Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be nervous about an undersubscribed one-form entry infant school with declining birth rates?

87 replies

Cheepcheepcheep · 04/01/2024 18:31

Coming to crunch time for Reception applications. I like the idea of a small school for late summer born DD, as does DH - and one of our options is a village school (we are on the edge of a town and would get in based on the last 3 years of data, once due to under subscription and twice on distance).

We’ve visited and it seems very friendly and welcoming. However, it’s one form entry and they only have 20 kids in the current reception. I’m nervous about the idea of going for it as I worry about funding, especially given the decline in birth rates and roll numbers.

Our alternative (and my preference) is a two form entry that we should get into on distance and which has been full this year.

Arguments for this school are the fact we both like it and a lot of her nursery friends are going there.

AIBU for worrying about the size and what that might mean for the future and funding?

To add, as DD is late august we are applying for a deferral - this is just the choice in case we don’t get it. DH has agreed the bigger school would be better if she starts at just turned 5 rather than just turned 4.

OP posts:
TrashedSofa · 04/01/2024 22:05

I can see why you'd worry that the smaller place isn't the long term option you need.

ZeroFucksGivenToday · 04/01/2024 22:04

One thing to consider is how you'll feel about maybe moving her if things change in a few years.

we picked a small village primary school for my daughter. 17 per year entry and mixed classes.

In reality it was a bad decision for us as the achool was quite poor and took no feedback.
However our main issue became the friendship groups. It was just too small, so any fall outs were hugely magnified and a couple of the kids really clashed.

In the end we moved to a single form entry but bigger primary school and it's helped my daughter lots. She's now being challenged. There's enough kids to dilute fall outs and get away from it if needed.
In two terms 8 of us removed out children for various reasons.

EcoCustard · 04/01/2024 22:04

I will add that our small village s hook has a good array of clubs & activities after school & at lunchtime run by teachers, TA’s and a few external sport groups. They also participate in lots of competitions & shows locally & further afield. Friends were quite scathing when we picked our local school due to its size and are often surprised at some of the stuff they take part in. I would agree with @Imuptoolate about not being able to get away from disruptive kid or in DD’s case a very noisy one or if they fall out it can be tricky.

cigarettesNalcohol · 04/01/2024 22:00

My DH went to a small primary hen he was little. Only 7 boys in reception. He said it was brilliant and the teaching was great. Made friends with everyone and thrived.

EcoCustard · 04/01/2024 21:57

Dd is August born and goes to the small village primary with siblings. Reception is 14-16 pupils she thrived in her class of 14 and was one of 3 girls, she’s year 2 now and is working above expectations in all areas, doing well and is very happy there. Siblings thrived & brother is currently in reception now (he’s early summer born). They have mixed yr1/2 class, 3/4 & 5/6 classes too, it’s undersubscribed currently. I would go for the smaller classes of village school, with a potential of 20 on roll I doubt it would close anytime soon.

Imuptoolate · 04/01/2024 21:48

As a teacher who has worked in 1 form entry and 3 form entry, some things to think about…

Pros of 1 form:

  • More relaxed vibe for the children, no rushing around to swap sets for Maths/English etc.
  • Teacher can be more spontaneous/child led because they are running on their own timetable and don’t have to be ‘consistent’ with other classes in the year group, as they are the only class
  • Children get to know all of the teachers in the school really quickly, helps with transitions to higher year groups
  • Teachers and TAs tend to stay together in the same year group each year, meaning they are highly knowledgeable on that year group’s curriculum

Cons of 1 form:

  • The smaller pool of potential friends can cause real problems. Even 2 form entries that don’t mix classes up, will likely still mix the children up into sets for certain lessons and children will have more people to mix with on the playground
  • On the same note, if there is a particularly disruptive child in the class, or a child that for whatever reason your child doesn’t get on with, there is never any opportunity in the day to get away from them
  • The workload for teachers is significantly higher in a smaller school, so if you have a teacher who isn’t very organised then the children will potentially miss out on opportunities if things aren’t resourced/planned as well. In a 2 form entry, the teachers will share the planning - the less subjects you have to plan, the more time you can spend on making each one as effective as possible.
  • Less extra curricular activities. Because the budget is smaller, TAs and teachers will likely be used to cover lunchtimes and playground duties. In a bigger school, teachers are more freed up to run clubs during lunchtimes.

Obviously I can’t speak for every 1 form/multiple form school, but these are things I have observed/experienced.

ThanksItHasPockets · 04/01/2024 21:33

I’m really fascinated by the horror of big schools that I often read on MN. IME children don’t realise that their school is especially big - it’s only as adults that we take in the scale of the whole institution. Children just plough their little furrow to their classroom, their playground etc. Bigger schools almost always have separate play spaces for different key stages and will generally stagger lunch times. There’s no getting away from your bully in a tiny school.

The benefits of bigger schools are significant and the economies of scale aren’t limited to finance. There’s a positive impact on workload when teachers can share planning and it’s less likely that one teacher will find themselves trying to lead multiple subjects with minimal support. I have great respect for teachers who choose to work in very small schools as it is HARD but they would not be my choice for my own children.

Cakescakescake · 04/01/2024 21:14

I wanted the smaller school and intake for dd. I would rather have the smaller teacher to kids ratio.

Numbers have increased since she started and year on year continues to increase.

All of the teachers, heads included, know all of the students.

I went to small schools and hate the idea of big schools. I really dread when she goes to secondary as it's literally 10 times the number of students in the one she will go to than the primary she's at.
I fear the possibility of bullying etc will increase with so many more kids.

ThanksItHasPockets · 04/01/2024 21:00

YANBU to be concerned. I don’t think many people have grasped that the fall in the birth rate is so steep that PAN reductions have already started and school closures will follow. The school is unlikely to close imminently but there is a good chance that they could reduce the PAN to 15 and introduce dual-year classes, so you should consider whether this would be an issue for you.

I will only add that the decision to defer isn’t the silver bullet that is sometimes suggested on MN. We did not defer our bright mid-August girl and this was the right choice for her, even acknowledging my confirmation bias. It can be as damaging to the child (and more disruptive to others) to be bored and unchallenged by school as it can to be significantly behind peers. It’s a complex decision to be taken on an individual basis.

Whinge · 04/01/2024 20:39

Kalevala · 04/01/2024 20:28

This can also happen with a two form entry if the classes are not mixed each year.

You're right it can still happen, but at least with 2 form entry there are more chances to find friends and opportunities to spend time with them even if they're in the other class. I'm sure there are schools that don't mix classes, but in my experience most schools do it at some point, even if it's not every year.

Saschka · 04/01/2024 20:36

Lots of people stating they single form entry schools are better “because the children all know each other”, or “because the teachers all know the children”.

DS goes to a two form entry primary, and the teachers all know him (even out of context - his headmaster came over to say hi in the park over summer), and he seems to know pretty much every child in the school (definitely knows everyone in his year, knows lots of people in the year above and below from playtime, and recognises children from much older years from after school clubs). A good school will just know all their pupils.

Kalevala · 04/01/2024 20:28

Whinge · 04/01/2024 19:58

Only having around 10 girls in the class your dd could be friends with is likely to cause her (& you) issues.

I agree this is something to be mindful of. It's all lovely when they're in reception and play with anyone, but once they get to around 7 they really start to form smaller friendship groups. Unfortunately having such a limited pool of potential friends often causes lots of problems.

This can also happen with a two form entry if the classes are not mixed each year.

MojoMoon · 04/01/2024 20:26

My nearest primary is closing in July (inner London borough).

Sad but it is one form entry and it's really hard financially for smaller schools as no economy of scale. It was a Good Ofsted school but just isn't the number of kids in area and it's the most sensible school to close economically.

It had 24 in reception this year. It wasn't that the school itself was much less popular anywhere nearby - all the local schools are not full. But because it is small, it makes more sense to close it and redistribute the children to other larger schools with empty places.

Sad for the kids there of course.

I think you are wise to be thinking of the risk of closure - are other schools in the area under subscribed? Is there a general surplus of places in the local education authority area? This would increase the risk to the school.

LolaSmiles · 04/01/2024 20:17

If you like the smaller school and think it will be a good fit, I'd go for it.

If everyone who likes a smaller school keeps opting for the big schools just in case, the numbers will fall. If enough people apply for where they think is best for their children things will stay steady unless there's a substantial change in birth rate, but even then parents want different things from schools.

I don't like large primary schools and neither does DH, probably because we both went to small primary schools ourselves and I find primary schools the size of some secondaries overwhelming.

PuttingDownRoots · 04/01/2024 20:16

@mindutopia I know of Primary schools with 6 form entry i.e 180 children per year!

My DDs have had as little as 16 in a year at one school, and as many as 120. My preference is two form entry as they get older. But friends have been very happy in village schools. There's no one right answer.

Zanatdy · 04/01/2024 20:16

My DS is late Aug too and he went to a primary with a 2 form intake and a secondary with 350 intake, he applied to Oxford Uni so didn’t do him any harm (no deferral, when he was at that age you had to go straight into year 1 if you deferred plus we didn’t see the need as he had been attending full time nursery and thriving). He was tiny, for years, but as I saw the fact he was in a big school was never a disadvantage. I think bigger schools often benefit from better facilities etc

Reugny · 04/01/2024 20:13

ShoePalaver · 04/01/2024 20:10

My August 28th born 4 year old has never cried or fallen asleep at school. And is in the top group for phonics. She absolutely loves school. Just to give another perspective. We considered deferring her but decided against and so far it seems to be the right decision.

If reception children are crying daily at school that suggests an issue with the school.

There are some factors on which deferral are supposedly a good idea.

Any child that is a girl immediately falls foul of this.

(The other ones linked to boys are socio-economic class, ethnicity and SEN. )

mindutopia · 04/01/2024 20:12

That sounds great. Mine have always gone to small village schools. Our current school has 13 in reception and 86 in the whole school. It’s lovely and we have a strong involved community. The next village over has only 35 in the whole school and 2 classes (reception/Y1/2 & Y3/4/5/6). That’s a bit too small for me, but I personally wouldn’t want more than a 1 form entry. My friends dd had 90 in year for reception. 😳

ShoePalaver · 04/01/2024 20:10

Muthaofcats · 04/01/2024 19:45

Trust your gut, go for the bigger one.

well done you for deferring your summer born! The august born 4 year olds in my child’s reception class are so tiny they cry all the time and fall asleep on the carpet and can barely do phonics whilst the 5 year olds are confident and reading. It’s so unfair on the smaller ones.

My August 28th born 4 year old has never cried or fallen asleep at school. And is in the top group for phonics. She absolutely loves school. Just to give another perspective. We considered deferring her but decided against and so far it seems to be the right decision.

If reception children are crying daily at school that suggests an issue with the school.

Reugny · 04/01/2024 20:10

PuttingDownRoots · 04/01/2024 20:02

If its not a fluke year, I'd expect them to combine classes at some point.

Not necessarily.

When my primary school did it in the 1980s we still ended up with class sizes of 25.

Also there is no guarantee that other parents may not have the same idea as the OP for this September.

My DD goes to an one form entry CofE school that was under subscribed for the previous 5 years. Her class has 30 children and had a waiting list of 13. The years before there are 18 to 25 children.

Likewise a friend in a different part of the SE sends her children to a one form entry state school. Her oldest child's year is under subscribed even though there were more births in that year than 5-6 years ago. Her youngest child year is full.

One of the issues is that people are becoming more knowledgable. So in our cases we like other parents know that school entry is based on distance not catchment, religion has nothing to do with it for CofE schools in our cases, and that OFSTED reports are completely unreliable.

Desolatewardrobe · 04/01/2024 20:08

We’ve got mixed classes which I was a bit worried about. But it’s fine actually. No idea how they actually manage it but the school’s results are great so clearly they do, and my kids have never had a problem with it.

ShoePalaver · 04/01/2024 20:07

20 isn't that small, they would probably combine age groups rather than close altogether.
Also there may be a COVID baby boom the year after, there is in my area
I would choose the school that's best for your child rather than worry too much about school size. A small class is a huge bonus at reception age even if they end up in a bigger class later on.

Mynaddmawr · 04/01/2024 20:02

I went to a very small primary in the 90's, there were 6 pupils in my year, 3 in the year below. My niece is currently in year 3 in the same school and there are 7 in her year, no talk of funding issues due to size. There are pros and cons but I think you get a better experience in a smaller cohort

PuttingDownRoots · 04/01/2024 20:02

If its not a fluke year, I'd expect them to combine classes at some point.

Whinge · 04/01/2024 19:58

Only having around 10 girls in the class your dd could be friends with is likely to cause her (& you) issues.

I agree this is something to be mindful of. It's all lovely when they're in reception and play with anyone, but once they get to around 7 they really start to form smaller friendship groups. Unfortunately having such a limited pool of potential friends often causes lots of problems.

Swipe left for the next trending thread