Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

HMV describing Jewish refugee children as Central European Children

164 replies

Trulywonderful · 03/01/2024 22:26

Would I be unreasonable to as any of you on twitter or willing to write an email complaint to HMV to do me a favour

HMV have described the Jewish refugee children in the new One Life film as Central European Children. This is erasing there Jewishness from the description. I know some may feel objection to this is petty but at the moment the Jewish community are seeing a far bit of this behaviour. Erasing us from things to make people feel more comfortable etc

Anyway if people want to help and tweet about this or email HMV I would be very grateful

HMV describing Jewish refugee children as Central European Children
OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Verv · 05/01/2024 16:46

NewJobNewMeNewLife · 05/01/2024 00:06

I find it ironic that on a thread about deleting a minority group by failing to mention the childrens’ Judaism that several posters have suggested an alternative that would delete other minority groups.

The kindertransport started in response to Kristallnacht. Kristallnacht was a pogrom specifically against the Jews, not the Roma, not homosexuals, not the disabled.
Winton was Jewish, the vast majority of the children were Jewish, and the first transport was 200 Jewish children from a Jewish orphanage decimated in Berlin during the Kristallnacht, a pogrom designed to delete Jewish people.

Ironic that Kristallnacht wasn't as inclusive of other minority groups as MNetters.

NewJobNewMeNewLife · 05/01/2024 16:41

Being Romany is.

Mushroomsouptonight · 05/01/2024 04:41

NewJobNewMeNewLife · 05/01/2024 00:06

I find it ironic that on a thread about deleting a minority group by failing to mention the childrens’ Judaism that several posters have suggested an alternative that would delete other minority groups.

Political refugees? Is that a recognised minority group?

Mushroomsouptonight · 05/01/2024 04:40

Trulywonderful · 04/01/2024 23:57

Well all the complaints they got about this worked. This thread and other social media messages were about getting people to complain via yweet and email. Also to debate this type of situation and what is currently happening regarding Jewish things.

Thank you anyone that did tweet or email, it is very much appreciated by myself and a lot of other Jewish people, probably a fair few other people too😉

https://www.theguardian.com/film/2024/jan/04/one-life-marketing-materials-altered-following-jewish-backlash

I see from the article that the non Jewish children were political refugees. It doesn't mention an ethnicity

Trulywonderful · 05/01/2024 01:45

sashh · 05/01/2024 01:32

No, disabled children were killed in their own homes or in hospitals starting pre war.

I think with films we see 'this is the story' when it is the story from one person's point of view and of a snapshot of the many stories.

I can't find a reference but I think I remember one of the children who is a film maker wanting nothing to do with this film.

I think 'predominantly jewish' would be the best description but these were children, not all were originally from Czechoslovakia, some had fled Germany.

Language does change and the language around WWII and the holocaust has been sanitized to a certain extent. In the 1940s the country was very much at war with Germany, now we talk about war with Nazi Germany.

Whatever the wording, this film and the twitterstorm around it will bring this story to a new audience who will hopefully go on to research what was happening and why people were prepared to send their children alone to strangers in a different country.

I found an interesting read in the guardian - in 1939 many Jewish people in Vienna advertised their children, hoping to find a home. And many did. I had no idea about this.

https://www.theguardian.com/media/2021/may/06/guardian-200-ad-that-saved-jewish-father-from-nazis

Thank you for the article

OP posts:
sashh · 05/01/2024 01:32

AbsoluteYawns · 04/01/2024 07:18

Did Sir Winton take disabled children out?
My apologies if so - I didn't know that.

No, disabled children were killed in their own homes or in hospitals starting pre war.

I think with films we see 'this is the story' when it is the story from one person's point of view and of a snapshot of the many stories.

I can't find a reference but I think I remember one of the children who is a film maker wanting nothing to do with this film.

I think 'predominantly jewish' would be the best description but these were children, not all were originally from Czechoslovakia, some had fled Germany.

Language does change and the language around WWII and the holocaust has been sanitized to a certain extent. In the 1940s the country was very much at war with Germany, now we talk about war with Nazi Germany.

Whatever the wording, this film and the twitterstorm around it will bring this story to a new audience who will hopefully go on to research what was happening and why people were prepared to send their children alone to strangers in a different country.

I found an interesting read in the guardian - in 1939 many Jewish people in Vienna advertised their children, hoping to find a home. And many did. I had no idea about this.

https://www.theguardian.com/media/2021/may/06/guardian-200-ad-that-saved-jewish-father-from-nazis

‘I seek a kind person’: the Guardian ad that saved my Jewish father from the Nazis

In 1938, there was a surge of classified ads in this newspaper as parents – including my grandparents – scrambled to get their children out of the Reich. What became of the families?

https://www.theguardian.com/media/2021/may/06/guardian-200-ad-that-saved-jewish-father-from-nazis

BackCat · 05/01/2024 00:07

Well done OP!

NewJobNewMeNewLife · 05/01/2024 00:06

I find it ironic that on a thread about deleting a minority group by failing to mention the childrens’ Judaism that several posters have suggested an alternative that would delete other minority groups.

Trulywonderful · 04/01/2024 23:57

Well all the complaints they got about this worked. This thread and other social media messages were about getting people to complain via yweet and email. Also to debate this type of situation and what is currently happening regarding Jewish things.

Thank you anyone that did tweet or email, it is very much appreciated by myself and a lot of other Jewish people, probably a fair few other people too😉

https://www.theguardian.com/film/2024/jan/04/one-life-marketing-materials-altered-following-jewish-backlash

One Life marketing materials altered following Jewish backlash

The promotional terms for the biopic of ‘British Schindler’ Nicholas Winton have been amended following criticism of the term ‘central European’ to describe the children he saved

https://www.theguardian.com/film/2024/jan/04/one-life-marketing-materials-altered-following-jewish-backlash

OP posts:
Trulywonderful · 04/01/2024 23:51

deragod · 04/01/2024 19:32

In, what we know as, (Western) Europe there is only Europe (civilised people like us) and EE (barbarians). However, there is Central Europe and history of Jewish presence in Europe is also history of CE - there is no region more influenced and influencing European Jews. However...

discourse in anglosphere, excluding niche academic journals, is set on polarising categories (Western) Europe - as it is always just Europe - vs EE. Thus, the trick here is obvious. in this context, CE means nothing and it is meant to not provoke questions that might be uncomfortable for paying viewers and as a result to not have all sorts of reactions to deal with.

Also, I am tried of people pretending Jewishness is only about religion. It is not.

Good post

OP posts:
deragod · 04/01/2024 19:32

In, what we know as, (Western) Europe there is only Europe (civilised people like us) and EE (barbarians). However, there is Central Europe and history of Jewish presence in Europe is also history of CE - there is no region more influenced and influencing European Jews. However...

discourse in anglosphere, excluding niche academic journals, is set on polarising categories (Western) Europe - as it is always just Europe - vs EE. Thus, the trick here is obvious. in this context, CE means nothing and it is meant to not provoke questions that might be uncomfortable for paying viewers and as a result to not have all sorts of reactions to deal with.

Also, I am tried of people pretending Jewishness is only about religion. It is not.

Mushroomsouptonight · 04/01/2024 16:14

bookworm14 · 04/01/2024 15:29

What is the source for this? I can’t find any evidence that any of the children Winton rescued were Roma.

Me neither.
I've searched for actual data and unable to find any. However, sir Nicholas did record the name of each rescued child. All the records I can find say predominantly Jewish children saved from Nazi concentration camps. Many in the last cancelled trip due to the outbreak of WW2 were subsequently murdered by the Nazis.

bookworm14 · 04/01/2024 15:31

Excellent post, Flatulence (your username isn’t ideal for this very serious thread!).

bookworm14 · 04/01/2024 15:29

Sartre · 04/01/2024 15:22

Probably because they weren’t exclusively Jewish, some were Romany.

What is the source for this? I can’t find any evidence that any of the children Winton rescued were Roma.

Mushroomsouptonight · 04/01/2024 15:23

Flatulence · 04/01/2024 15:14

Yes, not all the children Sir Nicholas rescued were not Jewish.
And of course we must never forget that the Nazis persecuted many other people including Romani people, disabled people, gay people etc.
However playing down the fact that the children were mostly Jewish to the extent it's not even mentioned is like trailing a film about the Civil Rights movement in 1960s America without showing that most of the major players were Black. It's that basic and that misleading.
Nicholas Winton, while raised a Christian, was ethnically Jewish (because Judaism, like Sikhism, is an ethnoreligon).
He was asked to assist people (in what was then Czechoslovakia) who were motivated by the plight of Jews in the late 1930s. While they didn't just help Jewish children, what brought Sir Nicholas and others together to arrange the transport was the plight of Jews and most of the children and families they assisted were Jewish.
And what prompted the whole movement to get Jewish children to Britain bia organised transport was Kristalnacht - a program against Jews. The Dutch authorities officially closed the borders to Jewish refugees after that point and it took people like Sir Nicholas - educated, intelligent, affluent, and connected - to broker the transport.
So without Kristalnacht, there wouldn't have even been the trains taking children to Britain from Prague.
These are some of the many reasons why in this specific example (not in terms of holocaust education in general) to fail to mention Jews is wrong and I strongly suspect has been done given the terrible ongoing situation in the middle east which has led to rates of antisemitic attacks rising by more than 1000pc in London alone.

Edited

This.

Sartre · 04/01/2024 15:22

Probably because they weren’t exclusively Jewish, some were Romany.

noblegiraffe · 04/01/2024 15:21

Equally though the people saying that it should say 'mostly Jewish' don't seem to be concerned about the other groups that they would be erasing by saying that.

How is it erasing them? It would only be erasing them if it said he rescued a bunch of Jewish children with no hint of any non-Jews.

As previously mentioned, the fact they were Jewish is important and worth mentioning because it explains a lot about the film in only a couple of words.

Mushroomsouptonight · 04/01/2024 15:21

itsmyp4rty · 04/01/2024 14:41

I think this was written by a non Jewish person who thought that Central European neatly covered all the kids that were rescued rather than listing out the different groups. I can see why Jewish people would see that as missing the point.

Equally though the people saying that it should say 'mostly Jewish' don't seem to be concerned about the other groups that they would be erasing by saying that.

669 predominantly Jewish children. Saved from the Nazis before WW2 and brought to families in England.

There are some who would deny the holocaust so important not to deny Hilter's intentions towards Jewish people.

https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-lancashire-67876587

Lady Milena Grenfell-Baines

Sir Nicholas Winton: Woman saved by Holocaust hero praises new film

Lady Milena Grenfell-Baines was among hundreds of children rescued by the famed philanthropist.

https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-lancashire-67876587

Flatulence · 04/01/2024 15:14

Yes, not all the children Sir Nicholas rescued were not Jewish.
And of course we must never forget that the Nazis persecuted many other people including Romani people, disabled people, gay people etc.
However playing down the fact that the children were mostly Jewish to the extent it's not even mentioned is like trailing a film about the Civil Rights movement in 1960s America without showing that most of the major players were Black. It's that basic and that misleading.
Nicholas Winton, while raised a Christian, was ethnically Jewish (because Judaism, like Sikhism, is an ethnoreligon).
He was asked to assist people (in what was then Czechoslovakia) who were motivated by the plight of Jews in the late 1930s. While they didn't just help Jewish children, what brought Sir Nicholas and others together to arrange the transport was the plight of Jews and most of the children and families they assisted were Jewish.
And what prompted the whole movement to get Jewish children to Britain bia organised transport was Kristalnacht - a program against Jews. The Dutch authorities officially closed the borders to Jewish refugees after that point and it took people like Sir Nicholas - educated, intelligent, affluent, and connected - to broker the transport.
So without Kristalnacht, there wouldn't have even been the trains taking children to Britain from Prague.
These are some of the many reasons why in this specific example (not in terms of holocaust education in general) to fail to mention Jews is wrong and I strongly suspect has been done given the terrible ongoing situation in the middle east which has led to rates of antisemitic attacks rising by more than 1000pc in London alone.

itsmyp4rty · 04/01/2024 14:41

I think this was written by a non Jewish person who thought that Central European neatly covered all the kids that were rescued rather than listing out the different groups. I can see why Jewish people would see that as missing the point.

Equally though the people saying that it should say 'mostly Jewish' don't seem to be concerned about the other groups that they would be erasing by saying that.

LolaSmiles · 04/01/2024 14:38

Given the timing it does seem to be about money.

There's a lot of people out there who are critical of the Israeli government position and are smart enough, and non-bigoted enough, to know that Israeli government decisions in war does not equal Jewish people worldwide. Therefore they'd have no need, for example, to boycott local businesses owned by Jewish people because obviously a local Jewish family business has nothing to do with the state of Israel.

Sadly there's also a lot of uninformed people who might, out of their own ignorance, blind spots, and openly held antisemitism, decide not to watch something because they believe that anything to do with Jewish people is somehow endorsing the state of Israel and Israeli foreign policy.

I've rewritten this post too many times but hopefully people will take it charitably.

Sauerkrautsandwich · 04/01/2024 14:37

noblegiraffe · 04/01/2024 14:14

Switching ‘mostly Jewish’ for ‘Central European’ is balls because it is confusing (what is Central Europe?) and doesn’t give any real hint as to why these children are being removed from their parents whereas ‘mostly Jewish’ instantly provides you with some insight into what the future threat was, and why it was important to take these children away from Central Europe.

It’s a bloody important plot point, and deliberately substituting it out makes it a worse advert for the film.

It's the central Europe. In the middle.
I did realise many on twitter switched to Eastern Europe when CS was mentioned but geography is not that hard really. 🤷

I agree with the "mostly" part

Trulywonderful · 04/01/2024 14:31

The it wasn't used to protect Jewish people argument is horrific for various historical reasons and very wrong

They did not use the word Jewish in the description because they thought in the current climate of rising Jew hate they would lose money. That people wouldn't want to watch the film if they mentioned before people saw it that it was about mostly Jewish children as well as other groups. Let's face it there are people out there that have no idea what the kindertransport is.

The decision is about money. This means that Warner Bros and others are erasing the word Jewish because of money and other people's antisemitism

OP posts:
Mushroomsouptonight · 04/01/2024 14:31

It feels like they are trying to not use the word Jewish due to the war in the middle East between hamas and Israel after the 7th October terrorist attack on people in Israel by Hamas.

History shows it was predominantly Jewish children not random central European children eg German, Swiss, Spanish etc....

It feels wrong and is wrong

Sauerkrautsandwich · 04/01/2024 14:31

KarenNotAKaren · 04/01/2024 13:47

It why should Jews ‘just be happy it’s made’?

Everyone should be happy a good(hopefully) movies are made about atrocities like that. That's how many get their knowledge nowadays. If it makes 1000 people google and read about it and learn, it's a good thing.

Just to add, not happy as cheerong, just happy it's talked about so the genocides, mass murders and exterminations don't get forgotten and people learn about them and history.
Those who don't know history are bound to repeat it

Swipe left for the next trending thread