Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

HMV describing Jewish refugee children as Central European Children

164 replies

Trulywonderful · 03/01/2024 22:26

Would I be unreasonable to as any of you on twitter or willing to write an email complaint to HMV to do me a favour

HMV have described the Jewish refugee children in the new One Life film as Central European Children. This is erasing there Jewishness from the description. I know some may feel objection to this is petty but at the moment the Jewish community are seeing a far bit of this behaviour. Erasing us from things to make people feel more comfortable etc

Anyway if people want to help and tweet about this or email HMV I would be very grateful

HMV describing Jewish refugee children as Central European Children
OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
AlisonDonut · 04/01/2024 06:51

Its just language guys.

Surely all you birthing parents understand we have to be inclusive now? We can't point anyone out and anyone that does, is themselves a Nazi bigot.

Coffeespill · 04/01/2024 06:26

Sapphire387 · 03/01/2024 23:13

I would agree with 'mostly Jewish' being used, for sure - but would rather not see my grandmother's identity erased. It is factually inaccurate to just say they were Jewish when over 100 were not. And that doesn't feel like 'whataboutery' to me - I loved her very dearly.

I haven't seen this but of course I don't agree with anyone trying to sugar-coat it and pretending it was just a bunch of random kids.

I would agree with this.

TinyYellow · 04/01/2024 06:22

It would have been inaccurate to use the word Jewish where you want it because as you have recognised, many of the children being referred to weren’t Jewish. Those children shouldn’t be erased either and it would be wrong to promote the idea that the holocaust in WW2 only affected Jews.

Sauerkrautsandwich · 04/01/2024 06:11

It should be mentioned yeah.
Our articles usually say "children, mostly Jewish". I think that's fair description

KarenNotAKaren · 04/01/2024 01:16

PurpleChrayne · 03/01/2024 23:12

Of course this is a conscious decision to erase the Jewishness of the majority of the children involved. It's disgusting.

Baddiel was right. Jews don't count.

Except we do. And we won't take this lying down.

Absolutely. It’s a scary time for us, and I will not give in to this racism

KarenNotAKaren · 04/01/2024 01:07

Wow!!

I am sick to the back teeth of Jewish erasure. It is anti-Semitic to change the language of what Jewish people are. It’s happening everywhere - people are even denying that Jesus was Jewish. And Holocaust deniers have bigger voices too.

Why are people afraid to say ‘Jew’?

I have fatigue from fire fighting this for me and for my children.

SemperIdem · 04/01/2024 00:06

The title could be more specific and would be better for it.

It is not inaccurate as it stands however, not all of the children involved were Jewish. Just as not all of the people targeted during the Holocaust were Jewish.

Trulywonderful · 04/01/2024 00:05

istoodonlegoagain · 03/01/2024 23:51

But if they were not all Jewish then surely it's not unreasonable not to refer to them as Jewish children? It's not about erasing their identity, it's about being factually correct. If you call them Jewish children and 10% (or whatever %) aren't Jewish then it's not only erasing the minority, but it's incorrect. Maybe "predominantly Jewish" would be better?

Agree with your suggestion works fine

It is the idea that they talk about the children like they could be any European Children that is the issue

OP posts:
MargaretThursday · 04/01/2024 00:04

My great aunt was one saved. She wasn't Jewish, but her parents were saving Jews from the Nazis. They were sent to a concentration camp because of this.

I am sure my great Aunt would prefer them all to be called Jews than it not mentioned at all.

Trulywonderful · 03/01/2024 23:59

Soontobe60 · 03/01/2024 23:22

So then surely you should be complaining about not identifying each different demographic of children who the Nazis wanted destroyed. I know about the Jewish children and families because I went to a school where around 3/4 of the girls were Jewish and as this was in the 70s, a great deal of those girls were direct descendants of Jews who fled the Nazis. It wasn’t until much more recently that I fully understood about the other groups that were also persecuted. I’m sorry that you see this as a deliberate omission. I hope it wasn’t.

Edited

School education of the holocaust is yes often very poor depending on the school and who is teaching it. However if you pop on the main holocaust memorial/ remembrance websites you will see they do talk about everyone.

Plus if you go to a holocaust memorial in the UK or most places in Euro that is run by the Jewish community you will see that other ethnic groups are mentioned on those too

What you experienced I am guessing is bad education about the Holocaust in the UK. This is something that I very much would like to address. For instance books used like the boy in the stripped pyjamas. That one was written by someone that has said in interviews they knew very little about the Holocaust when they wrote the book but had learnt more after writing it. Hence the reason it has not got much factual detail etc

OP posts:
BubziOwl · 03/01/2024 23:55

I am always very upset by the complete lack of acknowledgement of Romany victims of the holocaust. But I agree that "Central European children" feels a little off.

I think that in headlines such as these, something like "hundreds of Central European children who were mostly Jewish" seems reasonable perhaps?

istoodonlegoagain · 03/01/2024 23:51

But if they were not all Jewish then surely it's not unreasonable not to refer to them as Jewish children? It's not about erasing their identity, it's about being factually correct. If you call them Jewish children and 10% (or whatever %) aren't Jewish then it's not only erasing the minority, but it's incorrect. Maybe "predominantly Jewish" would be better?

OhpoorMe · 03/01/2024 23:47

Have you seen the film? It addresses this.

The point of Winton having to organise the trains was because the children didn't qualify for kindertransport, as that was restricted at the time to Jewish children from Germany and Poland, and these were displaced children in Czechoslovakia. Yes of course the majority were displaced as they were Jewish and so fleeing, but not all. They were children who appeared on vulnerable lists because they living in unhygienic camps, and were unlikely to survive winter.

sleepingdragon · 03/01/2024 23:46

The Sir Nicholas Winton Memorial Trust describes them on their website as Czech children, then later as mostly Jewish. They also say on their website that the film has been been written by Sir Winton's daughter, so it sounds like something to take up with them- particularly as the similarities in the descriptions suggests that the media outlets have taken the info from the press release?

I can't ever work out how to link sorry- hopefully this works- https://www.nicholaswinton.com/

Sir Nicholas Winton

This is the official website of Sir Nicholas Winton who was known for organising the rescue of 669 Czech children from Nazi-occupied Czechoslovakia during the 9 months before world war 2 broke out in 1939.

https://www.nicholaswinton.com/

hotdiggetydog · 03/01/2024 23:45

SerpentEndBench · 03/01/2024 22:40

You have a point.

One Life (bbc.co.uk) I note that The BBC here in the press release say that Mr Winton and co rescued 669 children from the Nazis. No mention of their Jewishness.

What is going on?

Judaism*

tobee · 03/01/2024 23:37

Let's put it this way; would they have done this for other groups? I think not.

Mostly Jewish. It's not hard.

Yanbu op.

VanityDiesHard · 03/01/2024 23:37

It's disgusting, isn't it? You have my full support and I will also write to HMV. It shocks me that anti-Semitism is such an acceptable prejudice.

Flatulence · 03/01/2024 23:34

Thank you for highlighting this. I'll message them.
The vast majority of the children Sir Nicholas rescued were Jewish, from a population where they were very much the minority. To not state this or, worse, simply say they were "central European" is misleading when it was the very fact that the Nazis didn't consider Jewish people to be "central European" that put most of the children he saved at risk.
Yes, a proportion were not Jewish and that should not be forgotten. But when the overwhelm majority were and when their Jewishness is why they were in that situation it's remiss not to mention it.

Soontobe60 · 03/01/2024 23:22

Trulywonderful · 03/01/2024 23:00

Not just Jewish you are right yes

Nobody wants to erase them either. The issue here is the way some of the descriptions for the film have been written is miss leading to say the least.

The nazis didn't just want to dehumanised, kill or put in camps random European citizens.

There were specific groups of people that had to flee

Edited

So then surely you should be complaining about not identifying each different demographic of children who the Nazis wanted destroyed. I know about the Jewish children and families because I went to a school where around 3/4 of the girls were Jewish and as this was in the 70s, a great deal of those girls were direct descendants of Jews who fled the Nazis. It wasn’t until much more recently that I fully understood about the other groups that were also persecuted. I’m sorry that you see this as a deliberate omission. I hope it wasn’t.

Trulywonderful · 03/01/2024 23:19

Sapphire387 · 03/01/2024 23:13

I would agree with 'mostly Jewish' being used, for sure - but would rather not see my grandmother's identity erased. It is factually inaccurate to just say they were Jewish when over 100 were not. And that doesn't feel like 'whataboutery' to me - I loved her very dearly.

I haven't seen this but of course I don't agree with anyone trying to sugar-coat it and pretending it was just a bunch of random kids.

Sorry if you thought that was directed at yourself. I was just trying to get ahead of too much whataboutism that tends to happen on these threads. My opening post was written in a rush and could have been worded better. Therefore I was trying to correct that. Sorry for any misunderstanding there.

OP posts:
Sapphire387 · 03/01/2024 23:13

Trulywonderful · 03/01/2024 23:09

I think we could whatabout this a fair bit. However the point is these were not random central European Children. These were groups targeted by the nazis. Most of which in this case were Jewish

Some media and business are currently a bit reluctant to use the word Jewish on anything. That has to stop before it becomes a thing most do. Jewish people around the world and definitely in the UK should not have to put up with their history or identity being censured, rewritten or erased.

I am sure the other identities of the children would have been mentioned by these people if it wasn't for the fact they are avoiding writing the J word

Edited

I would agree with 'mostly Jewish' being used, for sure - but would rather not see my grandmother's identity erased. It is factually inaccurate to just say they were Jewish when over 100 were not. And that doesn't feel like 'whataboutery' to me - I loved her very dearly.

I haven't seen this but of course I don't agree with anyone trying to sugar-coat it and pretending it was just a bunch of random kids.

PurpleChrayne · 03/01/2024 23:12

Of course this is a conscious decision to erase the Jewishness of the majority of the children involved. It's disgusting.

Baddiel was right. Jews don't count.

Except we do. And we won't take this lying down.

Trulywonderful · 03/01/2024 23:09

I think we could whatabout this a fair bit. However the point is these were not random central European Children. These were groups targeted by the nazis. Most of which in this case were Jewish

Some media and business are currently a bit reluctant to use the word Jewish on anything. That has to stop before it becomes a thing most do. Jewish people around the world and definitely in the UK should not have to put up with their history or identity being censured, rewritten or erased.

I am sure the other identities of the children would have been mentioned by these people if it wasn't for the fact they are avoiding writing the J word

OP posts:
BackCat · 03/01/2024 23:08

YANBU

Sapphire387 · 03/01/2024 23:05

DragonMama3 · 03/01/2024 22:59

Was she Romani?

She was not, no.

The family were political, very well known for being socialists, and then her mother, my great-grandmother, got married to a Jewish man (my grandma's stepdad).

I'm not completely clear on how this happened - but she came on the train with her younger brother and their mother also came with them. Definitely one of the Winton children - they were on the last of the trains to successfully make the journey.

She remembered the German guards stopping them at the border, ordering a load of them off the train and rifling through their belongings.