Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adult child not wanting to pay their way

491 replies

Cazzalou · 04/01/2024 20:23

18 months ago my daughter spilt up from the BF and moved back home with me.
We agreed that she would pay £500 a month for rent and bills. We live in London.
Now she and BF are back together and are hoping to buy somewhere out in Kent.
She would like to reduce her monthly payments to £300 a month so she can save for the deposit on a new home.
This could take a long time.
Should I agree the reduction or keep it at £500?
Is daughter taking me for a ride?
I'm an almost retired nurse and my monthly income has reduced as I have reduced my working hours to 30 per week.
Am I being mean if I say no?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
spriots · 05/01/2024 19:33

coffeeaddict77 · 05/01/2024 19:30

OP doesn't mention her dd is expecting really expensive food or even that she is buying all the food and the extra council tax won't be that high given it is 25%.

She equally doesn't say she isn't?

It's all speculation but it's certainly not out of the realm of possibility that £500 is the actual cost.

spriots · 05/01/2024 19:31

spriots · 05/01/2024 19:24

I don't find it at all hard to believe that these are the extra costs - it depends. If the council tax is high, the DD has expensive food tastes etc

To illustrate this - average grocery bill for two people is about £350 a month, adding in some extra for feeding the boyfriend, it's quite likely the cost of the food alone for DD + BF is £200/month

https://www.nimblefins.co.uk/average-uk-household-cost-food

Then add on £50 a month for the extra council tax.

Then utilities which vary a lot depending on how well insulated your house is/your usage, then wear and tear on your home costs, could easily be £500 in total

Average UK Household Cost of Food 2023

The average UK household spends £82.6 on the weekly shop and £31 on takeaways and eating at restaurants each week. Learn more about UK food bills per week, per month, per person and for larger families.

https://www.nimblefins.co.uk/average-uk-household-cost-food

coffeeaddict77 · 05/01/2024 19:30

spriots · 05/01/2024 19:24

I don't find it at all hard to believe that these are the extra costs - it depends. If the council tax is high, the DD has expensive food tastes etc

OP doesn't mention her dd is expecting really expensive food or even that she is buying all the food and the extra council tax won't be that high given it is 25%.

Firefly1987 · 05/01/2024 19:30

mottytotty · 05/01/2024 09:44

So you’re saying because I paid my mum £300 a month once I got a full time job, I should now go no contact with her?

The woman who gave birth to me, loved me, protected me, and cooked for me should just be dismissed as a nobody because she didn’t let me live rent free in her home?

Your view of parent-child relationships is so disgustingly transactional that I don’t even know where to begin with you. Truly horrified.

No I think most kids would be more than happy to help out in the first place if they had kind and supportive parents. It depends if it was demanded of them (depending on the amount as well) or a "well sling your hook then" kind of attitude. In response to that I don't see a point in continuing a relationship, it's kind of ran it's course and it's almost like parents see their kids as nothing but a burden at that point. It sounds like they're the ones done with their kids in that case (the extreme ones that won't help AT ALL I'm talking about) and there is no reason to have anyone in your life if they can't provide love and support when you need it. No one more so than your parents who you didn't choose in the first place. If they see their job as done because you're not a cute kid anymore-well then it seems like both parties would be fine with going NC. Unless the parent is holding out for help for themselves later on...

The woman who gave birth to me, loved me, protected me, and cooked for me should just be dismissed as a nobody because she didn’t let me live rent free in her home?

All that was a choice your parents made, if they hadn't you simply wouldn't have been born and wouldn't have needed any of those things in the first place. Also I'm sure she would've been very sad if she couldn't have had children (assuming she wanted them) and I'm sure most parents think the joy and happiness their kids bring them is priceless. I'm not saying she should've let you live rent free but I don't understand why some parents wouldn't help out if they can, or would seek to profit off their kids. That's what's transactional. It's family FFS.

SeatonCarew · 05/01/2024 19:29

The Dd is paying about £115 a week for her and the BF part time, not £125 as other posters have said. As a former accountant, I say she's got a very good deal. As always on MN so many posters cannot imagine that other people have different circumstances and costs, or properly calculate the full cost of things, particularly given the massive increase in energy costs.

YANBU OP.

verdantverdure · 05/01/2024 19:28

Charlingspont · 05/01/2024 19:24

I have to say that I think you're being a bit mean. How did you manage before she moved back in?

I imagine the OP got a single person Council Tax discount and didn't have the extra costs of her daughter moving in and her boyfriend staying half the month.

Plus of course in those days, if she needed extra cash she could air bnb her spare room now and then for £100 a night.

Loopylambs · 05/01/2024 19:28

I think the dilemma isn’t just financial. Having her boyfriend stay up to 3 times a week is a bit of an intrusion? This could be the situation for years ?

Gymnopedie · 05/01/2024 19:26

babyproblems · 05/01/2024 18:20

I’ll be honest and say I think it’s a bit mean of you. I’m assuming you managed when she was living away before so unless you’re planning on a lodger I don’t see why you would insist she pays you £500. If she’s only saving 200 a month anyway it will take years and years and years. Even with two of them saving that it would still take years. I would be inclined to support her in the house purchase if you can afford to. If you can’t, well it’s different. If it’s just to teach her a lesson etc then I don’t think this is the time to teach it!

But she isn't only saving £200 a month, or shouldn't be. The DD is a teacher. She 26 so if she's been a teacher since she was 22 she will take home easily £2000 and probably more. Plus the London weighting allowance - ironically to help towards the fact that living costs are higher than elsewhere.

So she takes home £2000 as an absolute minimum. £500 of that gives her a roof over her head, heating, lighting, food, hot showers etc - everything she needs for daily living. So I would rather hope that she's saving a very significant chunk of the £1500 left over after she's paid her mum.

spriots · 05/01/2024 19:24

coffeeaddict77 · 05/01/2024 19:20

I didn't say she shouldn't charge anything. I just wouldn't charge more than the extra costs. Seems odd that OP isn't in a position to do that given she will have to when her dd moves out

I don't find it at all hard to believe that these are the extra costs - it depends. If the council tax is high, the DD has expensive food tastes etc

Charlingspont · 05/01/2024 19:24

I have to say that I think you're being a bit mean. How did you manage before she moved back in?

DettolBath · 05/01/2024 19:22

Presuming OP daughter doesn't have any DC then 500 from a teachers salary should leave enough to save. Maybe work out the difference in bills with her living with you and BF half of the week and charge her that. At the end of the day OP you deserve not to scrimp, nurses hardly get paid millions!!! I have 4 DC and when they get older we can't afford to give them each a deposit but they can live with us and contribute to the bills and food which is far less than renting somewhere but adults paying their way in some form is part of life.

coffeeaddict77 · 05/01/2024 19:20

spriots · 05/01/2024 19:16

But the OP is helping out her daughter? Living with her and having the boyfriend round several times a week, I am sure the OP would rather not have that loss of privacy

The DD would have no chance of saving without her mother's help.

The OP even said that she would love to be in a position not to charge her DD anything but she can't afford it.

Of course parents should help their adult children but they aren't obliged to empoverish themselves.

I didn't say she shouldn't charge anything. I just wouldn't charge more than the extra costs. Seems odd that OP isn't in a position to do that given she will have to when her dd moves out

Thatusernamewastaken · 05/01/2024 19:20

Seems excessive, especially if she is buying her own food. Doubt her energy, water etc would be more than an extra £150-200 a month.
Lots of people talking about how much cheaper it is than a house share, but….so what? It isn’t a house share, it’s living with her family.

verdantverdure · 05/01/2024 19:18

And I don't understand not wanting to help your kids! Why have them if you aren't going to help them?

The OP has already probably saved her daughter over £18k in living costs and is prepared to go on doing that indefinitely.

I would certainly class that as help.

coffeeaddict77 · 05/01/2024 19:17

mbosnz · 05/01/2024 19:07

There gets a point where you suddenly realise that you really need to look to your ever dwindling future. You've done your best for your kids, but if you don't get very suddenly real, and start planning for your old age, you're gonna be so screwed. And your kids, that you've really done your best to help enable them to live their best life, they've got their future ahead, with their maximum earning potential. If you're not careful, the bank of Mum/Dad, can become 'hey, I did everything for you that I could, now I'm screwed, can I come live in your basement?!'

OP isn't giving her child money so is not the "bank of mum and dad". If anything her daughter will be helping her mum's finances (if op charges more than the extra costs)

spriots · 05/01/2024 19:16

coffeeaddict77 · 05/01/2024 19:11

Quite. I am well aware that it has been easier for my generation (x) to buy a property than it will be for my children and if I can help them to buy I certainly will.

But the OP is helping out her daughter? Living with her and having the boyfriend round several times a week, I am sure the OP would rather not have that loss of privacy

The DD would have no chance of saving without her mother's help.

The OP even said that she would love to be in a position not to charge her DD anything but she can't afford it.

Of course parents should help their adult children but they aren't obliged to empoverish themselves.

BreakingAndBroke · 05/01/2024 19:15

£500/mo for rent and bills is cheap for London already. I was paying that for a room only in a house share about 15 years ago.

If her relationship with her boyfriend is off again on again, I would keep it at £500/mo in case she moves in too soon with the boyfriend and ends up tied to a mortgage with the wrong person! You can always set the extra £200 aside as previous posters have suggested and give it to her once she has bought somewhere as a fund towards furniture/decorating etc.

Zanatdy · 05/01/2024 19:14

For two of them half the week £500 isn’t that bad, but it’s hard out there these days especially for young people trying to start out. If she’s going to save the rest I’d be inclined to agree but I wouldn’t be buying food for the boyfriend

coffeeaddict77 · 05/01/2024 19:11

VanityDiesHard · 05/01/2024 19:00

And I don't understand not wanting to help your kids! Why have them if you aren't going to help them?

Quite. I am well aware that it has been easier for my generation (x) to buy a property than it will be for my children and if I can help them to buy I certainly will.

mbosnz · 05/01/2024 19:07

There gets a point where you suddenly realise that you really need to look to your ever dwindling future. You've done your best for your kids, but if you don't get very suddenly real, and start planning for your old age, you're gonna be so screwed. And your kids, that you've really done your best to help enable them to live their best life, they've got their future ahead, with their maximum earning potential. If you're not careful, the bank of Mum/Dad, can become 'hey, I did everything for you that I could, now I'm screwed, can I come live in your basement?!'

laclochette · 05/01/2024 19:04

I would want to do all I could to help my child save for a house. It's a really challenging thing to achieve in today's climate, and I guess what strikes me is that there isn't much sense in your posts of this being a priority for you in terms of something you are really keen for your daughter to be able to achieve.

I also wouldn't feel comfortable profiting off a member of my own family in any way. I'm sure others differ but I just find it very odd to adopt the position of landlord to someone I love.

Equally, I think she should be covering her costs fair and square. So I'd charge her whatever extra it costs for you to live with her, and let her keep the rest to save. You won't be out of pocket, and your daughter will be closer to achieving something many young people now can only ever dream of, which gives her greater security in the future and therefore relieves you of that worry. (My mum is always telling me how incredibly relieved she is that I managed to buy a flat because of how awful the rental market it, and I'm relieved that it's a weight off her mind, too... As well as being relieved for my own sake of course.)

An alternative and harsher arrangement is to look at you both as cohabiting adults, and split the costs of the household in line with earnings, as you might with eg a partner. That's still fair, but I probably wouldn't do it as helping my children achieve security in life ASAP would be a priority to me, but of course not if it comes at risk to your own finances - which only you know the details of.

NewYear24 · 05/01/2024 19:04

And I don't understand not wanting to help your kids! Why have them if you aren't going to help them?

The OP is helping her DC, she could easily ask her 26 year old to move out and then the DC would have to rent a flat with her BF and possibly be trapped renting for years. The DC is a 26 year old professional earning a couple of thousand pounds per month not some young kid.

Mumtryingtolivethedream · 05/01/2024 19:03

She's 26 she is under no obligation to have an agreement with her mother about how much she saves it's her money up to her what she saves she doesn't have to show her mother any accounts
What is the mother's business is that she recieves enough money from the daughter to cover the daughters and boyfriends expenses whilst living it

VanityDiesHard · 05/01/2024 19:02

Flamingogirl08 · 04/01/2024 20:54

God some people on this thread really are against helping out their adult kids aren't they.

I know, it is absolutely weird and a bit absurd. Having children isn't compulsory, but when you do have them, why not help to get them the best life that they can live? I think that too many people on here have taken that tedious 'put your own safety mask on first' analogy a little too literally.

VanityDiesHard · 05/01/2024 19:00

Dacadactyl · 04/01/2024 20:43

How old is this DD? I really don't understand this giving your adult kids huge sums of money thing!! I mean, a reduced rent (which 500 quid in London certainly is) sure, but she's an adult. It's not up to her mum to pay her way for her.

And I don't understand not wanting to help your kids! Why have them if you aren't going to help them?