Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be nervous about an undersubscribed one-form entry infant school with declining birth rates?

87 replies

Cheepcheepcheep · 04/01/2024 18:31

Coming to crunch time for Reception applications. I like the idea of a small school for late summer born DD, as does DH - and one of our options is a village school (we are on the edge of a town and would get in based on the last 3 years of data, once due to under subscription and twice on distance).

We’ve visited and it seems very friendly and welcoming. However, it’s one form entry and they only have 20 kids in the current reception. I’m nervous about the idea of going for it as I worry about funding, especially given the decline in birth rates and roll numbers.

Our alternative (and my preference) is a two form entry that we should get into on distance and which has been full this year.

Arguments for this school are the fact we both like it and a lot of her nursery friends are going there.

AIBU for worrying about the size and what that might mean for the future and funding?

To add, as DD is late august we are applying for a deferral - this is just the choice in case we don’t get it. DH has agreed the bigger school would be better if she starts at just turned 5 rather than just turned 4.

OP posts:
Iwant2beJessicaFletcher · 04/01/2024 19:52

It wouldn't have worked for my dd. She is very sporty & needed a 2 form entry to find friends with similar interests (she was never into dolls, dancing, make beleieve etc & the sexes tend to stop playing with each other around year 2/3 in my experience).

Plus, girls friendships get incredibly tricky around year 5 and there are lots of fallings out. Only having around 10 girls in the class your dd could be friends with is likely to cause her (& you) issues.

I would be more concerned about limiting social interactions at a small school as there are just a lot less kids to be friends with & not everyone 'gels' with everyone. Because of that I would never send any of my dc to a school with less than 60 per year (& in seniors there are over 350 a year). Bigger year groups suited us much better.

MrsAvocet · 04/01/2024 19:51

That would be a big school round here!
But yes, I get your concerns. There have been closures and threats of closures of some very small schools in our locality over the years as they've become unsustainable. Over the last 20 years school my children went to has gone from threatened with closure, to pleasantly full, then bursting at the seams now back to undersubscribed and a bit worrying again. Whilst a small drop in applications might not make a huge difference to a two or three form school it can be a real issue if your PAN is 10 and you only get 7 for a few consecutive years. Likewise 11 in 3 consecutive years is also a problem! It's harder to absorb even small variations in a small village school. So you're not unreasonable to have concerns.
However, if you feel strongly that the school is right for your child in all other respects I would probably go for it and cross that bridge if you come to it.
If it's anything like round here nothing would happen quickly even if the school was threatened and there would be time for you to consider your options. The school in the next village to ours was down to tiny numbers a few years ago and nobody could imagine how it could survive but there had to be a consultation period and in that time planning permission was granted for quite a few houses on the edge of the village and now it's thriving again. You really can't predict the future and whilst there's some risk I'd probably be inclined to make your decisions based on the here and now, nit on things which may or may not happen in the future.

Yerroblemom1923 · 04/01/2024 19:47

I'd always go for the small village school every time. My dd went to a primary with less than 60 kids in the whole school and thrived.
The teachers knew all the kids and their parents, it was a lovely close school.
I was worried she'd struggle at the obviously much larger secondary but she's fine - it gave her a really good start to her education.

Rudolphtherednoseddog · 04/01/2024 19:46

It might not close, but in the current funding climate I’d be amazed if classes of twenty, with a full time teacher per class, remained viable long term. They must be making drastic cuts elsewhere. I’d fully expect composite classes - ie mixed year classes. Those are not necessarily a bad thing. But go into it with your eyes open - certainly where I live all the local primary schools are in deficit, the council has absolutely no money, there’s no way any of them can carry tiny class sizes indefinitely. People’s experiences of a few years ago aren’t really relevant anymore, the funding situation is absolutely dire and if I had an alternative of a decent size fully subscribed school then that’s what I’d go for.

Muthaofcats · 04/01/2024 19:45

Trust your gut, go for the bigger one.

well done you for deferring your summer born! The august born 4 year olds in my child’s reception class are so tiny they cry all the time and fall asleep on the carpet and can barely do phonics whilst the 5 year olds are confident and reading. It’s so unfair on the smaller ones.

crumblingschools · 04/01/2024 19:41

Many schools in our locality have under 50 pupils, but will get scarcity funding and share staff across the schools, and obviously have mixed year groups.

Spendonsend · 04/01/2024 19:41

I'd be nervous about a small school with a falling roll. Not so much the risk of closure but resources get so stretched as there are no economies of scale and you dont have the range of people on site to have much resilience.

Readyforrespite · 04/01/2024 19:37

I wouldn't say that's particularly small at all. The school that closed in my area and the other at risk have a handful of children per year group. My DS had 14 in his class last year, risen to 16 this year. We're pretty rural but it is normal here. And I'd say comparing to my nephew who is in a class of 30 my DS has a much better education. Obviously check ofsted reports for both.

58snowreindeer · 04/01/2024 19:36

A small school near me is also proposing to close with notice given of less than a year. If it's consistently below PAN it's very likely to close given the budget pressures on local councils.

Kalevala · 04/01/2024 19:34

TinyYellow · 04/01/2024 19:29

I’d go for the small school and let her start with her correct year group. She would thrive in a reception class of around 20.

I would do the same.

LlynTegid · 04/01/2024 19:34

If it is infant age and does not go up to 11, I'd take school 1. The point about how long it takes to close a school if it ever came to that is one well made.

crumblingschools · 04/01/2024 19:32

Not all Church schools get extra funding.

Is there a nursery attached to the small school, toddler group in the village? Can you get a feeling how many children will be coming through the school.

Really small schools can actually be better off than a school starting the journey to becoming small as they get additional scarcity funding.

One form entry schools with falling roll can struggle with funding whilst they still have classes of about 20 as they are too big to merge year groups, but are missing out on a third of their funding.

TinyYellow · 04/01/2024 19:29

I’d go for the small school and let her start with her correct year group. She would thrive in a reception class of around 20.

wonderingwhatlifemeans · 04/01/2024 19:24

I work near a school that has just announced it is proposing to close at the end of this academic year due to falling pupil numbers. It is a Church of England school. From announcement to closure can happen in a year.

StripeyDeckchair · 04/01/2024 19:14

Don't defer and send her to the small primary school.
To close a school takes years & masses of consultation

inappropriateraspberry · 04/01/2024 19:14

At my children's school there are 4 reception children! 😆 We love being in a small school, all the children know each other, the teachers know all the children (even when not in their class) and being in mixed age classes can push them a little more.
The classes are small and there is a real community feel. I could name all the children and most of the parents!

Orangesandsatsumas · 04/01/2024 19:13

Repeated years like this can cause problems. But it's worth considering lots of other things.

The infant school we use is one form entry year R to year 2. It's tiny. Most years it is als most at 30 but every so often a low birth rate means it is a very low intake. Last year being one of those years with only 15. The previous low intake year was about 7 or so years earlier. Next year, when my next child starts, will likely be low again.

We are fortunate to be in an area where the school has an active PTA and to a certain extent, that funds the gap. However the school doesn't expect the gap to be a problem for a couple of years.

My children have thrived at the school and I sort of wish I had deferred my summer born child by a year as she is in a class of 30. She would have benefitted hugely from the class of 15 the next year.

Houseplantmad · 04/01/2024 19:05

I’d be concerned. A local primary will close in July due to falling roll and demographic. Several other primaries in the area are also under threat. I’d be very cautious.

Coffeespill · 04/01/2024 19:04

If she's going to be the eldest I don't think the smaller class size matters so much. If she's the youngest then it will help.

MintJulia · 04/01/2024 19:02

My ds went to a village school with an annual intake of 17. It was generally good, and a lovely safe environment.

The local council knew they couldn't close the school because the freehold was owned by the local big estate. It had been granted 100 years earlier on peppercorn rent, but with the clear clause that if the building ceased to be a village school, the building would revert to the estate.

The council couldn't sell it for housing, couldn't sell off the playing fields, couldn't really do anything without losing the use of an essentially free primary school. So, funnily enough, they kept it open. 😊

Many village schools have similar clauses. Perhaps check if yours is the same.

Whinge · 04/01/2024 18:57

Our alternative (and my preference) is a two form entry that we should get into on distance and which has been full this year.

I would go for the bigger school. 20 in a year isn't tiny, but I would prefer a bigger group of children for friendships and larger schools usually offer more clubs and extra curricular activities.

It's also worth remembering that you could move from the bigger school to the smaller one, but not the other way round.

Cheepcheepcheep · 04/01/2024 18:57

Thanks all, this is really good food for thought and interesting to hear different perspectives.

School 1 (the undersubscribed 1 form entry) does say they have a good PTA but agree, my concern is that as numbers decline it will impact her school experience. Not helped by the fact we need to send DS to the same school we pick for DD in 2 years so having to have a 6 year crystal ball!

School 2 (the two form) is a similar set up and fairly villagey, but on the edge of town and I think has a more reliable future intake. The village school is in an area where lots of development has been blocked and families are increasingly getting priced out, so that combined with decreasing numbers does worry me.

i don’t think it helps that I read this on another thread today and it’s made me concerned: https://amp.theguardian.com/education/2023/dec/16/primary-schools-in-england-close-merge-and-shrink-as-pupil-numbers-fall

To a PP, not a church school. And I went to a small secondary and hated it as I couldn’t escape the bitchy girls, but I appreciate that’s my own bias and a different age group!

Primary schools in England close, merge and shrink as pupil numbers fall | Primary schools | The Guardian

London boroughs among hardest hit due to falling birth rate and family struggles with Covid and rising costs

https://amp.theguardian.com/education/2023/dec/16/primary-schools-in-england-close-merge-and-shrink-as-pupil-numbers-fall

OP posts:
Tippexy · 04/01/2024 18:57

The smaller one in a heartbeat, so much better for the children not to be one of 30 in the classroom!

scrunchmum · 04/01/2024 18:55

One near us only has 10 children in reception (PAN is around 25) and that has put us off. We thought that it would mean smaller class sizes and that really appealed however they seem to actually mix up the year groups which I feel may hold back older children.

Our other concerns were
Whether the school would be closed if intake continues to decline, although it is CofE which means that's less likely.
The school getting sufficient funding for basics and extras (CofE is also a factor here though)
We need wrap around care and I would worry about the sustainability of the external company who run that continuing to do so at the school with fewer "customers"
Other clubs / extra curricular activities / trips not having sufficient numbers to be worthwhile

Monsterjam · 04/01/2024 18:53

Mine go to a school with 6-10 per yr max. They academised last yr which seems to have brought with it an abundance of extra opportunities and funding. One of mine is 31st Aug and not deferred and the smaller setting has done wonders for him. The kids have such a nice experience.
I am concerned that secondary school will be a shock but we will deal with that as it comes