Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do we keep quiet about child trust fund?

211 replies

AuntieSoap · 03/01/2024 12:23

DD’s child trust fund matures shortly and I’ve been paying into it every month for 18 years. I split with her dad (exH) in 2015 but even when we were married, it was only me that paid in. ExH is really stingy, earns well into six figures but only pays the bare minimum maintenance and thinks I’m ripping him off in the process.

The CTF is now worth about £16k and so my plan was always to say that’s her parental contribution for university. She’ll only get the minimum loan as my salary is over the threshold, but I’m a single parent with two kids, a hefty mortgage and commuting costs etc so don’t have loads of spare cash. I’m fine, not crying poverty, just giving the full picture.

ExH knows that’s DD has a child trust fund but doesn’t know how much it is. Ideally, he would contribute half of DD’s university parental contribution to make it up to the equivalent of maximum loan. However, if he knows that DD is coming into this money, the likelihood is he won’t help her financially. If he was to pay ‘his share’, some of the CTF money could go towards a lifetime ISA or travelling, or anything really. It’s DD’s money and technically, she can do what she wants with it.

Anyway, I don’t want DD to lie, or put her in a difficult position, but it’s not her dad’s business how much she’s got in the bank. Am I being unreasonable to encourage DD to keep schtum about this, or is that a burden too great for an 18-year old? I suspect it is, so any ideas on how to play this are gratefully received.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
withthischoice · 03/01/2024 16:46

enchantedsquirrelwood · 03/01/2024 16:43

And?

It's the daughter's account, not his. None of his business, especially if he hasn't paid anything into it.

The OP could say "oh that, it had about £250 in it I think - whatever the original contribution was at birth and 7".

Read the OP re the OP’s concerns
If she wasn’t concerned about the implications of him knowing the true figure…. she wouldn’t have started the thread about it

Dancerprancer19 · 03/01/2024 16:44

AuntieSoap · 03/01/2024 12:23

DD’s child trust fund matures shortly and I’ve been paying into it every month for 18 years. I split with her dad (exH) in 2015 but even when we were married, it was only me that paid in. ExH is really stingy, earns well into six figures but only pays the bare minimum maintenance and thinks I’m ripping him off in the process.

The CTF is now worth about £16k and so my plan was always to say that’s her parental contribution for university. She’ll only get the minimum loan as my salary is over the threshold, but I’m a single parent with two kids, a hefty mortgage and commuting costs etc so don’t have loads of spare cash. I’m fine, not crying poverty, just giving the full picture.

ExH knows that’s DD has a child trust fund but doesn’t know how much it is. Ideally, he would contribute half of DD’s university parental contribution to make it up to the equivalent of maximum loan. However, if he knows that DD is coming into this money, the likelihood is he won’t help her financially. If he was to pay ‘his share’, some of the CTF money could go towards a lifetime ISA or travelling, or anything really. It’s DD’s money and technically, she can do what she wants with it.

Anyway, I don’t want DD to lie, or put her in a difficult position, but it’s not her dad’s business how much she’s got in the bank. Am I being unreasonable to encourage DD to keep schtum about this, or is that a burden too great for an 18-year old? I suspect it is, so any ideas on how to play this are gratefully received.

Personally I wouldn’t have told her how much it was and would simply say it should cover my half of the Uni contributions. Then once everything was sorted with uni in terms of dad’s contribution I would have helped to lock it into an ISA for a few years. My parents continued to manage the paperwork of my savings even though technically I suppose it wasn’t allowed as I was 18. I got them after graduating, which honestly I’m thankful for as had no opportunity to accidentally waste it!

enchantedsquirrelwood · 03/01/2024 16:43

withthischoice · 03/01/2024 15:38

He’s a successful business man?

Very unlikely he will forget about this so brace yourself for the message asking for a CTC statement imminently

And?

It's the daughter's account, not his. None of his business, especially if he hasn't paid anything into it.

The OP could say "oh that, it had about £250 in it I think - whatever the original contribution was at birth and 7".

silverbubbles · 03/01/2024 16:41

Definitely no need to tell him as you know how he will respond.

I remember when my sister got a sponsorship award for her Msc course. We advised her to keep it very quiet from estranged father as he would definitely have used her hard work to cut his miserly contributions to her uni course.

I am sure if you explain to your daughter to keep this info to herself, perhaps by feigning ignorance about the child trust fund, she would do this. With holding information is not lying.

Instead she should focus on what her costs will be and how much he will help her.

AuntieSoap · 03/01/2024 16:41

@MargotBamborough

Love this!!! Great advice 😊

(Apart from the sitting down together bit 🤮)

OP posts:
withthischoice · 03/01/2024 16:39

TheRoundWind · 03/01/2024 16:30

@withthischoice my own university experience? Current students? I was talking about the choices some university students make about where they spend their money, Netflix, Prime, Deliveroo etc. I have a son at uni. He is incredibly sensible, others are not. This is about money, not the experience itself. You were responding to the vodka shots and pot noodle quote. I know as a parent how much it costs me to support my child through uni on minimum maintenance loan.

i was responding to that because the poster seemed to think that the only value (or rather no value) of university is related to financial.

MargotBamborough · 03/01/2024 16:37

AuntieSoap · 03/01/2024 16:19

I'm not asking her to lie. I specifically said that I don't want her to lie.
I asked for advice on how to handle the inevitable from her father. Good advice from PPs has been to put it in an ISA for her future. That does leave me in a sticky situation as I'll have to find the money to help her through Uni which I thought I'd saved already. But if that's what it takes, so be it. And if her dad refuses to contribute, which isn't beyond the realms of possibility, that just makes it more difficult.

Perhaps then it would be better to bring the subject up with him directly.

"Hi XH, I know we don't usually talk that much but I think we really need to have a chat about DD going to uni next year. As my income is above A amount, she only qualifies for the minimum student loan. She is hoping to attend B university. We have had a look at the various accommodation options and the cheapest one is C pounds per year, leaving a shortfall of D pounds above what the student loan will cover. Of course, it's not even guaranteed that she will be allocated the cheapest accommodation, so the shortfall could be as much as E pounds per year. And that's before she's even bought any books or food, let alone anything "nice to have" like clothes or joining societies or socialising. I will obviously contribute to her university costs but I am just looking for some reassurance from you that you will also be contributing. Ideally it would be great if you could continue to support her at the level you currently do. Can we all sit down together and work out what her likely costs will be and sort out who is going to pay for what?"

I wouldn't even mention the child trust fund. If he does bring it up, I would say, "That is her money. Obviously I'm hoping she'll do something sensible with it like put it towards a house deposit, but she's over 18 now and I can't control what she does with it."

If he pushes the issue and demands to know how much is in it, you say, "Since you have never paid into it, I'm not sure how it is relevant to a discussion about how much we are going to financially support our daughter through university."

TheRoundWind · 03/01/2024 16:30

@withthischoice my own university experience? Current students? I was talking about the choices some university students make about where they spend their money, Netflix, Prime, Deliveroo etc. I have a son at uni. He is incredibly sensible, others are not. This is about money, not the experience itself. You were responding to the vodka shots and pot noodle quote. I know as a parent how much it costs me to support my child through uni on minimum maintenance loan.

AuntieSoap · 03/01/2024 16:30

@Winter2020
Thank you, that makes a lot of sense 🙂

OP posts:
withthischoice · 03/01/2024 16:28

I asked for advice on how to handle the inevitable from her father.

He will ask for a statement in advance of the closure. Guaranteed.

So the only advice to give is to spend time formulating how you negotiate CMS post providing him the closing statement

withthischoice · 03/01/2024 16:26

TheRoundWind · 03/01/2024 16:18

@withthischoice lots of current students including my nephew eat beans on toast so he has the money to go and get wasted in a club or happily spend £10 per cocktail on a night out. Ds's mate is on a full loan and lives in very cheap accommodation, blows all of his money plus overdraft every year. Not everyone is a saver.

😂

So you don’t think the university experience and studying is anything beyond either splurging on vodka OR saving?

withthischoice · 03/01/2024 16:25

you have said you don’t want her to lie

You have said he will definitely ask her about it

so how do you envisage that scenario playing out?

Winter2020 · 03/01/2024 16:20

Hi OP,
I think you (and many posters) are massively underestimating the financial resources that your daughter will need to put her through uni.

Take a look at what she will get in loans - you say it will be the minimum due to your earnings. If she wants to live away from home that probably won't even cover her rent.

Some students work lots of hours to support themselves through uni but having to work a lot of hours means poorer students without financial support are less likely to succeed e.g. working bar jobs in pubs and night clubs until the early hours then expected in lectures at 9.

Many degrees e.g. medical/ teaching there will be limited opportunity for work and some (top) unis don't allow students to work during term time.

I would suggest (after discussion with your daughter) that you ask her dad to support her at £250 a month (halving his commitment now that she is an adult) and you encourage her to put her child trust fund money in an account with a standing order set up to pay £250 each month into her current account. This would allow her £500 a month to live on with you contributing half each - if you think of the child trust fund, entirely saved by you, as your contribution..

She can cover most of her rent with her loan and work in the holidays to top up her income.

When dad asks how much is in the child trust fund your daughter could say - enough to cover mum's contribution to my uni expenses at £250 each month for my course.

Good luck with getting something worked out.

AuntieSoap · 03/01/2024 16:19

Britpop123 · 03/01/2024 15:59

the money is hers, not yours to decide to give her instead of your contribution

and yes the maintenance is irrelevant but you described it as him “engineering“ it. He has one child 50:50 and the other almost that. You’re implying he’s only doing that to save money

and you’re asking whether you should get your daughter to lie to her dad about money so he pays out

Edited

I'm not asking her to lie. I specifically said that I don't want her to lie.
I asked for advice on how to handle the inevitable from her father. Good advice from PPs has been to put it in an ISA for her future. That does leave me in a sticky situation as I'll have to find the money to help her through Uni which I thought I'd saved already. But if that's what it takes, so be it. And if her dad refuses to contribute, which isn't beyond the realms of possibility, that just makes it more difficult.

OP posts:
BloodyAdultDC · 03/01/2024 16:18

Cmonluv · 03/01/2024 13:51

https://www.wake-smith.co.uk/advice-centre/family-divorce-law/children-advice/How-does-children-going-to-university-affect-maintenance-and-ongoing-financial-support,-in-2023$3F#:~:text=If%20the%20child%20maintenance%20has,A'%20levels%20or%20the%20equivalent.

Here is the first link I found, until she's 20 he's obligato pay the same amount of maintenance he always has but direito her rather than you while in full time education .

I know this because my husband and his brother, years before we met, took their dad to court to ensure he continued to pay

Nope. Cms ends 31st August of the year they turn 18.

Anything after that can be argued through court but that's expensive, no way guaranteed and likely to destroy relationships.

TheRoundWind · 03/01/2024 16:18

@withthischoice lots of current students including my nephew eat beans on toast so he has the money to go and get wasted in a club or happily spend £10 per cocktail on a night out. Ds's mate is on a full loan and lives in very cheap accommodation, blows all of his money plus overdraft every year. Not everyone is a saver.

TheRoundWind · 03/01/2024 16:14

Ds fed his money into his LISA every year from 18. He did this because he knows that getting onto the housing ladder is going to be the hardest thing to do.

I would honestly sit with your DD, look at average graduate salaries for her field and run that figure through a salary calculator https://www.thesalarycalculator.co.uk/salary.php and use payment plan 2 as her student loan repayment amount. That will let her see how much she potentially walks home with not including a pension at this point.

Then run that same salary through a how much can I borrow mortgage calculator, lots online give out info without email addresses just salary, number of buyers and see a ballpark of what she is allowed to borrow. Then go on Rightmove for your area which is an area she knows, throw a 5 mile radius round it and put in that mortgage amount.

That will help her see that the more money she has for a deposit the better and so when making choices over how to spend her CTF whilst at uni. Personally the first £4k should go into a LISA which she opens at 18. I think Moneybox is still the top recommended one by MoneySavingExpert. It is a no brainer, £1k from the government for her £4k each year she pays into it.

Re her Dad, I would never reveal what was in the CTF or maybe a massively reduced amount and she tells him she opened a LISA.

The Salary Calculator - Take-Home tax calculator

The Salary Calculator tells you monthly take-home, or annual earnings, considering UK Tax, National Insurance and Student Loan. The latest budget information from April 2023 is used to show you exactly what you need to know. Hourly rates, weekly pay an...

https://www.thesalarycalculator.co.uk/salary.php

Fionaville · 03/01/2024 16:14

I'd try to keep him from knowing. He should contribute to her uni costs as he can afford it.

withthischoice · 03/01/2024 16:10

Amba1998 · 03/01/2024 16:08

Omg, frittering it away on vodka shots and pot noodles from Asda for 3 years hurts my head.

keep it for a house deposit!!

what’s your experience of university? The Young Ones?

Amba1998 · 03/01/2024 16:08

Omg, frittering it away on vodka shots and pot noodles from Asda for 3 years hurts my head.

keep it for a house deposit!!

withthischoice · 03/01/2024 16:07

withthischoice · 03/01/2024 15:52

, I don’t want DD to lie, or put her in a difficult position, but it’s not her dad’s business how much she’s got in the bank. Am I being unreasonable to encourage DD to keep schtum about this, or is that a burden too great for an 18-year old?

so if he asks her, which he will, you just want to zip her lip and shake her head?

i’m curious about this OP?!

And do you realise that he will be counting down until his maintenance reduced and he will ask for a closure statement

AuntieSoap · 03/01/2024 16:05

@Whinge
If I'd saved the same amount of money in an ISA in my own name and used it for the same means, it would be okay though?

I could have put zilch into the CTF and she'd have no options at all then.

OP posts:
coffeerevelsrule · 03/01/2024 16:04

Whinge · 03/01/2024 15:56

I really hope your DD has other people to guide and advise her on the best way to use / invest the money. As it seems as though you're going to push her into using it for university as this benefits you, rather than thinking about what will benefit DD.

OP says she doesn't have the required amount, so what do you think she should do to put her dd through uni? Sell a kidney? MAgic up some money out of thin air? What?

LesLavandes · 03/01/2024 16:03

It can be left in the trust fund until after uni or whenever

coffeerevelsrule · 03/01/2024 16:02

I'm in a pretty much identical situation, except the amount saved is a fair bit lower and the ex is useless with money and has none, though he's very free and easy with any money that does come his way, such as when he pissed the money I bought him out of the house with straight up the wall.

It's definitely none of your ex's business how much money dd has and it should be kept from him if at all possible. I have been straight with my boys about this as they know how unreliable their dad is - both agreed with me but I suppose it's a bit different as they probably won't get anything from him anyway but I still don't want him completely off the hook thinking it's all taken care of and he doesn't need to worry at all. If he does insist on knowing, could dd say she has already put it into an account that can't be accessed? If she's happy to do that of course.

All the moralisers saying it's dd's money and parents expecting her to use it for uni are stealing from her should live in the real world. Parental contributions are based on income alone for that year, ignoring previous years perhaps on a much lower income and unable to save; col crisis, mortgage rises, other siblings, other unavoidable outgoings etc etc. It's a fucking shitshow of a system and trying to guilt-trip people who are just trying to find a way through it is very fucking low imo.