Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want anything to do with my sister in law?

84 replies

grimandtonictl · 04/01/2024 01:58

Me and my DH have recently found out we are expecting our first child. A massive shock as we have been trying for nearly 10 years with no result. Had our 12 week scan today and have been told everything is progressing as it should.

My parents live locally (20 minute drive) so we went and told them the news and texted DHs parents and close friends and other family the news also.

SIL is younger than my DH. She struggles with mental health issues and IMO she is pampered by her parents- they top up her rent payments, support her with bills etc.

The issue is she dabbles in drugs- cocaine to be precise. Im not saying i think shes going to shove a bag of cocaine up my daughters nose, but drug addicts are not trustworthy people. I have little experience in dealing with drug users so im trying not to form my own opinions here but general consensus etc.

There have been times my in laws have had to bail her out, drug dealers have been at their door etc and the police ended up getting involved around 6 months ago as someone broke into their home while they were on holiday. This wasnt SIL herself I will stress- she was on holiday with them. But there is suspicion it is to do with a drug debt she owed.

She is attending a drug recovery program- again, I know little about these things but after years of ups and downs- can I be expected to trust her? Even if there are results to be seen, I dont know if i can.

It causes my DH a lot of stress as obviously his parents are getting older now and they are extremely upset/stressed out.

We have very little contact with her- I can count on one hand the amount of times I have seen her since we got married 13 yeard ago. She didnt even come to our wedding.

AIBU to not want her around my child?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Winnipeggy · 04/01/2024 12:30

Well if you want to see your PIL you'll have to get over it. I promise once you have a baby you will have many, many more things to think about than your SIL holding your baby once a week

SEG152 · 04/01/2024 11:07

Firstly congrats,

as previous posters have said, no you shouldn’t be handing over your baby for her to toddle off with alone but I wouldn’t see an issue with her visiting more and wanting to be involved. This could be the positive change in her life that she needs and of course if any boundaries are over stepped take action but until that happens stop stressing and creating issues in your head and enjoy this special time.

Rozbos · 04/01/2024 11:01

Huge congratulations OP. I think as others have said you are maybe focussing too much on your sister in law. I would imagine she has caused your PIL a huge amount of stress over the years which has been fed back to you. In reality, don't leave your baby alone with her and all will be fine. I wouldn't trust her to babysit but given the limited contact that you have with her that's unlikely to be an issue. As long as you are there you will always safe guard your child. That's all they need. Enjoy your pregnancy and put this aside. It's not something you need to dwell on.

JadziaD · 04/01/2024 11:00

Goodlard · 04/01/2024 10:49

What on earth do you think will happen whilst you're there?

If you haven't personally engaged with a known drug addict, it can be quite scary. We've all see tv shows where addicts are running around doing crazy things etc. In the real world, it's obviously less extreme in most cases.

I do remember though that the first time we took the DC to see in laws after we all knew that BIL was using again, I did feel a lot of irrational fear. I quickly realised that day to day, as long as we were around, it was fine. We implemented the "no driving" rule and DH and I didn't make a big song and dance about it but we agreed between us that not only would we never allow him to be alone with the DC, but we wouldn't leave the DC with MIL/FIL if BIL was there as we suspected MIL/FIL wouldn't be as vigilant about ensuring BIL wasn't in charge of them.

But the uncertainty and unknowing was scary so I do understand where OP is coming from, even while I agree she needs to chill out about it.

TheCorrupter · 04/01/2024 10:55

God just babywear.

Goodlard · 04/01/2024 10:49

grimandtonictl · 04/01/2024 02:19

Sorry i should of been more clear.

Chances are we will visit more regularly. And then there will be things like Christmas etc- she is single, PIL will be unlikely be willing to leave her (understanble) but want to spend a Christmas with their GC etc

They see her everyday so if we are there and she comes round I dont know what to do. I dont want to the one who says "dont touch my baby" but at the same time do I trust her.

What on earth do you think will happen whilst you're there?

Couchant · 04/01/2024 10:43

KenAdams · 04/01/2024 10:07

You're 12 weeks pregnant and going you're on about keeping SIL from her parents at Christmas.

Just chill out and focus on the pregnancy you've waited 10 years for. You don't know where your SIL will be progress wise in 6 months.

This. Stop borrowing trouble.

StaunchMomma · 04/01/2024 10:37

Of course you'd be in your rights to not allow her to babysit etc, but there's no need to make this an issue now when you have a good chunk of pregnancy left and, by your own admission, you hardly ever see SIL anyway.

I'd chalk this up to protective Momma feelings kicking in due to pregnancy hormones and try to forget about it.

KenAdams · 04/01/2024 10:07

You're 12 weeks pregnant and going you're on about keeping SIL from her parents at Christmas.

Just chill out and focus on the pregnancy you've waited 10 years for. You don't know where your SIL will be progress wise in 6 months.

JadziaD · 04/01/2024 10:06

OP, I think you are taking a bit of a beating here. Posters are right that you are making this into more of a drama than it needs to be, but if you've been trying for 10 years, I can understand why things feel so completely overwhelming.

Re your SIL, in the beginning, your baby isn't going anywhere without you anyway. As the baby grows and has more involvement with other family members, you can play that by ear according to how you feel at the time. it is totally not worth stressing about now because, and this is very important... YOU get to control who has the baby and spends time with the baby.

I'd also say that you need to understand that someone who is an addict or high being around your baby is not intrinsically dangerous but from experience, I can tell you that yes, you will be on higher alert and that as the in law, you will also be pooh poohed at times. Luckily, DH was on my side so when we said that BIL was not allowed to ever drive any of our DC anywhere (when we visited DH's side of the family), even if he was with other people, I got lots of eye rolling, but it was fine and that was a line I was not willing to cross.

Go back into your pregnancy bubble and let it go for now with th knowledge that you will be in control.

Mrsjayy · 04/01/2024 10:06

why would she be around your child you hardly see her what is she going to do to your baby ?

pictoosh · 04/01/2024 10:02

electriclight · 04/01/2024 06:34

It is honestly staggering to me that at such a happy time you are already focused on trying cut someone out of your baby's life.

I wouldn't want her to babysit but think you are being very dramatic about her visiting or touching your baby - honestly, ridiculously so.

Yes I agree with this.

Do you seize opportunities to take control and centre stage? Do you often exploit other people's foibles to promote your own agenda? Do you like conflict where people are forced to take sides or pay attention to you?

Seems to me you want drama.

Player001 · 04/01/2024 09:56

I found it hard to get past the part where you said you told your parents in person but sent a text to DH's parents. Seems like you are simply laying the groundwork nice and early to cut your in laws out of your life.

Future thread titles include but are not limited to: PIL enable SIL, AIBU to go NC with them all?

withthischoice · 04/01/2024 09:53

Nelliemellie · 04/01/2024 09:46

Load of replies by posters who have never been in that position giving their opinions. Your feelings are justified, and trust your instincts. My brother is unstable mentally, I wouldn’t trust him even now. Someone on drugs is not in their right mind.

did you clock the op has seen her SIL

ONCE
in
13 YEARS

hydriotaphia · 04/01/2024 09:53

I do think YABU to unilaterally say that you won't allow her to be around your child at all. Growing up, my uncle was an alcoholic who was in a relationship with a heroin addict. While I never had a close relationship with him I saw him at family events and I am glad I had that limited relationship with him (he has now passed away). I grew up happily and without any of these struggles 'rubbing off' on me. I do not think your niece should be allowed to babysit or be one on one with the child, and I think it would be best not to visit her at her house. However, her struggles do not mean that she has nothing to offer as an auntie.

Nelliemellie · 04/01/2024 09:46

Load of replies by posters who have never been in that position giving their opinions. Your feelings are justified, and trust your instincts. My brother is unstable mentally, I wouldn’t trust him even now. Someone on drugs is not in their right mind.

Velvian · 04/01/2024 09:36

@Sartre I would be confident that there is something in your SIL's childhood. I would take a guess at childhood/teen sexual abuse. Fair enough that you have nothing to do with her, it sounds a more extreme situation that OP's SIL, but I think you and DH could think a bit more carefully about your opinion of her.

Jessforless · 04/01/2024 09:33

So you spent 10 years trying to conceive and are now 12 weeks pregnant.. and your biggest concern is around someone you currently see less than every two years?

Calm down OP, honestly. There are bigger things to worry about.

Sartre · 04/01/2024 09:30

My SIL is a drug addict and we have nothing to do with her at all. This is DH’s choice as much as mine, she is trouble and there’s no way we want that sort of bullshit on our doorstep. She’s also had a lot of trouble with dangerous drug dealers and indeed the police over the years. She’s currently homeless because she’s shacked up with a heroin addict and become addicted to that herself. They keep causing trouble in shelters so get kicked out and PILs have understandably washed their hands of her unless she sorts her shit out, she kept stealing their belongings.

Wealthy middle class family and she was privately educated, nothing in her upbringing to cause this and DH is totally normal. MIL just thinks she’s severely mentally ill and blames that, maybe the case but we don’t want any part in it.

Cosycover · 04/01/2024 09:25

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 04/01/2024 09:21

Don't be one of those parents OP.
Holier than thou much!

You realise there are everyday people who were RAISED by drug addicts?

Like pp have said, stop trying to control the family dynamics just because you're having a child.
SIL is your in-laws child and they love her dearly despite her struggles.
She gets support from them which she clearly needs.
You sound a bit resentful of this but that's not for you to get involved in.
It causes your DH distress because he too loves her.
Don't be the one to make things worse.

This with bells on.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 04/01/2024 09:21

Don't be one of those parents OP.
Holier than thou much!

You realise there are everyday people who were RAISED by drug addicts?

Like pp have said, stop trying to control the family dynamics just because you're having a child.
SIL is your in-laws child and they love her dearly despite her struggles.
She gets support from them which she clearly needs.
You sound a bit resentful of this but that's not for you to get involved in.
It causes your DH distress because he too loves her.
Don't be the one to make things worse.

justanothermanicmonday1 · 04/01/2024 09:17

vorhees · 04/01/2024 02:06

Honestly, I wouldn't ruffle feathers over this. I mean I wouldn't let her babysit, but I'd let her around the child so long as she's not high at that time and there's others around.

Definitely agree with this.

If you already are low contact then just keep it that way.

I'd let her visit the baby and hold the baby. Like you said, she won't shove a bag a cocaine up the nose of your DC, but don't leave them unsupervised.

PaperDoIIs · 04/01/2024 09:12

You're worrying unnecessarily right now. First of all she might have no interest in your child. It happens a lot more often than you think, even with people that don't already have a lot on your plate. Then , you barely see her and while there might be family occasions there will be few and far between, with your inlaws ,you and your DH there to supervise and intervene. Touching the baby won't harm them. Just don't leave the baby alone with her,have her baby sit and if she's high when you see her you can just leave if you don't want that around your child.

None of this is as urgent or dire or as risky as you're making yourself believe.

Goldbar · 04/01/2024 09:06

She may not be interested. She sounds like she has a lot on her plate.

FFF3 · 04/01/2024 08:56

What?! As long as you’re not leaving the baby in her care, what is the issue? The child is going to come across all sorts of people in life - it’s up to you to protect her where necessary, not ban her from it entirely. I honestly can’t grasp the issue if she spends Christmas with you or whatever. My sister doesn’t do drugs, but nor would I trust her to babysit - I haven’t explicitly told her that!

Swipe left for the next trending thread