Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DH might have lost his job?

37 replies

greenpjs · 03/01/2024 18:32

A few issues which have been building for a while now have come to a head today. He works in a small team, they have been understaffed for months now and the workload is just too much for that amount of people.

He very rarely finishes on time because the work is just never done by 5. So that means he's pretty much gone 7:30-7 every day if he doesn't finish when he should, because of the commuting time and the fact public transport near us is very unreliable. I try to offer lifts where I can, but sometimes this is not possible and I'm left with a lot of the load of looking after DC when I work FT as well. Financially, it's not really possible for us at the moment for him to take driving lessons and then get a car either. We are both exhausted with it and I've lost patience. He's been working weekends as well over the past few weeks, although he is contracted to do this it seems ridiculous just so they can have the Bank Holidays off!

Anyway, tonight I offered to pick him up at 5:30, I was sat in the car waiting until 6 with no sign of him. I asked him where he was and he said he was waiting for another colleague to provide sign off for something so he couldn't leave until then but they were taking their time. I was obviously annoyed and next minute he comes out and says he basically told the manager he had had enough of doing overtime every single night and that it wasn't feasible anymore, that they should hire more staff, review current working processes to make them more efficient etc etc. He said he wasn't staying a minute longer and stormed out. The only suggestion the manager had was for him to change shift to finish later which also doesn't work, and why should he have to anyway?

Obviously this is not ideal, but I can understand his frustration and why he has basically just exploded at them. Realistically is he now going to lose his job?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Atethehalloweenchocs · 04/01/2024 19:46

I think sometimes in organizations they will push it like this until someone melts down/resigns/goes off sick. So I doubt they will sack him - I do hope he sticks to his guns though, and does not let them talk him round when he is feeling calmer.

DriftingDora · 04/01/2024 19:22

WhyMeWhyNowWhyNot · 03/01/2024 20:06

Why do people always suggest joining a union?!? They don’t step in and help people after the event FFS. It’s like only applying for car insurance after a crash - you need to pay your dues 🙄.

Agree with this. Like car or medical insurance, they often don't give protection for something that arose before you joined, so he could be wasting money by joining, but why not check your household insurance, OP, - that may offer some legal advice as part of the policy.

Coffeespill · 04/01/2024 19:19

They'll make sure he gets a shit pay rise so he looks elsewhere

pilates · 04/01/2024 19:15

If I was your husband I would arrange a meeting with his manager to explain the working conditions are not sustainable any longer. More professional than sounding off, although I understand why he did.

Startingagainandagain · 04/01/2024 19:09

The question should be why has he stayed in this job so long...

Short-staffed, expected to work unpaid overtime everyday and not even well paid? This sounds like an awful environment.

Your husband need to start looking for another job with better conditions/salary.

Coffeespill · 04/01/2024 19:01

Unlikely he'll loose his job straight away if they are that short staffed. He will be managed out so I'd expect him to look for something else

youveturnedupwelldone · 04/01/2024 18:59

Goodness, I hope the first thoughts of the management aren't "has he been here for more than two years? No? Great, I can sack him!"

If someone in my team did this I'd be taking them for a coffee to talk about it all and see what I could do to help. Assuming he doesn't do this sort of things regularly, I'd very much see it as an indication of a wellbeing issue and it wouldn't cross my mind to take any sort of action.

Mind you, I'd also not expect my staff to do regular unpaid overtime as a way to get the day to day work done.

He won't get sacked OP - an apology to the person on the receiving end of it will smooth it over and he's reasonable to say he's only going to do his contracted hours.

cristokitty · 04/01/2024 18:46

I've blown up like this at work... a few times. So far I haven't been fired, though I'd have welcomed it at the time. When I get that angry, it's when i'm most desperately needed and they can't afford to lose me.

Vieve1325 · 04/01/2024 11:51

Big deep breath.

He has over two years service, which means yes they'd have to go through a process to dismiss, and if they didn't he'd have a case for unfair dismissal.

Even if they chose to discipline, never in a month of Sundays would I class what he's done as Gross Misconduct - so if it's the first time he's done it (and there was no unacceptable behaviour) it shouldn't amount to a dismissible offence.

If I was their HR support, and his manager came to me to say 'you'll never guess what so and so has just done,' the first questions I'd be asking is
(1) Why do you think he did that?
(2) What's his value to you/ the team / the organisation
(3) Has he raised this to you before?
(4) Why do you think it came to a head today?
(5) Do you think the hours / ways of working he's been undertaking are fair / reasonable / sustainable?

And I'd be holding firm on informal action in the first instance as we obviously have a struggling employee (with no apparent prior outbursts) on our hands, and we need to support them.

Tell him to get ahead of this, write down his concerns, apologise for walking out with no notice, and ask for a meeting to discuss. I give massive kudos to anyone who can hit stuff like this head on, and be the driver for their own change - but of course as a business they should have been on the front foot to ensure this didn't happen in the first place!

If it continues after he addresses it, and he has documented requests / promises for improvements etc. he could then argue that his role has become untenable to the point he has to leave for his own health, and he could pursue constructive dismissal.

greenpjs · 04/01/2024 11:34

The boss he had the argument with wasn't in today so nothing has been said. Expect tomorrow she will probably pull him for a chat. He had told his line manager that he'll no longer be staying past his contracted hours

OP posts:
Codlingmoths · 04/01/2024 10:20

It doesn’t sound like they’d sack him!! His behaviour sounds perfectly reasonable, he should brush up his cv and take some stress leave due to being overworked…

Fiddlerdragon · 04/01/2024 10:13

They can’t sack him without going through a process. At most I’d say swearing in frustration might lead to a warning or a disciplinary. He not going to get sacked for calling the boss a dickhead. It sounds like they need all they staff they can get and he seems pretty irreplaceable atm

Ejismyf · 04/01/2024 10:07

Very much doubt it if they are already understaffed and he's doing the stand in managers job when his boss is off. I doubt your moaning at him helped the situation though.

Rewis · 04/01/2024 09:47

Doesn't sound like a fureable offence. However sounds like he has leverage that he should use to get better pay/conditions and/or look for another job.

Ponoka7 · 04/01/2024 09:45

They are massively understaffed, so no, they aren't going to sack him.

GingeNinga · 04/01/2024 09:42

Hi OP,

as he’s worked there for more than two years they would need to go through a formal disciplinary process to sack him.

As the job isn't well laid, does he get paid for all this overtime? If he doesn’t, it’s worth calculating what his hourly rate is when he includes all the hours he’s working overtime. He might find that his employers are paying below the national minimum wage which opens the company up to a whole host of legal ramifications.

Also it’s worth looking for a new job, nothing will get better from the sounds of it and he’s probably not getting paid his worth/industry average by the sounds of it.

ntmdino · 04/01/2024 09:23

They'd be on very shaky ground to fire him - on those hours, he's likely breaching the Working Time Directive, and they can't force him to do that.

Shinyandnew1 · 04/01/2024 09:18

I presume he’s gone into work this morning? Is everything ok?

greenpjs · 04/01/2024 09:09

He's been there over 2 years. And no it isn't even well paid, so all this overtime isn't even worth it. He earns less than his manager but they expect him to do the same job role, have the same responsibilities and when his manager is off, he is pretty much a stand in and he takes over, as nobody else is capable on the team

OP posts:
DuchessPotato · 04/01/2024 08:50

WhereYouLeftIt · 03/01/2024 20:31

"He works in a small team, they have been understaffed for months now and the workload is just too much for that amount of people."

I think they're far more likely to hang onto him for grim death that they are to fire him - they need the staff they have too much to let anyone go.

To fire him they need a reason, they need to go through a process, a medium-sized organisation should have HR department. And he could claim unfair dismissal.

I reckon his job is safe.

Legally they only need to go through a disciplinary process if he has been there more than two years. He cannot claim unfair dismissal with less than this.

WhereYouLeftIt · 03/01/2024 20:31

"He works in a small team, they have been understaffed for months now and the workload is just too much for that amount of people."

I think they're far more likely to hang onto him for grim death that they are to fire him - they need the staff they have too much to let anyone go.

To fire him they need a reason, they need to go through a process, a medium-sized organisation should have HR department. And he could claim unfair dismissal.

I reckon his job is safe.

WhyMeWhyNowWhyNot · 03/01/2024 20:06

Why do people always suggest joining a union?!? They don’t step in and help people after the event FFS. It’s like only applying for car insurance after a crash - you need to pay your dues 🙄.

Ellie1015 · 03/01/2024 19:56

They would be mad to let him go if they are so short staffed. Hopefully they see it as a sign if asking to much and are grateful for him doing the contracted hours and breaking the habit of working late.

tttigress · 03/01/2024 19:55

Is it a well paid job for the skillset?

Maybe you going on a bit drove him to it. I obviously get why you are annoyed, but in some jobs you can't finish at an exact time like if you were working in McDonald's (though admittedly half the time things could be improved dramatically by better organisation)

Goldenoldieallofasudden · 03/01/2024 19:46

Get him to join a union straight away. Several e.g. GMB, Unite, are active across a wide range of industries. Even if the employer doesn't engage with the union for pay negotiations etc. union membership is vital for legal advice, representation, etc when things go badly - and you need to be a member before you get fired, etc, afterwards is too late for them to help. Hope things improve for you both.