Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adult child not wanting to pay their way

491 replies

Cazzalou · 04/01/2024 20:23

18 months ago my daughter spilt up from the BF and moved back home with me.
We agreed that she would pay £500 a month for rent and bills. We live in London.
Now she and BF are back together and are hoping to buy somewhere out in Kent.
She would like to reduce her monthly payments to £300 a month so she can save for the deposit on a new home.
This could take a long time.
Should I agree the reduction or keep it at £500?
Is daughter taking me for a ride?
I'm an almost retired nurse and my monthly income has reduced as I have reduced my working hours to 30 per week.
Am I being mean if I say no?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
2chocolateoranges · 05/01/2024 11:07

GentleSponge · 05/01/2024 04:29

I think this comment really speaks to the heart of the issue. Charging your children rent isn't usually about paying their way, it's about exercising and enjoying power and control. The parents demonstrate they can still call the shots through a 'nominal' fee.

We don’t call any shots, we ask him to pay £100 of which £35 covers his phone bill and the other £65 goes towards food shopping and electricity as he is working from home at times.

this allows him to save as much as he can to buy his own property.

trulyunruly01 · 05/01/2024 11:06

I reckon there are hundreds of thousands of households where adult working children and their parents are living quite harmoniously for a variety of reasons - financial, emotional, logistical.
It doesnt have to be (a) pay up bigtime or get out, or (b) it's disgusting to have them pay housekeeping, poor darlings.
I have 3 young adults here and all contribute to the running of the household. They all have plans and objectives of their own and dh and I are keen to help them along. We see them for perhaps half an hour a day, along with the occasional Sunday roast. We sometimes have a little spat about parking (but no penguin bollards yet).
I'd rather have them for an extra year and see them move into good quality secure housing than have them leave now for some damp grotty flat with a weirdy landlord.
But in the same way that the council won't listen to my excuses if I don't pay my council tax, a housekeeping payment here is non-negotiable (but the amount is, depending on their future plans). I won't change it cos someone's overdoing it on ASOS, but I will change it for someone laying out for a DBS to start a better paid job. It's a life lesson.

mottytotty · 05/01/2024 10:24

LowRidingElf · 05/01/2024 10:21

without exaggeration, this is one of the saddest, grimmest things I’ve ever read. We live is completely different moral universes.

also you DH must be a hit at parties 😂

You must live an extremely sheltered and privileged life if this is the saddest thing you’ve read.

LowRidingElf · 05/01/2024 10:21

inloveandmarried · 05/01/2024 09:29

Last year my husband did raw number crunching on the actual cost of having another adult living in our house.

Based on extra electricity working from home, extra laundry loads and drying, extra dish wash loads and food, plus baths/showers.

It was £7.85 for the extra adult per day for our house at cost.

But that is based on our household bills and how we do things. We are well insulated and have free energy half of the year and free hot water half of the year too so these figures are personal to us.
We also eat basic home cooked food so costs are low.

That's an absolute bottom line of £235 a month per adult at cost.

You might need to also factor in the single occupancy discount for council tax which you might lose if you are currently the only adult in your property.

As other posters have commented I don't think £300 will cover her share of bills.

She at the very least needs to cover the cost of her living with you.

without exaggeration, this is one of the saddest, grimmest things I’ve ever read. We live is completely different moral universes.

also you DH must be a hit at parties 😂

mottytotty · 05/01/2024 09:44

Firefly1987 · 05/01/2024 04:35

If parents are not gonna help their kids out in any way once they're adults I don't see any point in continuing a relationship with them, they're not friends and people you choose to hang out with. If they view their job as "done" once you turn 18 they can crack on with their own life and don't expect any help if they need it either.

So you’re saying because I paid my mum £300 a month once I got a full time job, I should now go no contact with her?

The woman who gave birth to me, loved me, protected me, and cooked for me should just be dismissed as a nobody because she didn’t let me live rent free in her home?

Your view of parent-child relationships is so disgustingly transactional that I don’t even know where to begin with you. Truly horrified.

mottytotty · 05/01/2024 09:40

GentleSponge · 05/01/2024 04:29

I think this comment really speaks to the heart of the issue. Charging your children rent isn't usually about paying their way, it's about exercising and enjoying power and control. The parents demonstrate they can still call the shots through a 'nominal' fee.

So they’re controlling him by letting keep most of his money? This place is insane 🤣

saraclara · 05/01/2024 09:39

An almost retired nurse has a salary that is approaching £57,102£ and that is just for a basic nurse with no additional qualifications.

In that world is this? That is absolutely not the case and I have no idea where you get that from @monyk12

spriots · 05/01/2024 09:39

inloveandmarried · 05/01/2024 09:29

Last year my husband did raw number crunching on the actual cost of having another adult living in our house.

Based on extra electricity working from home, extra laundry loads and drying, extra dish wash loads and food, plus baths/showers.

It was £7.85 for the extra adult per day for our house at cost.

But that is based on our household bills and how we do things. We are well insulated and have free energy half of the year and free hot water half of the year too so these figures are personal to us.
We also eat basic home cooked food so costs are low.

That's an absolute bottom line of £235 a month per adult at cost.

You might need to also factor in the single occupancy discount for council tax which you might lose if you are currently the only adult in your property.

As other posters have commented I don't think £300 will cover her share of bills.

She at the very least needs to cover the cost of her living with you.

That sounds about right to me - added to that the cost of food and council tax, as well as having the boyfriend to stay twice a week, and I really don't think the OP is "profiting" with £500/month. I think some posters just haven't properly understood or thought through the numbers.

The daughter is very fortunate to only have these fixed costs - she should still have lots of scope to save.

mottytotty · 05/01/2024 09:39

Passingthethyme · 05/01/2024 04:11

I find it weird taking money from your children, afterall they never asked to be born. Maybe if they are middle aged, and you're now retired and they've come back home to live, but that's quite a different scenario. Even then if I didn't need the money, I wouldn't take it. I don't think anyone would choose to live at home after a certain age so I would assume they need to save as much as they can

Pretty sure the ‘they didn’t ask to be born’ excuse doesn’t apply when the child is 26 🙄

At some point adults have to start adulting.

Please have some sensitivity to other people’s needs, OP learns less than her dd and needs the money. Step out of your bubble and into OP’s shoes.

inloveandmarried · 05/01/2024 09:29

Last year my husband did raw number crunching on the actual cost of having another adult living in our house.

Based on extra electricity working from home, extra laundry loads and drying, extra dish wash loads and food, plus baths/showers.

It was £7.85 for the extra adult per day for our house at cost.

But that is based on our household bills and how we do things. We are well insulated and have free energy half of the year and free hot water half of the year too so these figures are personal to us.
We also eat basic home cooked food so costs are low.

That's an absolute bottom line of £235 a month per adult at cost.

You might need to also factor in the single occupancy discount for council tax which you might lose if you are currently the only adult in your property.

As other posters have commented I don't think £300 will cover her share of bills.

She at the very least needs to cover the cost of her living with you.

disappearingfish · 05/01/2024 07:19

I think in the circumstances she should cover costs and a little extra. That should include the costs of the boyf. She should also pull her weight domestically.

Will you be ok financially when she moves out?

HellsToilet · 05/01/2024 06:27

£500/month is a bargain in London but you're not doing this a commercial venture, you're her mother. How much does it cost you to have her there? Charge her that. I'd feel I was taking advantage of my children if I was making a profit off them, especially if that profit was enough for me to then start working part time!

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 05/01/2024 05:47

Anyone else now getting the ad for London flatshares at a grand a month popping up ?? 🤣🤣🤣

She's taking the piss op, she's on a good salary, you should not be subsidising her lifestyle.

Ohnoooooooo · 05/01/2024 05:09

I think you need to charge her an amount which covers the costs of her living there rather than the argument your hours are being reduced. I suspect her proposal of £300 would not cover her bills.
of course if you were planning on renting out her room for income that is a different story. I am usually help your children as much as you can but if you are on a nurses income you need to think of your future too. Hope you get it sorted.

Firefly1987 · 05/01/2024 04:35

If parents are not gonna help their kids out in any way once they're adults I don't see any point in continuing a relationship with them, they're not friends and people you choose to hang out with. If they view their job as "done" once you turn 18 they can crack on with their own life and don't expect any help if they need it either.

MyLibrarywasdukedomlargeenough · 05/01/2024 04:31

I do not need the money at all but my DS pays 65 per week, he is also saving up to buy a house, he is 22 . We worked out that it really does just cover his food and extra water for washing himself and clothes so we make no money at all but it covers himself and the 2/3 nights his GF stays over.

GentleSponge · 05/01/2024 04:29

2chocolateoranges · 04/01/2024 23:11

Our eldest (21) has recently graduated and has a graduate job with ok money. He is desperate to buy somewhere of his own. We have asked for a nominal fee of £100 a month on the condition he saves as much as he can. He goes out once a week/ fortnight with friends sometimes for drinks, sometimes for dinner and drinks and occasionally they go and play snooker. So not extravagant nights out but he assures me he is saving well and I believe him. He says he’s on track for moving out in 3 years max. By that time he will be fully qualified .

he has a tiny room and wants to have his own space, we are willing to help him and take as little off him as possible.

as a parent we can afford for this to happen so are only too happy to get rid of him…. Sorry help out! 😂

I think this comment really speaks to the heart of the issue. Charging your children rent isn't usually about paying their way, it's about exercising and enjoying power and control. The parents demonstrate they can still call the shots through a 'nominal' fee.

Passingthethyme · 05/01/2024 04:11

I find it weird taking money from your children, afterall they never asked to be born. Maybe if they are middle aged, and you're now retired and they've come back home to live, but that's quite a different scenario. Even then if I didn't need the money, I wouldn't take it. I don't think anyone would choose to live at home after a certain age so I would assume they need to save as much as they can

ilovesooty · 05/01/2024 04:01

@monyk12 I don't know how you've managed to deduce that the OP earns that kind of money.

verdantverdure · 05/01/2024 02:17

penjil · 05/01/2024 01:06

What will you do for money when she moves out?

Will your pension have kicked in by then and will it cover the £500 per month?

I'd imagine, get the single person council tax rebate and use less than half the hot water heat and food etc because she won't have to live to please someone else, having the heat and hot water used at different times, buying different food. Or drying three sets of towels etc.

My dad said you could really see it in their energy and shopping bills when my sister moved out.

They had charged her £400 a month based on what they thought she'd add to their costs. And my dad said it was an underestimate of the actual cost.

Ten or eleven years ago.

monyk12 · 05/01/2024 02:13

Please let me explain, is really important that I perhaps explain a bit, but I do not think is priviledged.

My parents and also my husband parents supported us to get excellent education and payed for our tuition as well as helping in the early stages of our careers.

For me and my now husband, our parents provided, each.
During University: Pocket Money and Rent, me in turn I got scholarships and distinctions
Early stages of my career: Rent. Me - saved fiercely and in 2 years I bought my first appartment. My parents gave a significant amount towards deposit money.

Then fast forward getting married:
Parents payed for honeymoon; no cost on their end for our wedding; wedding gift went all exclusively in pension savings.
Me and husband saved and bought a larger apartment before getting married, whilst his apartment was on rent and both were in good jobs; We took our parents toghether in one trip/year payed exclusively by us, as a rule.

When Baby arrived:
Each of our parents opened a Junior Bank Account and placed a very significant amount there;
We opened a Junior Bank Account for our DD with a very reasonable amount and we save each month too.
We bought our first House in central London, parents payed for stamp duty and furnished all house;
We go each year in one holiday toghether and we pay for that exclusively.
I pay private insurance for my parents and my husband for his. I oferr 200£/PM to my parents and this is just a little help to ensure they can enjoy their pension. I invite them for dinner at least twice a month and we go out at least once a month. I take my mum to all her medical appointments.
My mom drops and picks my daughter from school voluntarily as she absolutely adore my DD.

And now, yes, we are in a good job, but that;s because our parents sacriced for us almost half of their life. This is not privileged, it was a sacrifice on their end. Also, see example for my husband, same case.

Going back to the original poster:
An almost retired nurse has a salary that is approaching £57,102£ and that is just for a basic nurse with no additional qualifications.
She said she reduced her hours to 30pw, so let's just presume a very low salary as alleged. Bare in mind that nursing staff have a lot of benefits: time off after shifts in which you have time to get extra work (one relative that is a dialisis nurse makes a wooping 150.000£ after taxes from locuming, this is because she works a lot). Let's just assume that OP has restrictions that cannot let her work extensively - at least she can work an extra premium shift to boost her income, there is always staff shortage - she can do as she pleases with that money.
Also, now, how she will manage after her daughter her will move with her BF? Will she take a lodger or move out to downsize?

Is not yet clear if the OP has issues with the behaviour of her daughter or she simply cannot afford to live in that area alone.

I am not saying that all the parents should/can do the same, but at least family should come before money and there are always ways to solve a problem.

I do hope OP finds a good solution for her and her daughter.

mottytotty · 05/01/2024 02:11

Frangipanyoul8r · 05/01/2024 01:56

I wouldn’t charge my children for anything other than to cover utilities if they occupied a room I wouldn’t otherwise be renting out and making money on. You’re profiting from her being there whether you charge £300 or £500, she isn’t taking you for a ride. You’re the one taking advantage of her financial situation. I doubt she wants to be living at home at her age.

Do you have any concept of what life is like for many people or do you think everyone lives in your little bubble?

No one cares that you wouldn’t charge your dc, you are not the OP, you are not in her shoes.

verdantverdure · 05/01/2024 02:10

Frangipanyoul8r · 05/01/2024 01:56

I wouldn’t charge my children for anything other than to cover utilities if they occupied a room I wouldn’t otherwise be renting out and making money on. You’re profiting from her being there whether you charge £300 or £500, she isn’t taking you for a ride. You’re the one taking advantage of her financial situation. I doubt she wants to be living at home at her age.

She's at a perfect liberty to go and rent one of those £1000 a month single bedrooms in a shared house with no reception rooms isn't she?

Frangipanyoul8r · 05/01/2024 01:56

I wouldn’t charge my children for anything other than to cover utilities if they occupied a room I wouldn’t otherwise be renting out and making money on. You’re profiting from her being there whether you charge £300 or £500, she isn’t taking you for a ride. You’re the one taking advantage of her financial situation. I doubt she wants to be living at home at her age.

justanothermanicmonday1 · 05/01/2024 01:21

Flamingogirl08 · 04/01/2024 20:54

God some people on this thread really are against helping out their adult kids aren't they.

I thought it was just me.

😩

Swipe left for the next trending thread