Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

HMV describing Jewish refugee children as Central European Children

164 replies

Trulywonderful · 03/01/2024 22:26

Would I be unreasonable to as any of you on twitter or willing to write an email complaint to HMV to do me a favour

HMV have described the Jewish refugee children in the new One Life film as Central European Children. This is erasing there Jewishness from the description. I know some may feel objection to this is petty but at the moment the Jewish community are seeing a far bit of this behaviour. Erasing us from things to make people feel more comfortable etc

Anyway if people want to help and tweet about this or email HMV I would be very grateful

HMV describing Jewish refugee children as Central European Children
OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Sauerkrautsandwich · 06/01/2024 12:12

I don't think anyone here was denying that majority of victims in Holocaust were Jewish nor that majority going through Kindertransport were Jewish.

I think some might confuse Holocaust time with Holocaust occasionally, but that's a different matter. Tbf the conflicting information around the world on victims of Holocaust doesn't help. Some use it only for Jewish, the 6million, some include other groups which means that they count 11-17 milion people.

etmoiandme · 06/01/2024 12:11

LA's new Hollywood museum has totally erased mentions of the Jewish roots in Hollywood - created by Jewish people as Jews were banned from many professions, but not media, so they made the best of their situation

@sergeantsalt That's interesting, I didn't know this. On the one hand Jews being prohibited from other professions is an important part of the story. But I wonder in this specific case there might be an argument that it actually is protecting the Jewish community rather than erasing them, in order to dissociate from and not feed a very well known antisemitic trope?

sergeantsalt · 06/01/2024 12:03

Thank you. This erasure is going on worldwide and it is disgusting and needs to stop.

BA removed the sitcom Hapless from its lineup due to 'not wanting to be seen to support Israel' in the ME conflict. The sitcom is about a Jewish family in London.

LA's new Hollywood museum has totally erased mentions of the Jewish roots in Hollywood - created by Jewish people as Jews were banned from many professions, but not media, so they made the best of their situation.

bookworm14 · 06/01/2024 12:00

Why is there this desperate need to deny the incontrovertible fact that the majority of the victims of the Holocaust were Jewish? It’s weird and depressing.

Also, ‘gay people, academics and communists’ aren’t remotely relevant to this thread as we are discussing the Kindertransport.

etmoiandme · 06/01/2024 11:45

Quite surprised to learn there were "gay people....academics and communists" on the Kindertransport. @NannyOggsWhiskyStash

noblegiraffe · 06/01/2024 11:34

Why was the Kindertransport set up? Who was it designed to rescue and why?

NannyOggsWhiskyStash · 06/01/2024 11:33

Yes,and not just Jewish people. Romani, gay people, mentally ill,academics, communists.....

noblegiraffe · 06/01/2024 11:30

The film is about the Kindertransport so it seems pretty relevant.

Can't imagine why you wouldn't want to answer my question.

quisensoucie · 06/01/2024 11:29

@noblegiraffe This thread is about the film. My response was about the film
I am not getting dragged into your argument here

noblegiraffe · 06/01/2024 11:27

@quisensoucie why do you think the Kindertransport memorial was vandalised? Was it because the children were Central European?

quisensoucie · 06/01/2024 11:23

@ChalkWitch
Surely the answer here is obvious? You do realise that there is a war between Israel and Gaza currently, right?
Don't be obtuse, of course I do

The films producers do not want to risk financial loss so they remove the ‘Jewishness’ in order not to put off film goers who may be anti- Israel.
This is an assumption - no doubt that there are some people who are unaware of the topic of the film, but to assume that if the content was to be announced because a majority (not all) of the children were Jewish, it would determine whether or not they attended is daft. As with any film, it will cause polarisation of opinion; look at The Passion of Christ, Life of Brian, etc.
Also, are you saying those who are anti-Israel (your words) or anti-semetic? The distinction is important

Also I don’t think the original Warner brothers are still kicking about so whether they were Jewish or not is irrelevant. I doubt the current owners are bothered but I bet they’re bothered about taking a financial hit because of the geopolitical climate.
No, they are not alive; but in relation to the current owners, you 'betting they are bothered about a financial hit' is just as judgemental as you think others may be. What on earth are you basing this assertion on?

ChalkWitch · 06/01/2024 09:38

quisensoucie · 06/01/2024 08:50

You do realise the Warner Brothers were Jewish? Why then would their company erase reference to Jews for monetary gain?
The reference to central european children is technically correct

Surely the answer here is obvious? You do realise that there is a war between Israel and Gaza currently, right? Antisemitic incidents have risen, suggesting that there is a backlash against Jewish people because of this. The films producers do not want to risk financial loss so they remove the ‘Jewishness’ in order not to put off film goers who may be anti- Israel.
Its fairly straightforward.
Also I don’t think the original Warner brothers are still kicking about so whether they were Jewish or not is irrelevant. I doubt the current owners are bothered but I bet they’re bothered about taking a financial hit because of the geopolitical climate.
And given the motivation for the Kindertransport. (Kristallnacht) describing the children as Jewish is correct.

noblegiraffe · 06/01/2024 09:28

The Kindertransport memorial was vandalised in Berlin the other day with what looks like pro-Palestinian graffiti. Do you think this was because the Kinder were Central European?

If you haven't been paying attention, Jews are being targeted in lots of different ways at the moment. A boy was attacked outside a Jewish school in London on Friday and forced to say 'Free Palestine'.

Last week an group attempted to organise an anti-Israeli protest at the Holocaust Museum in Washington DC.

So yeah, you should be suspicious when the word Jew doesn't appear in the description of a film where being Jewish is pretty central to the plot.

quisensoucie · 06/01/2024 08:50

You do realise the Warner Brothers were Jewish? Why then would their company erase reference to Jews for monetary gain?
The reference to central european children is technically correct

sashh · 06/01/2024 01:14

Echobelly · 05/01/2024 20:15

I'm Jewish and my suspicion is they said 'central European' partly for accuracy to caprture the whole cohort and partly because they felt saying 'Jewish' would lower people's sympathy because of Israel/Gaze right now. Which I think was the wrong thing to to do both in itself and because actually I think most people have been very good about distinguishing Jewish people from Israel's actions.

It's tricky because the majority were jewish but they were all from central europe.

The thing I'm trying to articulate (but not very well, sorry if this isn't worded kindly) is that using the word 'jewish' is what the nazis did, they made sure they were not seen as true citizens, or not worthy of living in their homes, owning businesses or even receiving medical treatment.

Also the definition of 'jewish' is not always accurate, the mischling test was invented and used by the nazis, so someone brought up in the RC church with RC parents and 1 jewish grandparent would be either a jew or a mishling.

Sorry, this is a clumsy attempt, please understand I don't mean to upset or harm anyone but with discussions of this type, well it isn't going to be a fun fest is it?

CheldonSooper · 05/01/2024 21:54

Let's put it this way; would they have done this for other groups? I think not.

🙄 🥱

White people do feel put out when the slavery debates are termed around black people only, it's like only African slaves matter.

Someone will be on soon to claim that the white slaves had "white privilege".

Careful...your slips are showing. Taking a snide dig at other groups while talking about another group is...interesting.

Mushroomsouptonight · 05/01/2024 21:32

noblegiraffe · 05/01/2024 21:31

People wittering on about how the description is merely trying to be inclusive and nothing to do with erasing Jews from the story of the Kindertransport are going to have a hard time justifying this BBC article about one of the Jewish children Nicholas Winton saved. The web archive version shows which words were edited in later.

[https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-lancashire-67876587

This.

noblegiraffe · 05/01/2024 21:31

People wittering on about how the description is merely trying to be inclusive and nothing to do with erasing Jews from the story of the Kindertransport are going to have a hard time justifying this BBC article about one of the Jewish children Nicholas Winton saved. The web archive version shows which words were edited in later.

[https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-lancashire-67876587

HMV describing Jewish refugee children as Central European Children
HMV describing Jewish refugee children as Central European Children
Ibizafun · 05/01/2024 21:09

My father was a Jewish child on the last train out of Hamburg. I have to be honest I thought all the kids were Jewish.

Janesmom · 05/01/2024 20:45

In circumstances where some of the children definitely weren’t Jewish, YABU. Feels like trying to emphasise one group over others. What we should all be remembering is the incredible bravery of Winton and the evil these children faced.

Echobelly · 05/01/2024 20:15

I'm Jewish and my suspicion is they said 'central European' partly for accuracy to caprture the whole cohort and partly because they felt saying 'Jewish' would lower people's sympathy because of Israel/Gaze right now. Which I think was the wrong thing to to do both in itself and because actually I think most people have been very good about distinguishing Jewish people from Israel's actions.

Flatulence · 05/01/2024 20:08

Verv · 05/01/2024 16:46

The kindertransport started in response to Kristallnacht. Kristallnacht was a pogrom specifically against the Jews, not the Roma, not homosexuals, not the disabled.
Winton was Jewish, the vast majority of the children were Jewish, and the first transport was 200 Jewish children from a Jewish orphanage decimated in Berlin during the Kristallnacht, a pogrom designed to delete Jewish people.

Ironic that Kristallnacht wasn't as inclusive of other minority groups as MNetters.

Exactly this.
Make no bones about it: the Kinderstransport only happened because of what the Nazis and their collaborators were doing to Jews.
To not mention Jews in this context is like talking about AIDS in 1984 and not mentioning gay men.
I'm hoping all the people saying "other groups will get erased" are the very first to promote the use of terms such as "chestfeeding" and "birthing person" so trans folk dont get "erased".

Mushroomsouptonight · 05/01/2024 18:12

bookworm14 · 05/01/2024 17:09

But none of the children rescued by Winton were Roma.

Exactly, that's what I also understand. Political refugees were included but vast majority were Jewish to save them from the camps. I would find saying predominantly Jewish with some political refugees a bit if a mouthful.

Central European is used due to the current backlash against completely innocent Jewish people around the world (by ignorant people who don't seem to understand that Jewish people around the world aren't responsible for what is happening in Gaza).

CoatRack · 05/01/2024 17:28

I would have laughed if the article said "altered due to Central European backlash" 🤣

bookworm14 · 05/01/2024 17:09

NewJobNewMeNewLife · 05/01/2024 16:41

Being Romany is.

But none of the children rescued by Winton were Roma.