is abhorrent. This older generation need to own their privilege that they were able to buy a home. Pretty sure they’re gonna be the same generation that moan their kids don’t visit in their old age then wonder why :/.

Im 33 and a homeowner before anyone says anything. I wasn’t helped by parents or lived anywhere rent free. I did it the hard way, which is precisely why I will be helping my kids out as much as possible.

This is all well and good if it is affordable to you. The difference between someone who is keeping their head above water and then taking in an adult whether their child or not is enormous in costs. In my job I watch parents of adult children lose their home because they can't pay the rent or mortgage whilst their earning kids live for free or next to nothing because they are "their kids." Children need to learn fiscal responsibility and that comes from paying their way. I have seen judges call such children in to court and give them a right dressing do n for being so inconsiderate. So yes they need to save but saving comes after paying their living costs not at the expense of their parents

LuckySantangelo35 · 05/01/2024 18:05

Do people really truly honestly believe that parents should live on beans on toast or whatever to allow their adult children to live with them rent free?!

what if said adult child earned 80k per year and you earned 25k would you still see it as your duty to feed and house them for free?!

Middleagedspreadisreal · 05/01/2024 18:05

No, not a 40 year old. But £500 seems a huge amount for any age

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 05/01/2024 18:04

Wrong person. Was meant for whoever said they charge their kids for private educatikn

Ger1atricMillennial · 05/01/2024 18:03

500 a month is totally fair considering that the boyfriend is staying some night too.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 05/01/2024 18:03

Ponderingwindow · 05/01/2024 17:59

School and big ticket items were your responsibility. Landscaping etc, your responsibility.

I’m support teaching young adults responsible budgeting by charging real rent, but this is ridiculous.

Do you cost in their births and cost of midwives too?