Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adult child not wanting to pay their way

491 replies

Cazzalou · 04/01/2024 20:23

18 months ago my daughter spilt up from the BF and moved back home with me.
We agreed that she would pay £500 a month for rent and bills. We live in London.
Now she and BF are back together and are hoping to buy somewhere out in Kent.
She would like to reduce her monthly payments to £300 a month so she can save for the deposit on a new home.
This could take a long time.
Should I agree the reduction or keep it at £500?
Is daughter taking me for a ride?
I'm an almost retired nurse and my monthly income has reduced as I have reduced my working hours to 30 per week.
Am I being mean if I say no?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
verdantverdure · 05/01/2024 15:37

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 05/01/2024 15:32

If you’re in London, £500 pcm is way less than she’d have to pay in a halfway reasonable flatshare, even without bills!

I'm about 40 miles outside London and anything less than £1000 a month would involve living in a HMO with the kind of people you really wouldn't want to live with.

Even at that price it still might.

NewYear24 · 05/01/2024 15:35

You've got to imagine that with most of her basic living expenses covered by just £500 a month she can save money hand over fist

I hope she is, it would be piss me off if she’s having an extravagant lifestyle and asking for a reduction in housekeeping money.

verdantverdure · 05/01/2024 15:33

NewYear24 · 05/01/2024 15:24

OP how much is she currently saving and does she have an extravagant lifestyle?

You've got to imagine that with most of her basic living expenses covered by just £500 a month she can save money hand over fist

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 05/01/2024 15:32

If you’re in London, £500 pcm is way less than she’d have to pay in a halfway reasonable flatshare, even without bills!

NewYear24 · 05/01/2024 15:24

OP how much is she currently saving and does she have an extravagant lifestyle?

Moveoverdarlin · 05/01/2024 15:20

I would say ‘keep paying £500 a month, but I will take £200 of it and save it for you and give it back to you when you’re ready to buy a house’. That way you know it’s being saved.

Groovy48592747 · 05/01/2024 15:19

I do believe adult 'children' who are working should pay their way.

Can't believe the audacity to even try to bargain you down! I'd never have bartered about payment with my parents.

£500 or just over £100 a week is nothing compared to renting/having your own place. Food, utilities, council tax, etc. I wouldn't 'bargain' with her. She shouldn't go back on an agreement once she's moved in.

Epidote · 05/01/2024 15:16

I ve read your update.
She can save without the discount. Also charge her BF. I think they are being CF.

Zwicky · 05/01/2024 15:14

Realistically, if she wasn’t there, would you be renting her room to a lodger or would you be freeing equity by downsizing/renting somewhere smaller?

How much is she actually costing in increased bills?

if you are losing £400 a month through not being able to rent out her room plus she’s costing £600 a month in utilities, council tax and food then she is taking you for a ride.

If you have no intention of taking a lodger or moving and it actually only costs you £300 a month then just charge her £300. She’s getting a bargain but it doesn’t actually cost you anything.

SENDhelp2023 · 05/01/2024 15:09

No shes no ‘taking you for a ride’🙄 shes your daughter, if you cant afford it don’t

Busy75 · 05/01/2024 15:08

monyk12 · 05/01/2024 02:13

Please let me explain, is really important that I perhaps explain a bit, but I do not think is priviledged.

My parents and also my husband parents supported us to get excellent education and payed for our tuition as well as helping in the early stages of our careers.

For me and my now husband, our parents provided, each.
During University: Pocket Money and Rent, me in turn I got scholarships and distinctions
Early stages of my career: Rent. Me - saved fiercely and in 2 years I bought my first appartment. My parents gave a significant amount towards deposit money.

Then fast forward getting married:
Parents payed for honeymoon; no cost on their end for our wedding; wedding gift went all exclusively in pension savings.
Me and husband saved and bought a larger apartment before getting married, whilst his apartment was on rent and both were in good jobs; We took our parents toghether in one trip/year payed exclusively by us, as a rule.

When Baby arrived:
Each of our parents opened a Junior Bank Account and placed a very significant amount there;
We opened a Junior Bank Account for our DD with a very reasonable amount and we save each month too.
We bought our first House in central London, parents payed for stamp duty and furnished all house;
We go each year in one holiday toghether and we pay for that exclusively.
I pay private insurance for my parents and my husband for his. I oferr 200£/PM to my parents and this is just a little help to ensure they can enjoy their pension. I invite them for dinner at least twice a month and we go out at least once a month. I take my mum to all her medical appointments.
My mom drops and picks my daughter from school voluntarily as she absolutely adore my DD.

And now, yes, we are in a good job, but that;s because our parents sacriced for us almost half of their life. This is not privileged, it was a sacrifice on their end. Also, see example for my husband, same case.

Going back to the original poster:
An almost retired nurse has a salary that is approaching £57,102£ and that is just for a basic nurse with no additional qualifications.
She said she reduced her hours to 30pw, so let's just presume a very low salary as alleged. Bare in mind that nursing staff have a lot of benefits: time off after shifts in which you have time to get extra work (one relative that is a dialisis nurse makes a wooping 150.000£ after taxes from locuming, this is because she works a lot). Let's just assume that OP has restrictions that cannot let her work extensively - at least she can work an extra premium shift to boost her income, there is always staff shortage - she can do as she pleases with that money.
Also, now, how she will manage after her daughter her will move with her BF? Will she take a lodger or move out to downsize?

Is not yet clear if the OP has issues with the behaviour of her daughter or she simply cannot afford to live in that area alone.

I am not saying that all the parents should/can do the same, but at least family should come before money and there are always ways to solve a problem.

I do hope OP finds a good solution for her and her daughter.

This is lovely. Your parents sacrificed for you so you can live a privileged life, therefore, you are now in a position to give back to them by helping them out.

Some pp need to realise that not everybody has a good start in life or parents like this.

CHRIS003 · 05/01/2024 15:08

YANBU - To say no to the reduction- I suppose it depends on their lifestyles now.
If she pays £500 and this covers meals and utilities for her and boyfriend does she have a lot of spare cash - is she going on holidays - meals out - spending on luxuries etc.
If she is giving you £500 and has money left over for treats then definitely I would say no to the reduction
But if she is giving you £500 and they are struggling to afford this on their wages and save for a house too. Then maybe you should consider it otherwise u will never get rid of them lol!
Does the boyfriend work - I assume he does if they are saving for a house - if he stays over 2or 3 days a week does he contribute with food etc or give you any money ?

verdantverdure · 05/01/2024 15:07

Honestly, I'd pay £500 a month happily just not to have to share with strangers ever again. Priceless! Grin

verdantverdure · 05/01/2024 15:06

Cheshiresun · 05/01/2024 14:44

Just seen she's 26. Not as young as I'd imagined. I'd keep it as what you previously agreed, £500.

I do think there's some leeway when they are very young, in a low paying job, perhaps not a full time hours if it's a zero hours contract or something, but as a general rule I do think adults should pay their own way and not ask others to subsidise them.

In this case where the daughter is 26 and has been working for years, and in fact earns more than her mother I think the rule absolutely applies.

Particularly as a house share would be double what she is paying, and would probably be far less pleasant, involving sharing kitchens and bathrooms with far more people.

A medical student in our wider family is paying over £900 a month to rent a tiny room with a family whose mortgage has gone up and considers themselves very lucky.

Primarily because they only have to share with two adults and not 8 and can use the bathroom and kitchen at a suitable time for their schedule. This was not a given in shared houses.

Also the mum of the family often does their laundry and leaves them leftovers in the fridge to microwave whereas in shared houses people used their food without asking and they sometimes had to resort to the launderette.

They also enjoy that they only need to know the schedule of two adults and two children rather than 6-8 adults, plus their assorted regujar and irregular overnight visitors in order to know when is the best time to sleep.

And that there are no Tuesday night wild parties Grin

Appleofmyeye2023 · 05/01/2024 15:02

Seeline · 04/01/2024 20:30

But is now having increased energy bills, water bills, possibly lost her single person council tax reduction, and buying extra food.

this

op, write down these extra expenses, be clear what you are paying extra for.

tbh, I would be surprised if it amounted to £500 even in London. But happy to be proved wrong. The biggest costs are council tax, and energy . Heating won’t change much if there’s one or 2 people living in the home. Even electric won’t cost that much more. A few extra loads of washing a month. If she’s eating and cooking her own stuff then yep, not the way to go for her to get rent reduction. Maybe she could cook for you both to save costs.

I think it’s not unreasonable to charge her more (£500) per month given that’s a massive discount on what she’d have to pay commercially. But I’d have put the surplus into a secret account to pass on eventually to said dc to go towards deposit.

There’s also the element of whether you don’t want her to live with you. That’s absolutely fine even if MN seem to think it cruel and unusual . Personally I’d be digging up my patio if my 25 year old ds had moved back in (he’s 30 now and a much better human) . So in that case , yes, charge the £500 As her incentive to move out asap.

I don’t think it’s right to profit as such from your daughter staying. But if her staying means you can’t get a lodger to help with costs you don’t have income for, then absolutely you can and should. And if she has bf staying over for anything but occasionally or having meals /food occasionally she should cover his costs. Whatever you do, don’t let him move in semi permanently 🤦‍♀️😱. Even if he’s a lovely lad.

Busy75 · 05/01/2024 15:00

horseyhorsey17 · 05/01/2024 14:47

It really depends if you can afford it or not. If you can, then yes, charge her £300 and let her save the other £200. If not, then charge her the £500.

^This.

Bottom line, it all depends on what you can afford.

You’re a Nurse, your 26 yo DD earns more than you and her BF also needs to chip in if he’s living in your home 2-3 days pw.

There is absolutely no need to give back their ‘keep’ one day, if the parent/s cannot afford to.

NewYear24 · 05/01/2024 14:57

I would agree to the £300 and tell your DC that when the boyfriend stays over (maximum of 2 nights per week) they need to buy, cook and clear away their own food.

My two adult DC are 23 and 25, they earn 26k and 36k and I charge them £250 per month on the condition that they are saving a chunky monthly amount which they are doing.

Janieforever · 05/01/2024 14:53

She surely can’t cost you an extra 500 a month? I would charge what she actually costs additional. Anything else is unfair.

LaylaLayla1 · 05/01/2024 14:52

It depends on your financial situation. My son moved back in with me, I lost my 25% single person council tax discount, my electricity and gas went up (quite considerably) and my food shopping went up more than double. I charge him £300 per month which is less than what I should be charging him.

Its all fine and well people saying don’t charge family, but if you are struggling and your daughter is on a better salary than you and doesn’t have any bills, then it makes no sense not to charge her.

cassy16 · 05/01/2024 14:50

I would just work out an estimate of her expenses and not “rent” per say as you will have managed before and after she moved in, so I would only charge her the cost of the extra energy and food, I assume you had internet and tv etc before she moved in so wouldn’t include that. At the end of the day buying her home is an important life step we all want for our children, I think if you know she is being serious about saving you should charge her the bare minimum you can get by with and encourage her to save as much as she can

DeeLusional · 05/01/2024 14:50

Therunecaster · 04/01/2024 21:04

Agree

And some people are very judgemental. Not everyone can afford to keep one or two extra adults .

verdantverdure · 05/01/2024 14:47

MeridaBrave · 05/01/2024 14:21

What would you do with her room if she wasn’t there? If you’d rent it out to someone else then yes you should explain this and not reduce. If you won’t rent it out I’d reduce the rent to what she is actually costing you; extra water, gas, food etc. I don’t think it’s relevant what the market rate for the room is or what others charge unless you’d rent it to someone else.

It's relevant in that the daughter would be paying that amount at a miinimum to live somewhere so the mum is already saving her thousands of pounds a year.

horseyhorsey17 · 05/01/2024 14:47

It really depends if you can afford it or not. If you can, then yes, charge her £300 and let her save the other £200. If not, then charge her the £500.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 05/01/2024 14:46

Flamingogirl08 · 04/01/2024 20:54

God some people on this thread really are against helping out their adult kids aren't they.

God some people really are against people paying their way, arent they?

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 05/01/2024 14:45

NalafromtheLionKing · 04/01/2024 20:41

I would still charge the £500 but give it all back to her when she’s ready to buy. It’s worth the sacrifice for your DD 😊

All back? So where does OP get the money to cover the increaed costs associated with another aduöt living there?