Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adult child not wanting to pay their way

491 replies

Cazzalou · 04/01/2024 20:23

18 months ago my daughter spilt up from the BF and moved back home with me.
We agreed that she would pay £500 a month for rent and bills. We live in London.
Now she and BF are back together and are hoping to buy somewhere out in Kent.
She would like to reduce her monthly payments to £300 a month so she can save for the deposit on a new home.
This could take a long time.
Should I agree the reduction or keep it at £500?
Is daughter taking me for a ride?
I'm an almost retired nurse and my monthly income has reduced as I have reduced my working hours to 30 per week.
Am I being mean if I say no?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
verdantverdure · 05/01/2024 16:48

"No. You make more than I do, and I'm getting close to retiring. If you think £500 for London is unreasonable, move out and I'll get a workweek lodger that I can charge more."

Exactly @wronginalltherightways A work week lodger often pays £200-300 a week

And you can just do it some of the time. Not solidly for years if you don't need to.

DriftingDora · 05/01/2024 16:47

Soontobe60 · 04/01/2024 20:27

Presumably you managed without the £500 before she moved back in.

And now she has another person living there. QED: additional bills/costs. Two cannot live as cheaply as one is very true.

BeardyButton · 05/01/2024 16:46

Jaysus the way you lot treat your adult kids! My god!

If you can’t afford it, it’s one thing… but the idea that your kid is ‘taking you for a ride’ by trying to stay in the ‘family’ home to save money. VOMIT.

I will make sure that my kid knows they always always have a home with me. If I can afford it, I will not ask them for money.

verdantverdure · 05/01/2024 16:43

Depending on location the OP could probably rent out her spare room for a 5 night week or a weekend only now and then for considerably more than her daughter is paying for a whole month.

Lots more people are having to do it since mortgages went up so much.

Tax would be involved then but I do think the daughter here needs to take the other side of the coin into account.

wronginalltherightways · 05/01/2024 16:40

Cazzalou · 04/01/2024 21:23

She is 26 and is a teacher on a better salary than me.
BF stays 2-3 nights a week.
I feel that I've been happy helping them over last 18 months and £500 a month in London is a bargain.
I would love to be in the position of letting them stay rent free but I do feel like I'm being a bit of a door mat.

"No. You make more than I do, and I'm getting close to retiring. If you think £500 for London is unreasonable, move out and I'll get a workweek lodger that I can charge more."

fussychica · 05/01/2024 16:36

Sorry £300 contribution to the household pot.

fussychica · 05/01/2024 16:33

To those saying OP managed without DDs contribution before she moved back in so why not now? My understanding is that the OP has since gone part time in preparation for retiring so has taken a salary drop which she was comfortable with at the time.
Lots of things at play here. DD is getting a bargain already but doesn't seem to appreciate that. She earns more than her mum but is only happy to put in £200pm to the household pot and her BF sounds like he makes no contribution despite staying over several nights a week.
Taking those things into account, if it were me I'd be sticking with the £500 and if I didn't need the entire amount at any time I bank that for her separately, without her knowing, and without being held to a specific amount.

WhereYouLeftIt · 05/01/2024 16:32

Cazzalou · 04/01/2024 21:23

She is 26 and is a teacher on a better salary than me.
BF stays 2-3 nights a week.
I feel that I've been happy helping them over last 18 months and £500 a month in London is a bargain.
I would love to be in the position of letting them stay rent free but I do feel like I'm being a bit of a door mat.

In your OP you said : "I'm an almost retired nurse and my monthly income has reduced as I have reduced my working hours to 30 per week."

I'd be blunt with your daughter - tell her that you cannot afford to reduce her household contribution. If she were not there, you could rent out her room for more than £500, couldn't you? Maybe reduce your hours some more. (Whether you'd want to is beside the point. The point being, that 1. you could and 2. that you need the money.)

At 26, she's far too old to be being subsidised by her mum, particularly when she earns more than her mum.

Where does her BF live? I'd be suggesting she moves in with him!

Redcar78 · 05/01/2024 16:29

Newchapterbeckons · 05/01/2024 16:24

I would ask her to continue and save as much as I could for her… and keep it safe

She's 26, why would you infantilise her by saving for her, apron strings should have been cut long ago, OP wouldn't be helping her by taking this responsibility away.

Redcar78 · 05/01/2024 16:28

Based on your last post I'd keep it at £500 tbh, she's getting a great deal and if she can get a better one elsewhere then she can 🤷‍♀️ if she was 18 student it's different but she's a 26 year old teacher.

Newchapterbeckons · 05/01/2024 16:24

I would ask her to continue and save as much as I could for her… and keep it safe

Daisybuttercup12345 · 05/01/2024 16:18

She is being a massive CF. Is she sure she can afford a house AND all the expenses and bills that come with it?
Keep the money she pays you the same.

HappyHamsters · 05/01/2024 16:09

If bf stays over then don't change it, is he back with his parents. Who shops, cooks, cleans?

verdantverdure · 05/01/2024 16:05

muddyford · 05/01/2024 16:01

If BF is staying almost half the week I would be billing him too. Say £200/month.

If I was the daughter in this scenario, in this cost of living crisis, I would be scared to rock the boat in case mum did the suns and put my contribution UP.

43ontherocksporfavor · 05/01/2024 16:04

Depends if she’s still going out, to get expensive hair/beauty/ holidays . If she’s seriously cutting back I would allow it if I could afford it.

verdantverdure · 05/01/2024 16:03

enchantedsquirrelwood · 05/01/2024 15:47

If she earns more than you do she should theoretically be paying more into the bill pot than you do OP, excluding mortgage payments.

I've always said that when ds gets a "proper job" I'd expect him to contribute to the bills in proportion to his salary and our incomes if he is living at home. I'd not charge rent as I don't have a mortgage.

So if eg I earn £40K, DH earns 40K and DS earns £20K and the bills for food, utilities, council tax etc come to £1000 a month, he should contribute £200.

If they don't like it they can move out and pay a mortgage or rent. They'll soon notice the difference.

That's a very good point.

If she's earning more money then really she should be paying more of the expenses.

There's no way £500 is her fair share of the expenses of a two (2.5?) person household in London.

muddyford · 05/01/2024 16:01

If BF is staying almost half the week I would be billing him too. Say £200/month.

outdooryone · 05/01/2024 15:57

monyk12 · 05/01/2024 02:13

Please let me explain, is really important that I perhaps explain a bit, but I do not think is priviledged.

My parents and also my husband parents supported us to get excellent education and payed for our tuition as well as helping in the early stages of our careers.

For me and my now husband, our parents provided, each.
During University: Pocket Money and Rent, me in turn I got scholarships and distinctions
Early stages of my career: Rent. Me - saved fiercely and in 2 years I bought my first appartment. My parents gave a significant amount towards deposit money.

Then fast forward getting married:
Parents payed for honeymoon; no cost on their end for our wedding; wedding gift went all exclusively in pension savings.
Me and husband saved and bought a larger apartment before getting married, whilst his apartment was on rent and both were in good jobs; We took our parents toghether in one trip/year payed exclusively by us, as a rule.

When Baby arrived:
Each of our parents opened a Junior Bank Account and placed a very significant amount there;
We opened a Junior Bank Account for our DD with a very reasonable amount and we save each month too.
We bought our first House in central London, parents payed for stamp duty and furnished all house;
We go each year in one holiday toghether and we pay for that exclusively.
I pay private insurance for my parents and my husband for his. I oferr 200£/PM to my parents and this is just a little help to ensure they can enjoy their pension. I invite them for dinner at least twice a month and we go out at least once a month. I take my mum to all her medical appointments.
My mom drops and picks my daughter from school voluntarily as she absolutely adore my DD.

And now, yes, we are in a good job, but that;s because our parents sacriced for us almost half of their life. This is not privileged, it was a sacrifice on their end. Also, see example for my husband, same case.

Going back to the original poster:
An almost retired nurse has a salary that is approaching £57,102£ and that is just for a basic nurse with no additional qualifications.
She said she reduced her hours to 30pw, so let's just presume a very low salary as alleged. Bare in mind that nursing staff have a lot of benefits: time off after shifts in which you have time to get extra work (one relative that is a dialisis nurse makes a wooping 150.000£ after taxes from locuming, this is because she works a lot). Let's just assume that OP has restrictions that cannot let her work extensively - at least she can work an extra premium shift to boost her income, there is always staff shortage - she can do as she pleases with that money.
Also, now, how she will manage after her daughter her will move with her BF? Will she take a lodger or move out to downsize?

Is not yet clear if the OP has issues with the behaviour of her daughter or she simply cannot afford to live in that area alone.

I am not saying that all the parents should/can do the same, but at least family should come before money and there are always ways to solve a problem.

I do hope OP finds a good solution for her and her daughter.

What amazing generosity and commitment from your parents.

This however does not detract from the fact that to have the ability to do all that for you, your parents were fortunate and privileged. They have continued to convey that down to you and your children. You are in an incredibly fortunate position. Even having any savings, ability to gift large sums, or ability to take holidays, invest for grandchildren at birth etc places you in the top proportion of wealth in the UK.

It sounds like the OP is far from that, as are the majority of the people in the UK.

Busy75 · 05/01/2024 15:54

NewYear24 · 05/01/2024 15:35

You've got to imagine that with most of her basic living expenses covered by just £500 a month she can save money hand over fist

I hope she is, it would be piss me off if she’s having an extravagant lifestyle and asking for a reduction in housekeeping money.

Exactly. Our DD tried to barter us down only after a couple of months of paying 30% and after speaking to friends who also felt hard done by.

One of the friends also managed to move out last month to a flat share in London, once they also got their priorities in order.

verdantverdure · 05/01/2024 15:53

Cazzalou · 04/01/2024 20:23

18 months ago my daughter spilt up from the BF and moved back home with me.
We agreed that she would pay £500 a month for rent and bills. We live in London.
Now she and BF are back together and are hoping to buy somewhere out in Kent.
She would like to reduce her monthly payments to £300 a month so she can save for the deposit on a new home.
This could take a long time.
Should I agree the reduction or keep it at £500?
Is daughter taking me for a ride?
I'm an almost retired nurse and my monthly income has reduced as I have reduced my working hours to 30 per week.
Am I being mean if I say no?

I wonder if she fully appreciates that by letting her move in you've probably already saved her about £18,000?

verdantverdure · 05/01/2024 15:50

Kisskiss · 05/01/2024 15:39

500 for rent and bills is a bargain for London! Definitely mates / family rates .. if she’s a junior teacher she should still be able to save something out of her salary after paying 500 so I think you should keep it at 500 if you need the cash and maybe explain it that way. I imagine a lot of that 500 is going towards council tax and energy bills anyway

We've had our niece staying for the last month or so and just that she's on a slightly different schedule to us has added to the hours the house needs to be kept warm, and thus the heating bill.

Just the extra bedding and towels and clothes in the laundry has added about three loads a week, we have an old immersion so hot water is expensive, all the extra drying costs money. The extra washing up costs money. The extra baths and showers cost money.

People's set ups are all different but all the additions cost money and over the month they add up.

The weekend she had a couple of friends to stay our smart meter had a proper workout. Grin The display was practically a blur Grin

enchantedsquirrelwood · 05/01/2024 15:47

If she earns more than you do she should theoretically be paying more into the bill pot than you do OP, excluding mortgage payments.

I've always said that when ds gets a "proper job" I'd expect him to contribute to the bills in proportion to his salary and our incomes if he is living at home. I'd not charge rent as I don't have a mortgage.

So if eg I earn £40K, DH earns 40K and DS earns £20K and the bills for food, utilities, council tax etc come to £1000 a month, he should contribute £200.

If they don't like it they can move out and pay a mortgage or rent. They'll soon notice the difference.

ilovebreadsauce · 05/01/2024 15:45

Dd21 is a First year ECT so on £30knamd pays £200 a month which is more than she costs

verdantverdure · 05/01/2024 15:40

Groovy48592747 · 05/01/2024 15:19

I do believe adult 'children' who are working should pay their way.

Can't believe the audacity to even try to bargain you down! I'd never have bartered about payment with my parents.

£500 or just over £100 a week is nothing compared to renting/having your own place. Food, utilities, council tax, etc. I wouldn't 'bargain' with her. She shouldn't go back on an agreement once she's moved in.

I do think it's cheeky too.

Her mum has already saved her a fortune.

With all the price rises she's very lucky ithst £500 hasn't had to go up.

Kisskiss · 05/01/2024 15:39

500 for rent and bills is a bargain for London! Definitely mates / family rates .. if she’s a junior teacher she should still be able to save something out of her salary after paying 500 so I think you should keep it at 500 if you need the cash and maybe explain it that way. I imagine a lot of that 500 is going towards council tax and energy bills anyway